EPTWhen is this probably going to get started?
TL Mafia XLII
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
Mig
United States4714 Posts
When is this probably going to get started? | ||
|
Mig
United States4714 Posts
| ||
|
Mig
United States4714 Posts
When is the GF elected? | ||
|
Mig
United States4714 Posts
aidnai - aidnai posted in n0 that medics should ignore what BC said and protect the people on the zodiac list. Mafia then proceeded to blue snipe with 2 of their shots and shoot kita, someone unlikely to get medic protection on the Z list. Obviously this isn't even close to hard evidence but people should remember that aidnai pushed for a plan that was what the mafia either wanted or took advantage of n0. Besides that though I don't really have any problem with his posts, and he is active enough that I think he would be a bad day 1 lynch. ilj - I am suspicious of. I played with him last game where he was scum. He seems a lot more outspoken right now in defending himself than he did then. But he said repeatedly at the end of the game how bad he played etc. I am sure he planned on changing his meta for the next time he was scum. So I find it very suspicious when he tells youngminii don't try to meta me because I may just be trying to play differently. If he is trying to play differently it is much much more likely that he would be trying to adjust his scum play and not his town play. Still though he has been decently active and outspoken in defending himself so he is not my preferred lynch for day1. sinani - my preferred day 1 lynch. I played with sinani when he was scum in XXXIX. One of the main things sinani did that game was try to look like he was contributing without actually helping at all. He posted a list on inactives without commenting on it and he posted an extremely half-assed and nonsensical analysis of his thoughts on all the current players. He is doing the exact same thing here. He has posted several times criticizing other people's thoughts and telling various people to step up and start scum hunting without actually doing a single thing to contribute himself. His play to me seems consistent with his scum play in XXXIX So I am voting sinani. Brief thoughts on a couple other players Sandroba - bad plan day 1 but I am not suspicious of him. It is more likely for townies to introduce large/risky plans at the start of the game than it is for mafia since it draws a lot of attention and scrutiny to the player. Also just feels to me like he had town's best interests in mind but didn't completely think through the possible risks. node/impervious/ggq - I know all 3 of these players can contribute actively and be very pro town. The game is still early but people should keep their eyes on them if they don't become more active. | ||
|
Mig
United States4714 Posts
BC I really dislike posting a list of 3 inactves. Since there is 0 evidence to defend any of them providing 3 choices will just make it easier for mafia to influence the lynch and guarantee a town is hit. Would prefer if you just strongly push for 1 target that you feel is best. I don't really get the defense of sinani. Last game he played as mafia he showed that he likes to fake contribute exactly as he is doing now. He actually made one decent analysis that game and it was when he tried to bus his own team mate, so I know he is capable of writing decent posts if he puts the effort in. Everything he has posted has been without any real thought or effort to provide content for the town. I mean he hasn't defended himself at all or done any actual scum hunting whatsoever and he is clearly lurking because he insta responds when directly questioned. The only thing that somewhat worries me is the fact a bunch of people have jumped on voting for him without providing any real reasoning. Despite that I still think he is the best lynch. | ||
|
Mig
United States4714 Posts
| ||
|
Mig
United States4714 Posts
landen/giraffe are fine. Hiro would also be a good shot just because A) there is a strong case against him and b) it saves us from discussing his lynch all of day2. medics not a big fan of telling medics who to save but I definitely would not protect RoL. He hasn't done a single thing for the town despite promoting himself as a godly scum hunter. Dts Hiro is a bad choice because he is likely to be vigd or lynched tomorrow. Young I also think is town so disagree with checking him. GGQ/Scamp are both decent checks. Along with some lesser active players like impervious. | ||
|
Mig
United States4714 Posts
| ||
|
Mig
United States4714 Posts
| ||
|
Mig
United States4714 Posts
I was so sad to die early for my first game as detective. Especially with the ability to mason there were so many possibilities if I could live through a couple nights. I liked the pm mechanic and I would definitely play another game that used it. | ||
| ||
