Varp your plan is horrrrrrible. The reason is it makes it super easy for the mafia to pick out targets. They will hit the people who say they have information roles and avoid the ones who have survival. Come on common sense here.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

May 30 2011 20:51 GMT

#287

On May 31 2011 05:48 Varpulis wrote:

you misunderstand. not claiming our roles, the roles we chose for others. We don't say who we picked the role for. We're not giving the mafia any more information than they already know, really.

Oh ok well I don't have a real problem with that except we probably don't actually learn much from it and it would super clutter up the thread

One thing we can be sure of tho is that mafia probably has a ton of weird kp roles. Considering the mafia kp is permanently set at 1 with 33 people.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

May 30 2011 21:06 GMT

#313

On May 31 2011 05:57 bumatlarge wrote:

Are we picking people based on past history or are we going to base it on the current game? IIRC, this inevitably leads us to making "townie-lists". After PYPI, I don't really feel like thats a great idea. But for the sake of discussion I'm all for it, since I think you are focusing more on what people are saying rather then the lists themselves. I'll nominate you and myself.

You nominating yourself for all the valuable batman jokes you have made so far :p

Also what exactly is being nominated are you saying you and and BC are being the 2 most pro town so far?

Mig

United States4714 Posts

May 30 2011 21:21 GMT

#353

Huh I was sure it was a joke but can amber actually not speak? It would be a sick thing to fake if you were mafia. You wouldn't ever have to really contribute.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

May 30 2011 22:11 GMT

#413

Do we even want to know exactly what amber's role is? If we think he is lying about being a dog it would be good for us since it will be hard for him to fake it, but if he actually has a really strong night role and we announce it the mafia are just going to kill him. For this same reason I would suggest any dts we have should check someone else. And people should probably stop trying to figure out exactly what amber can do for now.

The mafia will either kill amber out of fear of what his blue role is or we will at least get some use out of it if we wait a couple days.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

May 30 2011 22:51 GMT

#433

On May 31 2011 07:35 Jackal58 wrote:
Or was that Kav DocH took out on day 1
I don't remember.

It was Kav.

Did node say that we can tell what roles we gave after day2? If so we can just have whoever gave them the roles say what they are once they feel the time is right. It would be a complete waste to dt check amber or palmar just to try and figure out exactly why they post strangely.

Dts use your checks on people you actually think are scum don't use them just to try and figure peoples roles out.

Anyway I guess BC seems most pro town right now but I am slightly wary of Bum. Simply because he nominated himself to the list before he had actually posted anything to help the town. Obviously this is nothing even close to solid but it is something that seems like a bit of a red flag to me.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

May 31 2011 01:47 GMT

#554

I am gonna toss my vote onto tnkted for now. He has been floating through the thread without contributing much, which is true for a lot of people right now, but then as soon as he is criticized by bum he throws out a 5 paragraph plan which isn't even really a plan so much as it's just common sense. Maybe it is just unfortunate timing for him but it looks a lot like someone over compensating and attempting to appear town after being pressured.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

May 31 2011 01:49 GMT

#556

On May 31 2011 10:46 bumatlarge wrote:

Oh now your just pulling my leg, are you actually chaoser? Are people secretly smurfing or something?

tnkted, one thing I've learned, people who call me town do not usually have a good track record of being town.

Chaos is not chaoser. He is from another mafia site this is his 2nd mafia game on tl.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

May 31 2011 02:08 GMT

#571

On May 31 2011 11:00 tnkted wrote:

Show nested quote +

This is precicely the same plan I posted. The following people acted in a scummy way in response to it:

If that is the same plan you posted why did you feel you needed to write 5 paragraphs and post it again after him? I don't have a problem with the plan (which was just common sense) but I have a problem with you writing out a long post to appear pro town, while not actually contributing anything, right after bum put a little pressure on.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

May 31 2011 04:26 GMT

#618

Why is db on there BC? I have played both of my last 2 games with DB. He was extremely active last game as a townie and much more of a lurker as a mafia so are you putting him on there because of his inactivity? The one thing I would consider for that is we just finished a long long game yesterday so he might just be taking a day off before he jumps back in.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

May 31 2011 04:29 GMT

#621

On May 31 2011 13:27 BloodyC0bbler wrote:

He is there as he was a member of a mafia team directly coached by me. As such I interacted with him on a fairly decent level to know what he is capable of. One does not have to be a massively known vet to be good.

Yea I don't disagree with that just wanted to know your reasoning since db hasn't posted in the thread or been mentioned yet.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

June 01 2011 22:51 GMT

#1251

Day 1 lynches are normally incorrect for a reason. We have limited information right now. For the same reason vigs don't shoot anyone and don't have bum kill anyone. We are more likely to hit a town right now.

I am sure there are mafia who are talking a lot but most of them are probably playing like I have so far (very limited activity).The town is in such a disorganized mess that most of the mafia will just sit back and watch. So I agree with something node said earlier. Dts check the lurkers/ people we can't get reads of. Vets like barundar who are not contributing should be focused on.

kurumi is very likely town (he played exactly like this in xxxix as town and lurked much more in pypi as mafia) do not shoot him just because he is annoying. Kurumi for the love of god put some effort into your posts. I honestly skip 2/3 of what you write because it is almost unreadable.

Anyway like I said focus hard on lurkers because this is the perfect environment for mafia to just hide in.

Oh also I know node already said it but chaos is actively trying to contribute to the town he is an asset don't kill him.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

June 02 2011 00:07 GMT

#1257

sinani why are you saying that during night. You should be trying to draw a mafia shot then right?

Mig

United States4714 Posts

June 02 2011 00:19 GMT

#1261

Maybe sinani has to be lynched for his power to work?

Mig

United States4714 Posts

June 02 2011 00:24 GMT

#1264

Varps idea is good have bum kill sinani tonight.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

June 02 2011 00:28 GMT

#1268

sinani asdfasf why say that it will revive bc. bum won't kill him now.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

June 02 2011 00:33 GMT

#1271

Ok well assuming we believe sinani do we think it is likely we have a protection role? Don't claim obviously but we need someone to protect bc if he comes back.

I would assume we probably do so I believe sinani and I think we should use a kp on him. Or we tell bum we will lynch him if he doesn't kill sinani?