|
On July 31 2010 13:46 chaoser wrote:Show nested quote +On July 31 2010 12:09 Divinek wrote:On July 31 2010 12:01 youngminii wrote: Red's probably just riding along letting town kill each other. Rastaban/chaoser gogogo. yeah wtf chaoser abstained from the second lynch vote or his name is somehow invisible to me in that list bm posted die die die I voted pan and tree. Kill me if you like, I'll only flip green and then youngminii has to do the run devil run dance for TL mafia =]
lol see your name was invisible on that list! thank you for pointing it out now i can see it
|
nights not over? it lasts 24h
|
On August 01 2010 09:26 flamewheel wrote: What's with dead people still posting =.=
i know we need some real flamewheel lightning up in here
especially on that subversion guy
|
nights over bm wherrrrrrrrrrre are thou
|
young certainly didnt surprise me, the second person was up for grabs then i suppose
|
On August 01 2010 11:01 citi.zen wrote: lylo
tomorrow is actually lylo
but today might as well be
|
okay remaining player list
5. chaoser 6. divinek 11. rastaban 16. ~OpZ~ 23. d3_crescentia 24. Misder 26. Pyrrholuxia 27. Tricode 29. protactinium
based on actual evidence to me it goes down to this
5. chaoser 11. rastaban 16. ~OpZ~ 24. Misder 26. Pyrrholuxia 29. protactinium
then based on feelings and surface ideas based on what has happened so far it comes down to this
16. ~OpZ~ 26. Pyrrholuxia 29. protactinium
sorry that chaoser and rasta arent on my final idea young! but this isnt my sure fire i think these are mafia list, it's just the people that seem most plausable to be red at this point, to me and im sure this list can be off, but i feel quite QUITE strongly there is at least 1 red in there, if not 2.
it'd be nice to have people who were eliminated from the original list (ie d3 and tricode) to put their input on this. Don't worry ill back up my narrowing with actual evidence since we have a whopping 48 hours to do nothing but talk
|
oh yeah he got removed in editing cause he was at the top of the list and i didnt notice thx, just imagine he's right above chaoser for the first two
|
On August 01 2010 11:40 Pyrrhuloxia wrote: I still think Misder and BC were working together. Even if he is town, he says he's gonna be mostly gone which gives town one less vote. Also, if Misder's red it was BrownBear's switch that saved him.
#vote Misder
why do you think they were working together? do you have tangible proof and stuffs of this because it would be nice to see.
I think what you're saying has been mentioned before but it'd be nice to see the actual posts explaining it
|
On August 01 2010 11:53 Pyrrhuloxia wrote:Show nested quote +On August 01 2010 11:51 Divinek wrote:On August 01 2010 11:40 Pyrrhuloxia wrote: I still think Misder and BC were working together. Even if he is town, he says he's gonna be mostly gone which gives town one less vote. Also, if Misder's red it was BrownBear's switch that saved him.
#vote Misder why do you think they were working together? do you have tangible proof and stuffs of this because it would be nice to see. I think what you're saying has been mentioned before but it'd be nice to see the actual posts explaining it see bottom of page 159 top of page 160
hm i see, i missed like half of that before cause i was reading through the thread too fast. I tend to agree with it for the most part though it could use more original input as a conclusion of all the facts or something but whatever.
I'm pissed misder didnt die yesterday, and somehow tree hugger ended up dying while i was unable to get on and apparently so was he
##vote Misder
for now, or until townie people can come forth with better candidates. I will miss young's activity even if it was fueled by a fair amount of blind rage 
whichever comes first, though it can be hard to wrap your mind around when for now will come but yeahhh it will
|
oh and misder is so totally supposed to be on my list after it's been completely narrowed down im so bad at editing stuff properly when im going through it in notepad
|
QUITE A LIST you've got there good sir
tell us something we dont know!
|
On August 01 2010 14:32 Tricode wrote: ##Vote Rastaban
He knew BC was going to die so I think he just added crap to keep him/her self alive and suspicion off him as if he/she were a good towny and made a lame ass fake post with fake messages.
The writing just doesn't seem like BC from how long I have known him. They lack his intellectual language and there are just some things I just never seen him write.
Though there is still a chance i could be wrong about this, either case I believe those pm's are fake and the time in which he tried to help get BC killed didn't really do much of a push to get BC killed.
could you be more specific please, i looked at them a bit and they look close to how he writes, but i'm of course not as familiar with his vocabulary and such to distinguish a fake.
|
the reason i claimed vet proct was because it was part of what i needed to tell bc in a pm to get a read off of him and it worked well enough
when i found out he was mafia i had to tell town what i had already told him so we could all have as much info as them in that respect
|
On August 02 2010 05:17 Protactinium wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2010 03:56 Divinek wrote: the reason i claimed vet proct was because it was part of what i needed to tell bc in a pm to get a read off of him and it worked well enough
when i found out he was mafia i had to tell town what i had already told him so we could all have as much info as them in that respect I can understand this. I'm not sure why you would claim Veteran to BloodyC0bbler in PMs when he wasn't confirmed (did you do this after he announced he was shot by Tricode?) but at that point you did the logical and correct thing. We can all mark Divinek as town now, though he's just going to not get shot by Mafia... Other Veteran, do not claim unless your life in danger, that is to say, you are going to be lynched. To be honest though, if you claim then you just won't get shot, but if we get it down to 2 Mafia 2 Veterans and a townie that's much better than not having two Veterans. Show nested quote +On August 02 2010 03:59 BrownBear wrote:Holy shit Protact. I am very impress. I want to raise the topic of Misder's inactivity - namely, it's nothing new. TL Mafia XXVI: Day 1: Shows up late, votes for me for Mayor right after I withdraw my candidacy, then doesnt post. Throughout the rest of the game, posted the bare minimum to stay alive, only stayed on bandwagons, occasionally popped up with some kinda-alright analysis... you get the picture. Only thing he had going for him this game was, he ended up being green. It's possible he is doing the exact same thing again. I went further back, and couldn't find any other games, so this is all we got to go on. One game isn't enough to really say anything conclusive, and inactivity is a damning curse to the town, since even at this stage of the game it allows Mafia to hide. I still want to see Pyrrhuloxia's evidence to back up his claim, but Misder can just as easily fit the inactive Mafia bill as the inactive townie bill, since BloodyC0bbler has taken up most of this thread's attention. At this point, [b]Misder still needs to talk more since he (am I correct?) has pretty much contributed nothing to this town, both in form of pro-town activity and in material to be analyzed. Interestingly enough, going back and looking at BloodyC0bbler's and SouthRawrea's interactions, there are virtually none before the Day 3 fiasco. This, in conjunction to BloodyC0bbler's 'analysis' on SouthRawrea leads me to believe that SouthRawrea was initially going to be bused by BloodyC0bbler but then that was disrupted by citi.zen. Of course, by saying that I just went back and had to examine the list of others that BloodyC0bbler had analyzed to see who else was on the list. No go, since they're all dead. My conspiracy theorist mind now makes me think that rastaban is even more likely to be innocent now, since BloodyC0bbler had started a bandwagon on SouthRawrea, and to draw it home and give himself credibility he would need some sort of conclusive evidence--such as a Detective check, no? And he wouldn't even have to come out in the open; he could use his mouth to do so. Bam, SouthRawrea flips red, and the mouth and "Detective" gain credibility. Once the other Detective claims to the mouth, BloodyC0bbler knows and then the Detectives are dead. While this is a very far-fetched and hindsight-induced scenario, it seems in my mind something very likely for BloodyC0bbler to do. He could remain in the shadows while still garnering town credit for offing a red, and it's just the sort of PM trap play he likes to engage in. I made a long post a while ago that was, sadly, ignored, which called for everybody to analyze each other. Since I see that there's not much discussion going on and I don't see that there will be much (why so inactive, town...) I once again propose for everybody to analyze somebody else, say the next surviving person above you or below you on the player roster. Either way, I don't care too much as I expect this to be ignored as well.
well what can i say mob did a good job of getting rid of people that actually are talented analyzers and people who are active, they of course made sure to leave alive the inactive fucks like misder
but i promise i will analyze at least one person shortly, i have a theory that leads me to believe chaoser and rasta are innocent and i will explain it in more detail as i go through and try to confirm it.
for some reason im just getting a feeling that their alignment needs to be the same but ill see
|
also just an fyi for town
people acting like proct are right now shouldnt be cleared and be like 'oh look he's helping out town by posting big blocks of text he can't be red!'
dont judge him on his contributions at this point, judge him on his objectives.
At this stage in the game it'd be perfectly fine for all of the mob to put themselves under the spotlight so long as to direct us to one more mis lync.
not that im saying he's red, just keep that in mind you few people that actually read and post in this thread still!
|
On August 02 2010 06:50 Misder wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2010 03:59 BrownBear wrote:Holy shit Protact. I am very impress. I want to raise the topic of Misder's inactivity - namely, it's nothing new. TL Mafia XXVI: Day 1: Shows up late, votes for me for Mayor right after I withdraw my candidacy, then doesnt post. Throughout the rest of the game, posted the bare minimum to stay alive, only stayed on bandwagons, occasionally popped up with some kinda-alright analysis... you get the picture. Only thing he had going for him this game was, he ended up being green. It's possible he is doing the exact same thing again. I went further back, and couldn't find any other games, so this is all we got to go on. this is the way i play >.< this is my second mafia game, so that is the only one in the past. i guess you really cant judge from only one mafia game. Luckily, this mafia game will also support the fact even when I'm inactive, I will end up green. Actually, a lot in that mafia game thought a was mafia member...
im pushing for you for night one kills in every game from now on
|
i still find it very interesting how sub died
cause the only people that knew about him were pandain, and proct (i still hate you for telling people you didnt confirm sub). Though i suppose pandain probably slipped up enough info to make it obvious who the dt was, aya.
and pandain flipped town and proct was never actually checked. Though it took subversion what a whole extra night after he was discovered to die?
surprisingly this doesnt make me that much more suspicious of proct really, it just makes me want to pray sub doesnt get dt again
quiiiite interesting.
|
I think an interesting thing for people to go back an analyze with their own sets of logic
is at the point where BB suggests for the vets to claim, with the idea in mind that the GF himself was using a vet cover.
i think this should clear BB, or im hoping the mob didnt read into it deeply enough to try a move like that, but more so the people that opposed the idea of vets claiming who are still alive. You can obviously see BC opposing this idea (even though it is a reasonable idea to oppose, it is extra pertinent for the mob as this is their GF's cover)
and i couldnt see a mob member so strongly pushing for this idea if he knew his own GF had this role, or at least i hope not
i dont think there is much to be had out from this early idea than taking a clearer look at bb's alignment but it is always helpful to narrow down that list it's around page 36 for you lazy dudes
also a fun person to put under the spotlight will be pyrr! never been in danger of dying yet...for good reason or not?
|
atleast tricode being a confirmed townie is useful in itself rofl you have 24 posts in this entire game
please do the research and then ill consider moving my vote!
|
|
|
|