I mean, sure it's a bit funny having this 3-game series where you can 3-0 another team but at least it's not the "3 points for win 1 point for tie" or other systems like that.
If I won 4 games and you won 4 games, and we played each other and the same other team, maybe you should have 3-0'd the other team as well instead of only beating them 2-1. The format even explicitly rewards teams that are guaranteed not to come top or 2nd to still try to win their last game.
On December 15 2017 05:21 Sn0_Man wrote: I don't like ever caring about head to head
I mean, sure it's a bit funny having this 3-game series where you can 3-0 another team but at least it's not the "3 points for win 1 point for tie" or other systems like that.
If I won 4 games and you won 4 games, and we played each other and the same other team, maybe you should have 3-0'd the other team as well instead of only beating them 2-1. The format even explicitly rewards teams that are guaranteed not to come top or 2nd to still try to win their last game.
You won 4 games and 1 match. I won 4 games and 2 matches, and I already beat you in a match. I think that should account for something.
I get why they're being cute with the full 3 game series, instead of bo3s. It makes 3 way ties less likely and probably makes scheduling easier and more predictable. But ignoring head-to-head seems like a big oversight to me.
edit: Another issue is, let's say EG wins the first 2 games against CoL. The third game matters 0% to CoL, but it makes it matters a lot for EG. It's just stupid, I hate it.
On December 15 2017 05:21 Sn0_Man wrote: I don't like ever caring about head to head
I mean, sure it's a bit funny having this 3-game series where you can 3-0 another team but at least it's not the "3 points for win 1 point for tie" or other systems like that.
If I won 4 games and you won 4 games, and we played each other and the same other team, maybe you should have 3-0'd the other team as well instead of only beating them 2-1. The format even explicitly rewards teams that are guaranteed not to come top or 2nd to still try to win their last game.
You won 4 games and 1 match. I won 4 games and 2 matches, and I already beat you in a match. I think that should account for something.
There is no handicap system in dota 2. Maybe the one with better head to head could get pick of Dire or Radiant. Or choice of first pick. But beyond that, there isn’t much else.
On December 15 2017 05:21 Sn0_Man wrote: I don't like ever caring about head to head
I mean, sure it's a bit funny having this 3-game series where you can 3-0 another team but at least it's not the "3 points for win 1 point for tie" or other systems like that.
If I won 4 games and you won 4 games, and we played each other and the same other team, maybe you should have 3-0'd the other team as well instead of only beating them 2-1. The format even explicitly rewards teams that are guaranteed not to come top or 2nd to still try to win their last game.
You won 4 games and 1 match. I won 4 games and 2 matches, and I already beat you in a match. I think that should account for something.
I get why they're being cute with the full 3 game series, instead of bo3s. It makes 3 way ties less likely and probably makes scheduling easier and more predictable. But ignoring head-to-head seems like a big oversight to me.
edit: Another issue is, let's say EG wins the first 2 games against CoL. The third game matters 0% to CoL, but it makes it matters a lot for EG. It's just stupid, I hate it.
3rd game matters because the best 3rd placed team goes to the next phase.
I think the format is pretty bad for several reason, but that is not one of them.
On December 15 2017 05:21 Sn0_Man wrote: I don't like ever caring about head to head
I mean, sure it's a bit funny having this 3-game series where you can 3-0 another team but at least it's not the "3 points for win 1 point for tie" or other systems like that.
If I won 4 games and you won 4 games, and we played each other and the same other team, maybe you should have 3-0'd the other team as well instead of only beating them 2-1. The format even explicitly rewards teams that are guaranteed not to come top or 2nd to still try to win their last game.
You won 4 games and 1 match. I won 4 games and 2 matches, and I already beat you in a match. I think that should account for something.
I get why they're being cute with the full 3 game series, instead of bo3s. It makes 3 way ties less likely and probably makes scheduling easier and more predictable. But ignoring head-to-head seems like a big oversight to me.
edit: Another issue is, let's say EG wins the first 2 games against CoL. The third game matters 0% to CoL, but it makes it matters a lot for EG. It's just stupid, I hate it.
3rd game matters because the best 3rd placed team goes to the next phase.
I think the format is pretty bad for several reason, but that is not one of them.
In the example, the third game doesn't matter. The losing team is last no matter if they lose 1-2 or 0-3.
On December 15 2017 05:21 Sn0_Man wrote: I don't like ever caring about head to head
I mean, sure it's a bit funny having this 3-game series where you can 3-0 another team but at least it's not the "3 points for win 1 point for tie" or other systems like that.
If I won 4 games and you won 4 games, and we played each other and the same other team, maybe you should have 3-0'd the other team as well instead of only beating them 2-1. The format even explicitly rewards teams that are guaranteed not to come top or 2nd to still try to win their last game.
You won 4 games and 1 match. I won 4 games and 2 matches, and I already beat you in a match. I think that should account for something.
I get why they're being cute with the full 3 game series, instead of bo3s. It makes 3 way ties less likely and probably makes scheduling easier and more predictable. But ignoring head-to-head seems like a big oversight to me.
edit: Another issue is, let's say EG wins the first 2 games against CoL. The third game matters 0% to CoL, but it makes it matters a lot for EG. It's just stupid, I hate it.
3rd game matters because the best 3rd placed team goes to the next phase.
I think the format is pretty bad for several reason, but that is not one of them.
In the example, the third game doesn't matter. The losing team is last no matter if they lose 1-2 or 0-3.
The best third placed (last placed) team out of the 3 groups goes to the next phase.
On December 15 2017 05:21 Sn0_Man wrote: I don't like ever caring about head to head
I mean, sure it's a bit funny having this 3-game series where you can 3-0 another team but at least it's not the "3 points for win 1 point for tie" or other systems like that.
If I won 4 games and you won 4 games, and we played each other and the same other team, maybe you should have 3-0'd the other team as well instead of only beating them 2-1. The format even explicitly rewards teams that are guaranteed not to come top or 2nd to still try to win their last game.
You won 4 games and 1 match. I won 4 games and 2 matches, and I already beat you in a match. I think that should account for something.
I get why they're being cute with the full 3 game series, instead of bo3s. It makes 3 way ties less likely and probably makes scheduling easier and more predictable. But ignoring head-to-head seems like a big oversight to me.
edit: Another issue is, let's say EG wins the first 2 games against CoL. The third game matters 0% to CoL, but it makes it matters a lot for EG. It's just stupid, I hate it.
3rd game matters because the best 3rd placed team goes to the next phase.
I think the format is pretty bad for several reason, but that is not one of them.
In the example, the third game doesn't matter. The losing team is last no matter if they lose 1-2 or 0-3.
The best third placed (last placed) team out of the 3 groups goes to the next phase.
Ooh like that. I guess it does than. What a weird format.
I like the format overall a lot actually. Its actually made me care about group stage results somewhat. I could go either way on the head to head as a viewer. Id be fucking pissed tho if I was competing haha.
They did their absolute best to make every game matter and thats cool.
I think they just said the tiebreakers will be a best of 1. Imagine you're Kinguin, you beat EG and Col 2-1 both, then you lose a bo1 tiebreakers and you're not first in the group. Must feel really nice and fair.
Of course it hasn't happened yet, and I really hope it won't.
That wasn't bad. I still have no idea way anyone would be a creepy internet connected microphone that pipes right into a billion dollar company. But people love stupid tech, even if its creepy and could totally listen to you banging your significant other.
On December 15 2017 09:50 Plansix wrote: That wasn't bad. I still have no idea way anyone would be a creepy internet connected microphone that pipes right into a billion dollar company. But people love stupid tech, even if its creepy and could totally listen to you banging your significant other.