Harry Potter Mafia! - Page 2

On December 15 2010 08:40 Airbag wrote:

It's really not gonna look good for you if he turns out to be a death eater.

On December 11 2010 12:57 why wrote:


Good point. Sorry about that.

I like reasoned vote a lot. Of all of them I think that would result in the most discussion and more discussion is always better.

On December 14 2010 14:49 why wrote:
right, sorry I'm not used to this.

On December 14 2010 15:24 why wrote:


Nevermind misread question. Sorry.

On December 11 2010 16:06 why wrote:
All my Harry Potter knowledge has gotten me is that whoever is Colin Creevey probably has the sample "Camera Fanatic" power.

Speaking of which, anybody got any good ideas of in flavor power roles for the death eaters? It would be nice to have some idea of what they could be capable of.

On December 13 2010 06:39 why wrote:
If I recall correctly, Snape looked evil but was actually good. I could see him as a miller, but if he was he probably would have claimed already.

On December 13 2010 06:52 why wrote:
^ this makes imperious curse unlikely since there are 8 confirmed death eaters. I guess one of the death eaters could have polyjuice potion or something. But I don't think any of the death eater characters are specifically associated with polyjuice potion like barty crouch jr would have been.

On December 14 2010 15:23 why wrote:


This is what annul said on page 25.

1. Substitution roles.
2. Protection roles
3. Investigation roles.
4. Non-standard kill roles.
5. Non-Voldemort standard mafia kills.
6. Voldemort's personal kill.

On December 16 2010 13:23 why wrote:


There are alternate win conditions. We know that when Beneather died, the alternate win count went down by 3. This suggested (to me) that there was a Ravenclaw shared victory (Mr. Zergling, as the 3rd member, is Roger Davies or Cho Chang). There could be a similar Gryffindor House alternate win condition that Lunar can share in (if the Gryffindor house has 3 members, this neatly makes 4 total alternate win conditions left), or Pavarti could have yet another alternate win.

On December 14 2010 10:46 why wrote:
(ps breadcrumb is when you fill your old posts with hints as to your role so you can confirm role-claim later, this is especially useful for mod-confirmed Masons )

On December 14 2010 13:18 why wrote:
I think we need some other people's thoughts on whether it is a good idea to reveal or not. I'm too inexperienced to know how this typically shakes out.

On December 16 2010 20:19 why wrote:
By the way, we can confirm (at least the characters of) 3 more people.

Cho Chang or Roger Davies (the one not in the Ravenclaw House) can confirm by saying they are in the Ravenclaw and having no one dispute them (there are 4 total Ravenclaws on the list, 3 are in the House).

There are 5 Gryffindor members on the player list (Harry Potter, Hermione, Colin Creevey, Angelina Johnson, and Pavarti Patil). 3 are in the house. The remaining 2 can claim to be part of the House and, if no one disputes, are confirmed.

Coincidentally, I am in Gryffindor.

On December 17 2010 10:05 why wrote:


To be clear, I am not claiming to be one of Jcarl's group. I am claiming to have a character that is Gryffindor that is NOT in Jcarl's group (there are 5 total Gryffindor members, 3 in Jcarl's group).