|
thedeadhaji
39489 Posts
Starcraft TiVo: Week 12
by thedeadhaji
TeamLiquid: Final Edits
I sense that I am becoming increasingly picky about which games deserve to be on this list. Survivor, OSC, and even OSL were all disappointing. The OSL games may have been exciting live, but as vods they simply cannot stand up to the scrutiny.
I watched Savior vs Bisu over 10 times, trying desperately to convince myself that they were somehow good games. Unfortunately, they weren't. If you want to read (ie be spoiled) about what happened and my take on it, you can read it here
So as usual, the best games of the week happened in Proleague (along with 60 boring as hell games as well). The center expansions on Bakemagoji were used for the first time in Tester vs Hero, Boxer and Free scrambled around in a messy but entertaining matchup, and we saw the best ZvZ game in a long time from Odin and Hyuk.
Oh, and the Estro vs Hanbit team game was hilarious.
Shinhan Proleague: Week 9
1v1
2007 - 12 - 01 eStro vs WeMade game 2 - Tester vs Hero on Baekmagoji
TLPD VOD LINK
2007 - 12 - 02 Ace vs Hanbit game 4 - Boxer vs Free on Monty Hall SE
TLPD VOD LINK
2007 - 12 - 03 Lecaf vs MBC game 1 - Hiya vs Bisu on Ungoro Crater
TLPD VOD LINK
2007 - 12 - 04 CJ vs KTF game 4 - Xellos vs 815 on Blue Storm
TLPD VOD LINK
2007 - 12 - 04 CJ vs KTF Ace Match - Much vs Haran on Katrina
TLPD VOD LINK
2007 - 12 - 04 Samsung vs SKT1 game 1 - Odin vs Hyuk on Python
TLPD VOD LINK
2007 - 12 - 04 Samsung vs SKT1 Ace Match - Stork vs iloveoov on Baekmagoji
TLPD VOD LINK
2v2
2007 - 12 - 01 eStro vs WeMade game 3 - Cool/Sangho vs Ho/Hoony on Hwangsanbul
TLPD VOD LINK
2007 - 12 - 03 OGN vs STX game 3 - Flower/Bifrost vs Calm/Soo on Hwangsanbul
TLPD VOD LINK
2007 - 12 - 05 eStro vs Hanbit game 3 - Cool/Sangho vs Max/Piano
TLPD VOD LINK
GOM TV MSL S4 Survivor Tournament
Group A
2007 - 11 - 29 GOM TV MSL S4 Survivor Group A game 3 - Anytime vs GoRush on Blue Storm
TLPD VOD LINK
Group B
None
Group C
2007 - 12 - 01 GOM TV MSL S4 Survivor Group C game 5 - Firebathero vs Pusan on Python
TLPD VOD LINK
Ever OSL: Week 8 (ro8 Week 2)
2007 - 11 - 30 EVER OSL ro8 week 2 - Upmagic vs Hwasin game 3 on Katrina
TLPD VOD LINK
2007 - 11 - 30 EVER OSL ro8 week 2 - Bisu vs Savior game 2 on Katrina
TLPD VOD LINK
2007 - 11 - 30 EVER OSL ro8 week 2 - Bisu vs Savior game 3 on Fantasy II
TLPD VOD LINK
Ongamenet Star Challenge 2007 Season 2: Group F
None
|
thedeadhaji
39489 Posts
If you wish to argue that Bisu vs Savior should be higher, please go watch the 500 odd games that have been played thus far this season, then make your case.
Even comparing them to the other games this week, it should be clear that they are simply inferior in entertainment value.
Impulsively responding with "What this is nonsense aoiehfal;skdjfowier" without the proper due diligence isn't going to make a very good case.
|
u gotta skate8152 Posts
|
thedeadhaji
39489 Posts
I'm retarded TT
thanks kizz
|
|
|
|
|
uhm... hero vs tester not working on TLPD?
and thanks tons for this, bored at work so going to start watching :D
hope you'll never get bored of making these!
|
On December 08 2007 03:38 PePe QuiCoSE wrote:
hero vs tester not working on TLPD? Yeah, something seems to be broken there. But BaeZZi has it up on youtube; it's embedded in my previous post. (Also added FBH vs. Pusan because haji is obviously an inattentive slacker that managed to miss some of the games last week.)
|
Thanks again Haji, greatly appreciated.
|
United States7488 Posts
Great job as usual.
I'd ask how you have time to watch every single game, but I am kind of wondering the same thing about myself.
|
|
|
Aotearoa39261 Posts
mmm i kinda feel pusan vs anytime (mbc vs lecaf s2 or s5) deserves to be there, top tier pvp at its best - atleast i think its better than the puasn fbh game
|
On December 08 2007 03:00 thedeadhaji wrote:
If you wish to argue that Bisu vs Savior should be higher, please go watch the 500 odd games that have been played thus far this season, then make your case.
Even comparing them to the other games this week, it should be clear that they are simply inferior in entertainment value.
Impulsively responding with "What this is nonsense aoiehfal;skdjfowier" without the proper due diligence isn't going to make a very good case.
haji, I can accept that you did not find the Bisu vs Savior games as exciting as some of the others that took place during that week. + Show Spoiler +What I can't understand is how you can rank the third game - a solid one-sided harass into macro-rape - higher than the intense, pitched battles of the second game. Maybe it's less impressive with a better understanding of game mechanics than mine, but it really seemed like Bisu was going down once his nat nexus was destroyed, and his comeback was very dramatic.
|
thedeadhaji
39489 Posts
>plexa
Yea I think I threw out a lot of games I could have given 3/5 to b/c I was getting so damn sick of standard decent/solid but unspectacular games and it's always a pain in the ass deciding what is borderline acceptable or not.
|
Baezzi: what are those red and blue bars showing before the game? ( @ 0:18 and @ 0:54) It seems that red one is for a win and blue is for a loss against a specific player. But why do they have different number of bars for each win and loss?
i'm not baezzi but oh well.
those bars represent the current play-skill of the players that a particular player has won or lost against
for example bisu would be like 4bars. when like KTF_yellow wud be like 1 or 2.
Is this actually what the bars mean?
|
thedeadhaji
39489 Posts
I havent the slightest idea Oo
yakii?
|
wheres BySun vs daezang? was it not a good game?
|
yakii
Korea (South)1448 Posts
That bars are related with wp rank. I'll make a thread if there's no thread about it.
|
On December 08 2007 08:47 Dark_Luster wrote:
was it not a good game? Correct, it was not.
|
United States5262 Posts
hajiiiiiiii I'm still on Week 7 T_T slow down!!!
|
Could you also list the games with ceremonies amusing enough to be worth watching?
|
Aotearoa39261 Posts
On December 08 2007 07:23 thedeadhaji wrote:
>plexa
Yea I think I threw out a lot of games I could have given 3/5 to b/c I was getting so damn sick of standard decent/solid but unspectacular games and it's always a pain in the ass deciding what is borderline acceptable or not. fair call
|
july raping backho was very entertaining
|
yakii
Korea (South)1448 Posts
On December 08 2007 08:28 ShaLLoW[baY] wrote:Show nested quote +Baezzi: what are those red and blue bars showing before the game? ( @ 0:18 and @ 0:54) It seems that red one is for a win and blue is for a loss against a specific player. But why do they have different number of bars for each win and loss? Show nested quote +i'm not baezzi but oh well.
those bars represent the current play-skill of the players that a particular player has won or lost against
for example bisu would be like 4bars. when like KTF_yellow wud be like 1 or 2. Is this actually what the bars mean?
|
Ah, the mystery solved at last. Thanks yakii!
|
So a good player will have massive red bars and any blue bars would be small?
|
yakii
Korea (South)1448 Posts
On December 09 2007 10:22 ShaLLoW[baY] wrote:
So a good player will have massive red bars and any blue bars would be small?
If he lose to good player, yes, that blue bars will be small.
|
are the bars in relation to the player at hand, ie if bisu lost to someone decent but someone bad compared to him, would it be 3 blue bars or say, 1 or 2?
|
yakii
Korea (South)1448 Posts
On December 09 2007 11:07 intotherainx wrote:
are the bars in relation to the player at hand, ie if bisu lost to someone decent but someone bad compared to him, would it be 3 blue bars or say, 1 or 2?
nope, it doesn't compare within the players. It only depends on how his opponent's WP rank (MBCgame's own ranking system) + Show Spoiler [W.P rank] + is high or low.
i.e Bisu has better wp points than savior but he would still get 4 red bars if he beats savior and if he lose to savior he would get 1 blue bar.
|
Melbourne5338 Posts
thanks for the explanation yakii. thats an interesting system.
|
yeah thanx.
Concerning Odin v Hyuk:
+ Show Spoiler +What exactly happened that made Odin lose? It seemed so close the whole time, and it actually looked like Odin got a small lead (killing Hyuk's ovies in the center, a little ling harassment). But it looked like Hyuk won all the muta/scourge battles. The only thing I noticed is that Odin didn't spread his mutas and Hyuk did. Is that really so important, or am I missing some other reason why Odin lost?
|
On December 08 2007 07:23 defenestrate wrote:Show nested quote +On December 08 2007 03:00 thedeadhaji wrote:
If you wish to argue that Bisu vs Savior should be higher, please go watch the 500 odd games that have been played thus far this season, then make your case.
Even comparing them to the other games this week, it should be clear that they are simply inferior in entertainment value.
Impulsively responding with "What this is nonsense aoiehfal;skdjfowier" without the proper due diligence isn't going to make a very good case. haji, I can accept that you did not find the Bisu vs Savior games as exciting as some of the others that took place during that week. + Show Spoiler +What I can't understand is how you can rank the third game - a solid one-sided harass into macro-rape - higher than the intense, pitched battles of the second game. Maybe it's less impressive with a better understanding of game mechanics than mine, but it really seemed like Bisu was going down once his nat nexus was destroyed, and his comeback was very dramatic.
agree 100% with this
|
thedeadhaji
39489 Posts
oh well. In any case having these sorts of "these games should be in too!" or "i dont agree with the way you rated these" are really good in providing secondary input for others to base their decision of what to watch on, so please keep them coming in the future ^^
|
Yuk, the first game listed Tester vs Hero on Baekmagoji was a 40 minute snorefest.
+ Show Spoiler +Blue had it won 20 minutes in, purple just dragged it on.
|
deadhaji the Haran vs Much game is on Katrina
Btw, what a good enterntaining game that was
|
thedeadhaji
39489 Posts
fixed all links in op.
edit: just did the ungoro -> katrina thing for haran vs much.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT![[image loading]](http://www.teamliquid.net/staff/thedeadhaji/45star.gif)
![[image loading]](http://www.teamliquid.net/staff/thedeadhaji/4star.gif)
![[image loading]](http://www.teamliquid.net/staff/thedeadhaji/5star.gif)
![[image loading]](http://www.teamliquid.net/staff/thedeadhaji/35star.gif)
![[image loading]](http://www.teamliquid.net/staff/thedeadhaji/3star.gif)
TiVo is always a good guide for me.![[image loading]](http://pds7.egloos.com/pds/200712/09/08/d0015408_475b330847043.jpg)
