Newbie Mini Mafia XXXVIII

On March 08 2013 02:06 OmniEulogy wrote:
@Arctic Can give us your thoughts on what has happened so far and answer most of the questions I have asked to the others.

On March 09 2013 00:34 TheRavensName wrote:


Why did you change your vote with no explination over the course of 13 minutes?

On March 09 2013 03:37 OmniEulogy wrote:
My Case on Frorgon



I believe now it is applicable to call you a lurker. I'm kind of confused as to why you think it is scummy to attack people to see their reactions and how they react under pressure. I've seen players vote on almost everybody in the game by the end of D1 who weren't scum but were fishing for information, I have yet to see scum play so ballsy.

You claim to not be afraid to call people out on things but when you tried you were almost afraid to commit and were very back and forth about it.



"The amount you talk to yourself while nobody is here raises a red flag, everything you've said while more than 1 person has been here has been awesome!" what? This to me seems like scum trying to pretend to contribute while at the same time not trying to make anybody upset. It wouldn't have made me look at it twice if you had been active and contributing but as we all know you've made 4 posts in nearly 48 hours. This is not acceptable for town. This is the behavior of scum.



So many things wrong with your last post.
- Attacks the weakest player in the game NW, WITHOUT placing a vote. Just a casual "wow you are so scummy"
- Makes an association case between NW and Bduddy.
- Claims he will make his case and we will have plenty of time to analyze and go over it. Nice case he's made.

##Vote: Frogron

We need to step it up town. The only two players I can identify as even having a chance at being town are Krafla and Rainbows. If you are town and have been content to just stay quiet and not contribute, wake the fuck up. Nobody is getting replaced tonight, stop talking about it. Everybody has posted D1 the only way somebody is getting replaced is if they don't vote.

The following players are also on my list of potential scum

Arctic Daishi - Playing the noob card after lurking for 36~ hours, NOT a smart move. I want to see some serious contribution from you starting D2 and if I don't I will be pushing for your lynch. Hell if Frogron can save his ass before the end of D1 from me I'll go after you in the next 7 hours.

Bduddy - Lurking, scummy, if Frogron hadn't contributed less I'd be happy to see him gone today. BUT he does claim he's been busy so for D1 he gets some slack. Could just be an uninterested townie. Nothing to really disprove that so far.

ChewOnStu - almost as bad as Frogron, really bad sheep vote. scummy.

NobodyWonder I was going to vote on for most of today but realized if he is lynched and flips town we gain nothing, I'm not against seeing him lynched as I agree he's scummy as hell but I don't want to put all of our eggs in one basket.

And then there is also Matriarch who is lurking as well... the largest problem I can see here, IS THAT THERE IS NO WAY ALL OF YOU ARE SCUM. So TOWNIES again I ask Wake The Fuck Up. I am seriously getting annoyed by the lack of activity out of you. You will cost us this game if you don't snap out of it before we end up lynching you.

On March 09 2013 06:10 Frorgon wrote:
@Arctic What about Omni's case is so "great"? The claim that I have contributed the least? Because I'm pretty sure you've contributed less than me. Seems pretty easy for you to just sit back and buddy up with people without at least explaining why you like their case so much.

On March 08 2013 06:29 Frorgon wrote:
@OmniEulogy I'm wondering why you asked me about what I thought was suspicious behavior. I clearly explained that in my initial post about the matter. It made me a bit uneasy about whether or not you were trying to get redundant information posted to cloud up the thread. As Wave said, the amount of posts you had started to raise a red flag for me. And don't get me wrong, it's not necessarily the amount of posts you had that was bad, it was that you seemed to be drowning the thread for a while with just your thoughts and limited discussion from others. That being said, I feel better about your contributions in the past few pages since other people have shown up.

On March 09 2013 06:40 Frorgon wrote:
@ArcticDaishi There is no shame in questioning someone's logic, in this case Omni. This will hopefully lead to better analysis in the future. I don't see how this would be an attempt to stop his investigation. I don't consider my behavior towards him to have been hostile, especially since I noted how I liked a lot of the recent analysis he had made.

Meanwhile, you ignore my questions towards you completely and instead try to turn the discussion onto me. I'd still like to hear your response to my question of why you loved Omni's initial read on me so much.

On March 09 2013 06:45 nobodywonder wrote:
I'd like Chew, Matriarch, MLuneth, Krafla to respond. They haven't said anything since their votes. Otherwise town gets no info from my lynch.

I second Omni's post about Arctic. I have to say you won't get any information from an Arctic lynch. On this basis, Frogron, you should change your vote on bduddy. for all your talk about contributions and your contributions in comparison to other posters such as bduddy and Arctic, you really need to make a stand

On March 09 2013 09:16 bduddy wrote:
Whether scum or not it appears that Arctic Daishi is basically clueless (or pretending to be). Not saying we should back off, just saying.

AD, you say this is your first time, but honestly, have you been reading this thread at all? Do you know how Mafia works? Because you're not showing either very well right now.

On March 09 2013 09:15 WaveofShadow wrote:
Wow. So now that Daishi has moved his vote to defend himself without even explaining I think we're pretty clear on where he stands.
As for the rest of you guys, you'd better move your votes onto him right now if you dont want a mislynch.

On March 09 2013 09:38 WaveofShadow wrote:
The problem here is, like OE said if he was using his coach, his coach certainly would've been telling him not to afk the whole day and to actually contribute to the scumhunt, of which he did neither.

Worst case scenario, he is bad townie (downgrade that to completely useless townie) and wasn't of any help to us anyway. Better than mislynching a townie who is actually helpful.

On March 09 2013 09:41 TheRavensName wrote:
Arctic, your being lynched because you only show up to vote on band wagons and when asked for opinions or reasons you never respond to them. That makes you incredibly scummy. Even if it your not scum, if your going to jump on evey band wagon thats a liability later in if the scum starts one up. You have to be able to think for yourself and not really on others if you can help it in Mafia, and your not doing a good job of showing you can do that. You've even shown that up until now you haven't been reading the thread all that well if at all.

On March 09 2013 09:55 bduddy wrote:
Well... good job, team. Or something like that, anyway.

You know you can do that after you actually get lynched, right?

On March 09 2013 09:57 WaveofShadow wrote:
Lol well if true it was a valiant attempt with half an hour to go to try and get your innocence going.
Hopefully you learn a little for next time!