|
On January 18 2011 03:07 moopie wrote: I also think listing 3-kills makes more sense than "almost allkills". I disagree, because the whole point of an all-kill is defeating the entire team, not just a majority. Oh and look, a terran joins the list of AK's. AK's are no longer exclusive to protoss.
|
On January 18 2011 03:09 Lightwip wrote:Show nested quote +On January 18 2011 03:07 moopie wrote: I also think listing 3-kills makes more sense than "almost allkills". I disagree, because the whole point of an all-kill is defeating the entire team, not just a majority. Then why list almost allkills? either way you didn't kill the entire team. All-kills aside, listing anything else is listing a failure to achieve an all-kill, either because of the player's fail, or simply because someone else got a single kill beforehand. It would be defeating the majority either way.
|
On January 18 2011 03:12 moopie wrote:Show nested quote +On January 18 2011 03:09 Lightwip wrote:On January 18 2011 03:07 moopie wrote: I also think listing 3-kills makes more sense than "almost allkills". I disagree, because the whole point of an all-kill is defeating the entire team, not just a majority. Then why list almost allkills? either way you didn't kill the entire team. All-kills aside, listing anything else is listing a failure to achieve an all-kill, either because of the player's fail, or simply because someone else got a single kill beforehand. It would be defeating the majority either way. Because almost AK's show that it was possible but the player falls just short. And why not also include 2 kills? You take out half the team that way.
|
On January 18 2011 03:14 Lightwip wrote: And why not also include 2 kills? You take out half the team that way. Eh, 2 kills happen too often. 3 kills are rarer. imo 3-kill and all-kill (obviously) would be post-worthy.
edit: actually, I have an idea edit2: + Show Spoiler +
|
Didnt Baby allkill ace last year too? lol
|
On January 18 2011 03:16 moopie wrote:Show nested quote +On January 18 2011 03:14 Lightwip wrote: And why not also include 2 kills? You take out half the team that way. Eh, 2 kills happen too often. 3 kills are rarer. imo 3-kill and all-kill (obviously) would be post-worthy.
Well im sorry that this thread didnt live up to your standards. I dont see how a 3 kill relate to an ak. while making an almost ak does. Since obvious i can infer that u said half of my thread is not post-worthy would you like to make a thread that is post-worthy to you??? Just remember this is an all-kill thread not a 3-kill and up thread.
|
On January 18 2011 03:19 Kenpachi wrote: Didnt Baby allkill ace last year too? lol
yes he did lol
|
On January 18 2011 03:22 jaiBing wrote:Show nested quote +On January 18 2011 03:16 moopie wrote:On January 18 2011 03:14 Lightwip wrote: And why not also include 2 kills? You take out half the team that way. Eh, 2 kills happen too often. 3 kills are rarer. imo 3-kill and all-kill (obviously) would be post-worthy. Well im sorry that this thread didnt live up to your standards. I dont see how a 3 kill relate to an ak. while making an almost ak does. Since obvious i can infer that u said half of my thread is not post-worthy would you like to make a thread that is post-worthy to you??? Just remember this is an all-kill thread not a 3-kill and up thread. Not really sure why you're being so defensive. I didn't say your thread wasn't up to my standards, nor how you inferred I said half your thread isn't post worthy (that was my statement to lightwip regarding 2-kills, which you don't seem to care about anyway). I gave my opinion on 3-kills as did several others before me, that was an opinion, not a a statement saying you have to go by my rules. Take it easy guy.
|
On January 18 2011 03:16 moopie wrote:Show nested quote +On January 18 2011 03:14 Lightwip wrote: And why not also include 2 kills? You take out half the team that way. Eh, 2 kills happen too often. 3 kills are rarer. imo 3-kill and all-kill (obviously) would be post-worthy. edit: actually, I have an idea edit2: + Show Spoiler +
hm.....thats actually pretty decent edit- well my bad then
|
Sea gets ALL KILL DENIED~! Close call though.
|
I'm pretty sure in the past the lists have been AK, 3kill, and reverse AK. You list 3kills instead of "almost AK" because what is an almost AK? 3kill the first 3 games and then the team loses? Is this favorable to being 1 set up and performing a 3kill so the team wins? I think both are noteworthy. Especially since some 3kills get closed in the 7th set.
|
I definitely think that 3 kills should be listed.
|
I don't think 3 kills should be listed. This thread is about all kills and the challenge to achieve them. The almost all kill list shows the players who came close but just couldn't make it. A normal 3 kill has nothing to do with an all kill
|
Love the thread jaiBing, don't change a thing! Your efforts are greatly appreciated
On January 19 2011 00:04 oBlade wrote: I'm pretty sure in the past the lists have been AK, 3kill, and reverse AK. You list 3kills instead of "almost AK" because what is an almost AK? 3kill the first 3 games and then the team loses? Is this favorable to being 1 set up and performing a 3kill so the team wins? I think both are noteworthy. Especially since some 3kills get closed in the 7th set. You are incorrect, only almosts were listed on Last year's list
Holgerius and Moopie only want 3-kills listed to see Flash on the board, and Lightwip doesn't so he doesn't appear
|
United States9960 Posts
seriously... KT to get all-killed??? ok first, there's someone called God Young Ho??? anyone heard of him??? yeah, he'll get AT LEAST 1 win, so no all-kill. then we got all the other awesome guys on the team. so, KT WILL NOT get aked this season.
|
On January 19 2011 06:39 FlaShFTW wrote: seriously... KT to get all-killed??? ok first, there's someone called God Young Ho??? anyone heard of him??? yeah, he'll get AT LEAST 1 win, so no all-kill. then we got all the other awesome guys on the team. so, KT WILL NOT get aked this season.
umm, it doesnt matter if flash wins a game. Its still an all-kill if its 4-1 or 4-2 etc. of course, flash would have to come out in the first set for that to happen, which isnt likely.
|
On January 19 2011 00:44 DropBear wrote:Holgerius and Moopie only want 3-kills listed to see Flash on the board, and Lightwip doesn't so he doesn't appear Cute theory but it doesn't explain the KT fan just one post above you.
|
On January 19 2011 06:39 FlaShFTW wrote: seriously... KT to get all-killed??? ok first, there's someone called God Young Ho??? anyone heard of him??? yeah, he'll get AT LEAST 1 win, so no all-kill. then we got all the other awesome guys on the team. so, KT WILL NOT get aked this season.
That's what we said about JD >.<
|
On January 19 2011 06:39 FlaShFTW wrote: seriously... KT to get all-killed??? ok first, there's someone called God Young Ho??? anyone heard of him??? yeah, he'll get AT LEAST 1 win, so no all-kill. then we got all the other awesome guys on the team. so, KT WILL NOT get aked this season.
Yeah, just like last season when you had "God" Young Ho and a promising backing lineup and you didn't get AKed then either
|
I wonder if we will see a Zerg all-kill at all this season. If we do my bet is on Hydra taking one home.
|
|
|
|