TL Mafia XL

On June 05 2011 14:02 freeloader625 wrote:


Oh but a townie does have reasons to ask such a question.

Don't take my SC2 Mafia as lack of experience, I was able to deduce roles within the 50seconds given. :D

On June 05 2011 14:50 DeMorcerf wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
What reason does a townie have to ask such a question?

A townie would ask the question in order to understand the game clearly. To defeat thine enemy, thou must know thine enemy. He needed to be sure whether the mafia had the power to coordinate or was as in the dark as townies are. And from having played SC2'sMafia, it seems to me like a question I'd be tempted to ask regardless of my role considering many of us are new to TL-Mafia (this is a game for "new players").
We shouldn't be rash. Haste makes waste. We still have many hours of this day left. I agree he is quite suspicious, but he could just be trying to confirm how the game operates. Perhaps SC2Mafia has made me adverse to random lynching. Unlike Jimbooo and cherubael, I'm not going to vote this soon.

Now seeing his updated response, of "All I can say", freeloader does feel more suspicious to me. Especially because I feel like the reverse is true in SC2Mafia, where people blindly trust the first people to speak not lynch them. I'm going to sleep now, but still not convinced beyond a doubt there's enough to bother 'sleeping on.'

On June 05 2011 16:11 heist wrote:


How do you know how many mafia there are? I thought role counts are not disclosed.

On June 07 2011 05:25 TranceStorm wrote:

Ok, just answer a couple of questions.
(1) What convinced you that freeloader was not a mafia after you had voted for him? Was it the defending that other people had done for him?
(2) Why didn't you respond to my initial analysis of you when you had clearly posted in other threads?
(3) Sort of related to (2), but why has your activity dropped off substantially from your initially bright start?