|
This is a thread that is dedicated to discussing One Piece. Do not read this thread if you are not currently caught up as there are spoilers in here.
If an episode or a chapter has already been officially released, then it is not necessary to post using spoilers.
If you have knowledge on a chapter that has not been officially released yet, do NOT post it in this thread. Ignoring this public note will result in a mod action. |
On February 04 2014 00:26 17Sphynx17 wrote:Show nested quote +On February 03 2014 22:08 Omnishroud wrote:
Doesnt make sense at all.
If that was the case, why didnt roger just do it? To do the actual combining as per the theory would need time, which Roger no longer had with his declining health. Can't exactly remember the specifics of the theory but it would need an ancient weapon (Pluton/Hades - if I am not mistaken) to destroy the Red Line island. To evacuate whoever people would need the Ark. To use Sea Kings to pull the Ark would need another ancient weapon which is currently Otohime (Poseidon/Neptune). Dont know where Uranus (Zeus) fits in all this. Anyway, only looked it up now so maybe this statement is not expanded on. Don't know if someone made this claim already as well.
Roger had one Ancient weapon, and considering how a big storm suddenly destroyed shiki's entire fleet of ships yet mysteriosly left rogers ships intact in episode 0 (wich was outlined by oda and can be considered canon), im betting he did posses Uranus (wich is the weapon connected to the skies).
|
|
|
I agree with Rei, listen this.
Poseidon is in fishman island, which is the 10,000 meters below sea level. Poseidon is the god of sea.
Pluton is in Arabasta, and it has to be 10,000 meters below of sands. Pluton is the god of underworld.
Uranus is the god of sky, which has to be on 10,000 meters above the ocean.. Guess who's there? Enel... Also Uranus is the grandpa of Zeus (god of lighting). More importantly Maxim's name may have come from the "Circus Maximus", an ancient Roman chariot-racing stadium east of the temple for Summanus, the god of nocturnal thunder.
TLDR = Enel is an ancient weapon.
|
On February 04 2014 00:26 17Sphynx17 wrote:Show nested quote +On February 03 2014 22:08 Omnishroud wrote:
Doesnt make sense at all.
If that was the case, why didnt roger just do it? To do the actual combining as per the theory would need time, which Roger no longer had with his declining health. Can't exactly remember the specifics of the theory but it would need an ancient weapon (Pluton/Hades - if I am not mistaken) to destroy the Red Line island. To evacuate whoever people would need the Ark. To use Sea Kings to pull the Ark would need another ancient weapon which is currently Otohime (Poseidon/Neptune). Dont know where Uranus (Zeus) fits in all this. Anyway, only looked it up now so maybe this statement is not expanded on. Don't know if someone made this claim already as well.
Uranus counterpart is Caelus.
Zeus would be Jupiter.
|
Everything right now points thowards Dragon being the current possesor of Uranus. He has shown to posses the power to control wind, rain and thunder. We know Enels powers come from his logia fruit, wich also works as the engine of maxim.
i highly doubt Uranus is based on a mid-end logia fruit.
|
On February 04 2014 01:10 BlackMagister wrote:Seen on the One Piece reddit Zoro Mousepad
first thing that came to mind was : "that's messed up."
|
"DOWN"
This definitely says to go to Blue Sea... HOLY SHIT
+ Show Spoiler +
"GOTTA DO IT"
+ Show Spoiler +
HOLY SHIT ENEL IS COMING LOL. I suddenly got excited hahahahahahaha
|
I am sorry, but you are not the entity who decides the tier system for devil fruits.
The Goro Goro No Mi = Uranus theory is in my opinion one of the better theories of this thread.
Enel wasn't a scholar so the chance that he actually designed a flying ship that can travel into space and create thunderclouds all by himself is pretty much nonexistant. However he made others built the Arch Maxim.
And he made them build a very large ship, which is another sign that he probably did not design it himself.
If he did design it himself, he would most likely choose to make the ship smaller and not contain a doomsday machine so it would be built faster and he could go to the moon sooner. He also would probably not built that doomsday machine on the ship because he already thought himself to be invincible.
Long story short:
Enel is a tyrant, not an inventor.
The Arch Maxim has signs to be a group effort, though.
|
On February 04 2014 01:40 Mensol wrote:"DOWN" This definitely says to go to Blue Sea... HOLY SHIT + Show Spoiler +"GOTTA DO IT" + Show Spoiler +HOLY SHIT ENEL IS COMING LOL. I suddenly got excited hahahahahahaha
Kizaru's reaction:
"Oooooh, a lightning logia, how friiightening huuuuuuuh! I could potentially be in big trouble heeeeereeeee huh, but well you might be lightning but i wield the power of light itself! Now "man from the sky", feel free to test for yourself if my light photon body will conduct your electricity, huuuuuuuh? now let me ask you, have you ever experienced a kick at the speed of liiiiiiiight?
|
On February 04 2014 01:50 Mataza wrote:
I am sorry, but you are not the entity who decides the tier system for devil fruits.
Sorry, but when it comes to logias there seems to be obvious tiers that anyone with half a brain can figure out.
Magma>Fire (molten rock can smother flames)
Ice>Snow (Both are cold-based logias and the former is simply colder)
Poison Gas>Smoke (virtually the same shape of matter except the the former is practically a form of highly poisonius smoke)
Light>Lightning ("Harder, Better, Faster, Stronger")
|
On February 04 2014 00:45 sc2holar wrote:Show nested quote +On February 04 2014 00:26 17Sphynx17 wrote:On February 03 2014 22:08 Omnishroud wrote:
Doesnt make sense at all.
If that was the case, why didnt roger just do it? To do the actual combining as per the theory would need time, which Roger no longer had with his declining health. Can't exactly remember the specifics of the theory but it would need an ancient weapon (Pluton/Hades - if I am not mistaken) to destroy the Red Line island. To evacuate whoever people would need the Ark. To use Sea Kings to pull the Ark would need another ancient weapon which is currently Otohime (Poseidon/Neptune). Dont know where Uranus (Zeus) fits in all this. Anyway, only looked it up now so maybe this statement is not expanded on. Don't know if someone made this claim already as well. Roger had one Ancient weapon, and considering how a big storm suddenly destroyed shiki's entire fleet of ships yet mysteriosly left rogers ships intact in episode 0 (wich was outlined by oda and can be considered canon), im betting he did posses Uranus (wich is the weapon connected to the skies).
I don't think there is any information about Roger "having" an Ancient weapon, all Chiki says in chapter 0 is that Roger knows the location of an Ancient weapon,probably Poseidon since its location is written on Skypia's bell.
As for the storm, the traduction of the chapter greatly differs, in one (mangafox's) it's said that half of Chiki's fleet was sunk by the storm, in an other, that the storm damaged the fleet allowing Roger to sink half of it.
I would argue that more than an Ancient weapon, Roger just has "the luck" same as Luffy and that a random storm happened to save his ass against Chiki.
|
On February 04 2014 01:28 sc2holar wrote:
Everything right now points thowards Dragon being the current possesor of Uranus. He has shown to posses the power to control wind, rain and thunder. We know Enels powers come from his logia fruit, wich also works as the engine of maxim.
i highly doubt Uranus is based on a mid-end logia fruit.
Do you remember what Robin said? Amongst the many Devil Fruits that exist, the Goro Goro no Mi is one of the few considered to be unrivaled.
yeah man definitely a mid-end logia.
|
On February 04 2014 02:21 Mensol wrote:Show nested quote +On February 04 2014 01:28 sc2holar wrote:
Everything right now points thowards Dragon being the current possesor of Uranus. He has shown to posses the power to control wind, rain and thunder. We know Enels powers come from his logia fruit, wich also works as the engine of maxim.
i highly doubt Uranus is based on a mid-end logia fruit. Do you remember what Robin said? Amongst the many Devil Fruits that exist, the Goro Goro no Mi is one of the few considered to be unrivaled. yeah man definitely a mid-end logia.
It is still virtually useless against other Logias such as light, fire, sand, swamp, gas, light, magma and even paramecias such as rubber wich do not conduct electricity. Enels zapped USOPP twice and it was not enought to kill him. The Goro Goro no mi is nothing but a weaker version of the Pika Pika no Mi, in every aspect.
|
Are you kidding me? Do you really think that Oda going to kill main characters such as Usopp?
Also his fruit is better than pika pika or w/e. If Oda made Robin say something like invincible, you can't say that "his fruit is shit kekekekekekek"
|
On February 04 2014 02:26 sc2holar wrote:Show nested quote +On February 04 2014 02:21 Mensol wrote:On February 04 2014 01:28 sc2holar wrote:
Everything right now points thowards Dragon being the current possesor of Uranus. He has shown to posses the power to control wind, rain and thunder. We know Enels powers come from his logia fruit, wich also works as the engine of maxim.
i highly doubt Uranus is based on a mid-end logia fruit. Do you remember what Robin said? Amongst the many Devil Fruits that exist, the Goro Goro no Mi is one of the few considered to be unrivaled. yeah man definitely a mid-end logia. It is still virtually useless against other Logias such as light, fire, sand, swamp, gas, light, magma and even paramecias such as rubber wich do not conduct electricity. Enels zapped USOPP twice and it was not enought to kill him. The Goro Goro no mi is nothing but a weaker version of the Pika Pika no Mi, in every aspect.
lol. this is just so wrong.
Kizaru cannot even teleport, why would he be faster than Enel who can nearly pull that off. why would it be useless against other logias like magma or fire? there is no logic behind that.
fire or ice cant dmg lightning, too then? that would have to be the case according to you.
also, u mistaken the strengh of a fruit with the strengh of the fruit combined with its user.
Give Rayleigh the lightning fruit and he can literally stomp the whole world. you think a punch of rayleigh's strengh and imba haki skills combined with the speed of lightning wouldnt be absolutly insane against everything?
The fruit is insane - Enel himself wasnt. He wasnt super weak either, he was overconfident and in shock. Luffy beat him, but he shouldnt have been able to touch him - even back then when enel himself was rather weak. 2 years passed. Who knows what happened in that time.
Also, dont forget about his unrivaled observation haki skills.
|
Austria24417 Posts
We finally landed back here!
|
On February 04 2014 02:36 Mensol wrote:
Are you kidding me? Do you really think that Oda going to kill main characters such as Usopp?
Also his fruit is better than pika pika or w/e. If Oda made Robin say something like invincible, you can't say that "his fruit is shit kekekekekekek"
Its faaaaar from "shit". But there is no way you can argue that the lightning logia is more powerful than the Light logia based on logic, what we have seen in the manga and simple common sense.
The lightning Logia has far to many natural weaknesses. Its useless against elements and matter that does not conduct electicity as shown in skypeia arc, and you could add like 70% of all logias to that list. Come on, use some common sense. What Robin said at THAT point in the manga is sort of irrelevant.
|
On February 04 2014 02:42 KalWarkov wrote:Show nested quote +On February 04 2014 02:26 sc2holar wrote:On February 04 2014 02:21 Mensol wrote:On February 04 2014 01:28 sc2holar wrote:
Everything right now points thowards Dragon being the current possesor of Uranus. He has shown to posses the power to control wind, rain and thunder. We know Enels powers come from his logia fruit, wich also works as the engine of maxim.
i highly doubt Uranus is based on a mid-end logia fruit. Do you remember what Robin said? Amongst the many Devil Fruits that exist, the Goro Goro no Mi is one of the few considered to be unrivaled. yeah man definitely a mid-end logia. It is still virtually useless against other Logias such as light, fire, sand, swamp, gas, light, magma and even paramecias such as rubber wich do not conduct electricity. Enels zapped USOPP twice and it was not enought to kill him. The Goro Goro no mi is nothing but a weaker version of the Pika Pika no Mi, in every aspect. lol. this is just so wrong. Kizaru cannot even teleport, why would he be faster than Enel who can nearly pull that off. why would it be useless against other logias like magma or fire? there is no logic behind that. fire or ice cant dmg lightning, too then? that would have to be the case according to you. also, u mistaken the strengh of a fruit with the strengh of the fruit combined with its user. Give Rayleigh the lightning fruit and he can literally stomp the whole world. you think a punch of rayleigh's strengh and imba haki skills combined with the speed of lightning wouldnt be absolutly insane against everything? The fruit is insane - Enel himself wasnt. He wasnt super weak either, he was overconfident and in shock. Luffy beat him, but he shouldnt have been able to touch him - even back then when enel himself was rather weak. 2 years passed. Who knows what happened in that time. Also, dont forget about his unrivaled observation haki skills.
Magma (molten rock) and fire (combusted oxygen) does not conduct electricity.
Even if light only travels in straight lines and has to be reflected, it is still several million times faster than lightning, and from what we have seen kizarus light beams are far far more destructive than enels lightning. A single Beam can blow up several buildings or a giant battleship.
Also, Weight=Speed. Kizarus attacks (mostly kicks) are a million times faster than lightning, hence more powerful. And Kizaru can charge up these kicks in less than a split second.
|
On February 04 2014 02:44 sc2holar wrote:Show nested quote +On February 04 2014 02:36 Mensol wrote:
Are you kidding me? Do you really think that Oda going to kill main characters such as Usopp?
Also his fruit is better than pika pika or w/e. If Oda made Robin say something like invincible, you can't say that "his fruit is shit kekekekekekek" Its faaaaar from "shit". But there is no way you can argue that the lightning logia is more powerful than the Light logia based on logic, what we have seen in the manga and simple common sense. The lightning Logia has far to many natural weaknesses. Its useless against elements and matter that does not conduct electicity as shown in skypeia arc, and you could add like 70% of all logias to that list. Come on, use some common sense. What Robin said at THAT point in the manga is sort of irrelevant.
No It wasnt. You know there is a book which includes all devil fruits right?
Robin probably knew it from that book, you cant say "AT THAT POINT or shit". It's definitely the best fruit we've ever saw.
|
On February 04 2014 03:09 Mensol wrote:Show nested quote +On February 04 2014 02:44 sc2holar wrote:On February 04 2014 02:36 Mensol wrote:
Are you kidding me? Do you really think that Oda going to kill main characters such as Usopp?
Also his fruit is better than pika pika or w/e. If Oda made Robin say something like invincible, you can't say that "his fruit is shit kekekekekekek" Its faaaaar from "shit". But there is no way you can argue that the lightning logia is more powerful than the Light logia based on logic, what we have seen in the manga and simple common sense. The lightning Logia has far to many natural weaknesses. Its useless against elements and matter that does not conduct electicity as shown in skypeia arc, and you could add like 70% of all logias to that list. Come on, use some common sense. What Robin said at THAT point in the manga is sort of irrelevant. No It wasnt. You know there is a book which includes all devil fruits right? Robin probably knew it from that book, you cant say "AT THAT POINT or shit". It's definitely the best fruit we've ever saw.
If you honestly think the Lightning Logia is stronger than fruits such as Marco's Mythical Zoan fruit (Wich makes him virtually invulnarable to any attack), Borsalino's Pika Pika no Mi or BBs Yami Yami no Mi i think continuing this debate would would only serve to hurt my brain.
It has never been stated that Robin owns a book wich includes a description of every devil fruit. And how can Enels logia fruit be the strongest we have seen when Mythical Zoans are said to be more rare and powerful than logia fruits?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT![[image loading]](http://i13.mangapanda.com/one-piece/472/one-piece-1693721.jpg)
![[image loading]](http://i11.mangapanda.com/one-piece/474/one-piece-64218.jpg)
