|
Last of Us is honestly the same kind of #gritty fantasy that appeals to 20-something-white males in terms of an idealized version of self the same way JRPG protagonists appeal to 15-something-japanese males
The world setting is interesting but the overall story arc really doesn't do anything special aside from presetting a different set of tropes that have been used to death, though I suppose not in AAA video games.
Harry Potter is fine as long as you accept that the plot is deadpan and the world is utterly nonsensical and inconsistent
|
On July 28 2015 23:53 goody153 wrote: Well i grew up with dragon ball but i don't give a shit about the story anymore or don't really care about it but i did love naruto although i found it really shitty near the end like it was too stupid and not dark enough for me(not super dark i don;t want that but naruto has a degree of being dark which made it interesting for me).
Harry Potter is probably not different from other fantasy story but it just disappointed me cause it ended up with a standard good vs evil + they grew up happily ever after. I expected more interesting end.
That's probably that. Also doesn't help that i dislike harry's character lol Ended up with standard good vs evil? I'm sorry but harry potter has been good vs evil from the first chapter essentially, lmao.
Also as far as consistency goes in harry potter, i feel each book is fairly self-consistent and follows the rules established in that one book just fine, but across multiple books it does indeed begin to be fairly inconsistent.
|
On July 28 2015 23:53 goody153 wrote: Well i grew up with dragon ball but i don't give a shit about the story anymore or don't really care about it but i did love naruto although i found it really shitty near the end like it was too stupid and not dark enough for me(not super dark i don;t want that but naruto has a degree of being dark which made it interesting for me).
Harry Potter is probably not different from other fantasy story but it just disappointed me cause it ended up with a standard good vs evil + they grew up happily ever after. I expected more interesting end.
That's probably that. Also doesn't help that i dislike harry's character lol What part of it didn't you like? Boring or the "good at everything" aspect?
|
Yeah idk but i actually expected something more. Like i;m ok with good vs evil (though i always preferred clash of ideology but those are rare) it's just that it ended up you know happy ending and shit.
I get really disappointed when the ending is all happy and bubbly sometimes.
|
Northern Ireland22213 Posts
i expected harry to suffer death
|
I mean the HP books changed drastically as they went from cute childrens fairy tale to #gritty #grown-up #fantasy (without succeeding very well) in order to try to reach their intended age group or something. I disliked it quite a bit tbh but like I said i couldn't just not read them (plus they always came out right around the end of july aka my birthday so i'd get them for that)
|
I think that if you look at Harry Potter as a childrens' book, it becomes a lot more bearable.
|
On July 28 2015 23:53 Kupon3ss wrote: Last of Us is honestly the same kind of #gritty fantasy that appeals to 20-something-white males in terms of an idealized version of self the same way JRPG protagonists appeal to 15-something-japanese males
The world setting is interesting but the overall story arc really doesn't do anything special aside from presetting a different set of tropes that have been used to death, though I suppose not in AAA video games.
Harry Potter is fine as long as you accept that the plot is deadpan and the world is utterly nonsensical and inconsistent I would argue that Joel is a character targeted at 30 something white males, just like Booker in Bioshock Infinite. Strong male figures with daughter figures to protect. See shadow of Mordor for further examples that have way worse plot.
The first two are interesting because the both characters are kind of human garbage seeking redemption and don't really find it.(its debatable in Bioshock, but there is a lot that is debatable about the end of that game).
On July 28 2015 23:57 IntoTheheart wrote: I think that if you look at Harry Potter as a childrens' book, it becomes a lot more bearable.
I am surprised every time anyone looks at them any other way.
|
It's a children's book series, there was basically no chance of it not being a and they lived happily ever after ending.
|
they kill and torture each other pretty often for a children`s book
|
On July 28 2015 23:58 SKC wrote: they kill and torture each other pretty often for a children`s book I think that death and violence aren't what make it an adult book as much as the method.
|
they torture with people excruciating pain until they become mentally insane and forever locked up in an institution. There are some pretty dark things in HP.
|
Joel is certainly not human garbage, he's actually a mostly decent logical character who's done what he's needed to do to survive in the world setting that is presented. Bioshock Infinite's writing and MC is arguably even worse and less logical in terms of motivation and characterization.
Shadow of Mordor actually does a better job in this regard by just dispensing with all the bullshit for the main character and going straight to the point (by putting all the shitty writing and baggage on to Celebrimbor)
|
I like Harry Potter a lot. I think what makes JK Rowling a bit different than most fantasy writers is that I feel like she wrote it from a child's perspective. The entire world is more of a childrens dream than let's say LotRs world. Everything was so genuinely pleasant and magical, from the diagon alley to the castle. Harry Potter 1 was such a great book from an imaginary perspective and could definitely see kids wishing it was real etc.
The red line throughout the series was good, most things was there for a reason. Some stuff was really dumb though, like Hermoines rescue the house-elves thing in the 4th(?) book.
I mean, JK Rowling wouldn't become the first billionarie for writing novels if the series was mediocre.
|
On July 29 2015 00:01 SKC wrote: they torture with people excruciating pain until they become mentally insane and forever locked up in an institution. There are some pretty dark things in HP.
Those are actually very commonplace themes in western children's stories
|
On July 29 2015 00:01 SKC wrote: they torture with people excruciating pain until they become mentally insane and forever locked up in an institution. There are some pretty dark things in HP. Sure but they never show it. It's certainly not an airy fairy sort of story and I agree, but I think that at its core, it's still a childrens' book.
|
Bioshock is like, an average game honestly. I dont get its hype.
Haven't played infinite though.
|
On July 28 2015 23:58 SKC wrote: they kill and torture each other pretty often for a children`s book That is why it’s a good children’s story. It addresses mature issues in forms kids can deal with and process. Teaching kids about violence, hate, rage, and misery is about letting them process it in a safe space where they can understand it on their terms.
Its also deals with other mature issues like “don’t trust the media” and “No every who does bad things is evil.” The Malfoy plot is one of the best parts of those books. That the family wasn’t good, but wasn’t pure evil either.
|
On July 28 2015 23:55 IntoTheheart wrote:Show nested quote +On July 28 2015 23:53 goody153 wrote: Well i grew up with dragon ball but i don't give a shit about the story anymore or don't really care about it but i did love naruto although i found it really shitty near the end like it was too stupid and not dark enough for me(not super dark i don;t want that but naruto has a degree of being dark which made it interesting for me).
Harry Potter is probably not different from other fantasy story but it just disappointed me cause it ended up with a standard good vs evil + they grew up happily ever after. I expected more interesting end.
That's probably that. Also doesn't help that i dislike harry's character lol What part of it didn't you like? Boring or the "good at everything" aspect? uhmm you know the standard good to the bones and conveniently the "chosen" one .. i just find his character 1 dimensional like his weaknesses doesn't feel like weakness
like for example the book series i read before "The Secrets of the Immortals" by Michael Scott (it's the uhm standard young adult childrens book i guess) but however + Show Spoiler +like for example the male main character has the bland stubborn to his beliefs and strong capability standard main character abilities but he was still interesting cause he wasn't on the right side he believes that the other villains side is the "good" which makes it interesting you knwo shit like that
|
On July 29 2015 00:03 Comeh wrote: Bioshock is like, an average game honestly. I dont get its hype.
Haven't played infinite though. I'm the same, i played the first and felt that it was okay but nowhere near as great as people had made it out to be.
|
|
|
|
|
|