• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EDT 12:48
CEST 18:48
KST 01:48
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Classic Games #3: Rogue vs Serral at BlizzCon9[ASL20] Ro16 Preview Pt1: Ascent10Maestros of the Game: Week 1/Play-in Preview12[ASL20] Ro24 Preview Pt2: Take-Off7[ASL20] Ro24 Preview Pt1: Runway13
Community News
SC4ALL $6,000 Open LAN in Philadelphia7Weekly Cups (Sept 1-7): MaxPax rebounds & Clem saga continues26LiuLi Cup - September 2025 Tournaments3Weekly Cups (August 25-31): Clem's Last Straw?39Weekly Cups (Aug 18-24): herO dethrones MaxPax6
StarCraft 2
General
Weekly Cups (Sept 1-7): MaxPax rebounds & Clem saga continues #1: Maru - Greatest Players of All Time Team Liquid Map Contest #21 - Presented by Monster Energy Classic Games #3: Rogue vs Serral at BlizzCon What happened to Singapore/Brazil servers?
Tourneys
Maestros of The Game—$20k event w/ live finals in Paris RSL: Revival, a new crowdfunded tournament series WardiTV TL Team Map Contest #5 Tournaments Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament SC4ALL $6,000 Open LAN in Philadelphia
Strategy
Custom Maps
External Content
Mutation # 490 Masters of Midnight Mutation # 489 Bannable Offense Mutation # 488 What Goes Around Mutation # 487 Think Fast
Brood War
General
Pros React To: SoulKey's 5-Peat Challenge ASL20 General Discussion BW General Discussion BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ BSL Team Wars - Bonyth, Dewalt, Hawk & Sziky teams
Tourneys
[ASL20] Ro16 Group B [ASL20] Ro16 Group A [Megathread] Daily Proleagues SC4ALL $1,500 Open Bracket LAN
Strategy
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Muta micro map competition Fighting Spirit mining rates [G] Mineral Boosting
Other Games
General Games
Borderlands 3 Nintendo Switch Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Path of Exile General RTS Discussion Thread
Dota 2
Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion LiquidDota to reintegrate into TL.net
League of Legends
Heroes of the Storm
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Heroes of StarCraft mini-set
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread The Big Programming Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine The Games Industry And ATVI
Fan Clubs
The Happy Fan Club!
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! [Manga] One Piece Anime Discussion Thread
Sports
2024 - 2026 Football Thread Formula 1 Discussion MLB/Baseball 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Linksys AE2500 USB WIFI keeps disconnecting Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread High temperatures on bridge(s)
TL Community
BarCraft in Tokyo Japan for ASL Season5 Final The Automated Ban List
Blogs
The Personality of a Spender…
TrAiDoS
A very expensive lesson on ma…
Garnet
hello world
radishsoup
Lemme tell you a thing o…
JoinTheRain
RTS Design in Hypercoven
a11
Evil Gacha Games and the…
ffswowsucks
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 1568 users

MAGOT #8 Science & Magic, the Glamour of Portal 2

Blogs > Thereisnosaurus
Post a Reply
Thereisnosaurus
Profile Blog Joined February 2010
Australia1822 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-04-29 12:58:53
April 29 2011 12:56 GMT
#1
[image loading]
Make a game of that returns with a double issue, first up an article to counter all the insane hype of portal 2 and look at the game in a more critical light. It must of course be stressed that this article contains spoilers, though not super ultra mega ones. Enjoy!

Once in a long while, a videogame comes along that is fresh, clever and deep all at the same time. Portal was such a game, with a new take on the first person genre, crisp minimalist design, depth of play and of course one of the more memorable aesthetics in modern gaming. Portal 2 has arrived, pushed out on a wave of almost overwhelming hype and advertising. It can't be argued that Valve has done anything but excel themselves in making our mouths water and our fingers twitch, yet a week later, waking in the sweaty aftermath of many hours of vigorous exertion, can we truly say the game was something to be remembered?

The answer on the surface is yes. It cannot be understated just how much polish and elbow grease Valve rubbed into the portal experience. Memorable lines come almost faster than you can listen to them, set pieces and easter eggs bounce around the screen like superballs and the whole thing reeks of so many hours of playtesting you start to wonder if valve has some kind of secret lab where they keep people chained to monitors, endlessly trying to break their puzzles. I mean, they had to get the feel of Aperture from somewhere, right?

Yet veterans of Portal have noted that in Portal 2, the game is not so much about figuring out which panel to put your portals on, but what to do with the few available panels you have. Even there, Valve's impeccable testing ensures that you are never too long in doubt which portal goes where.

[image loading]

Valve to an extent pioneered the art of designing what might be called perceptual guiderails for videogames, subtle or not so subtle tricks and hints to get you to look at a certain place, feel a certain way, come to a certain conclusion. For strongly narrative experiences like Half-Life and Portal 2, this provides a way the designer can ensure (or at least improve the probability that) the player experiences their design in the way they intended it to be experienced. To show just how good at this Valve are, I encourage you to play through the game again. Instead of marvelling at the intricate details and animations of the focal point of each area, be they flickering panels, gyrating robot eyeballs or production lines of turrets, take your time. Look around each area fully, drag your eyes away from the lights at the end of the assorted tunnels. Compared to a game like Modern Warfare or Halo: Reach, Portal 2 is remarkably sparse, great areas of simply textured, angular geometry peppered with a scattering of gorgeously rendered details. The genius is that you are so captivated by these little details that you don't notice the rest of the game is pretty bare. That's no accident. Portal 2 is Valve's piece-de-resistance in holding your eyes and mind to the narrow track they want it on. Even easter eggs and secrets are cunningly designed to be findable, not the opposite.

This same skill, fortunately for Valve, keeps our eyes away from Portal 2's dirty little secret. It's a tutorial. The whole bleeping thing. This may strike you as strange at first, but consider what a tutorial is- it's a carefully constructed area which fosters the understanding of a single skill, small set of skills, or applying a novel combination of previously learned skills. Sounds pretty much like Portal 2, eh? Each chamber or chamber-esque area is designed specifically to teach you a property of your latest toy. It can block bullets! Amazing! You can shoot portals onto it! Incredible! Despite being made of coherent light you can still apparently coat it in goo! ...Unexpected?

The purpose of a tutorial is to prepare you in shelter with skills for the wild world of whatever those skills is required for. Yet in Portal 2, there is no wild world. At no point does the carefully crafted, deliberately structured, obviously intently designed feel give way to one where you have only your wits, two toothpicks, a ceramic block and a quantum-loaded matter translocation enablement device against whatever evils the world decides to throw at you today. I feel this is terribly sad. It's almost like going to school for six years, then to uni for another six, finally coming to the end, taking a deep breath and preparing to face your great adventure only to have some guy with a clipboard wander over and say 'Ok, point your finger at the moon. Good. Now, hit this button. Right, we're done here, the incinerator is over that way.'

Frankly? That's not good enough.

I can't fault Valve for their craftsmanship, it is impeccable as always, perhaps even more so than usual, but at the core of Portal 2 is a craven game. It is cowardly, it takes no risks, there is little to no true creativity (excepting only the scriptwriters). The story is impeccably told but essentially more of the same, except for the bit where it's as trite as a Disney fairy tale. The new tricks you acquire are either just things like moving platforms and extendible key rods turned into floaty tunnels and laser beams, or stuff that has already been done by another team for another project (namely the Tag: the Power of Paint team, who Valve hired into the project). The game's only saving grace is the co-op campaign. While the puzzles and learning curve suffer the same faults as the single player, the constant riffing on the theme of cooperation (or decided lack thereof) is a deliciously meta-constructed game in and of itself. I can't imagine Valve didn't plan for this and it's the one thing I can commend them for creatively. It's superbly done.


I detect a subtle hint of robo-supremacy in that first bit there...


Ultimately, however, Portal 2 is a game of illusions, of glitter and glamour, a masterful performance of sleight of hand and showmanship. It lacks the true magic of the original and it is that magic that makes a game great. The magic which leaves you feeling not just smart, but godlike, the rush of mental exertion paying off in grand style, in the firm knowledge that you and you alone fought and won, with your own two hands and mind. At the end of it I put aside my mouse and sat back, the only thought in my head “that was beautiful, but it could have been so much more”

How do you judge such a game? If this had been a new company, a new IP, a new designer, I would have been all praise, astounded, in fact, at the deftness and polish. But this is Valve, a titan of innovation and refinement. This is Valve with a huge team and close to a 4 year development cycle. Valve throwing more money and talent at the thing than exists in some small countries. Excellence is a baseline. Being blown away is about what you should expect on average.

Valve has no public shareholders to pander to, it has a reputation second to none save perhaps Blizzard amongst the PC gaming fraternity. Thanks to Steam, it makes more profit per head than Apple or Google, or so our lord Newell attests. In the dog eat dog world of videogame development, Valve is in an almost unique position to be able to take creative risks and push the field forward. In Portal 2, they have squandered that privileged position.

There is still hope, however. It's clear Valve intends to support Portal 2 actively, though to what extent remains unknown. I can imagine a future in which the campaign truly was meant as a tutorial, a strong, easy to use level editor is released and community generated puzzles and content flood in, enriched by a universal knowledge of the multitude of subtle uses to which the tools we have been provided can be put. I can also imagine a future in which we play the same co-op levels over and over again wearing various types of silly hats. This second is not a happy future though it will, fortunately, have awesome hats.

I write this out of frustration that acclaim has been so universal. As I have discussed above, it's hard not to be captivated and to come out at the end singing praise to Valve almighty. Not that that is a bad thing, but the starry eyed fanboyism that has penetrated deep into the games media prevents us from ensuring that Portal 3 is not just as good, but twice, three times or perhaps even ten times as good. If you're still high off Portal 2, can you even imagine just how sweet that would feel?

It's time we plunged into the pit, we took off the glasses of rose-tinted perspective and tested as if we were built to test. A game like this only comes once in a long while, and it is our duty to ensure it does not go to waste.

For Science, of course.

***
Poisonous Sheep counter Hydras
HaNdFisH
Profile Blog Joined February 2010
Australia119 Posts
April 29 2011 13:05 GMT
#2
That is almost exactly how I felt after finishing portal 2, the whole game felt like a tutorial where new pieces were introduced slowly and carefully and their uses were made obvious in every instance.

Hopefully there will be some new content, either from valve or the community that is the actual "game" rather than the 10 hour long tutorial.

The dialog/polish/environments were amazing however.
Gamerah
Profile Joined May 2010
United States85 Posts
May 06 2011 19:00 GMT
#3
TL;DR version, it was too easy?

I didnt expect valve to make any challenging maps at all really, since they were appealing to a mch larger audience, the casuals. Hell my cousin had the hardest time comprehending the concepts of portals at the beginning, and probably took like 30 minutes for the first 5 levels, the ones without glados. I really did think the entire portal 2 main story was a expertly crafted tutorial experience, but the real challenges would probably come from future patches of pure test changes and little story/audio, and from the community itself. I still haven't finished many portal 1 mappacks because they were too difficult and frustrating.

Follow in the footsteps of others, until you are good enough to make footsteps of your own.
Zlasher
Profile Blog Joined February 2010
United States9129 Posts
May 06 2011 19:33 GMT
#4
My problem with portal 2 is it no longer became a puzzle FPS, it decided to ditch all semblance of skill required for FPS's and just go with the puzzle aspect. No more fligning with momentum and stuff, now its just goo and tractor beams which slows down the pace of the game. Did not enjoy
Follow me: www.twitter.com/zlasher
rauk
Profile Blog Joined February 2009
United States2228 Posts
May 06 2011 20:08 GMT
#5
On May 07 2011 04:33 Zlasher wrote:
My problem with portal 2 is it no longer became a puzzle FPS, it decided to ditch all semblance of skill required for FPS's and just go with the puzzle aspect. No more fligning with momentum and stuff, now its just goo and tractor beams which slows down the pace of the game. Did not enjoy


that's because momentum puzzles were too hard with a controller
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Maestros of the Game
13:00
Playoffs - Round of 8
ShoWTimE vs herOLIVE!
TBD vs Serral
TBD vs Zoun
ComeBackTV 1647
RotterdaM1194
PiGStarcraft517
IndyStarCraft 353
SteadfastSC230
Rex150
CranKy Ducklings120
EnkiAlexander 76
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
RotterdaM 1194
PiGStarcraft517
IndyStarCraft 353
SteadfastSC 230
Rex 150
StarCraft: Brood War
Britney 11419
ggaemo 110
Hyun 63
sSak 36
yabsab 27
Shine 20
sas.Sziky 17
Hm[arnc] 12
Noble 7
Dota 2
The International192738
Gorgc17740
Dendi1135
BananaSlamJamma187
PGG 24
LuMiX0
Counter-Strike
flusha141
Super Smash Bros
Mew2King58
Other Games
tarik_tv27575
gofns20409
Mlord591
FrodaN590
Hui .346
mouzStarbuck220
KnowMe206
Khaldor178
ToD126
ArmadaUGS108
Trikslyr48
SortOf43
NeuroSwarm37
B2W.Neo17
fpsfer 1
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick614
EGCTV542
BasetradeTV21
StarCraft 2
Blizzard YouTube
StarCraft: Brood War
BSLTrovo
sctven
[ Show 16 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• LUISG 21
• LaughNgamezSOOP
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• sooper7s
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• Michael_bg 9
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
• BSLYoutube
Dota 2
• Ler87
• Noizen65
League of Legends
• Jankos2124
Other Games
• Shiphtur219
Upcoming Events
BSL Team Wars
2h 12m
Afreeca Starleague
17h 12m
Snow vs Sharp
Jaedong vs Mini
Wardi Open
18h 12m
OSC
1d 7h
Sparkling Tuna Cup
1d 17h
Afreeca Starleague
1d 17h
Light vs Speed
Larva vs Soma
PiGosaur Monday
2 days
LiuLi Cup
2 days
RSL Revival
3 days
Maru vs Reynor
Cure vs TriGGeR
The PondCast
3 days
[ Show More ]
RSL Revival
4 days
Zoun vs Classic
Korean StarCraft League
5 days
RSL Revival
5 days
[BSL 2025] Weekly
6 days
BSL Team Wars
6 days
RSL Revival
6 days
Online Event
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2025-09-10
SEL Season 2 Championship
HCC Europe

Ongoing

BSL 20 Team Wars
KCM Race Survival 2025 Season 3
BSL 21 Points
ASL Season 20
CSL 2025 AUTUMN (S18)
LASL Season 20
RSL Revival: Season 2
Maestros of the Game
Chzzk MurlocKing SC1 vs SC2 Cup #2
FISSURE Playground #2
BLAST Open Fall 2025
BLAST Open Fall Qual
Esports World Cup 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall Qual
IEM Cologne 2025
FISSURE Playground #1

Upcoming

2025 Chongqing Offline CUP
BSL Polish World Championship 2025
IPSL Winter 2025-26
BSL Season 21
SC4ALL: Brood War
BSL 21 Team A
SC4ALL: StarCraft II
EC S1
SL Budapest Major 2025
BLAST Rivals Fall 2025
IEM Chengdu 2025
PGL Masters Bucharest 2025
Thunderpick World Champ.
MESA Nomadic Masters Fall
CS Asia Championships 2025
ESL Pro League S22
StarSeries Fall 2025
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2025 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.