|
On November 02 2010 10:34 infinitestory wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2010 10:31 youngminii wrote:On November 01 2010 04:22 youngminii wrote:On November 01 2010 04:20 Artanis[Xp] wrote:f a player is "gone for the night", would that player also be able to protect me if they were a bodyguard that same night? If Aeres hypothetically is the second bodyguard and my other bodyguard is dead: Aeres leaves for the night and the mafia hits me. Do I survive? This is a question too hypothetical to answer as it would require me to confirm or deny roles and give too much information away. Translation: Aeres is scum and he's making up the role. By answering this question, I would be confirming the existence of the fake role and as such, I can't give a real answer. Maybe. Hey wait, I was totally right here. Why are you using this as an argument, infinitestory? For one, we don't know if he's scum for certain. Also, he made the same response to a question about the Cruiseship Captain role, so by the same logic the Cruiseship Captain doesn't exist either. That just seems unlikely to me.
...............................................................................................................................................
You know the Cruiseship Captain role was made up, right? Or am I missing something here...
|
Okay maybe I made a giant assumption about the Cruiseship Captain role's authenticity. I always thought it was just assumed to be made up along with the whole bodyguard role.
|
lol
I think it's same to assume it was Fishball's PM group.
Anyway, did L just single handedly take all the attention away from Aeres with one post that doesn't really defend his actions in any solid manner? Seriously?
|
ok agreed
I'm interested in the analysis of Misder. I could almost swear he played very similarly in a game of mafia when we were both scum. I'll just go away and look for it now.
|
Okay based on TL Mafia XXX and TL Mafia XXXI, Misder is a lot more aggressive and willing to point fingers as scum. When he's town he tends to take a more neutral stance, and even when he's posting to voice his opinion of someone being scum (and voting for them) he would say something like "I feel as if x is more townlike than y and so I'm led to believe y is the most scummiest right now. That's why I'm putting my vote on him" whereas as scum he's more straightforward, "I'm voting for x because his posts are very scummy. Reasons x y z, he's scum".
He also likes bussing. I remember in XXX when we were on the same team, basically his first post of value was one bussing me, then he went on trying to bus one or two more teammates throughout the game.
|
Hmm, okay. According to that, he slipped up a hell of a lot as scum.
|
On November 02 2010 21:38 Glasse wrote:
More of a role claim than slip i thought
i work at a radio
What, so you the cat was you lol, that was a pretty random roleclaim.
I'm thinking there's a pretty clear connection between Aeres and jcarl, namely that jcarl does not want to touch the Aeres thing at all while he goes and basically goes and points fingers at every other person.
I mean, Aeres just said he 'can't post much because of schoolwork'. He's meant to be defending himself. My vote's going to stick with Aeres.
|
That is what the policy of LAL revolves around, discouraging blatant lies.
|
Well that sucks. I was the new addition to Fishball's PM group.
|
I think the fact that Pandain has 6 pages (100 posts each) of posts mostly to do with his interaction with DrH, then starting to lurk after the attention was brought on him indicates a little bit of his scumminess, don't ya think?
Lucky break with the mafia retard. I honestly thought infinitestory was more scummy than most others.
|
Hang on, he says his role is ADD Detective but he RNGs a target. But the ADD Doctor has a 10% chance of killing his patient if his patient wasn't 'sick'. Shouldn't that make an ADD Detective a Detective that gets a wrong reading 10% of the time?
Food for thought, don't look into it too much (yet).
|
On November 04 2010 10:15 DoctorHelvetica wrote:Show nested quote +On November 04 2010 10:13 youngminii wrote:
Hang on, he says his role is ADD Detective but he RNGs a target. But the ADD Doctor has a 10% chance of killing his patient if his patient wasn't 'sick'. Shouldn't that make an ADD Detective a Detective that gets a wrong reading 10% of the time?
Food for thought, don't look into it too much (yet). meh, I doubt it's exactly the same. I'm inclined to believe him because he fished for other ADD DT's in the same way I did for other stickys. I'd think it's more likely he has a 100% chance of investigating correctly, since orgolove actually had a 100% chance of saving right?
Yeah but I'm just saying there's the possibility of him lying about his roleclaim, since I've never seen an ADD role that wasn't a "x% chance of getting the opposite result" type of thing. Oh well Coagulation's mafia anyway, bus or not so no use worrying about it now.
By the way, Pandain voted at 10:06 TL time and hasn't posted in this thread (I was giving him time to post before writing this). At a time where someone should be defending themselves heavily instead of lurking like he is, I think it's fair to say he's either not playing well or he's very scummy.
|
His type of detective is easier to fakeclaim than others, since (if he is fakeclaiming), he doesn't have to follow a "check me and tell everyone what I am as proof" kinda thing, I mean as long as people are roleclaiming, he can fake a check on people that have already roleclaimed.
Perhaps we should start thinking about who to lynch (apart from pandain) tomorrow.
|
"Just stop, I hate reading long posts. Analytical posts are crap. I'm not going to debate your arguments but they're crap."
OR
"Just stop, you're posting crap. Repetitive posts are crap. I'm not going to debate your 600 posts of the same flawed arguments against DrH but they're crap."
|
I would agree with Nemesis but that was pushed forward by Ace. I'm still wary of bum's death post to be honest.
Shouldn't you be as well?
|
On November 04 2010 10:39 Pandain wrote:
Night 1 infinite, safe
Night two, nemesis, safe
i lol'd
|
Wasn't Pandain's main 600 post argument against DrH the fact that he 'lied' and he couldn't confirm himself 100% because he got roleblocked?
Now it's day 3 and Pandain can't confirm himself which is a bigger lie than DrH's? Does this not strike you as fucking stupid at all Pandain? Couldn't you have come up with a better argument/roleclaim?
|
On November 04 2010 10:50 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
i feel uncomfortable
something about his role feels really plausible to me, but at the same time its very easy to fake and much safer to fake than mine
i suggest we kill pandain/someone unconnected or opposed to pandain
if pandain turns up blue and the other turns up red that could be really good for us in the end.
No, we're killing Pandain. He's posting scummily (as usual though) and there is no reason for Artanis/LSB to make two roles that literally overlap yet have one *slightly* better than the other. If Pandain is blue then FoS infinitestory.
|
This is true...
And you role check while Pandain alignment checks.
Either way, I'm banking on Pandain having fakeclaimed.
|
On November 04 2010 11:10 Pandain wrote:Show nested quote +On November 04 2010 11:09 KtheZ wrote:On November 04 2010 11:07 DoctorHelvetica wrote:On November 04 2010 11:05 KtheZ wrote:On November 04 2010 11:02 Pandain wrote:On November 04 2010 11:01 KtheZ wrote:On November 04 2010 10:59 Pandain wrote:If I die, FoS on KtheZ for pushing me so hard with illogical reasons. At least Dr. H has had decent ones.... On November 04 2010 10:57 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
if a vig hits pandain we might have better information for our double lynch :O What illogical reasons? I simply ask why it took you so long to roleclaim and why your roleclaim clearly overlaps with a previously claimed role. and what does FoS mean :/ Because roleclaiming was plainly idiotic. It's not like I'm going to claim "Hey mafia, I have a role where I can find out people's alignments!" Also infinite has a good point with the doctor/plague doctor(town does have both fyi) FoS=finger of suspicion. Note that mafia also had their own plague doctor, so there may be role-checkers for the mafia also. So the standings right now is that you claim to be Garbage collector, and your results have turned up OBVIOUSLY unconfirmable results (who in their right mind would say "I'm not safe omg") mafia doesnt need an alignment checker since mafia know everybodies alignment I noticed, which is why I think hes lying about his role/role action So you think i'm mafia, because I claimed a role which you think mafia wouldn't have. Circular reasoning ftw.
Best post I've seen from you so far.
Agree with DrH.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
