I feel like Nani is just going to all in all day er day after seeing her series against Hitman. I don't think he gives a damn about 'proving' anything.

sd_andeh

Sweden371 Posts

December 09 2013 03:34 GMT

I don't think NaNi feels like he needs to prove anything. He has proven himself in Korea, and he has proven himself in the foreigner scene. Scarlett would have to play GSL to do the same, and unfortunately with today's WCS system that won't happen.

I think Scarlett is the better player mechanically, while I think NaNiwa is smarter (RTS-wise) and has a bigger chance of becoming 'the best'. I believe NaNiwa has better chance at winning a WCS global finals than Scarlett does, so to speak.

DavoS

United States1909 Posts

December 09 2013 04:39 GMT

#10

Is this a "who do you like more" poll or a "Who is the better player" poll?

deathgod6

United States4974 Posts

December 09 2013 05:46 GMT

#11

I think this is one of those marry/kill/one night stand kinda things.

TJ31

630 Posts

December 09 2013 06:55 GMT

#12

On December 09 2013 13:39 DavoS wrote:
Is this a "who do you like more" poll or a "Who is the better player" poll?

Yeah... there's a big difference.
I dislike both, but I think Naniwa is a better player. So I voted "don't care/neutral".

Noz890

United States34 Posts

December 09 2013 07:18 GMT

#13

Naniwa by far. Lets see Scarlett even attempt to make a deep Code S run.

ppgButtercup

United States159 Posts

December 09 2013 08:54 GMT

#14

Aren't 1 and 3 the same thing?

ThePlagueJG

Sweden1010 Posts

December 09 2013 09:26 GMT

#15

I don't remember voting at all :O, but if I had to re do it I would have chosen Neutral since I consider them equal despite my NaNi bias.

FrostedMiniWheats

United States30729 Posts

December 09 2013 09:31 GMT

#16

Zerg-bias was the tipping point for me and I voted Scarlett.

I think Naniwa would win the showmatch, but Scarlett just seems better overall and I've been far more impressed with some of her A-game performances. Namely at Redbull battlegrounds.

As for if the poll is who I like more in popularity...tie I suppose. Really, it's nice they both are legit foreigners that can easily mix it up with the average Korean but screw em. I want my Stephano back T_T.

Innovator, entertainer, the true foreign king!

Drake

Germany6132 Posts

December 09 2013 11:46 GMT

#17

i think the different is
naniwa cheeses the koris out of tournaments (or mindgame strange strategy)
scarlett GET cheesed out of the tournament by koris ^_^

the respect difference they bring out vs scarlett for me is the point, they scared by her

but people here only vote by who they LIKE ^^ yes a showmatch could be good for nani since his pvz is good and her zvp isnt, but in overall skill, for me shes miles ahead.

protoss speaking here ^^

pms

Poland611 Posts

December 09 2013 11:52 GMT

#18

This question is badly timed.

Scarlet has had one runner-up tournament this year, and it happens to be the last one...

Naniwa had many more good showings this year, always slightly better than Scarlett, and was the only player to qualify to WCS Global Final.

pms

Poland611 Posts

December 09 2013 11:56 GMT

#19

Lol, this poll makes no sense anyway...

Is this about who do we think is the better player, or who do we like?