I think physical card games get away with being technical lootboxes, because that's the only way to get the actual game. I think even digital card games get away with it. Building up your collection and making decks with what you got is definitely a big part of the appeal of TCGs. People mainly got pissed at Battlefront 2 because it's a $60 game with a mobile f2p game's progression model.
Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion - Page 9127
| Forum Index > Dota 2 General |
|
cecek
Czech Republic18921 Posts
I think physical card games get away with being technical lootboxes, because that's the only way to get the actual game. I think even digital card games get away with it. Building up your collection and making decks with what you got is definitely a big part of the appeal of TCGs. People mainly got pissed at Battlefront 2 because it's a $60 game with a mobile f2p game's progression model. | ||
|
PassiveAce
United States18076 Posts
if it was gambling you would be able to win money | ||
|
Faruko
Chile34173 Posts
as you always get something in return in THEORY the house NEVER wins (in theory, because they get your money and you get some shitty item, but you are always on a safe bet, and im pretty sure that doesnt count as real gambling) It's a shitty model, based on greed and whatnot, but it's not exactly gambling IMO | ||
|
Atreides
United States2393 Posts
On November 18 2017 21:06 cecek wrote: How much have you spent on Hearthstone? I checked the transaction history on battle.net and I spent 25 euros on Hearthstone, and I still feel that't too much. I think physical card games get away with being technical lootboxes, because that's the only way to get the actual game. I think even digital card games get away with it. Building up your collection and making decks with what you got is definitely a big part of the appeal of TCGs. People mainly got pissed at Battlefront 2 because it's a $60 game with a mobile f2p game's progression model. Probably 200$? I dunno. None for over a year. For a while I bought the 50$deal every expansion, and all the adventures. Truth is I played a lot on my phone so I could have spent a lot less, Ive basically played f2p last year or so and still been able to play whatever I want. I did have a huge dust stockpile from spending money that I still havent exhausted so yeh. btw I think lootboxes in games are dumb. outside of dota compendiums I've never bought them in any game ever. (ofc only shooter Ive played in last 13 years is a bit of pubg) I think people crying "gambling aimed at children" are stupid as fuck though. Even watered down versions of it. | ||
|
cecek
Czech Republic18921 Posts
Gambling is defined as a game, betting or a lottery where the participant places a bet and both: There is no guaranteed return on the bet. The winning or loss is entirely or partly subject to chance or unknown circumstances. So here, lootboxes are not gambling, because you're always guaranteed some return. But I'm sure it's not the same everywhere, you just need the first clause to be a little different and it becomes legally gambling. | ||
|
Artisreal
Germany9235 Posts
On November 18 2017 11:56 SKC wrote: Honestly, the gambling outrage is pure bullshit. Noone complaining actually cares about "gambling" for children, which lootboxes actually aren't. They just realized that if they are loud enough about it people unrelated to the whole thing will hear the bad word and put pressure on EA. It's fake outrage at its finest. They just want to see lootboxes burn because it's a shitty practice, no matter what they have to do. If lootboxes are gambling, so is opening card packs from TCGs, figurine packs, baseball cards, Kinder Eggs, any kind of product with randomized rewards. But noone cared about protecting children from those. Not that p2w systems like this don't deserve to die, but the outrage about it being gambling is 100% fake. If you could straight up buy what you want it wouldnt be any better. Kinder eggs aren't a game where people are supposed to compete against each other somewhat fairly. I'd definitely say that the others are pretty much luck based. You could add panini to that. What has to be appreciated with these real world items tough is the possibility of trade. Haven't seen that with SW. Although the luck based factor or content quality is still there. | ||
|
SKC
Brazil18828 Posts
On November 18 2017 22:53 Artisreal wrote: Kinder eggs aren't a game where people are supposed to compete against each other somewhat fairly. I'd definitely say that the others are pretty much luck based. You could add panini to that. What has to be appreciated with these real world items tough is the possibility of trade. Haven't seen that with SW. Although the luck based factor or content quality is still there. Being able to compete with other people has nothing to do with gambling. It's about it clearly not being gambling, not wether it is a shitty practice or not. It's probably closer to kinder eggs because unlike MTG, there is zero money value in a higher level unit in the game. There is no side market. | ||
|
cecek
Czech Republic18921 Posts
![]() | ||
|
Maverick_2009
Somewhere2002 Posts
On November 18 2017 23:42 cecek wrote: Does anyone know why this: + Show Spoiler + ![]() have you tried restarting explorer from task manager? it normally fixes the issue but uh | ||
|
Slomo
Germany7198 Posts
| ||
|
Artisreal
Germany9235 Posts
But I'm not all out on the gambling for minors train but rather on the shit business model one. Randomised rewards scream a lot like gambling though. There's a reason this stuff around lottery tickets is highly regulated here. Even on a family fair where you can win teddy bears and the like by drawing tickets out of a bucket for 50ct a piece. | ||
|
SKC
Brazil18828 Posts
On November 19 2017 00:07 Artisreal wrote: I think I disagree with loot boxes being closer to kinder eggs if you contextualise why and what for they're bought. But I'm not all out on the gambling for minors train but rather on the shit business model one. Randomised rewards scream a lot like gambling though. There's a reason this stuff around lottery tickets is highly regulated here. Even on a family fair where you can win teddy bears and the like by drawing tickets out of a bucket for 50ct a piece. Another key part of gambling is the chance of not winning anything. That's why every lootbox will always give you something. You are not buying the chance to win something, you are buying something, but you do not know exactly what that thing is. It's exactly like buying those little boxes that comes with a random Dota plushie hero. | ||
|
cecek
Czech Republic18921 Posts
On November 19 2017 00:13 SKC wrote: Another key part of gambling is the chance of not winning anything. That's why every lootbox will always give you something. You are not buying the chance to win something, you are buying something, but you do not know exactly what that thing is. It's exactly like buying those little boxes that comes with a random Dota plushie hero. I don't see why we're so focused on the possibility to win nothing at all. If you made it so that you win 1 cent whenever you miss on a roulette would it stop being a form of gambling? Because that's how it works in cs:go for example, if you get a bad drop from a crate, you literally get a couple cents worth of value. | ||
|
SKC
Brazil18828 Posts
On November 19 2017 00:34 cecek wrote: I don't see why we're so focused on the possibility to win nothing at all. If you made it so that you win 1 cent whenever you miss on a roulette would it stop being a form of gambling? Because that's how it works in cs:go for example, if you get a bad drop from a crate, you literally get a couple cents worth of value. Because that's just how it works. If you open a MTG pack you can also get a card that you could sell for a few cents or 50 bucks. There are all kinds of issues with this kind of stuff but it is not the same as having the chance of not getting anything. But this doesn't even apply for Battlefront. If the game had Valve's model, people would be ecstatic. Because the rage has nothing to do with gambling. | ||
|
cecek
Czech Republic18921 Posts
| ||
|
SKC
Brazil18828 Posts
It's kinda like in Charlie the Chocolate Factory, or when Coca-Cola puts prizes in caps. It doesn't matter if you are buying it strictly for the super rare prize, they are selling you the base good. | ||
|
cecek
Czech Republic18921 Posts
| ||
|
SKC
Brazil18828 Posts
You put roulette in it to make people think of gambling. But if you sold cookies, and 1 in a million of them came with a coupon that would get you a bar of gold, it wouldn't be gambling. | ||
|
cecek
Czech Republic18921 Posts
| ||
|
Nevuk
United States16280 Posts
| ||
| ||
![[image loading]](https://i.imgur.com/5sZlcff.jpg)