On August 31 2013 01:37 VayneAuthority wrote:
Also I have a very good reason to play very pro-town this game, so get off my nuts ty

already showed in my first post through elegant trickery that i'm not scum

Why does he have to shout to everyone "Hey guys I'm playing pro-town". When the obvious best thing to do was be reasonable and continue scum hunting. He does that immediately after anyways. So that makes me think why reveal at all?

Another thing that struck out to me was

On August 31 2013 01:33 VayneAuthority wrote:
cephiro, felkyr, obviousone all scum lol

this game is easy so far

cephiro - get softly discredited by multiple people for "caring about the game" when I play differently every game so it's just an excuse to have an opinion. My case is promptly swept under the rug and nobody ever mentions him again until he responds to my post.

Felkyr - how long did it take you to make that entrance post, an hour?

obviousone - Instead of going with town sentiment and finding me scummy he immediately jumps to a 3rd party conclusion since he knows I'm not on his scumteam. Very strange conclusion to draw this early in the game.

Bold mine.
When reading though the thread I don't feel like there was any town sentiment that Vayne was scummy at the time. Did I just read the thread wrong/forgot about it in the 500+ posts I read, or was there actually town sentiment who wanted vayne lynched?

randombum

United States2378 Posts

August 30 2013 19:46 GMT

#890

I realize and remember there were some who were looking at him, but I don't get where he feels like the whole "town sentiment" was out against him. Seems like somebody who takes thing far too personally, or what I'm leaning on a scum playing scared.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

August 30 2013 19:50 GMT

#893

My gut also said lynch gerpt, since he's pretty much done nothing but throw out random THESE ARE SCUM. With no explanation until he is pressured into giving them. However the timing of his posts gives him a little leeway since it was so early in d1 when honestly there's little else to talk about.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

August 30 2013 19:51 GMT

#895

On August 31 2013 04:47 VayneAuthority wrote:

Show nested quote +

we've played together before. I was blindalbino in TL mafia II. I can take on many different personalities.

Oh god, I hated that game. So imbalanced!

randombum

United States2378 Posts

August 30 2013 23:15 GMT

#1051

Well, I wanted to give geript a chance, but his most recent play deserves a vote.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

August 31 2013 00:31 GMT

#1061

On August 31 2013 08:40 strongandbig wrote:
i still can't decide what to do with geript. randombum i choose you! Why does his claim mean I should vote for him.

well to begin with I didn't like anything he said at the start, but I didn't do too much since early d1 means very little. And it's not necessarily not his claim that I dislike. But read his next four posts after the claim. He's completely stopped trying to offer the town anything. That on top of my gut reading is enough for me to vote him.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

August 31 2013 01:38 GMT

#1094

I don't know if you deserve credit for getting cora replaced by dandel (whom I'm not sure is as good of a player as you seem to think since dandel failed to make us gods amongst mafia players in our last game together). Like you said you didn't expect that as the outcome. So what could have happened was he gets super angry, but not quit, and the two of you argue in thread dis-railing everything which one could easily see as a scum thing to do.

I personally want to believe you weren't trying to get him to quit, because winning by being so unfun to play with that others quit is no good.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

August 31 2013 01:40 GMT

#1097

You can still be scum though.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

August 31 2013 07:00 GMT

#1148

Risen now that you are presumably going to post more, how do you feel about the geript lynch, and if not him who would be your lynch target?

randombum

United States2378 Posts

August 31 2013 07:27 GMT

#1150

So do you still think wos is anti-town?

randombum

United States2378 Posts

August 31 2013 08:22 GMT

#1155

Risen, you don't think there's merit in somebody calling you out that you responded negatively towards somebody, essentially calling them anti-town, but you have zero follow up and eventually conclude the dude is town anyways?

Outside of cheesecake what are your feelings. What about geript since he's the forerunner at the moment.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

August 31 2013 08:37 GMT

#1156

Going to bed and I won't be able to play of this game tomorrow till way past deadline. I may be able to comment on something directly pointed at me, but little else. Will probably also be able to change vote to help get majority.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

September 03 2013 02:48 GMT

#2300

Ok I'm back.

First thing's first I still believe geript is scum. There's just this sense of not caring about the lynch. Then there's the fact that he basically wasted everybody's time with his un-lynchable claim (which was a lie) and subsequent discussion about it. He eliminated a lot of town information by using this ability so early.

As he said

On September 01 2013 06:51 geript wrote:
Vote placement is completely inconsequential and doesn't matter in the slightest. People should wholly disregard a large majority of the votes today.

Vote placement is normally a good source of information for town since when somebody flips we know his alignment and who voted/pushed for him.

And it doesn't help that he killed a townie.

Basically, everything he did day 1 has hurt town. He wasted our time, denied us information, and killed a town player.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

September 03 2013 03:12 GMT

#2302

I don't see any likely situation where both hassy and kita are both town and claiming different things. It's possible, but so unlikely that I feel one of them has to be mafia. I think it's Hassy.

I could also get behind a slam lynch because while there's possible reasons a town would use his item I don't really see any likely ones. Then again, there's even less likely reasons for a scum to tell the thread that he's going to do so. Dunno, I guess everybody saying he's unreadable is true.

Hiropro- I see why people would be voting for him, but I don't think I find any cases compelling. All that shit about brown and is pretty scummy, but he has recently started to do other stuff and actually scum-hunt.

Also, I'm suspicious of risen because he pretty much ignored me and has since still failed to do much in this game. Don't think he's a likely lynch at this point though.

Current thoughts on my lynch preference would be something like

Geript>>>hassy/slam>Risen.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

September 03 2013 03:52 GMT

#2307

On September 03 2013 12:21 geript wrote:

Show nested quote +

None of this actually makes me scum.

That's like the definition of scum? Make it as difficult as possible for town to win.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

September 03 2013 19:13 GMT

#2496

With what has been said since my last post I feel a bit better about slam and hassy. Slam apparently has stated he will start posting coherently, and Hassy's claim makes me want to believe that. However during this time I've gotten worse feelings about risen. He still hasn't done anything to help town find scum. Perhaps this will spur him to try a little harder.

##vote risen

I would still happily support a lynch on any of these 4 with geript still being my top choice.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

September 03 2013 19:23 GMT

#2499

On September 04 2013 04:16 Clarity_nl wrote:

Show nested quote +

Or this dude, holy fuck.

"yeah well, there's 4 possible lynches that I have nothing to do with and all of them are fine, but let me put my vote on risen as PRESSURE so that he does something"

I've been on geript since forever, slam/hassy seem to be what the thread is heading towards and who I had commented on before.

So, comment on thread sentiment is wrong, following up my previous statements is wrong, and start on somebody else is wrong. What am I suppose to do? Come up with a huge case on somebody who hasn't been considered at all and try to swing enough people in under 5 hours to get him lynched when my top scum target is still alive?

You've been on my ass all game clarity it's getting annoying.

1 2 3 Next All

Please or register to reply.

Live Events Refresh