|
If you come in here looking for "anime recommendations" then please refer to this chart before posting: Anime Recommendations (as of may 2014). We also have an IRC channel called #tladt where we all hang out. The channel is on Rizon, not QuakeNet! Feel free to check it out. TLADT discord is Discord.ggFor currently airing anime, please see Anichart.net |
On September 26 2012 23:39 OutlaW- wrote:
fate/zero
hyouka
steins;gate
controversial but i'd put sao there
Agree with steins gate dont know about fate/zero/hyouka, but sao definitely doesnt belong on the list. Imo its mediocre at best and the forced drama makes it more comical than moving. If youve seen ep 12: + Show Spoiler + the part where he starts slamming the keyboard (which is still there for some reason) and without seeing anything can make a new item into the game of their 'kid' which is just a computer program to begin with..... yeah...
|
F/Z
Madoka
Test to Baka
Nisemonogatari
Hanairo
AW
are no brainers from last couple years
some maybe (all better than a good portion of the ones on the list):
Binbougami
Ben-To
Haganai
Horizon
Idolmaster
Hourou Musuko
Anyway I find the list's lack of Last Exile disturbing.
|
On September 26 2012 23:56 solidbebe wrote:Show nested quote +On September 26 2012 23:39 OutlaW- wrote:
fate/zero
hyouka
steins;gate
controversial but i'd put sao there Agree with steins gate dont know about fate/zero/hyouka, but sao definitely doesnt belong on the list. Imo its mediocre at best and the forced drama makes it more comical than moving. If youve seen ep 12: + Show Spoiler + the part where he starts slamming the keyboard (which is still there for some reason) and without seeing anything can make a new item into the game of their 'kid' which is just a computer program to begin with..... yeah...
The situation makes a lot more sense in short story than in anime because the books are clearer thematically for this particular kind of plot device in SAO, anime has yet to even bother to establish the point for whatever reason.
On September 27 2012 00:04 ragz_gt wrote:
F/Z
Madoka
Test to Baka
Nisemonogatari
Hanairo
AW
are no brainers from last couple years
some maybe (all better than a good portion of the ones on the list):
Binbougami
Ben-To
Haganai
Horizon
Idolmaster
Hourou Musuko
Anyway I find the list's lack of Last Exile disturbing.
I think the majority of the 'maybe' part of the list would get you hanged, so would stuff like hanairo and AW.
Pretty sure Last Exile is on that list.
|
We shouldn't touch that chart, other than maybe adding F/Z. Gundam Unicorn isn't finished, and I wouldn't put it on the mecha part either. There is a reason stuff like Zeta Gundam or Turn A isn't on there. SAO sucks huge dick, and shouldn't even be in contention for being up there. Also its not finished, and will only get worse.
|
On September 27 2012 00:16 Ecael wrote:Show nested quote +On September 26 2012 23:56 solidbebe wrote:On September 26 2012 23:39 OutlaW- wrote:
fate/zero
hyouka
steins;gate
controversial but i'd put sao there Agree with steins gate dont know about fate/zero/hyouka, but sao definitely doesnt belong on the list. Imo its mediocre at best and the forced drama makes it more comical than moving. If youve seen ep 12: + Show Spoiler + the part where he starts slamming the keyboard (which is still there for some reason) and without seeing anything can make a new item into the game of their 'kid' which is just a computer program to begin with..... yeah... The situation makes a lot more sense in short story than in anime because the books are clearer thematically for this particular kind of plot device in SAO, anime has yet to even bother to establish the point for whatever reason. Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 00:04 ragz_gt wrote:
F/Z
Madoka
Test to Baka
Nisemonogatari
Hanairo
AW
are no brainers from last couple years
some maybe (all better than a good portion of the ones on the list):
Binbougami
Ben-To
Haganai
Horizon
Idolmaster
Hourou Musuko
Anyway I find the list's lack of Last Exile disturbing. I think the majority of the 'maybe' part of the list would get you hanged, so would stuff like hanairo and AW. Pretty sure Last Exile is on that list.
Nope, no last exile, though I did find Hourou Musuko there.
AW might be weaker than others but Hanairo definitely belong there. And really, you can't say any of the "maybe" weaker than stuff like Working, ef, true tears, densetsu no yuusha, hidamari sketch, manabi straight
|
On September 26 2012 23:10 Requizen wrote:
On a similar note...
Out of the past however many seasons (couple years or so), do you think there were any shows memorable or good enough to add to the "recommendation list" up at the top of the thread? Obviously there were some good ones each season, but do you think any that will keep with you over the years? Bungaku Shoujo, Steins;Gate, Hyouge Mono, Penguindrum and Idolmaster are only ones that I can think of that I would genuinely wish to recommend to someone unless they were very very specific.
I guess F/Z aswell, though it's hard to place it since it's a prequel (or sequel depending on your point of view) and IMO those should not really be on the list. I also do not think Madoka belongs on the list, it gives a pretty good impression on you initially but I do not believe it's something that will live on for longer periods of time. Though if wedid end up adding S;G there would be enough QQ to have Madoka and vice versa so whatever I guess.
Edit: Ragz, the only one better than those would be im@s, the other ones are definitively not on par when it comes to rec material.
|
On September 27 2012 00:25 ragz_gt wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 00:16 Ecael wrote:On September 26 2012 23:56 solidbebe wrote:On September 26 2012 23:39 OutlaW- wrote:
fate/zero
hyouka
steins;gate
controversial but i'd put sao there Agree with steins gate dont know about fate/zero/hyouka, but sao definitely doesnt belong on the list. Imo its mediocre at best and the forced drama makes it more comical than moving. If youve seen ep 12: + Show Spoiler + the part where he starts slamming the keyboard (which is still there for some reason) and without seeing anything can make a new item into the game of their 'kid' which is just a computer program to begin with..... yeah... The situation makes a lot more sense in short story than in anime because the books are clearer thematically for this particular kind of plot device in SAO, anime has yet to even bother to establish the point for whatever reason. On September 27 2012 00:04 ragz_gt wrote:
F/Z
Madoka
Test to Baka
Nisemonogatari
Hanairo
AW
are no brainers from last couple years
some maybe (all better than a good portion of the ones on the list):
Binbougami
Ben-To
Haganai
Horizon
Idolmaster
Hourou Musuko
Anyway I find the list's lack of Last Exile disturbing. I think the majority of the 'maybe' part of the list would get you hanged, so would stuff like hanairo and AW. Pretty sure Last Exile is on that list. Nope, no last exile, though I did find Hourou Musuko there. AW might be weaker than others but Hanairo definitely belong there. And really, you can't say any of the "maybe" weaker than stuff like Working, ef, true tears, densetsu no yuusha, hidamari sketch, manabi straight
Sure we can
|
How's the Code Geass movie?
It done yet ?
|
On September 27 2012 00:25 ragz_gt wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 00:16 Ecael wrote:On September 26 2012 23:56 solidbebe wrote:On September 26 2012 23:39 OutlaW- wrote:
fate/zero
hyouka
steins;gate
controversial but i'd put sao there Agree with steins gate dont know about fate/zero/hyouka, but sao definitely doesnt belong on the list. Imo its mediocre at best and the forced drama makes it more comical than moving. If youve seen ep 12: + Show Spoiler + the part where he starts slamming the keyboard (which is still there for some reason) and without seeing anything can make a new item into the game of their 'kid' which is just a computer program to begin with..... yeah... The situation makes a lot more sense in short story than in anime because the books are clearer thematically for this particular kind of plot device in SAO, anime has yet to even bother to establish the point for whatever reason. On September 27 2012 00:04 ragz_gt wrote:
F/Z
Madoka
Test to Baka
Nisemonogatari
Hanairo
AW
are no brainers from last couple years
some maybe (all better than a good portion of the ones on the list):
Binbougami
Ben-To
Haganai
Horizon
Idolmaster
Hourou Musuko
Anyway I find the list's lack of Last Exile disturbing. I think the majority of the 'maybe' part of the list would get you hanged, so would stuff like hanairo and AW. Pretty sure Last Exile is on that list. Nope, no last exile, though I did find Hourou Musuko there. AW might be weaker than others but Hanairo definitely belong there. And really, you can't say any of the "maybe" weaker than stuff like Working, ef, true tears, densetsu no yuusha, hidamari sketch, manabi straight
denyuuden is fine since the anime cut back on dango significantly, ef is fine, working is better comedy than everything you've listed, so is hidamari. idk about manabi straight though. idk who left True Tears on that list but I do recall people wanting to remove it, I think in the end I didn't bother making any points about it because back then things with eufonius doing op/ed was still rare, so better one show on list with that than not 
Binbougami is a shitty as hell half-assed parody, I'd even put seitokai no ichizon before it. Bento is retarded as well, you can't even get the hotblood shounen sense from it when you think about how they are fighting over...bento. Let's not even go into how bad haganai is both as parody (which it discarded quickly) and romance (which there isn't any of). If you want to suggest it from a fanservice point of view then why not just put tolove or something? Horizon I can't suggest anyone to watch in good conscience. Idolmaster is a niche pick at best, though I think we left k-on on that list so if people really wanted to throw more moe based titles, why not.
and I am pretty sure Last Exile is on it because I think literally everyone in the thread has enjoyed it lol.
Oh, and if you are gonna put hanairo I'd rather put taritari, at least in terms of shit that PA Works put out tari tari has more going for it than the silly show that's supposed to be about drama but doesn't have drama. Or maybe it is supposed to be a slice of life, except it doesn't do anything that old shows haven't covered. Even in terms of girls it loses to Tari Tari lol.
|
On September 27 2012 00:25 ragz_gt wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 00:16 Ecael wrote:On September 26 2012 23:56 solidbebe wrote:On September 26 2012 23:39 OutlaW- wrote:
fate/zero
hyouka
steins;gate
controversial but i'd put sao there Agree with steins gate dont know about fate/zero/hyouka, but sao definitely doesnt belong on the list. Imo its mediocre at best and the forced drama makes it more comical than moving. If youve seen ep 12: + Show Spoiler + the part where he starts slamming the keyboard (which is still there for some reason) and without seeing anything can make a new item into the game of their 'kid' which is just a computer program to begin with..... yeah... The situation makes a lot more sense in short story than in anime because the books are clearer thematically for this particular kind of plot device in SAO, anime has yet to even bother to establish the point for whatever reason. On September 27 2012 00:04 ragz_gt wrote:
F/Z
Madoka
Test to Baka
Nisemonogatari
Hanairo
AW
are no brainers from last couple years
some maybe (all better than a good portion of the ones on the list):
Binbougami
Ben-To
Haganai
Horizon
Idolmaster
Hourou Musuko
Anyway I find the list's lack of Last Exile disturbing. I think the majority of the 'maybe' part of the list would get you hanged, so would stuff like hanairo and AW. Pretty sure Last Exile is on that list. Nope, no last exile, though I did find Hourou Musuko there. AW might be weaker than others but Hanairo definitely belong there. And really, you can't say any of the "maybe" weaker than stuff like Working, ef, true tears, densetsu no yuusha, hidamari sketch, manabi straight
Stuff like Hidamari sketch being there is already enough of a compromise, besides those shows dont make a good portion of the list and are not particularly worse than Haganai or Ben-to, or Hanairo oorrr AW lol..
Its genre specific anyway. Even if Ben-to is better than I dont know.. true tears. Your cant really replace it can you..
|
Steins gate actually reaaally belongs on that list imo. Sure it had some flaws but what anime doesnt? Its definitely a memorable anime.
|
On September 27 2012 00:32 Sentenal wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 00:25 ragz_gt wrote:On September 27 2012 00:16 Ecael wrote:On September 26 2012 23:56 solidbebe wrote:On September 26 2012 23:39 OutlaW- wrote:
fate/zero
hyouka
steins;gate
controversial but i'd put sao there Agree with steins gate dont know about fate/zero/hyouka, but sao definitely doesnt belong on the list. Imo its mediocre at best and the forced drama makes it more comical than moving. If youve seen ep 12: + Show Spoiler + the part where he starts slamming the keyboard (which is still there for some reason) and without seeing anything can make a new item into the game of their 'kid' which is just a computer program to begin with..... yeah... The situation makes a lot more sense in short story than in anime because the books are clearer thematically for this particular kind of plot device in SAO, anime has yet to even bother to establish the point for whatever reason. On September 27 2012 00:04 ragz_gt wrote:
F/Z
Madoka
Test to Baka
Nisemonogatari
Hanairo
AW
are no brainers from last couple years
some maybe (all better than a good portion of the ones on the list):
Binbougami
Ben-To
Haganai
Horizon
Idolmaster
Hourou Musuko
Anyway I find the list's lack of Last Exile disturbing. I think the majority of the 'maybe' part of the list would get you hanged, so would stuff like hanairo and AW. Pretty sure Last Exile is on that list. Nope, no last exile, though I did find Hourou Musuko there. AW might be weaker than others but Hanairo definitely belong there. And really, you can't say any of the "maybe" weaker than stuff like Working, ef, true tears, densetsu no yuusha, hidamari sketch, manabi straight Sure we can
Really?
Densetsu no Yuusha is one of the worst butchered show in recent memory, while Manabi Straight was fun (and Hayashibara Megumi made a cameo at end), not exactly something you remember. True Tears just ran to a totally random direction for some reason and along with ef while worked, not exactly a masterpiece, I'd recommend Oretachi ni Tsubasa wa Nai (not that I would) before either. Hidamari Sketch... only thing it got going is that alot girls like it (and nowhere near the level Aria).
|
On September 27 2012 00:36 Ecael wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 00:25 ragz_gt wrote:On September 27 2012 00:16 Ecael wrote:On September 26 2012 23:56 solidbebe wrote:On September 26 2012 23:39 OutlaW- wrote:
fate/zero
hyouka
steins;gate
controversial but i'd put sao there Agree with steins gate dont know about fate/zero/hyouka, but sao definitely doesnt belong on the list. Imo its mediocre at best and the forced drama makes it more comical than moving. If youve seen ep 12: + Show Spoiler + the part where he starts slamming the keyboard (which is still there for some reason) and without seeing anything can make a new item into the game of their 'kid' which is just a computer program to begin with..... yeah... The situation makes a lot more sense in short story than in anime because the books are clearer thematically for this particular kind of plot device in SAO, anime has yet to even bother to establish the point for whatever reason. On September 27 2012 00:04 ragz_gt wrote:
F/Z
Madoka
Test to Baka
Nisemonogatari
Hanairo
AW
are no brainers from last couple years
some maybe (all better than a good portion of the ones on the list):
Binbougami
Ben-To
Haganai
Horizon
Idolmaster
Hourou Musuko
Anyway I find the list's lack of Last Exile disturbing. I think the majority of the 'maybe' part of the list would get you hanged, so would stuff like hanairo and AW. Pretty sure Last Exile is on that list. Nope, no last exile, though I did find Hourou Musuko there. AW might be weaker than others but Hanairo definitely belong there. And really, you can't say any of the "maybe" weaker than stuff like Working, ef, true tears, densetsu no yuusha, hidamari sketch, manabi straight and I am pretty sure Last Exile is on it because I think literally everyone in the thread has enjoyed it lol.
Nope... I went over it like 10 times, which is why I recommend it every time.
|
On September 27 2012 00:44 ragz_gt wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 00:32 Sentenal wrote:On September 27 2012 00:25 ragz_gt wrote:On September 27 2012 00:16 Ecael wrote:On September 26 2012 23:56 solidbebe wrote:On September 26 2012 23:39 OutlaW- wrote:
fate/zero
hyouka
steins;gate
controversial but i'd put sao there Agree with steins gate dont know about fate/zero/hyouka, but sao definitely doesnt belong on the list. Imo its mediocre at best and the forced drama makes it more comical than moving. If youve seen ep 12: + Show Spoiler + the part where he starts slamming the keyboard (which is still there for some reason) and without seeing anything can make a new item into the game of their 'kid' which is just a computer program to begin with..... yeah... The situation makes a lot more sense in short story than in anime because the books are clearer thematically for this particular kind of plot device in SAO, anime has yet to even bother to establish the point for whatever reason. On September 27 2012 00:04 ragz_gt wrote:
F/Z
Madoka
Test to Baka
Nisemonogatari
Hanairo
AW
are no brainers from last couple years
some maybe (all better than a good portion of the ones on the list):
Binbougami
Ben-To
Haganai
Horizon
Idolmaster
Hourou Musuko
Anyway I find the list's lack of Last Exile disturbing. I think the majority of the 'maybe' part of the list would get you hanged, so would stuff like hanairo and AW. Pretty sure Last Exile is on that list. Nope, no last exile, though I did find Hourou Musuko there. AW might be weaker than others but Hanairo definitely belong there. And really, you can't say any of the "maybe" weaker than stuff like Working, ef, true tears, densetsu no yuusha, hidamari sketch, manabi straight Sure we can Really? Densetsu no Yuusha is one of the worst butchered show in recent memory, while Manabi Straight was fun (and Hayashibara Megumi made a cameo at end), not exactly something you remember. True Tears just ran to a totally random direction for some reason and along with ef while worked, not exactly a masterpiece, I'd recommend Oretachi ni Tsubasa wa Nai (not that I would) before either. Hidamari Sketch... only thing it got going is that alot girls like it (and nowhere near the level Aria).
If your gonna harp on the moeblobs then suggest alternate moeblobs or can it.
Couldnt give a shit about Yuusha..
EF is pretty popular and well True Tears does generic better than most other shows. Doesnt really warrant replacing mediocre with juiced up mediocre.
|
On September 27 2012 00:44 ragz_gt wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 00:32 Sentenal wrote:On September 27 2012 00:25 ragz_gt wrote:On September 27 2012 00:16 Ecael wrote:On September 26 2012 23:56 solidbebe wrote:On September 26 2012 23:39 OutlaW- wrote:
fate/zero
hyouka
steins;gate
controversial but i'd put sao there Agree with steins gate dont know about fate/zero/hyouka, but sao definitely doesnt belong on the list. Imo its mediocre at best and the forced drama makes it more comical than moving. If youve seen ep 12: + Show Spoiler + the part where he starts slamming the keyboard (which is still there for some reason) and without seeing anything can make a new item into the game of their 'kid' which is just a computer program to begin with..... yeah... The situation makes a lot more sense in short story than in anime because the books are clearer thematically for this particular kind of plot device in SAO, anime has yet to even bother to establish the point for whatever reason. On September 27 2012 00:04 ragz_gt wrote:
F/Z
Madoka
Test to Baka
Nisemonogatari
Hanairo
AW
are no brainers from last couple years
some maybe (all better than a good portion of the ones on the list):
Binbougami
Ben-To
Haganai
Horizon
Idolmaster
Hourou Musuko
Anyway I find the list's lack of Last Exile disturbing. I think the majority of the 'maybe' part of the list would get you hanged, so would stuff like hanairo and AW. Pretty sure Last Exile is on that list. Nope, no last exile, though I did find Hourou Musuko there. AW might be weaker than others but Hanairo definitely belong there. And really, you can't say any of the "maybe" weaker than stuff like Working, ef, true tears, densetsu no yuusha, hidamari sketch, manabi straight Sure we can Really? Densetsu no Yuusha is one of the worst butchered show in recent memory, while Manabi Straight was fun (and Hayashibara Megumi made a cameo at end), not exactly something you remember. True Tears just ran to a totally random direction for some reason and along with ef while worked, not exactly a masterpiece, I'd recommend Oretachi ni Tsubasa wa Nai (not that I would) before either. Hidamari Sketch... only thing it got going is that alot girls like it (and nowhere near the level Aria).
The thing is that the list isn't really about masterpieces, it is a mix of things that are popular, things that are 'good', and things that got something going genre/style wise.
OreTsuba is one of those things that I feel like the readers appreciate far more than people who just watched it, they also felt obliged to keep first-time viewers interested with excessive amount of fanservice, which really detracted from the show far as I was concerned. Not really something that has a wide appeal overall.
Denyuuden butchered? If anything it is a massive improvement over that horrible source material, and the mood is actually proper to lead into daidenyuuden. Maybe you liked dangos though, in which case I'd just have to regard you as insane.
True Tears is honestly borderline for me, though for that particular genre there just isn't a lot of material. I think there are a decent amount of options if we are to look at it now though, if people really care enough to update that chart for around...umm, 1.5 year's worth of animes, then why not.
Hidamari sketch started a lot of the things that we see today, I think we left Nadesico on that list, so the same logic applies here imo.
ef was honestly a rare mix of quality and pretty, even by today's standard I don't think it particularly loses out. It also doesn't have much in the ways of weaknesses to shore up either, which makes it a pretty appealing choice for something that isn't tailored to someone's specific tastes.
On September 27 2012 00:49 ragz_gt wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 00:36 Ecael wrote:On September 27 2012 00:25 ragz_gt wrote:On September 27 2012 00:16 Ecael wrote:On September 26 2012 23:56 solidbebe wrote:On September 26 2012 23:39 OutlaW- wrote:
fate/zero
hyouka
steins;gate
controversial but i'd put sao there Agree with steins gate dont know about fate/zero/hyouka, but sao definitely doesnt belong on the list. Imo its mediocre at best and the forced drama makes it more comical than moving. If youve seen ep 12: + Show Spoiler + the part where he starts slamming the keyboard (which is still there for some reason) and without seeing anything can make a new item into the game of their 'kid' which is just a computer program to begin with..... yeah... The situation makes a lot more sense in short story than in anime because the books are clearer thematically for this particular kind of plot device in SAO, anime has yet to even bother to establish the point for whatever reason. On September 27 2012 00:04 ragz_gt wrote:
F/Z
Madoka
Test to Baka
Nisemonogatari
Hanairo
AW
are no brainers from last couple years
some maybe (all better than a good portion of the ones on the list):
Binbougami
Ben-To
Haganai
Horizon
Idolmaster
Hourou Musuko
Anyway I find the list's lack of Last Exile disturbing. I think the majority of the 'maybe' part of the list would get you hanged, so would stuff like hanairo and AW. Pretty sure Last Exile is on that list. Nope, no last exile, though I did find Hourou Musuko there. AW might be weaker than others but Hanairo definitely belong there. And really, you can't say any of the "maybe" weaker than stuff like Working, ef, true tears, densetsu no yuusha, hidamari sketch, manabi straight and I am pretty sure Last Exile is on it because I think literally everyone in the thread has enjoyed it lol. Nope... I went over it like 10 times, which is why I recommend it every time.
Strange, I thought we made a point to have Last Exile on it. Hell, Last Exile should've been on the original list from 4chan.
EDIT - hm I don't see it either, odd.
|
On September 27 2012 00:44 ragz_gt wrote:
Hidamari Sketch... only thing it got going is that alot girls like it (and nowhere near the level Aria). Hidamari is wiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiide. Unlike your way of thinking. I'm starting to think you might just be a massive troll, this is beyond the level of most other tools here.
|
On September 27 2012 00:56 Elem wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 00:44 ragz_gt wrote:
Hidamari Sketch... only thing it got going is that alot girls like it (and nowhere near the level Aria). Hidamari is wiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiide. Unlike your way of thinking. I'm starting to think you might just be a massive troll, this is beyond the level of most other tools here.
Hidamari Sketch scores pretty mediocre on MAL (7.67, compared to 7.66 of Ben-to and Ben-to got more than double the votes) and slightly better on ANN. I don't really take much weight to those but if you are going to argue that it's "wiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiide", that's not a good start.
|
On September 27 2012 00:59 ragz_gt wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 00:56 Elem wrote:On September 27 2012 00:44 ragz_gt wrote:
Hidamari Sketch... only thing it got going is that alot girls like it (and nowhere near the level Aria). Hidamari is wiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiide. Unlike your way of thinking. I'm starting to think you might just be a massive troll, this is beyond the level of most other tools here. Hidamari Sketch scores pretty mediocre on MAL and slightly better on ANN. I don't really take much weight to those but if you are going to argue that it's "wiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiide", that's not a good start. If you actually took the wide comment seriously I do not know what to say, really. And judging by MAL scores, wtf? You must be pulling my leg here.
|
On September 27 2012 01:03 Elem wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 00:59 ragz_gt wrote:On September 27 2012 00:56 Elem wrote:On September 27 2012 00:44 ragz_gt wrote:
Hidamari Sketch... only thing it got going is that alot girls like it (and nowhere near the level Aria). Hidamari is wiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiide. Unlike your way of thinking. I'm starting to think you might just be a massive troll, this is beyond the level of most other tools here. Hidamari Sketch scores pretty mediocre on MAL and slightly better on ANN. I don't really take much weight to those but if you are going to argue that it's "wiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiide", that's not a good start. If you actually took the wide comment seriously I do not know what to say, really. And judging by MAL scores, wtf? You must be pulling my leg here.
MAL score is not good at determine what is good, but it is good at determine what is popular (which was your point).
|
On September 27 2012 01:05 ragz_gt wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 01:03 Elem wrote:On September 27 2012 00:59 ragz_gt wrote:On September 27 2012 00:56 Elem wrote:On September 27 2012 00:44 ragz_gt wrote:
Hidamari Sketch... only thing it got going is that alot girls like it (and nowhere near the level Aria). Hidamari is wiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiide. Unlike your way of thinking. I'm starting to think you might just be a massive troll, this is beyond the level of most other tools here. Hidamari Sketch scores pretty mediocre on MAL and slightly better on ANN. I don't really take much weight to those but if you are going to argue that it's "wiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiide", that's not a good start. If you actually took the wide comment seriously I do not know what to say, really. And judging by MAL scores, wtf? You must be pulling my leg here. MAL score is not good at determine what is good, but it is good at determine what is popular (which was your point). I never claimed so. It was you who claimed that it was mainly liked by girls.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
