Well, being that I'm new, i really don't know anybody except Damdred. I'll go ahead and share a little about myself. I'm Old, Fatherly, Tech Support Genus, and attended college for English & Chinese. When it comes to talking, I'm a little reserved normally, I blame introversion and being ridiculed by girls! My hobbies include living peacefully and camping - camping for the win. Who else wants to share? How about you. Kush?

Mages

96 Posts

August 11 2014 01:45 GMT

#87

I can't help but feel I'm at a disadvantage still, people already stating townreads, all I'm seeing is introductory day 1 posting, course where im from this is a lot more than what i'm used to granted, but i will learn your ways. Is it considered a red herring for someone to so blatantly declare that they're town?

Mages

96 Posts

August 11 2014 02:43 GMT

#93

Okay gotcha, thanks for letting me know!

Mages

96 Posts

August 11 2014 02:56 GMT

#97

I basically got a "here i'm going to seem important and offer a high level of deductive reasoning based off discussion." So he's either very very good at the game, setting himself up to not talk too much and hoping his response could get lost in hundreds of posts, or something completely different.

Mages

96 Posts

August 11 2014 02:57 GMT

#98

So I guess I ask, IS he very very good at the game?

Mages

96 Posts

August 11 2014 03:00 GMT

#100

Sorry if I was unclear. I'm not certain on Koshi yet. But he's certainly talking big - and to me that seems like he either has game history to back up that he's good at the game and therefore can be a rallying force for good, or hes confident he won't be killed because he has an evil tendency. So can you tell me, is he what I am used to calling a power player? I'm used to there being 'so so' mafia players, and badasses.

Mages

96 Posts

August 11 2014 14:23 GMT

#174

Has TheKingOfTheCats Posted at all? (And is there an expedient way to see if he has been online or anything like a comment tracker here or seeing if he's posted in this thread specifically?)

Mages

96 Posts

August 11 2014 14:23 GMT

#175

Obviously I've searched the thread but didn't see anything, granted im on my 2nd cup of coffee and the newborns crying, so i may be moderately distracted.

Mages

96 Posts

August 11 2014 14:27 GMT

#181

Okay, thank you ( and sorry for double post, Im still adjusting to specific rules ). So he's posted but its mostly been comments of an inquisitorial nature. He's playing very safe and might be good based on the most basic consideration and limited interaction. I say I get a town read off of him.

Mages

96 Posts

August 11 2014 15:32 GMT

#210

Right, even i gave an explanation as to why I thought Cat was townie. Damdred, what do you think about Haru?

Mages

96 Posts

August 11 2014 15:50 GMT

#225

But see, I was trying to get to know people here too as it would get some conversation going, he started talking about fluffy stuff, the same could be said of me when i was giving out some background on me, i dont believe that anything in that was particularly suspicious, but whereas i have a genuine reason to downplay myself (as a newbie here), I dont know if MM had a reason to downplay himself as 'trash at forum mafia.' If he was trying to make me feel more at ease, that's one thing, but understand I have played mafia for the last decade, i'm not a weak player i just dont know people here yet. That is probably the most suspicious thing about MM that I find.

Mages

96 Posts

August 11 2014 16:05 GMT

#231

I think Koshi is good at least because of his ideas on the duality of downplaying between me and MM not being completely sound, how we both downplayed reasonably the same yet one of us was chosen as evil simply because of fluff. I had asked Kush at the beginning to tell me about himself so i could get to know him a wee bit better, the way he responded didn't look so nice.

Note : Bolds are mine to draw attention to the crux of my discussion.

On August 11 2014 08:39 Mages wrote:
Well, being that I'm new, i really don't know anybody except Damdred. I'll go ahead and share a little about myself. I'm Old, Fatherly, Tech Support Genus, and attended college for English & Chinese. When it comes to talking, I'm a little reserved normally, I blame introversion and being ridiculed by girls! My hobbies include living peacefully and camping - camping for the win. Who else wants to share? How about you. Kush?

On August 11 2014 09:32 kushm4sta wrote:
rayn-no spamin
ve-nice to see you again. i love you <3
MysteryMeat1-wasup cutie
Damdred-hii there
onevone-who teh fuck are you
koc-awww yeahs omgus represent
Mages-who the fuck are you, guy
koshi-please dont rage bro
batsnacks-remember damdred, lol
Sn0_Man-wb
Onegu-how's thailand or whatever
HaruRH-u are one sketchy mofo

and so ends the most comprehensively useless post of all time

So, Koshi's fine to me, Kush is a little bit more suspicious because of hostility, and Onevone im gonna need a little bit more time on.

Mages

96 Posts

August 11 2014 16:16 GMT

#235

Ohhh, okay I got ya. That makes more sense One

Mages

96 Posts

August 11 2014 17:15 GMT

#262

On August 12 2014 01:47 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Mages where have you played mafia in the past 4 years?

I started playing WW in 2000, with high school friends. I've jumped from one board to the next as players stopped playing.
I play with Damdred currently on another board.

Mages

96 Posts

August 11 2014 18:05 GMT

#276

I'm kind of leaning that way.

Mages

96 Posts

August 11 2014 18:34 GMT

#307

Right, they should be at the same level until we get a read on him. Cats has had opportunity, so I guess that's what I'm going with, please feel free to change my mind.

##vote TheKingofCats

Mages

96 Posts

August 11 2014 18:37 GMT

#311

Mostly because I can only vote for one person per day. I was on the fence about em both but just wanna vote for somebody that i believe can be evil so the pressure to vote is off. I dont want time to elapse and me not have cast a vote at all, and given that i can change, upon further evaluation i may choose to do so, it is only day 1 after all.