|
On June 12 2011 14:55 hi im new wrote: No, protoss above all (0) 0%
would have been funny if someone actually chose this
you guys aren't so bad
@topic terran is op if played perfect and it's also quite easy to get to a high level with so no surprise. it's not even just korean tournaments that are tvtvtvtvtvtvtvtvtvt same story in eu. na to a lesser extent as far as i know but i dont really know much about na.
also zerg was the strongest race in beta by far so thats kind of an invalid reason. if you said release you might be more right, but most people who are at a high level now played since beta.
also i think the every other point you made probably plays a role as well. to a lesser extent than just the race being op but it still does. there's a lot of tournaments that aren't tvt, and don't include terrans at all
the last gsl didn't have a terran in the finals, and neither did the one prior to the WCs
the point here is that there have always been several top terrans while nestea and MC were leagues ahead of everyone else in their respective race
anyone complaining about terran being OP is probably just some protoss/zerg whining because they can't get above diamond
|
well, terran have the most cost effective units in game as well as the most compatible unit combos in game. They also are most microable. also:
-Longest range for both air and ground attack (tank, thor, viking) -AoE for both air and ground (Tank and Thor) -Highest DPS units(Marine , marauder with stim) - every unit is able to harass (mmm, ghost [nuke], reaper, hellion, banshee, even assault mode viking)
Therefore, a good terran is able to use all these strong points of the race. Good terran being someone who is great a multitasking, which the top koreans are. (200-300 apm)
|
On June 12 2011 14:57 canikizu wrote: Add this reason: Terran has the most classic RTS mechanic out of 3 races (classic units queuing in rax; use a worker to build stuff, repair; distinct unit tech such as bio, mech, sky). Because Terran has such classic mechanic elements in them, it's much easier for people who somewhat play RTS before (C&C, AOE, Warcraft, Cossack...) to play.
I would agree with this reason if a lot (if not all) of these top terran players were playing BW. They choose the race that there favorite players played and then when it came time to switch to SC2 they had no reason to change race.
|
Idk what crazy person voted that the campaign had anything to do with Terran being prominent in GSL 
Crazy people!
|
On June 12 2011 14:39 Itsmedudeman wrote:
but I'd also like to point out that in china most of the top players are protoss and there's this general consensus that protoss is the best race among the chinese
actually, no. protoss is considered the weakest race. they interviewed mc recently (few weeks ago) and one question stated that chinese players consider protoss to be pretty weak compared to the other races and then went on to ask some question about what mcs opinion is and how he deals with playing the weak race etc.
i thought that was a really stupid kind of question to ask in a professional interview but mc did a good job at giving an answer that somehow avoided the balance talk.
|
Also, having by far the best early game harassment options and early scouting ability means Terran is the safest race to play in the early game. - TL Lurker
I think terran has fundamental problems in the early game in a luck based way that patches won't be able to correct any time soon. - Morrow
|
On June 12 2011 14:57 canikizu wrote: Add this reason: Terran has the most classic RTS mechanic out of 3 races (classic units queuing in rax; use a worker to build stuff, repair; distinct unit tech such as bio, mech, sky). Because Terran has such classic mechanic elements in them, it's much easier for people who somewhat play RTS before (C&C, AOE, Warcraft, Cossack...) to play. too bad this has no real justification for the purpose of this thread which is around the KOREAN scene where 90% of the top terrans came from BW and not any of those games mentioned
|
Am I allowed to say what I think? lol
(if I made a list of things I thought were OP in sc2 like 75% of them would belong to terran)
|
On June 12 2011 15:01 hi im new wrote:Show nested quote +On June 12 2011 14:39 Itsmedudeman wrote:
but I'd also like to point out that in china most of the top players are protoss and there's this general consensus that protoss is the best race among the chinese
actually, no. protoss is considered the weakest race. they interviewed mc recently (few weeks ago) and one question stated that chinese players consider protoss to be pretty weak compared to the other races and then went on to ask some question about what mcs opinion is and how he deals with playing the weak race etc. i thought that was a really stupid kind of question to ask in a professional interview but mc did a good job at giving an answer that somehow avoided the balance talk. that's pretty interesting considering the best player in china is protoss and 3 of their chinese protoss players made it to the ro4 in the stars wars tournament
|
On June 12 2011 15:02 Techno wrote:Show nested quote +Also, having by far the best early game harassment options and early scouting ability means Terran is the safest race to play in the early game. - TL Lurker Show nested quote +I think terran has fundamental problems in the early game in a luck based way that patches won't be able to correct any time soon. - Morrow
Care to make a point rather than just posting a quote of Morrow that doesn't even specifically address that post?
|
On June 12 2011 14:42 darkcloud8282 wrote: Terran gives you the most benefit for multi-tasking. With good mechanics, you can multi-drop, kite, control banshees, etc.. Making the most out of your units. For the other races, battles are mostly determined by positioning and flanking instead. With the most harass options available, Terran allows the player to make use of their multi-tasking abilities..
Yeah, the multi-tasking options is the most with Terrans. All the best terrans listed there are known because they have one of the aforementioned options at a stellar level. Since Terran isn't really known for going death balls like Protoss and Zerg, multi-tasking smaller harassment are better rewarded.
Also, if I might not add, the terran units have personality. =D Thus more engaging as a race? LOL
|
On June 12 2011 15:03 travis wrote: Am I allowed to say what I think? lol
(if I made a list of things I thought were OP in sc2 like 75% of them would belong to terran)
65% for me
|
On June 12 2011 15:03 Itsmedudeman wrote:Show nested quote +On June 12 2011 15:01 hi im new wrote:On June 12 2011 14:39 Itsmedudeman wrote:
but I'd also like to point out that in china most of the top players are protoss and there's this general consensus that protoss is the best race among the chinese
actually, no. protoss is considered the weakest race. they interviewed mc recently (few weeks ago) and one question stated that chinese players consider protoss to be pretty weak compared to the other races and then went on to ask some question about what mcs opinion is and how he deals with playing the weak race etc. i thought that was a really stupid kind of question to ask in a professional interview but mc did a good job at giving an answer that somehow avoided the balance talk. that's pretty interesting considering the best player in china is protoss and 3 of their chinese protoss players made it to the ro4 in the stars wars tournament
yes that's why i still remember it. i thought it's pretty strange to generally assume protoss is the weak race when the most successfull chinese players use protoss.
that was a few weeks ago though maybe their opinion has changed now i don't know.
|
Yeah very good point, with the SC1 role model things.
I admit myself that after playing Zerg in BW, Zerg 4 months in SC2, then Protoss 4 months, then Random 4 months, all of which were for 4 month periods coincidentally, I think I will stick with Terran because I love Boxer.
|
On June 12 2011 15:03 GwSC wrote:Show nested quote +On June 12 2011 15:02 Techno wrote:Also, having by far the best early game harassment options and early scouting ability means Terran is the safest race to play in the early game. - TL Lurker I think terran has fundamental problems in the early game in a luck based way that patches won't be able to correct any time soon. - Morrow Care to make a point rather than just posting a quote of Morrow that doesn't even specifically address that post? Terran on 1 base is a dice roll.
|
You should just add a "Boxer" reason. lol
|
On June 12 2011 15:07 Techno wrote:Show nested quote +On June 12 2011 15:03 GwSC wrote:On June 12 2011 15:02 Techno wrote:Also, having by far the best early game harassment options and early scouting ability means Terran is the safest race to play in the early game. - TL Lurker I think terran has fundamental problems in the early game in a luck based way that patches won't be able to correct any time soon. - Morrow Care to make a point rather than just posting a quote of Morrow that doesn't even specifically address that post? Terran on 1 base is a dice roll.
Cool, so at what point are you actually going to actually try and dispute that Terran is the safest race in early game with the best harassment and scouting options? The consistent results of the Korean Terrans only reinforce this.
|
Because of the multi-tasking potential there is for top tier Terrans and the number of legends who were Terrans in BW.
|
Terran on 1 base is a dice roll.
Do you see any of the players on the OP's post one basing often?
|
I kind of want to say that it's not a feature of Terran that makes them dominant, but rather a facet of Protoss and Zerg, especially when playing against Terran. Specifically, they're fragile.
By fragile, I don't mean that their units die quickly, but that one moment of less than perfect responses or unit control can lead to a loss. Part of this is drop play. Sniping enough pylons and psi blocking Protoss with a drop right before Protoss warps in a round of units (say, 5 seconds or less remaining cool time) results in the Protoss missing TWO rounds of unit production, which is probably enough to let the Terran just attack the front. Drop kills Zerg's spawning pool and baneling nest? That's probably a dead Zerg. Even just the spawning pool is probably enough. Terran pokes Protoss's front, causing his spread units to start to clump up as they move to attack, then EMPs in the 10/th of a second where the units are clumped and Protoss is just starting to spread them again? GG. Robo sniped by a drop with a Colossus half done? That's a gigantic timing window where the Protoss is too low on that critical unit. Thor's AA range is 10. Mutalisk's sight range is 11. That's not a lot of buffer to spot a Thor and back out before taking a big hit on clumped up Mutas.
In short, it's not that Terran is incredibly overpowered, but that it's very hard to be consistent with Protoss and Zerg because they're much less forgiving of mistakes, especially against Terran, which contributes to Terran acting even more forgiving of mistakes.
Case in point, the early GSLs, where professional Protoss dropped games constantly to Terrans simply stimming a bio force and running up the Protoss's ramp in hopes (which were usually met) that the Protoss player wouldn't be able to forcefield his ramp in time.
|
|
|
|
|
|