On March 21 2010 10:54 XeliN wrote:
Fairly high so feel the need to make useless posts but wanted to say BloodyCobbler really seems good at this game, remember early on he very quickly called me out as being mafia and although his main argument at the time seemed to be based on just his impression I remember thinking it was impressive, would get my nomination for best player this game.

As other people have mentioned L's attitude as well i'll agree, think you need to be less forceful//antagonistic

You were on my list almost the entire game :p

BloodyC0bbler

Canada7876 Posts

March 21 2010 02:08 GMT

#1496

On March 21 2010 11:00 XeliN wrote:
Just out of interest what was your opinion on me later on in the game after i tried harder to come across as town?

I still had you as red. I was originally checking you last night till L messaged me at like the last second to swap to opz.

you just put yourself out to early on a radar. I also had dubbed anyone trying to really criticize me on day two on legitmacy of being a dt a idiot. (I'll go more into this). Then you were "vocal" but primarily in defending Bm to a degree and going after me. :p as such I figured you more as red since you would want me offed more than anyone else would.

However, I am surprised that you guys didn't try to sacrifice someone to off me day 1. Soon as I claimed DT, one of your team should have jumped up and down to try and discredit me then. It would have gotten a few people from the town on board as well and possibly prevented me from getting elected, or caused enough doubt day 2 or 3 to get me killed. Letting the claim go unchallenged was so terrible, especially bad as both L and I claimed day 1. He was pushed for not claiming his specific role, while I was left alone. Also, anyone should have realized that his style of posting was begging to be hit and had him pegged as hatter/vet, then as soon as he offered to get lynched should have put him instantly down as hatter.

Overall this game, you guys as mafia were too complacent.

BloodyC0bbler

Canada7876 Posts

March 21 2010 02:10 GMT

#1498

On March 21 2010 11:05 XeliN wrote:
lol again post before you, pre-empive question answering is a nice talent toi have

haha. I guess :p.

Please also note, that most of what I ignored for responses to most posts is really because the answers were already stated, or just not needed. I know I should have led more actively. But realistically with this format, all I had to do was say "wait for me to finish my checks" and the longer i was protected, the easier it was to destroy. Game was way to town favoured.

BloodyC0bbler

Canada7876 Posts

March 21 2010 02:17 GMT

#1502

On March 21 2010 11:13 XeliN wrote:
Felt pretty guilty in regards to BM, we even played games on iccup together and were chatting together about the game, felt like an evil manipulator xD

IF BM didn't spam so much useless posts that no one wanted to read, he would be fairly decent. He has the potential to be very good, but he just spams a bit to much

If he could learn to cut it back he would do so well.

BloodyC0bbler

Canada7876 Posts

March 21 2010 02:26 GMT

#1505

On March 21 2010 11:21 flamewheel91 wrote:

Show nested quote +

Haha yeah--blue roles aren't that fun, in my opinion. Honestly though, I was just thinking about how one medic would have a hell of a time protecting people with bus drivers thrown in, which I believed would have led to blue sniping instead of the mafia always hitting green (I don't understand why the hitlists were as they were, but meh.) With the two public bodyguards, I had pretty much thought that the medic would be tied up protecting either important targets (like L) or the bodyguards (which is essentially what happened--L was protected first two nights and then BGs die.) On the first night, I was really surprised that L didn't get doublestacked, which would've been massively hilarious, or as I recall L saying to me in XVIII: "because we (the mafia) are such cool cats" when Ver was doublestacked.

Also: Fishball for MVP, baller switch on d3 and Zona led to the mafia having a winning situation for the next period of time, and BM's lynch should've put them ahead (hmm and then during night two more townies hit?)

The roles flipped how they did due to the random number generator, and being the type of person that accepts all kinds of luck (good, bad, otherwise) I just left it as is. Yeah, it was imbalanced, but some games tend to be. All in fun in games though, right? I had hoped that the three "leaders"--Incognito, BloodyC0bbler, and L would try to kill each other. [I actually recall an instant when I asked Incognito over ICQ "what's your next step?" and he replied "get BloodyC0bbler killed."]

Mafia, threadwise at least, were very quiet... and that just lead to the town being more controlled. Once again, even with the imbalanced start the two bodyguards dying during the night would've put the town in a bad situation, since neither BC nor madnessman had released their check results threadwise.

Overall, I'm just glad that people enjoyed the game, even though thread activity dropped pretty low due to things like death and spring break (mlah.) Sorry again for the imba setup, and I believe the next game I host will have no gimmicks.

Yeah, Madnessman claimed to incog and since incog thinks like I do balance wise, he instantly thought I was fake. However, he let me prove myself before offing me first

Mafia lost this mainly due to letting Me, Incog and L do what we wanted with very little pushing, and we just either ignored or bullied the town objectors into submission. Their play this game was too idle. Also, wtf at their hits?

BloodyC0bbler

Canada7876 Posts

March 21 2010 02:28 GMT

#1506

On March 21 2010 11:21 XeliN wrote:
Think he makes a big mistake that I also do, specially in my first game as town, in thinking too much about the game from his own perspective and not objectively

Meh, you can take it from your perspective, but when you really just spam a thread with a bunch of one liners, people just want you to die, regardless of what your are saying. Combined with the fact most of those posts didn't contribute much other than "I will flip green" it just wants him dead more. However, he did point at malongo, and yourself. Pretty sure with a bit more work he could be good.