Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion - Page 9058
| Forum Index > Dota 2 General |
|
Artisreal
Germany9235 Posts
| ||
|
Fleetfeet
Canada2856 Posts
| ||
|
Faruko
Chile34173 Posts
On October 26 2017 02:50 intotheheart wrote: Where did Faruko post for the other 15k+? I'm amazed I only have like.. 3-4k on LR threads. i was a TLnet fangay then i see the light and realized gd was much better because gosi and comeh | ||
|
intotheheart
Canada33091 Posts
On October 26 2017 03:52 Fleetfeet wrote: We should have force-displayed LD debate MMR attached to our posts. It automatically goes down if you talk about anime. What about Friends? I'd have very low MMR, just like with everything else. | ||
|
harodihg
Japan1344 Posts
On October 26 2017 03:10 Sn0_Man wrote: Fortunately most places don't have to justify *not* instituting onerous requirements on their users with no upsides. First, people who suggest the idea have to prove the upsides. It wouldn't be requirement, it would just display a tiny baby chicken signifying that they're CHICKEN if they don't. The upsides are that people are accurately labeled what they are, there's no downsides! On October 26 2017 03:10 Plansix wrote: My MMR is my business and I choose who I share it with is my business. If LD wants it, they and fuck right off. If there is a section of the site that requires it, it can fuck right off too. If other posters want it, well they can ask and I’ll consider it. Also any can just buy a 5K account and strap it on to this site and then we can all debate if its real or not. It is a pointless feature that will only be used by people who A: don’t want to have real discussion or B: want to show off their E-peen. Finally, some people with high MMR are also fucking morons and just grind their way to it with flavors of the month. MMR does not measure skill at dota. Your MMR is basically public and shown to everyone at the end of every game. Even if you don't display it, if you share y our match history sites like opendota will predict your MMR. People can even watch your matches and see your MMR displayed at the end too. Adding sections is another good idea. Perhaps segregating posters into MMR brackets might be a good idea too. Like making a 6k+ section that anyone can read, but only those truly worthy can post in. Yes, anyone can buy an account, but account buyers are pretty obvious from looking at their match history. Like why is their winrate on NA only 30% whereas most of their matches were on SEA? Or why is their most played hero meepo, with a 80% winrate, last played 3 months ago? Or even simpler, why did they suddenly change their common item positions like putting wand, TP, or boots into a certain slot? Adding it would elevate discussion and allow true brain geniuses to wade through the muck of low MMR trench creatures much more easily, what you deem a means of showing off "e-peen" is actually a way to demonstrate value. Like buying a nice suit or nice car. | ||
|
harodihg
Japan1344 Posts
On October 26 2017 03:52 Fleetfeet wrote: We should have force-displayed LD debate MMR attached to our posts. It automatically goes down if you talk about anime. This post should be stickied. | ||
|
Plansix
United States60190 Posts
| ||
|
harodihg
Japan1344 Posts
On October 26 2017 04:31 Plansix wrote: Harodihg: Adding MMR would do nothing. Just like having .Esquire after your name does not make you good at trial argument or drafting pleadings. Good discussion requires moderation and good faith, not metrics to prove that someone knows what they are talking about. A 2K MMR player can have a discussion about play with a 6K player and it can be productive for both parties. -How is having a moniker added after your name comparable to an actual skill rating that is backed up by evidence? -Good discussion does indeed require moderation and good faith, but it doesn't stop there. If you placed Albert Einstein in a room with Comeh to talk about astrophysics do you think Einstein would walk away thinking "boy, I sure did gain a lot from that!" -2k players bring virtually nothing to the table when theorycrafting with a 6k+ players. As far as DotA goes, strategies essentially work like Reaganomics. People at the top make builds and new strategies, and they trickle down until the gutter dwellers at 2k are playing bastardized versions of them. There's a reason that it isn't the other way around. | ||
|
Nevuk
United States16280 Posts
| ||
|
harodihg
Japan1344 Posts
On October 26 2017 04:43 Nevuk wrote: It depends on how much dota they watch. Some of the better insights I've seen about pro play were from people who watched dota 24/7 rather than the ones who played it the same amount. Incorrect. As an example: just because Comeh says something that you think is insightful about astrophysics does not make it actually insightful or significant at all, and someone who has a PhD in astrophysics might giggle at the comment. | ||
|
digitalctrash
San Marino74 Posts
| ||
|
Artisreal
Germany9235 Posts
internet came online now I have to call customer support and tell them the technician isnt needed anymore fun evening | ||
|
Nixer
2774 Posts
On October 26 2017 02:35 harodihg wrote: Why isn't there forced MMR's displayed next to people's usernames on TL/reddit and then people are also given the ability to sort posts by MMR Never happening. | ||
|
Plansix
United States60190 Posts
On October 26 2017 04:40 harodihg wrote: -How is having a moniker added after your name comparable to an actual skill rating that is backed up by evidence? -Good discussion does indeed require moderation and good faith, but it doesn't stop there. If you placed Albert Einstein in a room with Comeh to talk about astrophysics do you think Einstein would walk away thinking "boy, I sure did gain a lot from that!" -2k players bring virtually nothing to the table when theorycrafting with a 6k+ players. As far as DotA goes, strategies essentially work like Reaganomics. People at the top make builds and new strategies, and they trickle down until the gutter dwellers at 2k are playing bastardized versions of them. There's a reason that it isn't the other way around. Esquire means they are an attorney. Attorneys pass a series of tests to become attorneys and are licensed. Many of them are bad at law and all the things having to do with law, but they have the title and passed the tests. The rest of your post doesn’t pass the smell test. If skill was required to have a discussion, then the Socratic method wouldn’t be a style of teaching. Discussion would have no point in college, everyone should just listen to the professor and STFU. As someone who was certified to teach people things, having input from a variety of experience levels has value. Gate keeping rarely does. | ||
|
cecek
Czech Republic18921 Posts
| ||
|
Sn0_Man
Tebellong44238 Posts
On October 26 2017 05:12 cecek wrote: Black's stream is surprisingly great. Good skills, talks a lot, has a nice attitude. Music is kinda meh, but still infinitely better than the anime screeching on Envy's or Arteezy's german rap. He also streams a lot these days which is nice Hope he's doing well from it | ||
|
Artisreal
Germany9235 Posts
Yes. | ||
|
Sn0_Man
Tebellong44238 Posts
On October 26 2017 05:21 Artisreal wrote: The only occasional downside of his stream is when he's unpacking the German humour. I mean,I get it and it's kinda funny but not funny and very German. Yes. Most Germans i've interacted with online like to shit on other Germans/German things | ||
|
OmniEulogy
Canada6600 Posts
On October 26 2017 05:12 cecek wrote: Black's stream is surprisingly great. Good skills, talks a lot, has a nice attitude. Music is kinda meh, but still infinitely better than the anime screeching on Envy's or Arteezy's german rap. I was talking to him about music choices when he was going to get back into streaming and he decided to just find 10 hour playlists called "epic music" and hope for the best lmao sometimes the music fits well and chat loves it though so I guess it's worth it. He had one day of playing with a "gaming mix" or something and I don't think it's been back. | ||
|
harodihg
Japan1344 Posts
On October 26 2017 05:03 Plansix wrote: Esquire means they are an attorney. Attorneys pass a series of tests to become attorneys and are licensed. Many of them are bad at law and all the things having to do with law, but they have the title and passed the tests. The rest of your post doesn’t pass the smell test. If skill was required to have a discussion, then the Socratic method wouldn’t be a style of teaching. Discussion would have no point in college, everyone should just listen to the professor and STFU. As someone who was certified to teach people things, having input from a variety of experience levels has value. Gate keeping rarely does. If you needed a lawyer, would you rather have a lawyer you deem bad do the job, or a homeless man named Comeh who's brain is rotten from syphilis and frequently purchases stout shield on ranged supports? Skill isn't required to have a discussion, but it is something that can be taken into context, especially in regards to something that isn't concrete. There's a reason people look for and put what degrees they have on their resumes. It's funny how you mention that you're CERTIFIED to teach things in this argument, given that it's an argument about merit and what merit is actually worth in DotA. In some sense, it is worthwhile having 2k players around in discussions, not that they have anything particularly useful to say, they're just the Mortys and 6k+ players are the Ricks. | ||
| ||