The Game [N]

On March 16 2013 17:33 goodkarma wrote:
Let's look at Viscera's "policy post." I disagree with pretty much everything he has to say in his attempt at starting a circle.:




Anyhow, going to bed. Will be back tomorrow. I humbly request we focus on scumhunting.

Thank you and good night.

Overall, leaning scum on geript.

On March 17 2013 09:22 Wade Fell wrote:


More reason, btw, why his so-called "case" on coag is bad. He should definitely know better.

On March 17 2013 20:36 DarthPunk wrote:


LoL just cacthing up now. One thing though. I doubt anyone could interpret my vote as anything more than some pressure to stop his RNG bullshit. That's clearly what it was but you claiming that I was trying to lynch him off that is complete BS.

I doubt this misinterpretation could be anything but deliberate.

##unvote

##Vote:Cosmicomics

Explain how the fuck you think I was actually doing anything more than a pressure vote on someone in order to get them to cease a terrible idea/plan?

On March 17 2013 19:41 sciberbia wrote:
Thoughts on lynch candidates

GreyMist
I could pretty easily see GreyMist being scum. I agree with what sandroba and somebody else said about his first post. Then he lurked for a while. Upon emerging from lurking, he jumped on a post of GK accusing him of lurking saying "I've been waiting for this!". Then he repeatedly piled on GK. I see scum motivation here where greymist justifies his lurking and pushes a mislynch. Two birds with one stone. Also, I don't think his arguments about GK are particularly good. I wouldn't feel too bad about a greymist lynch today.

Peashooter
I don't want to lynch him. Pretty good chance he's town. He drew attention to himself with the Coag thing, continued to push Coag, picked a fight with DH, and has shown willingness to interact with the thread. Seems more likely town than not. Not sure if he is even a lynch candidate anymore.

Coagulation
I don't vote people unless I think they are scum and I really don't have a clue. if I had to hazard a guess I would say town.

TestSubject
The main accusation seems to be that he chose to talk about stuff other than who he thinks is scum. I don't know TestSubject but he seems relatively new so it's a bit unreasonable to demand original scumreads after just one read-through. Also, his willingness to interact with the thead and some of the stuff he says about GK gives me a townie feel. Not interested in lynching TestSubject.

zarepath
I'm pretty interested in lynching this guy.

I stated some supsicions before and his behavior since then further suggests he is scum. Here are the quotes:
+ Show Spoiler +

I don't like the first post at all. He says he hasn't commented on the GK or TPS bandwaggons because he isn't "entirely convinced". Again, he makes it seem like he is very suspicious of people but doesn't commit. He says that the fact that TPS is a proxy "muddles the waters a bit" but does not explain at all how it affects his read of TPS. Seems like a way to just avoid having to give a read on TPS.

Furthermore, he describes GK's behavior as "quite scummy" but then sympathizes with the same behavior that he just called "quite scummy." More of the same non-commital and devil's advocate.

Next, he says he is busy on Sundays and disappears when I ask him to clarify his read on TPS.

goodkarma
Here are some of the more important reasons that I found goodkarma suspicious:
- he felt the need to comment on VE's SAST post but didn't come to any conclusion about VE from it
- his first few posts reek of 'i am goint to say non-controversial things so please don't pay any attention to me'
- his playing mr. nice guy with coag

However, after reading through some of his previous games, I think there's a pretty decent chance he's townie this game. He loves to talk about policy in general so I can see him going out of his way to talk policy about VE. Also, his posts since his accusation of Greymist have just been giving me a townier feel. He is willing to talk with people in the thread and isn't just vanishing like scum are prone to do when under pressure.

Blech I dunno about this guy. Right now my gut feeling is town.

cosmicomics
I don't know if he's really a lynch candidate but his filter is pretty alarming. It consists of a pretty much 100% sheep off of layabout onto DP and pretty much nothing else. Also I think he is a smurf which makes this an even bigger cause for concern.

---

I feel best about a zarepath lynch. I'm voting him now. Going to bed pretty soon but will be online for at least a little while longer if anyone wants to discuss something with me.

##Vote: zarepath

On March 17 2013 23:29 glurio wrote:
Ok finally done with reading.
Here are some of my thoughts on the first read through.

zarepath: I played two newbie games with him and he's always busy on weekends, and so far he always gave me a slightly scummy vibe D1 although he was town. He usually picks up his play along the way, so i really can't support a zarepath lynch today.

TestSubject: In his last game where he was anti-town he played pretty tame D1, usually agreeing to stuff and basically not drawing attention, picking a fight with one of the loudest voices in the thread? Don't think he would draw that much attention to him as scum. He won't get a vote from me either.

TPS: While i think his setup speculation makes for a scummy beginning he kinda redeemed himself for me with his posts pointing out coagulation who i think looks scummy right now.

Coagulation: I think he looks scummy. Although he has a few posts none of them have any kind of content. Since he obviously is not new to mafia, i really think he should pick up his play.

sandroba: His play (or the lack of) also lacks town motivation. If you compare it to his last game where he was town (Fruity Mafia). He actively pursuits his scum reads, asks them question, all of this completely non-existant this game.

He posts this but so far no follow-up.
Scum.

##Vote: sandroba

On March 17 2013 23:29 glurio wrote:
Ok finally done with reading.
Here are some of my thoughts on the first read through.

zarepath: I played two newbie games with him and he's always busy on weekends, and so far he always gave me a slightly scummy vibe D1 although he was town. He usually picks up his play along the way, so i really can't support a zarepath lynch today.

sandroba: His play (or the lack of) also lacks town motivation. If you compare it to his last game where he was town (Fruity Mafia). He actively pursuits his scum reads, asks them question, all of this completely non-existant this game.

He posts this but so far no follow-up.
Scum.

##Vote: sandroba

On March 18 2013 02:06 Mr. Wiggles wrote:
I'm still catching up, but to Kenpachi and Kitaman if you're still around, are you still in support of your votes on GK, or are you looking at other candidates?