I think I agree about the red pharmacist. One of the 3 deaths had claimed that he had a pill and won't die.

That would also account for the seemingly weird role count right now.

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

December 07 2010 02:10 GMT

#816

On December 07 2010 11:02 jcarlsoniv wrote:
Ok, crazy crazy WIFOM just hit my brain, just hear me out.

What is kingjames is scum and lying about being the insane detective? I know it's unlikely, but just a scenario I want to bring up.

He knows annul is the lover. He knows that annul will die and take out Node when he dies. This puts the town into mylo. KJ uses this to false claim DT and incriminate annul, using Opz's public town confirmation as his explanation. He then uses everyone's trust to kill aeres, who turns up to be town, and this wins mafia the game. It would also kind of explain why our role count is amiss...

I know it's highly unlikely, and so convoluted, but holy shit my brain just exploded. Plus, I wouldn't put it past KJ, he's a damn good player. =P

Well, we know that there were 2 detectives, one sane and one insane. The other detective was killed - there is one detective left in the game. None else has claimed, and everything kingjames has said matches based on his claim as an insane detective.

And the role count can be explained by the existence of a red pharmacist. If the pill that the guy claimed to have before dying in day 3 was from the red pharmacist, then he must've taken the pill and died because of it - leading to 3 deaths - 1 mafia hit, 1 vigiliant miss, 1 death pill.

Btw, kingjames, let me get this straight. You got a pill last night, and took it immediately?

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

December 07 2010 02:17 GMT

#819

On December 07 2010 09:14 kingjames01 wrote:
Also, I received a pill last night which I took. Thanks to the pharmacist who kept me alive. =)

##unvote Aeres

At this point, the townie pharamcist can roleclaim. Even if he dies, we can get both mafia using today's lynch and tomorrow's lynch.

1. Did you really send a pill to kingjames01?
2. Can your pill be taken immediately after you send it to him?

I say this because I received a pill last night, but I am prohibited from taking it until the next day. I think Kingjames just made up the part about receiving a pill.

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

December 07 2010 02:26 GMT

#825

I'm going to wait for the town's pharmacist to speak up. The timing isn't the only thing that's wrong with what you mentioned btw.

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

December 07 2010 02:28 GMT

#826

Hmm.

Was yours in pill form?

ghur, tell me, in what form is your medicine?

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

December 07 2010 02:33 GMT

#832

On December 07 2010 11:30 ghrur wrote:

Show nested quote +

My medicine is a bottle of pills. That's about as specific as my role PM gets.

Ah, close enough. the exact form is a bottle of medicine. I'm assuming ppl just equate medicine with pills.

Ok, considering how fast you have responded, you two couldn't have coordinated all this so fast. I'm inclined to trust you.

## Vote: Aeres

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

December 07 2010 02:34 GMT

#835

Ah are you kidding me, I was the hammer? LOL I fear it!

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

December 07 2010 02:34 GMT

#836

Oh greeeaaaattt.....

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

December 07 2010 02:37 GMT

#842

I'm guessing the vigilant variety in this game only had one shot. And he wasted it night 1.

Didn't think you both were red...

Barring a freak killing, our only chance is the target surviving a lynch.

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

December 07 2010 02:39 GMT

#844

wait wait, wtf? ghrur was a pharmacist? the hell...

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

December 07 2010 02:40 GMT

#848

On December 07 2010 11:39 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Conclusion:
Pharmacist is a shittier version of medic. The original version was that anyone who visits them is protected, but that is also really OP.

Priest/Executioner are both good roles but not if used in the same game.

Unsure about ghost because jcarls had no idea how to use his role.

Using the Whisperer to fake DT is a bad idea(he used his actions to confirm two mafia players as town). The best thing to do IMO is to send messages to players you suspect to gauge their reactions and see if they will claim it in the thread or not.

Radar Tech is really overpowered, too bad Barundar claimed it and got killed for it.

This game was setup for town to be extremely OP and mafia won anyway. GG

Couldn't help it when we lost 5 blues in one day. -_-