TL Mafia XXVIII - Page 20

On August 05 2010 08:19 Protactinium wrote:

I seriously wonder how many people bothered to read them...

Also what if I said I had made up a lot of the PMs between Pandain and myself?

On July 25 2010 07:37 BloodyC0bbler wrote:

We lynch southrawr
A) is mafia trying to save himself
B) is hatter with one bomb on chaoser
C) he flips green and we all go wtf
.

On August 05 2010 08:22 BrownBear wrote:


Dude, it's all good. I got too frustrated during the game, I'm sorry. I know how much work you put into this.

On August 05 2010 08:48 Incognito wrote:
Oh also one more thing you always lynch people who flip red. Always. Even if they're miller.

On August 05 2010 09:04 Divinek wrote:


yeah but he talked back enough to peg him as red for me so i figured it was a fair trade.

really i thought they might think i was some other blue role just bs'ing as vet so they wouldnt hit me then they might etc etc

On August 05 2010 10:26 citi.zen wrote:


I am fully at fault for not being sufficiently active the day of the claim. Reading back pages 92-onwards, the mafia never found logical "holes" in the plan - they never even invoked the argument Ace brought up (which I continue to think rests on the assumption a hatter is primarily valuable for their bombs, an assumption that is not always correct). Because they could not find logical flaws they started to sacrifice people: BC, South, rastaban. They also made a HUGE number of plainly nonsensical arguments. For example, when it was leaked that there were "multiple dt rep" claims, the mafia said "why would citi.zen not tell us? he must be red!" Of course, multiple DT rep claims should have made it 100% obvious I was telling the truth: if I was red the fake claims would have to come from townies, but why would a townie every fake claim in that situation? So fake claims to me = I could NOT be red. Whatever... there are way too many incoherent arguments that day to talk about all of them.

So I don't think at all that the plan was bad, had big logical flaws, or screwed the town over. It was solid and surfaced clear reds. The town was better off for it. I am really surprised to see everyone watching this, from Ace to Ver or Incognito say it was a bad idea.

And just to be clear: I think this was indeed a town favored set-up. The mafia won so they deserve 2x the congratulations for being active and having a fantastic PR machine when it counted.

On August 05 2010 10:29 rastaban wrote:


These are some good points but I disagree with the first, if it had been a closed circle then yeah, that might be legit, but when he died was there anyone who didn't already know he was DT? I mean Zeks PM to me was the sub was my DT and he pretty much outed him in the thread. The infiltration gave us good information on others but it only occurred because subversion had outed himself.

On August 05 2010 10:48 rastaban wrote:


But I was arguing there were only 2 claims, and your DT never existed because you were actually mafia trying to flush them out.

On August 05 2010 11:10 youngminii wrote:
Damn I suck