This is one of the more unusual situations I have replaced into. I have just finished catching up but I am stepping out for the evening. I will have a more in-depth post tomorrow morning.

The short version of my thoughts right now is that we should definitely be going after the list of people that got Radfield killed. So that's me, Cwave, Jackal, Bum, Wiggles, and Blazinghand. I agree with the people that just posted that Blazinghand is not looking scummy, and obviously Wiggles doesn't need to be looked at.

Therefore we should focus our efforts on Cwave, Jackal, and Bum. I am confident that at least two of them are scum.

Scamp

United States1086 Posts

January 29 2012 17:18 GMT

#522

Well this is just awesome, I wake up to a smattering of votes. While four of you have it right, I'm now suspicious of vaderseven, Refallen, and Jackal58. Don't pretend that the Radfield debacle isn't important or a good source of information.

Refallen may get a reprieve here depending on what happens with redFF, but I personally don't get what he's doing at all. If he has some kind of power that activates when people vote him, then why doesn't he ask for everyone to vote him? The rules don't actually say anything about when the lynch ends, I think it's just at the end of the day. I don't think there's any kind of majority hammer.

Also this seriously caught my eye.

On January 29 2012 13:38 Navillus wrote:
1. While I would love a CWave lynch and think the Wiggles shot also points to him being scum, I also think the Wiggles shot was probably them fishing for blues.

How exactly do you figure this?

Scamp

United States1086 Posts

January 30 2012 10:55 GMT

#574

Vader I said very clearly that I think we should focus on the members of the Radfield lynch. Going away from that idea is anti-town. I don't mind looking into other people or questioning actions or whatever, I'm not expecting to nail the entire mafia team with this. However, actively directing the lynch target away from it is anti-town as we get way too many suspects.

Hopefully Navillus will answer my question to him whenever he decides to post again. I don't want that to get lost.

Lanaia what exactly do you want to hear more from me about? Just general stuff? Right now I want to lynch Bum or Cwave.

Scamp

United States1086 Posts

January 30 2012 19:21 GMT

#586

On January 31 2012 03:27 Zephirdd wrote:
huh

Show nested quote +

is the correct vote count. In fact, it should be 8 for bum and 2 for Cwave, but redFF never "##unvote"d.

That said, today bum is dieing. I doubt someone is going to give a better candidate in six hours.

This vote count isn't quite right either. There are only 6 votes on bum. Cwave hasn't voted yet.

Scamp

United States1086 Posts

January 31 2012 00:11 GMT

#615

I was so sure about scumatlarge.

Could he have been framed?

I think I'll just sleep this one off first before I do anything else.

Scamp

United States1086 Posts

January 31 2012 05:06 GMT

#632

On January 31 2012 10:30 Hesmyrr wrote:

Show nested quote +

Lynch town, leave completely stupid post thereafter.
DING DING DING DING

Pot. Kettle. Black.

Also, throw light suspicion on half the people in the game. Do nothing otherwise. Yeah, you don't have to work with me here.

Anyway, I agree in that I don't think Jackal is scum. Also redFF I don't think he's actually made a case against you.

Scamp

United States1086 Posts

February 01 2012 08:28 GMT

#689

It's difficult to chastise someone else for voting without much cause when I personally have no idea what's going on. I kind of went all-in on the Bum lynch because that was pretty much the only thing that I was certain of. I don't really see much going on from anyone at this point other than Vader on GGQ.

It's too early to discuss the nokill because not everyone has chimed in yet.

Scamp

United States1086 Posts

February 02 2012 10:53 GMT

#758

I used to have no idea what to think of Jackal. However his last post is making me lean scum.

I feel weird lynching Refallen with the argument that he's acting nooby but he's not a noob. If BH is right and we can put him together with Jackal then I have no problems with it.

Likewise I don't think BH is scum. Like at all.

Scamp

United States1086 Posts

February 02 2012 20:08 GMT

#778

Hes it's actually really simple. Giving up (or pretending to) is a scumtell because why would a townie ever do that?

Scamp

United States1086 Posts

February 03 2012 08:31 GMT

#825

Obviously the link I have to Refallen is so strong even after it's proven we're both not scum I'm still getting pushed for pretty much no reason.

I had a plan. Bumatlarge messed it all up by being town. Hoping someone had a better idea didn't really work out. It's time to take another look at Cwave.

But of course, there's always GGQ. Going after me is the obvious final step for scum that's about to win the game.

Scamp

United States1086 Posts

February 03 2012 16:14 GMT

#832

I haven't been able to get a solid read on Jackal all game long, but one thing for sure is that he's certainly active.

Being suspicious of someone isn't quite what I'd call having a good read on them. Case in point: people thinking I'm scum. I'm still not against lynching into the Radfield voters but that plan was not based solely on individual suspicion. The most suspicious person in the list for me (Bum) flipping town hurt my confidence in persuing it further.

Scamp

United States1086 Posts

February 03 2012 17:21 GMT

#834

GGQ or possibly even GCQ. When I have more time tonight I will look into Cwave and Jackal.

By that way that wasn't phrased very nicely. You've posted a few opinions but it's unclear if you have solid reads or if you're just posturing.

Scamp

United States1086 Posts

February 04 2012 08:05 GMT

#992

You guys are insane. I'm the most likely scum why?

Hesmyrr overexaggerates what I said about Refallen and makes it look like I was solidly against lynching him. Then he uses GGQ making useless switches at the end of the day as evidence against me somehow. What?

The rest of you, I actually have no clue. It looks like you're just making bad guesses.

And honestly, why is redFF asking about doctors?

Scamp

United States1086 Posts

February 04 2012 14:36 GMT

#998

On February 04 2012 22:51 Blazinghand wrote:
EBWOP: I'm off to bed, and will be up in like 8ish hours. I honestly think Scamp is highly likely to be scum and a good lynch due to his inactivity, lack of contributions, etc.

Have I been the greatest player in this game? No, I can admit that easily enough. I haven't had the easiest time making sense of what is going on in this game. But I have tried to go along with the town and not be disruptive. Yes, I know this could just be a scum play which has been referred to as lazy bandwagoning. But just compare what you and others think of me to the cases againt Bum, Refallen, and so on.

I have been wrong about Bum and Refallen since I joined the game. Apparently I was also wrong about Cwave and Jackal. You want to make a case about being helpful, fine. I have not been the least helpful person this game, yet you all are centered on me. The best way I can be useful to the town is to keep myself alive somehow because if you lynch me the game will probably end.

Scamp

United States1086 Posts

February 05 2012 23:07 GMT

#1027

Well yeah, because nothing is going on.

Dying is not so bad. I'm playing a lot of Soul Calibur 5.

There will be some things I'd like to say during the post-game discussion.

Scamp

United States1086 Posts

February 06 2012 00:59 GMT

#1034

Yeah I was wondering about the Superbowl.

See you guys after the game.

Scamp

United States1086 Posts

February 14 2012 08:29 GMT

#1528

The power roles that the town had were way too powerful IMO for this setup.

But meh, I don't really want to say much because redFF is calling everyone an idiot, both before and after the game ends. If that's the only way he knows how to get a point across then I'm making it a policy to never play with him again.