|
Macro mechanics were literally added to be busy work for people because they were whining that APM requirements would be lower than in BW (it turned out that, hey, that was never really the case).
The max cap might have been lower or something, but we're talking like 4000 apm vs 5000 apm here, a human couldn't have played a perfect game of either. (And stork and a few other pro P players played games with <200 APM on occasion in BW. Certain matchups require high 350-400+ apm and lots of micro like zvz, but outside of terran it wasn't a flat out requirement).
Sure, mules/scan were a nice tradeoff, but the other two were almost always nobrainer dumb apmsinks, to the point that you got people queuing up inject larva for the entire goddamn game. That's just bad design. and mules, while a good trade, were really fucking stupid for balance, making killing t workers lategame almost pointless.
Warpgates and mules are the sort of thing that should have never left single player. Or as an alternate, if gateways produced units noticeably faster than warpgates it would also have made pvp not pants on head retarded for most of WoL. I stopped caring after a couple of months into SC2, when it was obvious blizz had no idea what they were doing and that the game wasn't anywhere close to as enjoyable as BW. And I never bought the "wait for the expansions" argument, and after having tried them out a bit, I'm glad I didn't.
SC2 had a weaker overall design team than BW did, and they somehow only listened to the absolute worst ideas of the community. I still have no idea why lurkers weren't in WoL multiplayer, and that's just the tip of it.
On October 27 2017 11:43 OmniEulogy wrote: tbh I feel like the economic advantage from those mechanics is larger in broodwar. Part of what I was good at after years of playing the game was being able to have very little down time on when a probe spawned and when I sent it to the minerals as well as the opening split and stuff like that, players fell behind quite quickly just because they weren't mining efficiently which automining really took away even if they did forget a mule (and then just use two at once anyway) or forget to chronoboost their nexus immediately. I liked having an edge over people because I had an internal timer telling me when probes were popping out xD Don't really need an internal timer, there's the green box on the minimap everytime something spawns lol + the cute little meow they make
|
On October 27 2017 11:42 intotheheart wrote: Ah okay, so your return to posting about WoW means your home internet is stable again enough to play rather than an actual reason you stopped recently-ish? I remember you asking a lot about offline gaming since you had issues.
yeah, i bought and moved into a house that I couldnt get internet in a few years ago and so had no internet to play on at home til this fall.
I still value some offline games a lot to play when its down, or im off on some boat in middle of nowhere etc.
(its not like ive played wow continuously besides that but ive played every expansion since vanilla)
|
11589 Posts
I can tell you from experience that the APM requirement of performing a basic build in BW is much higher than the equivalent requirement to doing the same thing in SC2. MBS and automine essentially guarantee that even a relative newbie can macro to a reasonable level as long as they can hit a single hotkey at a regular interval. You're talking about skill ceiling, the design of SC2 was always about lowering the skill floor to be able to just enjoy the game. In this aspect, it succeeded - in some others, it failed miserably.
Brood War was a happy accident, though; to give credit to the design team is a bit of a stretch. Much of the beauty and nuance of the game was discovered years later. Mutalisk micro was not intentional, but it's one of the defining aspects of an entire race in the modern era of the game. The unit AI being terrible at pathing was, again, not a feature the design team actually chose to implement into the game, but it shaped how players were able to utilize their armies. SC2 "fixed" that and it has had a controversial effect on the types of engagements that are seen at the highest levels.
|
BW is magical, and getting to watch people play it again because SC : R makes me happy. Or maybe it's just watching sayle cast. Not sure :D
|
Imagine trump asking a question and someone answers: why the fuck not? And trump goes: I didn't tie no knots. I use slippers or zippers or velcro. I never did knots.
|
STRANGERS THINGS 2 IT'S HEREEEEEEE
|
This Mercedes ad on ESL telling you to get a "real job" and grow up so you can buy a Benz
at a video game tournament
smooth
|
I would rather see 4 min of those ads between games than 1 min of "get the alpha BE THE ALPHA" and other ridiculous betting sites
|
urn real money
foresight passion and calculation
|
Great I'll be working till the liquid games are over. Smh
|
On October 27 2017 20:25 Artisreal wrote: Great I'll be working till the liquid games are over. Smh You can keep "working", can't you?
|
On October 27 2017 20:32 Slomo wrote:Show nested quote +On October 27 2017 20:25 Artisreal wrote: Great I'll be working till the liquid games are over. Smh You can keep "working", can't you? What?
|
On October 27 2017 21:31 Artisreal wrote:Show nested quote +On October 27 2017 20:32 Slomo wrote:On October 27 2017 20:25 Artisreal wrote: Great I'll be working till the liquid games are over. Smh You can keep "working", can't you? What? Having the stream open on your phone.
|
|
|
I love BW and enjoyed my time with SC2, but I’m more than ready for RTSs to move beyond the core design around them. I feel like every RTS since SC2 has been chasing this “skill cap” idea though massively overtooled units that just increase the amount of shit you need to care about. Its complex units on bland maps and base building that is there because people demand base building. I have more fun in the average 10 minute total warhammer match than I do in most modern RTS games.
|
How did you feel about Supreme Commander if you've played it?
Also weren't you excited for DoW3?
|
Supreme commander is really good and I enjoyed those games. The balance is kinda shit, but whatever. I disliked how the UI and command chains were linked to specific buildings, but its fun. DoW3 is fine for what it is, but suffers from over tooled units and a kinda shit economy system. No one wants to manage an economy in a warhammer game.
|
Was it like the first DoW where you take over resource nodes that pump out money for you? I was thinking of getting it, but realized I had enough games (read as: VNs) to get through right now.
|
It is the same system, but you can upgrade them to pull in more resources. So you need to decide when to upgrade them and it is not cheap to do it. All which gets in the way of producing more orks to fight with.
It’s a fun game, but the whole economy is a distraction from the tactical squad combat and use of elite units.
|
I came back a bit to the ME3 multiplayer coop and it's still super fun, and a lot of people are still playing on Silver and Gold so no problems with finding games.
|
|
|
|
|
|