Three Kingdoms Mafia (三国演义)

On May 19 2010 08:52 johnnyspazz wrote:
i think the game is over once there's only one faction left regardless of neutral members...right?

On May 19 2010 11:16 Scamp wrote:


Did I miss something here? How do we know that there are DTs and Assassins in this game? Was this all just hypothetical? If so, what's the point?

On May 19 2010 12:55 Scamp wrote:
Yeah but why expect roles like all the other mafia games when this one is clearly different?

Also I'm totally a major player in this game. My questions are simply way too sneaky.

On May 20 2010 00:39 Fishball wrote:


Strong Town read.
Town read.
Town.
What town?

Also, reading the posts from some of you guys, when did YT became the "bad" guys in this game?

On May 21 2010 10:24 BrownBear wrote:
LU BU WILL HAVE NONE OF THIS NONSENSE.

But yeah. I wonder what Diao Chan's power was, because my Three Kingdoms knowledge is limited to Dynasty Warriors... :D

Also, Trezeguet23... no offense but I'd rather we give the power of voting to someone who's contributed a little bit more, not just a lurker. It's a good incentive to get people to contribute, plus, we should be giving the vote to people we can analyze so that we can be reasonably sure they're neutral and not a faction-aligned person hiding amongst the inactives.

On May 20 2010 14:18 johnnyspazz wrote:
ok ill let you know if i'm still neutral by the end of tonight cause i want to kill someone for fun

On May 22 2010 04:40 Tricode wrote:


Seriously I have no idea what you're talking about here. Is the movie/game/book/ or w/e that good? Like which do you recommend and if you refer me the game which system please lol?

On May 22 2010 07:41 L wrote:

Fishball gave you the name for Sun Shangxian. Not Sun Ren. Sun Ren is 孫仁.

She has a different name in ROTK, afaik.

On May 22 2010 09:25 DarthThienAn wrote:


I told you, I'm Zhou Jie Lun.

On May 22 2010 10:40 Fishball wrote:
I can be recruited, but I get to escape the next cycle if I wanted.
Uses, of course, is limited, so no, I'm not perma-neutral.

On May 22 2010 10:47 Fishball wrote:
After reading so many pages regarding our current situation, I'd still say stick with Tricode's original proposal, then kill Tricode if things did not go as planned.

I DON'T CARE who is lying. It is all a distraction. Just kill them one by one if need be.

On May 22 2010 13:40 DarthThienAn wrote:


Yeah I was just fishing ^^.

On May 22 2010 10:30 Fishball wrote:
I wonder who was the first to bring up the idea of Name and Roleclaiming 2-3 days ago? Hmm... I think it was me.

Also, stop saying that I'm MIA ffs. I have a full time job that requires me to work from 7-4pm weekdays. I also go to the gym 4 days a week and am back home usually around 6 MST.

I'm Meng Huo. I get to escape from recruitment.

On May 22 2010 18:12 MyHeroNoob wrote:

cos thats my character, meng huo <_<

On May 22 2010 13:40 DarthThienAn wrote:


Yeah I was just fishing ^^.

On May 22 2010 18:25 LunarDestiny wrote:
Updating the chart made by Radfield:

OK, people who haven't name claimed:
6. Ohn
8. Iaaan
24. Jugan

Contradictions:
1)Fishball claims Meng Huo (p.47)
MyHeroNoob claims Meng Huo (p.50)

2)DarthThienAn claims Ma Chao after five page of trolling us (p.47)
TwoToneTerran claims Ma Chao (p.49)
DarthThienAn responds that he was fishing(p.49)

On May 23 2010 02:42 Radfield wrote:



Trezguet has claimed in thread to be Cao Cao's son, can't remember the name. His ability is to kill any leader who tries to recruit him. Him claiming Vig to L seems awful strange, unless he was just fishing for information.

On May 24 2010 14:18 LunarDestiny wrote:
Bill Murray, I think Fishball and MyHeroNoob who name claimed Meng Huo are not likely to be the third faction leader (not saying that they are not likely to be Zhang Jiao (leader of Yellow Turban)).

The reason is they both claim to have the ability to escape recruitment.

Think about it this way:
If either is a faction leader, they WANT Zhang Jiao to recruit them which will kill Zhang Jiao instantly.

Again, I am saying they are not likely to be the third faction leader. I have no idea if either is Zhang Jiao or not.

On May 24 2010 14:29 LunarDestiny wrote:
Oh shit, I just came up with a good idea. Abenson (YT killer) whould target either MyHeroNoob or Fishball since they are suspicious. They are also not likely to be a faction leader. They are also not likely to know they are recruited by Liu Bei since it is unlikely that Liu Bei contacted them.

My argument why it is unlikely to Liu Bei contacted his recruit is there is more con than pro by contacting his recruit. By now, Liu Bei should only have one recruit which does not give him significant control over the voting. By contacting his recruit, the recruit might not be loyal to him 100% since there is a chance he would be recruited by YT after. By contacting his recruit, it gives away his identity which would be bad if YT recruited this person or this person reveal his lord's identity. It is better for faction leader to contact his recruits in the mid to late game where he can greatly influence the voting.

On May 25 2010 14:30 Bill Murray wrote:
Guys, I hate to break it to you, but I have an ability I have yet to mention except in passing.


I am a busdriver. Last night, I bussed Trezequet23 with Scamp as a result of a plan I had with Jugan. Scamp must be the YT leader. I am affiliated with noone yet, or haven't been told that I've been recruited by Caller. You can kill me if you all don't trust me, as I am completely oblivious to caring the way this game has gone. I really want a neutral victory, so you can kill me to figure out that I'm not lying to you. We need to cut off the head of this beast by getting rid of Scamp. The only way that this should be wrong is if Scamp and Trez are both YT, but I'm 100% sure Scamp is the YT leader if the night has gone the way I am understanding it to have gone.

You all really really really need to believe me on this.

The way I've understood this to have gone they are both YT, but Scamp NOT Trez is the leader.

On May 26 2010 05:41 Bill Murray wrote:
no, it's 4
everyone starts with a bodyguard

On May 26 2010 05:46 DarthThienAn wrote:
@BM, where does it say that leaders start with bodyguards? where it the evidence that bodyguards exist?

On May 23 2010 06:22 LunarDestiny wrote:
Aside from Fishball and his refusal to cooperate:
Bill Murray - Yuan Shao
He said his ability is a poor general which isn't historically true. Yuan Shao is a little bit above average general.

BloodyCobbler - Huang Gai
Huang Gai plays a much smaller role than other character claimed. But the movie/battle "Battle of Red Cliff" is the most famous battle in ROTK and Huang Gai plays a significant role in it.

Trezequet23 - Cao Pi (copied from previous so this is more in depth)
Cao Cao's son is Cao Pi which Trezguet name claimed. Cao Pi was never part of another faction in the history of ROTK in both novel(fictional) and recorded history.

However, in the PS2/PSP game Warrior Orochi (Dynasty Warrior and Samurai Warrior fusion), Cao Pi worked for Orochi who is the main villain of the game (similar to Zhang Jiao in this Mafia game) and revolted against Orochi.

Since Warrior Orochi is a fairly recent game (released in 2007) and a very popular in the Dynasty Warrior franchise, it is likely that Caller also played the game.


Futhermore, Cao Pi automatically getting recruited into Wei is questionable. If I was Caller, I would pick the Sun Jian->Sun Ce->Sun Quan succeeding process since all three play significant role in history. Cao Pi didn't do much for Wei accept being the emperor.

It is also likely that Caller picked a couple of minor roles since he said he randomize the process.

Lastly, it is sad to say my character (Xu Zhu) acts mostly as the bodyguard for Cao Cao. His most significant achievement is his duel against Ma Chao when Cao Cao is attacking the Xi Liang which earned him the nickname "Crazy Tiger".

On May 26 2010 09:47 johnnyspazz wrote:
YEAH GO KILL TREZEQUET23!
i got a worthless ability since wu is dead

On May 24 2010 09:39 flamewheel91 wrote:
I still, still have no idea whats going on.

On May 25 2010 06:49 Caller wrote:
DAY


Jugan was just minding his own business when suddenly some guy ran over and punched him in the face. Enraged, Jugan took his blade and swirled it around, killing hundreds of his own troops. But even the sacrifice of so many of his allies was not enough to stop Jugan from getting annihilated by a single man.

Jugan, aka Zhang Fei the Bold, has fallen.

On May 26 2010 09:47 johnnyspazz wrote:
YEAH GO KILL TREZEQUET23!
i got a worthless ability since wu is dead

On May 24 2010 09:39 flamewheel91 wrote:
I still, still, still, still have no idea whats going on.

On May 12 2010 15:58 Bill Murray wrote:
i promise to play as poorly as humanly possible