Kita - his 10 game winning streak is impressive, but useless for us it he's scum.

cyber - the usual "my scum play is bad"

Murray (foolishness) - not sure if troll, or just stupid

risk.nuke - doesn't talk about how he will mayor powers

wiggles - no platform for campaign

bumatlarge - does not understand that mayor does not control town

Murray - no platform for campaign

Nisani201

United States1400 Posts

January 13 2012 17:00 GMT

#594

Alright, just caught up on the thread, and I really like BC's campaign, because he is the only one who wants to take responsibility. He is also following up his intro post with solid activity. However I don't want to vote for anyone until I know who they are going to lynch.

Nisani201

United States1400 Posts

January 13 2012 17:02 GMT

#596

On January 14 2012 01:59 Kurumi wrote:
1. kingjames01
2. Refallen
3. supersoft
4. Slardar
5. risk.nuke
6. kitaman27 - Maybe vet but not sure. Plays quite good both alingments
7. Cyber_Cheese
8. Jayjay54
9. Kenpachi - lurks a lot, sucks a lot, shoots scum a lot. (vet?)
10. Munk-E
11. EchelonTee
12. Adam4167
13. Mattchew
14. Liquid`Sheth
15. L Shit son.
16. Meapak_Ziphh Same thing as Foolishness.
17. ~OpZ~
18. wherebugsgo
19. BrownBear Damn.. was he good scum? Can't even remember.
20. Ciryandor
21. Bill Murray known for distruptive and puzzling behaviour
22. rgTheSchworz
23. Foolishness Can't think of anything because he always played minor role when he played with me ._.
24. Toadesstern
25. Jackal58 Known for short posting style and likes to tunnel a bit. Good.
26. d3_crescentia
27. BloodyC0bbler Fear him.
28. Lanaia
29. Kurumi
30. blahz0r
31. VisceraEyes - people say he improved a lot, idk personally
32. GGQ rarely plays but mostly does well as town
33. sandroba Maybe not the amazing-amazing, but he's very good as town.
34. Jitsu
35. zeks
36. Mr. Wiggles
37. igabod
38. Palmar - very good overall, active and likes to bite
39. Erandorr
40. p4NDemik
41. GiygaS
42. evantrees
43. Chaosquo
44. Protactinium (Mystlord/Incognito) Incognito tends to die quite quickly, he was one of the reasons PYPI was won by the Town
45. Macpo
46. rtgICEMAN
47. Maxella
48. bumatlarge - he has his good moments, like being a Good Bad Santa.
49. Scamp
50. Nisani201
Thereotically new, but good (without colour)
Amazing town capabilities
Very good scum play
Veteran
any ideas to those might be good
remember zodiac lists? I only remember the name of that strat lol
Anyway, the thing is we should get lists like "Good ol' players" which prove to be quite useful when somehow there are two out of 6 left standing and they're beginning to look scummy.

Heh, maybe one day I'll be regarded as a veteran.

Nisani201

United States1400 Posts

January 13 2012 17:05 GMT

#600

On January 14 2012 02:03 Kurumi wrote:
Nisani, why You active lurk?
Maybe You at least have those fun graphs regarding everyone?

No, I just finished reading through the thread and now I can start talking.

I stopped making node graphs a while ago

Nisani201

United States1400 Posts

January 14 2012 00:15 GMT

#802

BC's mason claim is disappointing. This was said earlier, but it's important to note that if we end up electing him, we wont be able to check him with a DT. With my mayor, I don't give a shit if I know what role he is. I want to know his alignment. That's why I no longer support his campaign.

I however am really starting to like Sandroba. He is making a lot of sense, and the fact that he is aggressively pushing for mass mason claim (which I support) makes him seem town to me.

Nisani201

United States1400 Posts

January 14 2012 00:32 GMT

#809

##Vote: Sandroba

Nisani201

United States1400 Posts

January 14 2012 03:16 GMT

#885

I would recommend against a Palmar lynch. The argument against him is entirely meta-based, and as such should not be used as the basis of an argument.

However I would like to see him post more.

Nisani201

United States1400 Posts

January 14 2012 03:21 GMT

#887

On January 14 2012 12:17 Mattchew wrote:

Show nested quote +

If he is scum and I am town, why would he endorse me?
If we are both scum, do you think scum team or even me and him would call this attention? I even posted our entire pm convo.
If I am scum and he is town, do you think scum would a. mason me and b. let me pm one of the best townies?

most likely
If we are both town, we are trying to elect a townie

This isnt that hard of logic. Think it through fully

This is all WIFOM.

Nisani201

United States1400 Posts

January 14 2012 03:29 GMT

#890

The different outcome is, scum chose you and told you to mason an experienced townie. They want to use that to "prove" your innocence, because it is unlikely.

Nisani201

United States1400 Posts

January 14 2012 03:31 GMT

#891

ninja'd by VE, he covered the other scenarios but I think the most likely ones are, he is either town or scum. I don't think Foolishness is mafia.

Nisani201

United States1400 Posts

January 15 2012 02:01 GMT

#1373

Oh my god, it took forever for me to read through the thread. But I've done it.

Bill Murray is definitely best choice for mayor. He is making a lot of sense and I am starting to like his case on Sandroba. Sandroba hasn't followed up much on his candidacy which makes me feel weird about maintaining my vote on him (also, he he has no chance of winning the election

)

Proactinium wants to kill Macpo because Macpo is being apologetic. That case is weak; when I was a noob I was also apologetic. He has a much more in-depth case on BC, but doesn't want to lynch BC. This seems a bit weird to me.

FoS on the 3 people who voted WBG.

FoS on L for asking VE who he wants to shoot.

Nisani201

United States1400 Posts

January 15 2012 02:02 GMT

#1376

On January 15 2012 10:59 wherebugsgo wrote:

Show nested quote +

I don't need an explicitly written case just because someone who I think is scum asks for one. I really don't understand what mafia players attempt to accomplish when they insist there's no case on them and then demand one. It's just a waste of time.

Which, I suppose, is a win for you. You love wasting time as scum.

Cases don't become invalid because they use meta.

Nisani201

United States1400 Posts

January 15 2012 02:04 GMT

#1378

ffffffffffffffffffffffuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu i pressed post by accident...

Anyways, WBG, a case based entirely on meta IS invalid. If Palmar acts like this in D2, we can treat him like a lurker. We should all expect scumhunting from him tomorrow, but until then, the case on him is stupid.

Nisani201

United States1400 Posts

January 15 2012 02:13 GMT

#1381

It's pointless to scumhunt on D1 with elections because no one is really getting lynched anyways. If he decided to scumhunt with correct reads, that would make him a mafia target anyways.

That's why we should keep an eye on him on D2.