Death Note Mini Mafia

On August 30 2012 04:59 Blazinghand wrote:


Wait, L is playing in this? I haven't seen that dude in months.

On August 30 2012 21:48 Mementoss wrote:


By this he means, every time you put together a case that no one else believes just tell them if your wrong you'll eat your hat.

On August 31 2012 21:51 Mementoss wrote:


Im not familiar with zentor fill me in

On August 31 2012 22:51 ghost_403 wrote:
Calm down, Hapa. Just because BMB wrote up a subpar case on Day 1 does not mean that he's scum. BMB (aka DoctorHelvetica) is very good at this game. I doubt that anyone can know his alignment quite yet, nevermind based on a single case he's presented on Day 1.

@BMB: You are DrH, right?

On August 31 2012 23:22 ghost_403 wrote:


I'm not attacking, I'm telling him to take a step back and evaluate whether he thinks that BMB's case was due to (a) him being scum or (b) him writing up a case 5 hours into the game. The two of those are very different, and I don't see evidence in his analysis of him thinking that question through.

On August 31 2012 23:27 ghost_403 wrote:
Risen is very aggressive in Mafia when he plays town. He's abrasive and abusive and plays hard. In this game, I haven't seen that quite yet. I'm still trying to decide why that is. It could just be that we're 12 hours into the game, and he hasn't had an opportunity to call anyone stupid yet.

On August 31 2012 23:29 ghost_403 wrote:


WIFOM mode engage!

Don't you think that someone as good as BMB would, as scum, be more careful to not make a bad case?

I see this as BMB just being aggressive and trying to get the ball moving. I can't imagine him being quite so bold and careless as scum.

Do you think that his case is really a scum-tell?

On September 01 2012 00:41 ghost_403 wrote:
@hopeless: My problem is that I can't see a scum motivation for BMB presenting a bad case. Bringing forward an immature (as in age) case like that doesn't buy him any towncred. He didn't need it to prove that he's active in this game. It's not like he's trying to convince the town to stop listening to Hapa. I can't see why a scum BMB would present that case.

On September 01 2012 00:49 ghost_403 wrote:
That post would make more sense if it had ended up below Marv's post on the previous page. Serves me right for not specifying who that comment was aimed at.

(it's you, Marv.)

On September 01 2012 04:47 strongandbig wrote:


Marv you were obsing ptp. VE and wiggles both made cases that were just as crappy as this one, I called them both scum, and they both flipped town. I just am not convinced that making bad cases is a good scum tell anymore. Like, does his case push a scum agenda or sew confusion? No, to me it just looks bad.

It is weird that blackmamba just disappeared. If he leaves his vote on hapahauli without making a new case then he'll jump to the top of my scum list.



And one other thing - I had been looking at hapa's vote on hopeless as "I think you are scum and want to kill you." That's how I vote - if I vote early in the day like that, I expect everyone to understand from that "I really mean what I'm saying right now, I'm serious about it." Like I said last time, it makes no sense when you think of it as meaning that, but when you change how you're thinking of it to a "pressure vote" it sounds better.