EPTOn March 28 2009 03:22 lololol wrote:
Klazart, quickly make a video!
Klazart, quickly make a video!
ahahaha
(do it, klaz. do it)
Relic vs Blizzard, lets show'em [Escapist Vote] - Page 7
| Forum Index > Closed |
|
chobopeon
United States7342 Posts
ahahaha (do it, klaz. do it) | ||
|
h3r1n6
Iceland2039 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + votingforblizzard Anonymous Source Posts: 1 Joined: 27 Mar 2009 I signed up just to vote for Relic. But let me introduce myself (First post lol!). I'm a prebuscent intellectual who really understands art in general. Whether it's music or video games, I have a true knack for appreciated exceptional work and the innovation therein. So I think I'm qualified to make a vote in this Blizzard-Relic debate. (Mods, could you please allow my vote to count 5 times to accurately reflect my expertise?). Let me explain my stance by analogy -- I think the Blizzard-Relic debate is isomorphic to the following example in music: In my prepubertal intellectualism, I really think that daft punk or some shit is really on par with, say, Rachmaninoff. Because, after all, it's been about a century since that dead Russian composed anything worth listening to. And daft punk is just like, more innovative. I like weird ass robot sounds in my music because I can't understand the virtuosic climaxes and diatonic melody from the "Allegro mon on tanto" movement in Rach's 3rd Piano Concerto. Seriously guys, this debate is over. Relic wins. 10/10 for whoever wrote that post | ||
|
Velr
Switzerland10962 Posts
 | ||
TheYango
United States47024 Posts
On March 28 2009 03:01 GoodWill wrote: Blizzard Starcraft √√√ Diablo √ Diablo 2 √ Warcraft 3 √√√ WOW Relic Homeworld √√ Homeworld 2 √ Dawn of War and expansions √√ Company of Heroes and expansions √√ Dawn of War II √√ Relic 9 - 8 Blizzard voted Relic gg guys Sorry, but this just REALLY makes your genre-bias show through. So you don't like hack-and-slashes. That doesn't automatically make Diablo and Diablo II bad games. For those who use WoW as a point against Blizzard, what's the deal? Sure, it might not be your style, but quite frankly, it was just as big of a leap forward in the MMO genre as Starcraft was in the RTS genre. It popularized the genre beyond any previously known level, and, in terms of actual content, was the first MMO to provide strong, high-level encounter design. Debatably, other MMOs still have yet to match the encounter design quality of WoW. | ||
|
Empyrean
17082 Posts
<_< I'm a dick. | ||
|
chobopeon
United States7342 Posts
| ||
|
KurtistheTurtle
United States1966 Posts
I really don't give a fuck if some teenager with a brain half the size of my ballsack thinks a company who released a couple good games is better than the one which created progaming. | ||
Liquid`Jinro
Sweden33719 Posts
On March 28 2009 03:19 Empyrean wrote: When does voting close? I voted twice for Blizz. Someone want to post this on the sc2gg forums? Heard "9 am tomorrow". No clue what timezone! Don't have a sc2gg account :[ | ||
|
Disarray
United States1164 Posts
On March 27 2009 20:57 Hurricane wrote: I have yet to see a decent valid statement as to why DoW or CoH is better than starcraft. You seem to be missing the entire point. If this were a SC vs DoW poll, I'd fully expect the TL community and any other huge fan of Starcraft to go over there blindly with feverous cheers about the greatest game ever, how its an e-sport yadda yadda. However it is not. It is a Blizzard v Relic poll/discussion. And the arguments some of you are posting here, and there are really mis-informed, and downright bad mannered. Its like some of you are cheering for a sports team. + Show Spoiler + (I wish I could link here the thread/poll conducted here on TL where someone asked if Blizzard truly designed SC to be as great as it is, or if they just got really fucking lucky, and the poll was overwhelmingly favored to Luck.) | ||
|
Liquid`Jinro
Sweden33719 Posts
| ||
|
chobopeon
United States7342 Posts
| ||
|
chobopeon
United States7342 Posts
On March 28 2009 04:35 Disarray wrote: And the arguments some of you are posting here, and there are really mis-informed, and downright bad mannered. Its like some of you are cheering for a sports team. I think it's fair to say that that's true of both sides. there have been some decent posts though! and some diplomatic ones, too. kind of. maybe. | ||
|
Pieguy314
Canada262 Posts
| ||
|
D10
Brazil3409 Posts
But after years of modifications (patches and maps) the end product ended up being much greater than initially previewed. But It couldnt be all based on luck, after all they got everything right with BW expansion, they knew what they were doing, they just didnt know it would do so well. =p As Gai sensei said to Rock Lee, luck is an important part of any battle. "You wont be able to do the impossible if you are no ready when the chance comes" | ||
|
Disarray
United States1164 Posts
On March 28 2009 04:36 FrozenArbiter wrote: Blizzard should still win even if you look at the big picture tho. Depends on your personal criteria of determining what the better company is really. Good and bad could be said of both. Blizzard made some huge breakthroughs, but sadly, most of the original talent that brought those breakthroughs left, and the remaining new staff has just been riding the success of the name. Think of the breakout amazing things they did, Warcraft, Starcraft Diablo. and what games are on the horizon ? Starcraft 2 and Diablo 3. come on. I won't get into the positives because they're abundantly clear, and most have already been posted. Relic on the other hand, is actually attempting very new things, if you look at what they've done from DoW1 (taken the basic build/gather rts) to CoH (Completely redone the idea of "massing troops and sending them to their deaths") to DoW2, they really are innovative and doing well in pushing for new things. | ||
|
D10
Brazil3409 Posts
| ||
|
Sprite
United States1015 Posts
| ||
|
Kaniol
Poland5551 Posts
On March 27 2009 21:30 Hurricane wrote: No, terran missions on SC, not broodwar. When she's a ghost and you have to cloak her and go in and kill some guys in a cc. Then you have to build dropships and the entire bottom of the map is an island. I'm done arguing. I've made my final point and I'm going to play popkart. Have fun trolling. Lt. Sarah Kerrigan: Captain Raynor, I've finished scouting out the area, and... you pig! Jim Raynor: What! I haven't even said anything to you yet. Lt. Sarah Kerrigan: Yeah, but you were thinking it. Jim Raynor: Oh, yeah! you're a telepath. [referring to the mission] Jim Raynor: Look, Lets just get on with this, ok? I guess you meant this one :p BTW previous one was from vanilla zerg campaign ^^ When you had to destroy Raynor's CC (4. mission i think?) | ||
|
Disarray
United States1164 Posts
On March 28 2009 04:42 D10 wrote: Well Disarray, I would argue that it was kinda like Coke, they brewed the original mix and thought it would be a nice product. See thats the thing, and In bringing up the argument of DoW vs Starcraft (altho starcraft is DUH the better game) it also brings up the subtle argument of Games Workshop vs Blizzard, in wich blizzard straight up RIPPED sc from wh40k and warcraft from warhammer fantasy. Seriously, Warcraft 1 was supposed to be a warhammer RTS, then it got changed later. | ||
|
Tinithor
United States1552 Posts
Ahhh well the fact that Blizzard is losing just goes to show how far the gaming community has fallen.... People nowadays seem to care more about flashy lights and "innovation" more than having an actual game to play. | ||
| ||
