EPTOf course an experienced player won't just use some random arguments to try and get people to bandwagon someone. They try and pick on someone weak who can't defend himself and push for a lynch on him. Also, I don't see how Aeres lied as "proof" he is scum. As been mentioned by other people in the thread, scum are not the only ones who lie, a townie lying can be of benefit to town if done correctly, which Aeres didn't do and as such an easy target for someone such as yourself by pulling LAL.
Insane Mafia - Page 3
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Nemesis
Canada2568 Posts
Of course an experienced player won't just use some random arguments to try and get people to bandwagon someone. They try and pick on someone weak who can't defend himself and push for a lynch on him. Also, I don't see how Aeres lied as "proof" he is scum. As been mentioned by other people in the thread, scum are not the only ones who lie, a townie lying can be of benefit to town if done correctly, which Aeres didn't do and as such an easy target for someone such as yourself by pulling LAL. | ||
|
Nemesis
Canada2568 Posts
On November 02 2010 11:06 Ace wrote: 2.) I didn't get a bandwagon going on Aeres. I started a lynch on Aeres. If I was starting a bandwagon I wouldn't be using logical arguments, or you know the fact that Aeres lied as proof that he is scum. Of course an experienced player won't just use some random arguments to try and get people to bandwagon someone. They try and pick on someone weak who can't defend himself and push for a lynch on him. Also, I don't see how Aeres lied as "proof" he is scum. As been mentioned by other people in the thread, scum are not the only ones who lie, a townie lying can be of benefit to town if done correctly, which Aeres didn't do and as such an easy target for someone such as yourself by pulling LAL. Just fixing the quotes | ||
|
Nemesis
Canada2568 Posts
| ||
|
Nemesis
Canada2568 Posts
| ||
|
Nemesis
Canada2568 Posts
On November 02 2010 13:19 DoctorHelvetica wrote: The problem with talking about inactives, is you can't really talk about inactives. If players are truly inactive, not posting at all, then really they're all equally likely to be scum and no real conclusions can be drawn. However it is by no means a good thing that the town gets split 50/50 or that one argument/conflict is the spotlight of the entire day. Inactives need to start posting! I want to see Divinek post D: Yes and only way to force inactives to post is to start lynching inactives to scare them into posting. | ||
|
Nemesis
Canada2568 Posts
I am just too lazy right now as I have a lot of work to do. | ||
|
Nemesis
Canada2568 Posts
On November 02 2010 22:59 deconduo wrote: Sitting back and letting 3 letters be law for every single scenario just boggles my mind. Not looking at things in a case by case basis is utterly utterly utterly demented. But hey, people seem to be set in their ways and who am I to change that. Exactly. I thought we were supposed to lynch people for being SCUM, not for lying. This is a bit of a ridiculous policy. Why must it be one way or the other? We have to consider things case by case, not handle them all the same. | ||
|
Nemesis
Canada2568 Posts
 | ||
|
Nemesis
Canada2568 Posts
On November 03 2010 02:28 Infundibulum wrote: Lynch all Liars is a metagame policy that extends beyond just this round of mafia. I still have trouble coming to terms with it because last game I was in LAL got a couple townies lynched. Because they lied and fucked up the town, and mafia pushed LAL on them. Even so, as a long term policy LAL can and will discourage these lying plays on both sides, town and mafia and so it should be used. As for Aeres, I'm guessing if lynched he's going to flip town. There's less of a motive for claiming BG as a mafia, since the purpose of claiming BG is to draw a hit and the mafia won't hit itself. The other thing is mafia completely ignored 666's bodyguard softclaim, for whatever reason. Exactly why I don't like it. Mafia can use it against town every time someone gets caught for minor inconsistencies in his posts. I really dislike the bandwagon on Aeres right now because of LAL. YOU SHOULD LYNCH SOMEONE BECAUSE YOU THINK THEY ARE SCUM NOT STUPID LAL. If Aeres flips town, I will go batshit crazy on all the people that bandwagoned him. | ||
|
Nemesis
Canada2568 Posts
| ||
|
Nemesis
Canada2568 Posts
| ||
|
Nemesis
Canada2568 Posts
On November 03 2010 07:02 KtheZ wrote: #vote Aeres Looks like we have another lurker again | ||
|
Nemesis
Canada2568 Posts
On November 03 2010 08:45 Coagulation wrote: also im wondering exactly how many blues are you allowed to lynch before its justifiable for us to question you? is there a number? I would say that if DrH fails to confirm himself this night phase. This is the part where I say "I told you so" And the part where I go batshit crazy. Seriously, we don't fucking lynch FOR BAD TOWNIE PLAY, WE LYNCH FOR SCUM PLAY. It was pretty obvious that aeres did the former. So I really want to lynch the people who started the bandwagon now, but I guess it will have to wait until next day phase. | ||
|
Nemesis
Canada2568 Posts
On November 03 2010 09:16 bumatlarge wrote: Here are some theories also. Rolebloker targetted Dr.H we assume, right? Dr.H is immune to M-rus. Mafia has a now dead PD. I think mafia is very conservative in their actions for fear of the virus. Which makes me think that town is likely to have a virus spreading role if they found some unprecedented infected. I suggest a medic considers dr. h as a target, since he is immune and becoming a clearer townie day by day. M-rus spreads whenever someone infected visits someone uninfected during the night. Other than that maybe mafia has a role that can spread it. As for the night phase, I think I want to talk about medic's best target for this night: 1. DoctorH - He just lost his only bodyguard 2. DCLXVI - Even if node is lying about his role, mafia has to target DC or else node is lynched. 3. Node - If node is not lying about his role, that is a big benefit for town. That is 1 less kill point for mafia as long as node stays alive. | ||
|
Nemesis
Canada2568 Posts
| ||
|
Nemesis
Canada2568 Posts
On November 03 2010 09:21 Nemesis wrote: M-rus spreads whenever someone infected visits someone uninfected during the night. Other than that maybe mafia has a role that can spread it. As for the night phase, I think I want to talk about medic's best target for this night: 1. DoctorH - He just lost his only bodyguard 2. DCLXVI - Even if node is lying about his role, mafia has to target DC or else node is lynched. 3. Node - If node is not lying about his role, that is a big benefit for town. That is 1 less kill point for mafia as long as node stays alive. Hmm actually I suggest to CubedIn to protect DCLXVI, because that would confirm his role + he can tell us if DCLXVI was actually hit as he is the only known medic at this point. | ||
|
Nemesis
Canada2568 Posts
On November 03 2010 09:51 CubEdIn wrote: Yeah that sounds good and all, as long as someone protects me. I don't really care for DCL THAT much at this point, honestly. Maybe if he'd post more often.. Don't forget that by doing this you will most likely confirm your role too. | ||
|
Nemesis
Canada2568 Posts
On November 03 2010 11:33 jcarlsoniv wrote: Well, this worries me and it doesn't. Assigning blue roles in thread isn't always the smartest thing (as I learned in Haunted) because then Mafia knows what's going on. Downside is we have no PMs, so we don't really have much choice. One thing good that we will learn is whether or not the +1 Mafia KP can be protected against (as we are assuming this is what Node is predicting). I assume it probably can be, but it would definitely be nice to know for sure. Well seeing as the DCLXVI kill is predetermined in the beginning of the day post if Node is not lying, I doubt mafia can change that. | ||
|
Nemesis
Canada2568 Posts
Well I'll be back after dinner | ||
|
Nemesis
Canada2568 Posts
On November 04 2010 08:29 infinitestory wrote: Points Of Note in this day post: 1) No additional infections. How the hell did that happen? 2) Someone was protected. I find it highly likely that was DC. 3) Bum's dead. Fuck. 4) jcarlsoniv was Elder. Fuck. 5) hey there Glasse, what did you send for the radio? Also, why is LOONY decapitalized and spelled different? 6) 3 (?) people tried to force their way into houses and failed. Whaaaat? And that extra guy on the rooftops? 7) Someone else was out of town. That's definitely NOT Aeres this time. 8) A silenced shot killed bum? Could that mean something? 9) hello mayor, help us lynch a baddie! 1. I'm gueesing that mafia don't have a role that can give infection, and the first 3 infection was RNG, so the only way for infection to spread is through visiting. Are we told about the person being infected if someone infected dies? 2.most likely 3. Fuck. | ||
| ||
