It IS relevant. You never want anti-town players around. He just proved he isn't playing to win with the town. He might as well be Mafia. Stop being dumb.

citi.zen

2509 Posts

March 08 2010 02:00 GMT

#502

The game is structured so the town and mafia alternate taking shots. We missed two shots thus far. If we go after the rogues we 100% miss two more. The mafia lose nobody and still get to kill at night.

I don't see how this is good for the town.

I also fail to see how killing greens for 2 more days brings "order". Egos get bruised easily in these games, especially with red agitators amongst the greens. It seems highly likely to me that some other person will get angry enough at someone else at the end of those two days to pull off another solo, vigilante-type shooting. Then I guess we ought to kill them too, right? While the mafia keep at 100% strength, killing more green every night. Bottom line is people do not rally behind failure, so killing greens will not bring order and a disciplined following. On the contrary.

More and more I think this "plan" to kill off confirmed greens is mafia-scripted: buy 4+ days of quiet time, while the town kills each other off. How can the reds ever hope for a better start?

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 08 2010 02:00 GMT

#503

Actually Bill Murray has not posted AT ALL since after the incident.

When i compare this with the last game it seems to contrast his attitude completely, he would post loads impulsively especially if he was put in a "lime light" kinda spot.

This to me is more worrying than his actual rush execution and seems consistent with the idea that it might have been a mafia strategy and not his own idea.

Ace

United States16096 Posts

March 08 2010 02:01 GMT

#504

Because not every that can day kill is playing for the town. I'm this close to just saying screw it all together and just watching the chaos. Games with stupid players and there's no point in trying to play seriously.

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 08 2010 02:02 GMT

#505

And Ace that post was in response to what JeeJee wrote about a hypothetical that was NOT relevant.

Stop being dumb.

Ace

United States16096 Posts

March 08 2010 02:02 GMT

#506

Shockey if you PM me one more time I'm killing you tomorrow.

citi.zen

2509 Posts

March 08 2010 02:07 GMT

#507

Let's look at this from another angle: how sure are we Incognito is blue?

If we think him "confirmed" we can start to build a circle around him and create "order" that way, no?

ShoCkeyy

7815 Posts

March 08 2010 02:08 GMT

#508

Wow, can you read the fucking pm? And you will see why I'm pming you, you douche bag. Instead of trying to kill me, pay attention to my words. Seems like you don't want the town to win apparently if you're not going to help me.

ShoCkeyy

7815 Posts

March 08 2010 02:09 GMT

#509

If some one is blue, please pm me. I will help this town win.

CynanMachae

Canada1459 Posts

March 08 2010 02:09 GMT

#510

The thing with not killing BM is that if we don't enforce anything (we've been saying before this day that whoever did like Malongo should be killed), what will stop the CIA agent from killing someone tomorrow, or the day after? While it is indeed bad to have to waste a kill on someone that is quite likely green, the situation could quickly get out of hand.

johnnyspazz

Taiwan1470 Posts

March 08 2010 02:11 GMT

#511

when will BM be allowed to execute again? if we were to kill someone else instead, will he be able to kill someone the next night? if that was the cause i would understand killing him now but if he needs to wait another night then we don't have to kill him right away.

Ace

United States16096 Posts

March 08 2010 02:12 GMT

#512

I DONT PLAY THE GAME THROUGH PMS. Seriously how many times do I have to tell you this? Lurkers are anti-town. As soon as day comes I'm shooting you. I can't stand idiots.

johnnyspazz

Taiwan1470 Posts

March 08 2010 02:12 GMT

#513

On March 08 2010 11:09 CynanMachae wrote:
The thing with not killing BM is that if we don't enforce anything (we've been saying before this day that whoever did like Malongo should be killed), what will stop the CIA agent from killing someone tomorrow, or the day after? While it is indeed bad to have to waste a kill on someone that is quite likely green, the situation could quickly get out of hand.

if the cia agent decides to do this, then its a guaranteed death sentence right before he is allowed to kill again. i'm not against killing BM but i think we should wait until its absolutely necessary.

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 08 2010 02:13 GMT

#514

If someone else took a hit then surely they would instantly say, as no-one has that makes it extremely likely that Incog is a townie, unless someone else claims to have taken a hit I think we have to assume that Incog is a confirmed Townie.

dozko

United Kingdom160 Posts

March 08 2010 02:13 GMT

#515

On March 08 2010 11:09 CynanMachae wrote:
The thing with not killing BM is that if we don't enforce anything (we've been saying before this day that whoever did like Malongo should be killed), what will stop the CIA agent from killing someone tomorrow, or the day after? While it is indeed bad to have to waste a kill on someone that is quite likely green, the situation could quickly get out of hand.

Because the agent can be next ?

ShoCkeyy

7815 Posts

March 08 2010 02:18 GMT

#516

On March 08 2010 11:12 Ace wrote:
I DONT PLAY THE GAME THROUGH PMS. Seriously how many times do I have to tell you this? Lurkers are anti-town. As soon as day comes I'm shooting you. I can't stand idiots.

Shoot me ace please, so you can die instantly after I've been protecting your dumb ass. Yes, I'm roleclaiming, I'm a medic. If I die, good luck guys, but ace is being a fucking retard and anti town more than anybody in this damn game. Like I said, who ever is blue and wants to be saved, let me know before I die.

Iaaan

Canada578 Posts

March 08 2010 02:18 GMT

#517

I might just kill BM tomorrow, people like him degrade the quality of every game, not just this one. I don't know about malongo, I don't think he is going to do anything dumb anymore, I mean, I can see why he wanted chezinu dead, but BM has a history of stupidity, like Ace said, you can't play this game with idiots around. Who knows, he could even be the CIA agent, since Caller assigns it and not the mafia.

Ace

United States16096 Posts

March 08 2010 02:20 GMT

#518

What fucking plan do yo possibly have as a fucking medic that can possibly wtf own Mafia in a game with DAYKILLS? If your plan was that good surely you'd do the pro town thing and POST IN THE THREAD instead of Pming me after I warned you about doing so? Whatever, you die tomorrow. I don't have time for useless players.

Ace

United States16096 Posts

March 08 2010 02:22 GMT

#519

On March 08 2010 11:18 Iaaan wrote:
I might just kill BM tomorrow, people like him degrade the quality of every game, not just this one. I don't know about malongo, I don't think he is going to do anything dumb anymore, I mean, I can see why he wanted chezinu dead, but BM has a history of stupidity, like Ace said, you can't play this game with idiots around. Who knows, he could even be the CIA agent, since Caller assigns it and not the mafia.

I guess whichever one of us gets there first. Either way just keep track of who's used a shot and we're fine.

citi.zen

2509 Posts

March 08 2010 02:24 GMT

#520

So Ace, right now you want to kill: BM, ShoCkeyy and Malongo. None of which you suspect being red. Do I have it right? Do you see something wrong with this pattern?