|
On January 26 2010 02:59 Ng5 wrote:Show nested quote +On January 26 2010 02:22 Phrujbaz wrote:
I remember somebody arguing (ng5?) that it doesn't matter if we could reduce kill power with double lynch or not. If we need to kill three Mafia, it doesn't matter if we first kill two and then one or if we kill one first and then two. I think that logic is wrong.
First you have to remember that our double lynches are limited. That alone means we should only use one if we really think we can lynch two Mafia. Furthermore, there is always the risk of lynching two innocents. If we cannot reduce kill power right away it doesn't make sense to use double lynch already. We don't lose anything by waiting a day in that case. And we gain more information, leading to better informed lynches.
We NEVER gain anything by using double lynch on a day where even killing two Mafia wouldn't reduce kill power.
What does complicate things is that we cannot vote double lynch into place for today's lynch. It's always for the day after. So we have to think ahead a little. If we have a 100% confirmed Mafia, then we know that tomorrow there will be one less Mafia. That means we might want to use double lynch tomorrow, which means we have to vote for it today.
When would we have such a situation? I think we need three Mafia suspects, at least one of which is very solid. We lynch the solid Mafia today, vote for double lynch, and have the potential to kill two more Mafia the next day (we'd even have more clues than we do today).
I don't think we should use double lynch yet. I don't know how you guys are feeling but I'm not very confident in anyone being Mafia. AT ALL I also said that if maths and logic doesn't rub off on you I won't explain again, nor in more detail.
I agree with you in the fact that it doesn't matter which order we take the mafia down, if we have 2 suspects to take down we do it - even if it doesn't reduce their KP. It seems that you, now correct me if I'm wrong, are ignoring the possibility that we won't have 2 mafia to lynch. You are one of the biggest supporters of using the double lynches asap, but you even abstained from voting in this last lynch. It seems that you don't think there are mafia we have figured out to lynch either, but still push for the double lynch. So, who would be the 2 people you would have suggested double lynching tomorrow (I know we don't have day 3 clues yet). You should have at least 1 in mind if you're going to push for it so hard.
|
I have a feeling we're going to lose a lot of townies to mod killing.
|
Lol irony.
I'm not saying you don't help - I'd have to review your posts first. But I find it funny 10 minutes after you were accused of popping out only when accused you popped out. The timing is hilarious.
|
Ok, so what I just did was compare postcounts vs post on the site in the last week in general. The high post count on the site in general gets rid of the "don't have time" issue.
Mystlord
JohannesH
skronch
These are the three names that stood out on that cross check. Skronch especially ... with almost 100 posts in the last week and only 1 here.
|
It is too far out to say, the deadline for the next lynch vote is a little over 2 days away still. A lot can still happen. I was just throwing the facts out for now.
|
"1. Posting after death. One polite goodbye post is acceptable but please do not post anything which could POSSIBLY affect the game."
Well here is my polite good bye. It was fun playing with yall, good luck to the remaining townies; I think you might need it at this point. Why didn't Zona and Faronel come with me! lol.
And yes I did just turn into a body guard, Incognito edited it to reflect that I was a bodyguard, not just green.
|
EDIT: Eh, I'm not supposed to post when I'm dead, it wouldn't have affected anything but I deleted it anyway.
|
Oh it's over ... GG everyone. Hope to see yall in future mafia games.
|
The only problem would be if the mafia start hitting eachother haha.
|
Yeah i had my suspicions about DrH early on - but I didn't really do anything with them because I thought if I did no one would side with me, and I would just get killed one way or another. Glad it worked out for the rest of the town, things ended up busting wide open - unfortunately after I had died lol.
|
I only really had 2 mafia pegged (DrH and Keit) at the time I was killed. I suspected a couple others that ended up being right - but I certainly wasn't sure. There is also some townies that I had pegged wrong - ghote as an example. I wasn't sure what to think of him and he ended up being a medic lol.
|
On February 02 2010 06:29 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
We communicated via mIRC at #eggsalad
mostly myself/mystlord/keit, but keit eventually tilted and started acting very strangely. He told Jugan in a PM that I was an asshole and told everyone to lynch him and that this game is hella gay after painting me as mafia for no reason
phrujbaz/hyperbola occasionally dropped in, but there was zero communication with derfboy
it was mostly me and mystlord conversing over irc
Oh so that whole arguments and voting for eachother was real. I assumed it was staged to throw suspicion off the other if one of you got found out lol. It was when I decided that I thought Keit was definitely mafia.
|
It makes sense now lol. At the time after reading it all I was like ... ok they are both mafia, but why the heck would they be doing this? Is it staged? So why did Keit flip out like that?
|
Yeah citi.zen ... I thought it was the same kind of deal.
|
On February 03 2010 09:03 citi.zen wrote:
I don't know if a "rematch " per se is possible, it would have all new "teams".
It would work out extremely well for the town lol.
|
I updated my profile for the next time I'm involved in a mafia game.
|
On February 04 2010 12:14 citi.zen wrote:In this particular game we caught 6/7 mafia yet we misinterpreted clues all the way to the end. Just ask poor Hobbes. + Show Spoiler +On January 29 2010 13:07 [NyC]HoBbes wrote:
all I know is finally the clues dont suggest me... considering the last few nights I was expecting tonight to be "his orange, stripy attacker left a great deal of fur and tuna fish behind..." Sorry. Could not resist.
Well I was right about the knife pointing to DrH from killer 2 on the first batch of clues. That's the only one I got right b4 I died though.
|
Guess he's considering BCs number 17, eventhough they were both numbered 16. You playing in 18?
|
Oh din see you when I glanced at it lol. I'll be playing too.
|
Oh snap! But which family .......... DEN DUN DEN
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
