On June 19 2010 16:37 semantics wrote:
Well i suggested a long time ago have sc2 icons only in the sc2 section as like all of the sc2 section you will have a sc2 icon no choice about it.

I kinda like that idea because I don't wanna see the BW icons go to waste...especially cause judging by those examples the SC2 3d icons aren't really easy on the eyes

Sanguinarius

United States3427 Posts

July 08 2010 17:40 GMT

#24

On June 19 2010 02:07 jamaZn wrote:

Show nested quote +

thanks chill, i found this earlier along with a bunch of other posts regarding this topic with the flying monkies and got basically nothing out of it,

this post helped alot for anyone else new to TL looking for info on it

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=16170#1

Hrm, I dont see any flying monkeys. Might be something weird with my phone.

Anyway, I think having an option for SC1 or SC2 icons would be neat - but probably alot of work. I like the nostalgia associated with the SC1 though.

DemiSe

883 Posts

July 28 2010 18:22 GMT

#25

The icons looks pretty sweet.
I don't mind whether or not TL implement SC2 icons.

sYz-Adrenaline

United States1850 Posts

August 05 2010 00:55 GMT

#26

This idea needs more attention! I really like it and i so want to be a phoenix :o or spam like hell to get my dt icon :>

darmousseh

United States3437 Posts

January 14 2011 19:53 GMT

#27

This really needs to be bumped. I never played scbw and I can't tell what my icon is, although it kinda looks like a reaver. It would be great if an option to the profile was added to let you select which icons you preferred (scbw or sc2). I'm sure a lot of people would really like sc2 icons and the OP of this thread has a great list of icons.

darmousseh

United States3437 Posts

January 14 2011 19:56 GMT

#28

Also I recommend using a higher quality version of the image and using offset parameters so that users only have to download a single asset.

semantics

10040 Posts

January 14 2011 21:56 GMT

#29

I think motbob should post in this thread.

Torte de Lini

Germany38463 Posts

January 15 2011 23:21 GMT

#30

Keep these icons, but perhaps add a subtitle below in small-small print or something.

.Aar

Korea (South)2177 Posts

January 23 2011 08:31 GMT

#31

I like the idea of just having the BW icons. It's something that sort of defines TeamLiquid for me, and it's a good visual reminder of this website's roots.

t3tsubo

Canada682 Posts

January 25 2011 18:48 GMT

#32

On January 15 2011 04:53 darmousseh wrote:
This really needs to be bumped. I never played scbw and I can't tell what my icon is, although it kinda looks like a reaver. It would be great if an option to the profile was added to let you select which icons you preferred (scbw or sc2). I'm sure a lot of people would really like sc2 icons and the OP of this thread has a great list of icons.

this post makes me sad.

aimaimaim

Philippines2167 Posts

January 26 2011 12:53 GMT

#33

why dont we just remove all the things together?

im way over my head here but i think if this is going to be implemented .. its gonna create another divide on an already divided community ..

my 2 cents

emperorchampion

Canada9496 Posts

January 26 2011 15:06 GMT

#34

On January 26 2011 21:53 aimaimaim wrote:
why dont we just remove all the things together?

im way over my head here but i think if this is going to be implemented .. its gonna create another divide on an already divided community ..

my 2 cents

It's a really, really tough situation, because if you remove the BW icons then you alienate the BW players in a way. Also, it's cool to rank up- so having no icons would suck

. Personally, I think the best option, for the moment at least, is to keep the same icons- for those who don't know BW is still a big game, and an important part of our community. As well, as someone already said, it's a reminder of what started this whole site.

To those who don't understand what the icons mean, maybe you should look into the history of Starcraft and Teamliquid. Watch some BW, heck the OSL finals are coming up this weekend. This is a great opportunity to find out about Broodwar, I assure it's not a boring game!!

Funnytoss

Taiwan1471 Posts

January 27 2011 12:50 GMT

#35

On January 27 2011 00:06 emperorchampion wrote:

Show nested quote +

It's a really, really tough situation, because if you remove the BW icons then you alienate the BW players in a way. Also, it's cool to rank up- so having no icons would suck

Definitely agree. Even if TL becomes 90% SC2, 10% BW or something, I'd be in favor of keeping the BW icons, if only because that's where the site began.

Sarang

Australia2363 Posts

January 27 2011 23:19 GMT

#36

Why on earth would they just remove the BW icons? That's ridiculous. BW is still going strong, and while it is, there is absolutely no way the mods would remove the icons.

Hell, even if BW completely died, they'd probably keep the icons for nostalgic purposes.

Seriously, can you imagine the outcry if those icons were removed? It won't happen, so don't worry. =)

I'm all in favour of us being able to choose either SC2 or BW icons. Only problem is I'd have no idea which to choose. D:

(Oh and I have to disagree with Torte de Lini's idea of having subtitles under the icons, IMO that wouldn't look too flash. People can just figure out what the unusual ones look like on their own xD)