|
I'm currently doing a 32 Man "Who would win in a fight" Superhero Bracket with some friends and we just had an intense debate over who would win between The Punisher and the Invisible Woman. My argument was that The Punisher is basically just a military guy with a van whereas the Invisible Woman can turn herself invisible as well as create forcefields and create psychic weapons. For reasons unknown to me, some people think The Punisher actually has a chance.
We could not come to a consensus over who would win so we need some outside votes. It should be noted that this fight is taking place on a neutral field to give an equal advantage to both.
The discussion is found the link below and starts at 1:46:45 and goes until 2:04:00.
http://www.4manrush.com/2011/11/02/podcast-8-the-schism/
Poll: Who wins in a fight?The Punisher (10) 53% The Invisible Woman (9) 47% 19 total votes Your vote: Who wins in a fight? (Vote): The Punisher
(Vote): The Invisible Woman
Please leave a comment on the site with the podcast with who you think should win. We will be tallying votes to determine who gets knocked out before next week. Thanks!
|
The Invisible Woman has a habit of getting caught in traps. In my opinion, the Punisher could take her out before she even thinks to turn invisible or use a forcefield.
|
Invisible Woman = Sentry/DT
Punisher = Ghost/Reaper/Raynor
Punisher>Invisible Woman.
|
On November 03 2011 13:36 Conquerer67 wrote:
Invisible Woman = Sentry/DT
Punisher = Ghost/Reaper/Raynor
Punisher>Invisible Woman.
Doesn't the Punisher need detection for that comparison to work? :p
|
I think that just based on power, invisible woman would win for sure.
|
On November 03 2011 13:38 Mr. Wiggles wrote:Show nested quote +On November 03 2011 13:36 Conquerer67 wrote:
Invisible Woman = Sentry/DT
Punisher = Ghost/Reaper/Raynor
Punisher>Invisible Woman. Doesn't the Punisher need detection for that comparison to work? :p
EMP Brah
|
United States33422 Posts
isn't it the entire Batman with resources of entire world and 3 months preparation vs superman thing ;o?
|
On November 03 2011 14:52 Waxangel wrote:
isn't it the entire Batman with resources of entire world and 3 months preparation vs superman thing ;o?
Pretty good comparison. As you may have heard in the mp3, my friends were swearing by the "tactical expertise" of Punisher. Not sure if I buy it though..
|
hard to say since punisher could set something up but straight up fighting i dont know what hes gonna do really other than shoot guns
|
In terms of sheer power Invisible Woman should win but...
Since Invisible Woman can't kill and the Punisher can't not kill, it's hard to say.
|
Depends on how it is set up. I mean, the Invisible Woman isn't going to see a sniper shot or a car bomb coming, she's not psychic. Lock them both in a room though and the Invisible Woman would do work.
|
It should be noted that this fight is taking place on a neutral field to give an equal advantage to both. It's somewhere between being locked in a room together and starting in different cities.
|
United Kingdom14464 Posts
IMO The Punisher is a just a pussy Batman who needs guns unlike real men, who use fists.
The Invisible Woman would win against him, but not against all non-super humans (such as Batman).
|
The Punisher doesn't need guns. Did you ever play the PC game?
|
10387 Posts
Well the situation depends .. if the Punisher and the Invisible Woman are thrown into a fight suddenly without them expecting it, the Invisible Woman would probably win easily. However, the more preparation the Punisher has, the better his chances imo
|
On November 04 2011 02:15 Lucumo wrote:
The Punisher doesn't need guns. Did you ever play the PC game?
I'm assuming he didn't fight any invisible people in this game.
|
I don't know anything about the invisible woman, can she throw ff's faster than bullets or is her reaction time normal? I'm not sure what 'equal' advantage means, I mean, if they both start visible I'm pretty sure punisher with his reaction speed can put a bullet in her before she can turn invisible and dodge.
|
On November 04 2011 22:47 Count9 wrote:
I don't know anything about the invisible woman, can she throw ff's faster than bullets or is her reaction time normal? I'm not sure what 'equal' advantage means, I mean, if they both start visible I'm pretty sure punisher with his reaction speed can put a bullet in her before she can turn invisible and dodge.
I'd assume she'd be able to turn invisible or throw up a forcefield before he could fire his gun.
|
Ok, come on, now you're just godmodding.
"I'd assume she'd be able to turn invisible or throw up a forcefield before he could fire his gun."
"I'm assuming he didn't fight any invisible people in this game."
What if she can't? And what if he did? 
That said, it's given the circumstances. However, I'm pretty iffy even on that.
On November 04 2011 00:28 Deadlift. wrote:
It should be noted that this fight is taking place on a neutral field to give an equal advantage to both. It's somewhere between being locked in a room together and starting in different cities.
Not sure I follow. A neutral field, but like a room and starting in different cities. A room full of cities? A field with 2 cities in it? Wut?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
