Don't lose yo village!
|Forum Index > TL Mafia|
DAY 1 LYNCH COAG GOGO
PLEASE if you notice me not posting alot attribute it to me trying to be a more contributing but less messy town player and not being a lurker. honestly i tried this last game and it got me lynched day 1 and i was very confused about what kind of activity level you guys want from me.
Extremely pro town poster regardless of roles. very active poster.
Has a tendency to be extremely aggressive when mafia and extremely defensive when town
Gave me a retarted role in insane mafia.
was a fairly active poster in insane mafia.
Posting quality and town contribution fluctuates based on his roles he receives
if hes got a role hes not happy with hes pretty bad
if hes got a decent role he contributes alot
doesnt have internet right now. will probably be lurking alot.
a little bit of a lurker in haunted mafia ?
isnt he the one that only reads post's if they talk about him. kinda bad for town.
Extremely aggressive poster extremely prone to making slips when he post's however his post's are so cluttered and chaotic that its sometimes easy to miss them. everyone assuming that hes a just a bad player could be dangerous like what happend in insane mafia.
On November 12 2010 13:05 KtheZ wrote:
What if the tracker claim is a false claim?
i assume the real tracker would also claim and then there would be 2 people and we would have to decide what one to lynch. a mis-lynch would be terrible for us.
On November 12 2010 15:29 Pandain wrote:
Is there only one of each role?
well if you count the roles there are 9 of them and 9 players...
Im noticing a trend here.
On November 14 2010 11:00 youngminii wrote:
Not much to post about.. Perhaps we should just do random votes and get the ball rolling, instead of trying to figure out a complicated plan.
This post just seems anti town. who would want town to lynch randomly and not plan?
also worth noticing that glass appears to be trying to fly under the radar
On November 15 2010 04:32 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
i said I'm changing my game strategy
I posted too much in insane mafia and I let the town know too much of what I was thinking. my plan is to be more withdrawn, keep more to myself, and only post when I have something to say. not feeling great about glasse, youngminii, or kenpachi. kenpachi never really contributes anything, just parrots what others say and is generally inactive
i don't have good meta read on glasse yet or youngminii though.
out of the active posters you're the scummiest imo
is that what you wanted to hear? i'm going to go away now until something happens thats worth posting about
i dont feel pandain is scummy yet just over ambitious and eccentric like always.
im gonna ##vote youngminii
On November 15 2010 08:14 Hesmyrr wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
On November 15 2010 04:57 deconduo wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 15 2010 04:51 KtheZ wrote:
On November 15 2010 04:23 deconduo wrote:
Just fyi, mafia have a copy of all role PMs.
Wait wtf, seriously?
Yep, to stop any 'my role PM says this so I'm legit' sort of thing.
Honestly I thought it was standard on all the semi-open setups like this =/
i dont get it are you calling kthez a lurker??
On November 15 2010 09:48 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
if in doubt, lynch coagulation.
stop trying to walk all over me for no reason.
its getting old.
On November 15 2010 04:38 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
you guys can lynch me if you're really stupid but please lynch pandain when i flip blue
ok sounds good. you already treat me like im stupid so nothing to lose right?
we need information
The best way to get information is to flip people and analyze posting based on their role.
On November 15 2010 11:12 Pandain wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 15 2010 11:06 LSB wrote:
Okay, say we lynch coag. What information will we get?
Say we lynch Dr. H. What information will we get?
1.One less person that could be mafia(if town)
2.Information on Dr. H
3.Information from his posts.
4.If he's mafia/town
1.Information on Coag
2.Information on ARtanis
3.Information from whether he's scum/town
4.Possibly one less mafia.
5.Information on Pandain
On November 15 2010 12:01 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
rofl lynching people for "information" is such a bullshit scumplay
lynch your best and most experienced player cause it might give you "information", good call.
Pandain I never contradicted myself, stop beating a dead horse trying to get me lynched on bullshit. You don't get any information on anybody from me. What information on coagulation? That I think he's terrible at this game as either town OR mafia? Wow.
What information on Artanis? Everyone seems to agree that his claim seems legit and makes no sense as a mafia play. What information do you get? You can get the same bullshit "information" lynching anybody, that's why this play is so weak and terrible.
Hey town, why don't you think for a second before you go and off get rid of your most experienced player. Why does Pandain want to get rid of me? Think about if Pandain is mafia here:
- Mafia doesn't hit me
- Push suspicion on me for because I wasn't targeted night 1
- Make up shit about how I contradicted myself about pressuring or whatever Pandain is talking about, it doesn't even really make sense to me because his arguments never make sense
- Left out the fact that me flipping blue might incriminate him (obviously purposely)
- Same bad argumentation style in Insane Mafia (twist my words to make it seem like I'm being inconsistent, saying things that don't really make sense with the intent NOT of understanding what I'm saying but just of making me look bad)
- This terrible bullshit "lynch for information!" argument
Here's the thing. I always do the "lynch for information" bit when I'm mafia, or at least I had until BloodC0bbler told me in BrownBear's game that it was super obvious and that he was shocked no one knew I was mafia from DAY ONE starting that. I've been mafia probably more times than anyone here and I know bullshit when I see it. Guess what, that's all Pandain has to bring to the table.
Pandain if you are town then you seriously need to go through Mafia boot camp and read Ver's guide. Seeing as how you always seek advice after games (and you usually PM me about it) I seriously doubt you still lack the skill and logical insight necessary to stop these awful tirades.
so you vote pandain cause he voted you?
I dont think i have seen him do anything that would draw attention to him but that might be exactly what hes trying to do.
from the 2 games i have played with him he is generally very outgoing and jokes alot and has very little worries about what town thinks about him.
he hasnt done that at all this game. mostly inactive at this point.
He hasnt really contributed much but from what i remember he doesnt post at all in any of the other games unless someone is actually actively trying to get him lynched or what not. so i dont see any significant warning signs in him laying low but i think we really need to get him talking.
about pandain pushing doch
I wouldnt be too suprised to find out one of them are red. but im a little confused why pandain would back down and ask drh who he thinks a good lynch right after doch got done writing a half page analysis on why he thinks pandain is scum and then votes pandain. i dont know what to make of that. is it scummy? i dont know. is it weird. yes.
On November 15 2010 12:47 LSB wrote:
Regarding the lynch.
I believe that Pandain, Coagulation, Glasse, and Kenpachi are all playing like normal. The issue is whether or not we should peruse a policy lynch. Whether or not we should lynch people because they are acting like scum.
Things to consider. I can track one of the four people mentioned. That could verify a player, one way for us to doge using a policy lynch.
Normally I'd suggest against a policy lynch. However, there have been no major 'slipups' day 1. Except for Pandain, but that's normal for him.
If we are going to actually go for a policy lynch, I am against policy lynching Pandain and Coagulation
Pandain actually tries to do stuff, and he has moments.
I know/think that Coag actually tries, so I'd rather not lynch him. Addressed to Coag: if you want to get better, maybe you can bounce ideas off of someone else who isn't playing the game?
i will be the first to admit i am very inexperienced. i will be playing in mafia boot camp and hopefully refining my ability to contribute to town more efficiently.