TL Mafia XV - Page 3

On October 22 2009 13:47 redtooth wrote:
see this makes no sense. i'm sorry to keep bringing this up but this is in no way an "angry individual" talks to someone he is angry at. if you were really pissed off at L and genuinely defensive (and not psuedo-defensive) then the last thing you would care about is what L thinks.

also vet idea was ruined as soon as it was posted in public. godfather can take any role and can roleclaim it without much risk because DT check would show him being blue.

On October 22 2009 15:57 redtooth wrote:
so who should we lynch? should we go with the killing-the-vet plan and risk cutting off our own heads? what about just killing a random person off the list? we don't have any other good lynch candidates at the moment except motbob who i assume will be dead before long.

anyways, assuming tricode is townie, killing him leaves DT with a lot of options and a good deal of information. i was thinking about this earlier and the way incognito's plan will work out will allow DT to establish the color of ONE type of player (green, red, blue). there are three possible scenarios:

i believe the last bit is the most important aspect we have to focus on. obviously we want to lynch a mafia and that would give us the best scenario (DT knowing the color of mafia in his checks, knowing the color of town-aligned players in checks) and lynching a blue is bad (no explanation needed). but let's look at the scenario where a townie is lynched. using tricode as an example:
the scenario the DT is left with is not bad. whenever a check flips townie, DT can and should ignore that individual (he should not roleclaim because there is a chance that townie is a godfather). however, in the case that a check flips one of the other two colors, the individual has a special role and should be scrutinized and pressed by the DT. that person is either mafia (who the DT should try to get lynched) or a special town role (who the DT should try to form a circle with).

so in the end, i still stand by the idea that we should kill tricode on Day 2. he is a detriment to the town regardless of his role. there are some signs pointing to him being a mafia and lynching him in that case would be very good. also, the lynch is not totally useless if tricode turns out to be a townie. the information DTs gain about their sanity is priceless as they are absolutely useless without knowing their own sanity. killing tricode is a win-win scenario.

On October 23 2009 01:15 Shikyo wrote:

I sounded credible? Or tried... well I was just being sarcastic, basically it means that people have bad games, although you had quite a bit of unwelcome effect on the game even though you weren't playing.


Tricode: Two lynches of different colors are enough. One lynch gives it a 50/50.

On October 23 2009 07:52 HeavOnEarth wrote:
i mean i want tricode to be pardoner, not mayor
hell tricode wants to lynch YOU (noted in his platform)
mafia pardoner , which pyrr could possibly be = good bye double lynch at end of game and o oops
also im not good at interpreting poems =/

On October 24 2009 02:41 redtooth wrote:
mafia please do us all a favor and kill this man. BC's rhymes are a bit humorous and require effort on his part to keep us slightly entertained (or annoyed) but this guy is just derailing the thread and being an overall idiot. and he doesn't even put in any effort in being annoying (copy pasta scrub)! and wtf does shikyo have to do with anything? you deserve to die. a vigi hit on you might actually be worth it.
+ Show Spoiler +

On October 24 2009 16:12 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote:
DT/Vet plan I suppose. And yeah I guess we should. But we kind of need to see who dies tonight first. The vet plan. I guess we COULD start that plan now, the DT's can check people as of now.

RIGHT NOW. DT's please do NOT use your checks yet.

Edit: Fixed tags.

On October 25 2009 05:41 Vivi57 wrote:
Someone explain to me why we shouldn't post the bg names publicly.

2 mafia: massive protection for pyrr and ace

1 green 1 mafia: still very strong protection because they'd be sacrificing one of their own for ace and pyrr

2 green: this puts the mafia in a hard spot unless one of them is a vet. They'll have to decide whether they want to waste a nights worth of hits just for the possibilty they can kill ace and pyrr the next day. It'll make the medic mindgame harder for sure, but historically, medics have missed every night anyway.

On October 25 2009 05:58 iNfuNdiBuLuM wrote:
That said, since there has been no veteran claim yet, I think it's safe to say that there is either no veteran or that motbob is the veteran. Thus, the move rests on Pyrr for now;