Yeah we'll have to use it eventually but if it's one of the least mafia favored then we should probably save it for a day when we can't risk anything worse. Personally I think we should either use mafia get a vote or it takes majority +1 today

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

May 30 2012 03:17 GMT

#54

Also I'm fine with the encrypt idea but to be safe everyone needs to choose a real word or phrase as their key because if scum wanted to really put the work in they could choose a gibberish key, post the result, then figure out what gibberish key would take that result into the other vote, so make the key an actual word or phrase. Also make sure your vote isn't just the name of the position obviously because then they just count the letters, make it something longer like "my vote is for X as mafia position".

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

May 30 2012 03:19 GMT

#55

That's not as bad as no flip or secret ballot, I think those should not be used, other than those I think we should get rid of the worst late game ones we have left.

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

May 30 2012 04:37 GMT

#63

Lynch lock is definitely not that bad, it's actually the standard vote method on other sites and im used to using it right now, also sloosh splitting it further makes mafia's secret vote less useful not more, with majority lynch rules there's no way with even people they can cause a mislynch by tie and if it's split they just throw another vote into the mix, no way that causes a mislynch, worst case scenario if we choose that day 1 is if we for some reason (and there are almost 0) we want a no-lynch and they push someone over. For that reason i think a mafia vote for today is probably a good choice.

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

May 30 2012 19:02 GMT

#111

My vote
+ Show Spoiler +

ZZZZZ GVRSG KTULX EDLNH OTJLU XGKUU XEIOK PKIWI IRUCV RDGQQ QBGFF
DQRJI ASFKU XLUBV AXNFG VETUB WWJRT JEHTD HOBHO PVHKB UZZZZ YYYYY

I'll comment later or after the day post, if I comment now my vote will be obvious.

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

May 30 2012 21:58 GMT

#139

Just voted for mafia hidden vote, I agree that it will be hard to get a majority day 1 so majority plus 1 should be saved til tomorrow at least.

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

June 01 2012 02:00 GMT

#229

Key: LQFSH-QASBA-YLXPQ-NRQIR-GHEZR-QKFLB-FSHPM-VLKAN-RYVSG-WXHHT-IKNVL-VMLNS

Vote: + Show Spoiler +

ZZZZZ GVRSG KTULX EDLNH OTJLU XGKUU XEIOK PKIWI IRUCV RDGQQ QBGFF
DQRJI ASFKU XLUBV AXNFG VETUB WWJRT JEHTD HOBHO PVHKB UZZZZ YYYYY

I voted roleblocker

Hiro I don't entirely understand, if you think mafia would choose tracker no matter what why choose GF, RB seems like the best role to give them if we're probably gonna get a tracker.

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

June 01 2012 02:02 GMT

#230

Ninjaed EBWOP: I will at some point look at Kurumi's meta to check that out but if you're really sure of that it would be very helpful if you linked some of the posts in this game and some of the games in his meta that lead you to this WBG

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

June 01 2012 22:09 GMT

#298

First I'll say for the sake of people knowing I'm not new, I've been playing on another site, I've played a few games here before, and if you go checking the other site (mafiascum) I have played as scum. With that out of the way...

WBG I think you're getting games confused, you wanted to lynch me in the OTHER game, not this one silly. More seriously one thing that I didn't realize before that game because I was used to games with a couple weeks to each day was that I have a fairly short period of possible activity in my days, I get home at 4-5pm edt and go to sleep at probably 12-1am so just in terms of the course of a day i won't be posting for more than 2/3s of it.

Also can we get a votecount

for now ##Vote: Zephirdd He has no posts that really push anyone, he's defensive, asks questions, points out what he apparently thinks is a scummy post then forgets about it and the poster (nuke's post). He basically doesn't look like he's trying to find scum in any of his posts, just that he wants to keep talking and look active. Now I would like to know from someone else because I don't remember anything about who's a vet here or not, how much has he played/how experienced is he, I could see his type of posting from someone new and not wanting to push people but I also thought I saw him referring to some older game so he doesn't sound new. (if he's like the most experienced person here and that was a really dumb question my bad)

I also am not a huge fan of the hiro lynch because I personally am bad at getting setup specific reads, but I also think it could be a legitimate slip, he wouldn't be my first choice (obviously that's zeph) but I also don't have a town read or something on him.

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

June 01 2012 22:59 GMT

#311

12 people, majority 7

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

June 01 2012 23:03 GMT

#314

1. It's really late for you to be pushing someone totally new and 2. you haven't made any sort of case on him, what about toad is scummy?

Navillus

United States1188 Posts

June 02 2012 01:39 GMT

#355

Okay I don't see this getting moved before I die, though I would say I still fully support a Zephridd lynch, and prplhz I wasn't apologetic because it was one afk stretch and I simply planned to be more active, I also clearly didn't want you to defend me more (and I think that's a definite misconstrual of what I was saying) as I specifically contradicted you in me being new or never playing scum despite it being on another site.

Anyway I guess I'll go into reads since I'll be confirmed soon enough.

I'm looking at toad right now who definitely looks suspicious, he votes me after literally one post that only calls me a plan B behind 2 other people and in general talks a lot without many reads or relevant posts.

I would worry about risk who has 100% lurked up until this point and the fact is I think there are many games where town screws itself over while a bunch of mafia just lurk the day away so either kill him or stop his lurking letting him live more than another day or 2 the way he's playing now would be shooting town in the foot.

Finally I would ABSOLUTELY lynch zephirdd who without doing anything big or protown or even being here managed to get a fairly big wagon to disappear off of him onto me. Actually he didn't get it to disappear others did but that would point strongly along with his very scummy activity beforehand to him being scum so I would make him the first lynch then I would look very hard at the people who pushed me early and got the wagon to move. PLEASE DON'T FORGET THIS. I imagine most people will by tomorrow's day post but I think it definitely could point to a number of people.

I would particularly look at rad and wbg simply because I think they're good enough that both could pull of looking very town even if they're not and they both helped move this lynch.