Battle Report II: Paranoia in TvZ

CakeOrI)eath

United States327 Posts

December 11 2011 12:55 GMT

In my previous blog, I covered the first game to put me up to C-. That was a little while ago, and I've been laddering hard since then. I was planning on doing another BR for the next game that put me over to C- but alas... tis the beginning of a new season I can't even make D+. I'm starting to share Gargamel's hatred of smurfs. After I watched this replay though, I really wanted to write a BR for it and here is the product of that insomnia causing urge.

Warning, some people might think this report is too detailed. I tried to add as much commentary on the mind games going on as I could, because that's what made this particular game so interesting to me. Hopefully, by explaining my thought process I can help beginning players gain a better understanding of some of the subtleties of the match up. Likewise, the great minds here at TL will hopefully point out where I got things wrong, or missed something important. But most of all I hope you enjoy it!

The Game
Rep: http://repdepot.net/replay.php?id=49816

I spawn at 5 and he spawns at 1 on Fighting Spirit. Barely into the game and he starts chatting. I quite enjoy friendly conversation at the beginning of a game but it quickly becomes clear that he's either trolling or trying to distract me.

[image loading]

This chat makes me rather suspicious of cheese and I'm lucky enough to scout his position first and see his 9pool.

[image loading]

I see a drone leave his base and so I follow it out to see if it makes an expo or if it was just a scout. He brilliantly sees my scv go down to check and hides his drone! I don't stick around because I don't want to get stuck on low ground after his lings get out and he promptly throws down the hatch.

[image loading]

At this point I'm really expecting heavy aggression, so I throw down a 2nd Rax. In hindsight an overreaction, but in the moment I thought it was justified. I realized my mistake as soon as I saw a drone pop out of larve after 8 lings.

[image loading]

Fortune was again on my side as his overlord scouted in the correct direction, but didn't have vision of my base and so he sent his lings the wrong direction. By the time his 8 lings got to my base, I already had a healthy enough number of marines to easily hold my ramp

[image loading]

My medics arrive and I move out to pressure while I finally take my own natural.

[image loading]

Alas, his sunkens are complete and I back off, content with the slight dent I put in his econ. I also spotted his spire timing, which was lucky since I never open with 2rax normally, so all my normal timings from 1rax expo couldn't be trusted.

[image loading]

Knowing mutas wouldn't be out for a little while, I sent my mm group roving to check for stupidly greedy 3rds. I check his natural 3rd, the main across from me, but nothing to be found... because he took the 9 o'clock! I continued to look for his 3rd the whole game, and eventually checked every since expo except for that one. Never saw it until I checked the replay =(

[image loading]

Despite not know the 2rax timings in the slightest, I still get off the money scan on his morphing mutas and get my turrets up with not a moment to spare.

[image loading]

I had probably over made turrets and so he wasn't very aggressive with his harrass, only killing 1 or 2 scvs at the nat and picking off the scv on the starport. I reacted quickly and got my tech up in decent time, but he was one step ahead of me. Because his hidden 3rd was just a little bit earlier than normal he was about to finish lurkers and had already started his hive.

[image loading]

At this point I'm still trying to figure out if he is doing a 2base all-in and so I scan the other 2 mains and 12 o'clock. It probably would have been better to scan his main to check his drone count / hive timing but I don't have the game sense to really be sure of what he is doing from drone counts. Something to work on!

[image loading]

I was very confused, since a 2base lurk-muta timing would have hit already but it really seemed to me as if he hadn't taken his 3rd. Almost to confirm my paranoia, his lurkers finally do show up and he tries to bait my mm over them with his mutas.

[image loading]

Although my vessel wasn't quite out yet, I had siege and a good size group of mm, so with a scan and a bit of a spread, I engage!

[image loading]

Victory! Just 30sec later and my vessel pops and I'm feeling really good about my upcoming push.

[image loading]

Up unto this point my macro had been great! After watching the rep, I confirmed that I didn't miss a depot the whole game (rather rare for me). My barracks had too much queued at times, but they were almost never idle. But still, my minerals shot up through the roof just as I started my push! I think this was because I had just completed my tech path, and I didn't have an outlet for the income that was going to that before.
The answer to all of that (I think), is that my additional rax were late (I only added them as I moved out and realized I had 1k!). They should have been added right after I start 3rd tank + vessel + irradiate.

[image loading]

As I move out I scan his natural and see just a few lings popping out. To me this means his army is out on the map, so I have to be very careful about counter attacks and surrounds. Sure enough, I catch just a brief glimpse of his force on the minimap as I advance!

[image loading]

I thought this was the start of a counter attack so I quickly turn my force around. But instead of catching him on my natural bridge, he goes for a pincer attack! Because I had turned my army around though, it meant that the two sides hit just slightly one after the other.

[image loading]

The end result was that I lost a good number of mm, but kept my tanks and vessel! Right here at this moment, I direct your attention to the 1700 minerals I have sitting in bank. That's 2 control groups of marines I could have had here! I really feel like that would easily have dealt with what he had left right then and there:

[image loading]

Instead, I had to wait for my reinforcements before I moved out again. By that time he had reinforced his own force with a large group of lings and it ended up being just too much for my meager force.

[image loading]

Soon after that, consume was finished, he had taken his 4th at 8 o'clock, and my time on this world was coming to an end. I started an expo at 6 o'clock to try and make a comeback.

[image loading]

I sent out scouts looking for the 3rd I knew he must have and all I found was a freshly made base. There were no drones on gas so I knew that couldn't be it.

[image loading]

And the final thrust, 3 defilers spamming swarm over lurker-ling in my natural.

[image loading]

For the umpteenth time so far this season, I played better starcraft than anything I ever did in previous seasons and was still crushed. Cursing myself and this game, I looked to my fellow player for redemption by asking a simple question; and his answer turned this loss from something shameful into an affirmation that I really am improving and that soon, someday, I might actually win a game just like this one.

[image loading]

JMave

Singapore1805 Posts

December 11 2011 13:18 GMT

A- nice

The_Templar

your Country52797 Posts

December 11 2011 13:35 GMT

GJ going toe-to-toe with an A-!

shucklesors

Singapore1176 Posts

December 11 2011 13:38 GMT

First picture made me laugh immediately. Awesome battle report, wasn't expecting a loss tbh.

sc4k

United Kingdom5454 Posts

December 11 2011 13:43 GMT

Hahha, that very last picture turns the entire experience from frustrating to amazing.

Hesmyrr

Canada5776 Posts

December 11 2011 14:13 GMT

I love detailed commentary

And it wasn't even that WoT...

Keyboard Warrior

United States1178 Posts

December 11 2011 14:47 GMT

You were no match for him.

He got you where he want you every step of the way.

craaaaack

479 Posts

December 11 2011 15:09 GMT

Sorry to disappoint but he certainly wasn't A- last season or ever. I got curious from your screenshots and checked his ICCUP profile. He didn't play all that much this season but judging from the screenshots I'd say he's C at best. Nice write-up though.

Black[CAT]

Malaysia2589 Posts

December 11 2011 15:14 GMT

Sending scv's out on the map to check for hidden bases is always good

3FFA

United States3931 Posts

December 11 2011 15:18 GMT

#10

At first pic I expected proxy hatch

. Also, nice job facing that A- just uhh.... wheres that replay you forgot? o.O
edit:

On December 12 2011 00:09 craaaaack wrote:
Sorry to disappoint but he certainly wasn't A- last season or ever. I got curious from your screenshots and checked his ICCUP profile. He didn't play all that much this season but judging from the screenshots I'd say he's C at best. Nice write-up though.

Can you link us to his profile please?

The_Templar

your Country52797 Posts

December 11 2011 15:45 GMT

#11

He didn't drone scout at the beginning?

FlaShFTW

United States10217 Posts

December 11 2011 16:41 GMT

#12

LOL A-. well all you gotta do next time is scout every base possibility.

gen.Sun

United States539 Posts

December 11 2011 16:44 GMT

#13

why u no virgin? :D

garlicface

Canada4196 Posts

December 11 2011 16:57 GMT

#14

On December 12 2011 01:44 gen.Sun wrote:
why u no virgin? :D

Yeah really? Why?

Nice detailed writing style. Was fun to read along.

mOnion

United States5657 Posts

December 11 2011 17:12 GMT

#15

I bet your PvT is still terrible

I miss you

great game btw! BW macro too hard imo

Roe

Canada6002 Posts

December 11 2011 17:16 GMT

#16

i always love these battle reports!

PenguinWithNuke

250 Posts

December 11 2011 18:33 GMT

#17

These broodwar battle reports are awesome! SC2 needs to churn some of these out. I always love to read these things.

surfinbird1

Germany999 Posts

December 11 2011 18:45 GMT

#18

Great job on the battle report. Always love to see people still playing and enjoying BW.

Megaliskuu

United States5123 Posts

December 11 2011 18:50 GMT

#19

LOL gg Andrew :>.

Also when I play on fish, and say something in english, they like asking stuff like "virgin?" or "u sex alot?"..its weird O_O.

Kiante

Australia7069 Posts

December 11 2011 19:01 GMT

#20

nice breport. I too know the feeling of losing to a hidden expansion. it burns deep inside, but you played a good game. nice

CakeOrI)eath

United States327 Posts

December 11 2011 19:39 GMT

#21

Thanks everyone for reading!

Just because that account hasn't played in previous seasons doesn't mean the guy didn't play.
I will admit, even though the way he played the mind games and the general flow of the game was at a very high level, there were some pretty big holes in his play. I honestly wouldn't expect an A- to have 1k min / 500 gas unspent at the critical moment of the game, his muta harass could have done more damage, etc. My suspicion is that he really was A- at some point, but his mechanics are a little rusty. Just a guess though, he could be making that up to.

On December 12 2011 00:14 Black[CAT] wrote:
Sending scv's out on the map to check for hidden bases is always good

Even if I scouted the 3rd with an scv I probably wouldn't have been able to kill it unless I found it before mutas were out. But, yea it would have helped set my mind at ease about the 2base all-in.

On December 12 2011 00:18 3FFA wrote:
At first pic I expected proxy hatch

. Also, nice job facing that A- just uhh.... wheres that replay you forgot? o.O
edit:

Can you link us to his profile please?

Added rep and:
http://www.iccup.com/starcraft/gamingprofile/wal.html

On December 12 2011 00:45 TehTemplar wrote:
He didn't drone scout at the beginning?

Nope, he used the drone to expand, used the overlord to check bottom-right (though he didn't look far enough) and sent lings to top-left. I'm not sure, but I doubt 9pool would be able to do as much damage cross map unless the Terran 14 CC, so it might not be worth the drone to scout.

On December 12 2011 02:12 mOnion wrote:
I bet your PvT is still terrible

I miss you

great game btw! BW macro too hard imo

Miss you too mOnion! You could always prove that my PvT is terrible... just play me anytime!

On December 12 2011 03:50 Megaliskuu wrote:
LOL gg Andrew :>.

Also when I play on fish, and say something in english, they like asking stuff like "virgin?" or "u sex alot?"..its weird O_O.

Thanks! At least this TvZ I wasn't mascaraed by stop lurkers! The guy spoke pretty good english, I kinda doubt he was KR. Definitely trollin though.

Normal

Please or register to reply.

Battle Report II: Paranoia in TvZ

Completed

Ongoing

Upcoming