|
Please do not let this thread turn into a race war/balance whine, I don't want this thread to get closed. Also stay CIVIL! Thanks
This is NOT a thread for "why players choose terran", this is mainly about the Korean scene, while there are many great foreign terran, but their presence is not as dominate in the non-korean scene. (just see the ELO and recent tournament wins) There are plenty of great zerg and protss as well.
So my main question why there are so many great KOREAN terrans? Please stay on topic.
Poll: Is there a bigger talent pool of terran players in KOREA?Yes, all the best players are playing terran (283) 69% No, there are equal in quantity. (128) 31% 411 total votes Your vote: Is there a bigger talent pool of terran players in KOREA? (Vote): Yes, all the best players are playing terran (Vote): No, there are equal in quantity.
I don't think many people will argue that Terran have thus far been the most successful race in the GSL, where it lacks in title wins (only 2 GSLs) it more than makes up in the quantity of high placements. (5 runners up and even more semi-finalists) Also + Show Spoiler +GOMTvTvTvT for this SuperCup Here is a quick peak at the SC2 korea ELO:
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/hyvpH.png) There are just so many good terrans, 7 in the top 10 and 14 int he top 20. Whereas the crown for best zerg and protoss are NesTea and MC (some may argue but no one else comes close to these 2 in terms of success and skill), the throne for the best terran is always at doubt (a poll on TL couple of days ago places MVP as the favorite, but other are constantly closing in), progamers such as TOP, MKP, sC, NaDa, MMA, recently Polt and many others remain competitive. So this begs the question, why are there so many solid Korean terrans?
SC2 campaign: Reasoning: The campaign acts as a tutorial for the multiplayer, since the first installement of SC2 is terran based thus many programers are first introduced to this race. Good reason? No, while this would apply to people who never played SC2/SC before but most progamers don't even play the single players.
People relate to terrans: Reasoning: We are human, terran is human, we like to play terran? Good reason? I'm no specialist in how the mind work, but this seems unlikely.
Terran is OP: Reasoning: Terran requires no skills! Good reason? Sorry, my inner frustrated zerg came out.
Brood War/Hero worship: Reasoning: Most korean SC2 pros were also BW pros. Terrans have also been very successful in BW, with 4 of the 5 Bonjowas being terran. ( Flash, NaDa, BoxeR, iloveoov) Young progamers obviously look up to these players and want to emulate them by choosing the same race. Many newer SC2 players still look to the BW legends for inspiration. Good reason? Logic seems sound, many pros cited BoxeR/ NaDa as why they play.
Versatility: Reasoning: Terran is extremely versatile, capable of many styles of plays. This will make the race more attractive. Good reason? Maybe, i do recall MKP saying this is why he switched from protoss to terran in SC2.
Strong in Beta: Thanks to zyzski Reasoning: Terran was extremely strong during the beta, many choose terran for that reason and stuck to it. Good reason? Seems plausible.
On June 12 2011 14:57 canikizu wrote: Add this reason: Terran has the most classic RTS mechanic out of 3 races (classic units queuing in rax; use a worker to build stuff, repair; distinct unit tech such as bio, mech, sky). Because Terran has such classic mechanic elements in them, it's much easier for people who somewhat play RTS before (C&C, AOE, Warcraft, Cossack...) to play.
On June 12 2011 14:42 darkcloud8282 wrote: Terran gives you the most benefit for multi-tasking. With good mechanics, you can multi-drop, kite, control banshees, etc.. Making the most out of your units. For the other races, battles are mostly determined by positioning and flanking instead. With the most harass options available, Terran allows the player to make use of their multi-tasking abilities..
On June 12 2011 16:31 Veritassong wrote:Show nested quote +On June 12 2011 16:29 Voltaire wrote: The game is 100% balanced; people just play Terran because of the music. in that sense, Terran is OP cuz it's got the BEST MUSIC, and protoss music sounds like shit..
So these are all the possible reason I can think of for why we have such a flood of terran talents. What do you guys think? Did I miss anything? And more inportantly will they be more top tier Protss and Zerg players in the future?
Poll: why are there so many top Korean terrans?OP! (I'm a troll) (295) 38% BW legends (211) 27% Versatility (194) 25% SC2 Beta (39) 5% Others (please state in thread) (14) 2% Campaign (progamers always finsih campaign prior to choosing race) (12) 2% People relate to Terran (err...ok...) (8) 1% 773 total votes Your vote: why are there so many top Korean terrans? (Vote): BW legends (Vote): OP! (I'm a troll) (Vote): People relate to Terran (err...ok...) (Vote): SC2 Beta (Vote): Versatility (Vote): Campaign (progamers always finsih campaign prior to choosing race) (Vote): Others (please state in thread)
Poll: Will the quantity of top players balance out in the future?No, Terran remain top (337) 52% Yes, all will be well (219) 34% No, Zerg will crush (65) 10% No, protoss above all (26) 4% 647 total votes Your vote: Will the quantity of top players balance out in the future? (Vote): Yes, all will be well (Vote): No, Terran remain top (Vote): No, Zerg will crush (Vote): No, protoss above all
|
better multitasking + terran was super strong in beta and probably attracted a bunch of players because of that
|
it's a pretty interesting question
but I'd also like to point out that in china most of the top players are protoss and there's this general consensus that protoss is the best race among the chinese
it's pretty obvious that terran was very strong in the earlier seasons so a lot of players may have picked it back then, but I don't think that's the best reason
|
I think Terran is most similar to it's BroodWar counterpart minus the lack of medics and the new marauder.
|
Terran gives you the most benefit for multi-tasking. With good mechanics, you can multi-drop, kite, control banshees, etc.. Making the most out of your units. For the other races, battles are mostly determined by positioning and flanking instead. With the most harass options available, Terran allows the player to make use of their multi-tasking abilities..
|
Brood War/Hero worship: Reasoning: Most korean SC2 pros were also BW pros. Terrans have also been very successful in BW, with 4 of the 5 Bonjowas being terran. ((T)Flash, (T)NaDa, (T)BoxeR, (T)iloveoov) Young progamers obviously look up to these players and want to emulate them by choosing the same race. You nailed it there: role models. Terran's hero trifecta (NaDa, Boxer, Flash) naturally attracts the most dedicated and devoted players. I also think T is probably most unexplored in terms of getting the most out of your units and koreans are the ones who can actually achieve that, since they transfer their BW mechanics.
|
In my opinion Terran just has the most flexibility and safety netting. You can choose between 400 minerals, instant detection for a couple of seconds, or instant supply unblockage, tech switching is quick and easy, bases can be reused, sensor towers for spotting drops and enemy movement, and more. When I compare the other two races to Terran, it just seems that a lot of the other race's handicaps to Terran's there seems to be less of them. Just my opinion.
|
I think the versatility is the only reason that you stated that makes sense. It is also why I think it was chosen as well. Limitless unit combinations with terran, and Terran benefits more from high end micro than any other race as well. Which is, in my opinion, the 2nd most important reason.
Edit: What I mean by the micro is that perfect micro from zerg and toss doesnt increase the effectiveness of their units as much as it does with terran. Just to clarify.
|
Add this one Terran has a higher skillcap
|
I do agree it is mostly because of BW, everyone watching terrans have like 5 year stretches of dominance is pretty influencial, due to watching people like Boxer, Nada and Flash just dominate for years.. I think thats why Korea has such a high concentration of terran; also most of the pros switching to SC2 were also terran in BW.
Outside of korea, it seems to be a heavy concentration of P/Z, with very few terrans.. Im actually surprised with people who have switched over from terran in BW (Idra, Artosis, etc) ..
I think in 3-4 years, we'll see Z being the top race though. It was starting in BW with Jaedong, until Flash came along.. and I would say Z is stronger in SC2 than it was in BW.. but just the nature of macro oriented play does ultimately favor zerg, yet not many zergs can fully control that advantage yet, but once more safe buildorders are figured out and the metagame reaches a longer-stable situation, it will be downright scary.
|
On June 12 2011 14:43 ptrpb wrote: In my opinion Terran just has the most flexibility and safety netting. You can choose between 400 minerals, instant detection for a couple of seconds, or instant supply unblockage, tech switching is quick and easy, bases can be reused, sensor towers for spotting drops and enemy movement, and more. When I compare the other two races to Terran, it just seems that a lot of the other race's handicaps to Terran's there seems to be less of them. Just my opinion.
I don't know about that... I mean, floating buildings from a reactor a tech lab is easy enough, but switching your army composition up on the fly is not something Terran is really great at. Protoss has that ability to an extent in regards to how much you can get out of gateway units and Zerg has it for obvious reasons, but I wouldn't really highlight that as a Terran strength.
I think most top players gravitate towards Terran due to it's dominance at launch and in the beta and possibly because of the number of legendary Brood War Terrans. I think that it could also very easily just be coincidental.
|
On June 12 2011 14:42 darkcloud8282 wrote: Terran gives you the most benefit for multi-tasking. With good mechanics, you can multi-drop, kite, control banshees, etc.. Making the most out of your units. For the other races, battles are mostly determined by positioning and flanking instead. With the most harass options available, Terran allows the player to make use of their multi-tasking abilities..
Agreed. Terran rewards higher APM and better decision making the most. Comparatively Protoss and Zerg are fairly one-dimensional with their tactical decision making. Terran can do various (very annoying :b) things with their drop ships and siege tanks, etc while Protoss only has to ff and move colossi back, and Zerg is largely about positioning. I think once strategies start to develop Protoss and Zerg will start to catch up regarding skill cap and potential. We're already seeing Zerg players use infestors to great effect, and infestors are, of course, a very micro intensive unit.
|
|
|
My theory is the "Strong in Beta" one. At release, Terran was widely considered overpowered. When the B-teamers started switching over to SC2, I'm sure they chose largely based on which race "fit" them the most, but they were probably influenced by Terran being the race they were mostly likely to win with at that time.
This sort of happened in the beta. Zerg had all of the sort of "top" players (save for Tester) for a while. A lot of those players, however, switched to zerg from protoss, back when warp gates were nerfed the first few times and roaches still cost 1 food. It's why for instance the big Chinese world tournament in the beta was dominated by Zerg players, even though at that point Zerg was pretty weak.
|
Terran seems to be more solid against cheese and aggressive openings in the early game. That doesn't make it OP or anything trollish like that; it just means that on average their results may be more consistent.
|
On June 12 2011 14:43 ptrpb wrote: In my opinion Terran just has the most flexibility and safety netting. You can choose between 400 minerals, instant detection for a couple of seconds, or instant supply unblockage, tech switching is quick and easy, bases can be reused, sensor towers for spotting drops and enemy movement, and more. When I compare the other two races to Terran, it just seems that a lot of the other race's handicaps to Terran's there seems to be less of them. Just my opinion.
This is probably pretty close to the reason. Also, having by far the best early game harassment options and early scouting ability means Terran is the safest race to play in the early game.
|
No, protoss above all (0) 0%
would have been funny if someone actually chose this
you guys aren't so bad
@topic terran is op if played perfect and it's also quite easy to get to a high level with so no surprise. it's not even just korean tournaments that are tvtvtvtvtvtvtvtvtvt same story in eu. na to a lesser extent as far as i know but i dont really know much about na.
also zerg was the strongest race in beta by far so thats kind of an invalid reason. if you said release you might be more right, but most people who are at a high level now played since beta.
also i think the every other point you made probably plays a role as well. to a lesser extent than just the race being op but it still does.
|
On June 12 2011 14:48 igLeX wrote:Show nested quote +On June 12 2011 14:42 darkcloud8282 wrote: Terran gives you the most benefit for multi-tasking. With good mechanics, you can multi-drop, kite, control banshees, etc.. Making the most out of your units. For the other races, battles are mostly determined by positioning and flanking instead. With the most harass options available, Terran allows the player to make use of their multi-tasking abilities.. Agreed. Terran rewards higher APM and better decision making the most. Comparatively Protoss and Zerg are fairly one-dimensional with their tactical decision making. Terran can do various (very annoying :b) things with their drop ships and siege tanks, etc while Protoss only has to ff and move colossi back, and Zerg is largely about positioning. I think once strategies start to develop Protoss and Zerg will start to catch up regarding skill cap and potential. We're already seeing Zerg players use infestors to great effect, and infestors are, of course, a very micro intensive unit. Could you elaborate on the various things Terran can do that Zerg/Protoss can't? I think this argument is bullshit, Terran play is simply more interesting because we're constantly being told we can do anything, while other players rigidly stick to the guidelines set out by IdrA and Tyler.
Can zerg not put Hydras on a cliff?
terran is op if played perfect and it's also quite easy to get to a high level with so no surprise Just don't.
|
Add this reason: Terran has the most classic RTS mechanic out of 3 races (classic units queuing in rax; use a worker to build stuff, repair; distinct unit tech such as bio, mech, sky). Because Terran has such classic mechanic elements in them, it's much easier for people who somewhat play RTS before (C&C, AOE, Warcraft, Cossack...) to play.
|
You mean 4 of the 4 bonjwas
|
|
|
|
|
|