EPTThis seems like fun!
Orgah Mafia
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Misder
United States1557 Posts
This seems like fun! | ||
|
Misder
United States1557 Posts
Vote: thefluffyone93 | ||
|
Misder
United States1557 Posts
On February 11 2011 18:08 gryffindor wrote: unvote My vote was more for pressure than anything. It didn't really gain the reaction that I wanted. @Misder, why are you voting who you are voting? Better question is why did thefluffyone93 vote for me. | ||
|
Misder
United States1557 Posts
| ||
|
Misder
United States1557 Posts
| ||
|
Misder
United States1557 Posts
On February 12 2011 12:22 why wrote: Looking at insanious's post history, I believe the last post he's had on TL was his /in post for this game. It's quite possible he doesn't even know that Orgah mafia has started, especially as there was no confirm period. With regards to pressuring inactives, I would hesitate to pressure people who haven't even posted yet. These people might not have even read their role pms yet and will be modkilled anyway. It is basically a RNG. We can look for people who post closer to the deadline and FoS them, but I think mafia that have read their pm are much more likely to have a vote or at least a post in by this point. I'll Vote: Misder because all he has done is posted once or twice and voted. Nice of you to single me out  I wonder why I stood out to you instead of the others?Unvote thefluffyone93 Vote Ace Unfortunately, I don't get to vote for thefluffyone93 anymore  , cause I feel that Coagulation has a point. Ace just feels scummy, esp. stop analysis? Reminds me of Fishball last game tbh. | ||
|
Misder
United States1557 Posts
On February 12 2011 12:50 why wrote: So I ask you who you find scummy, and you basically scroll up the page, find an analysis you can piggyback on, and say that you agree with it. It feels to me like you were just looking for the first possibly scummy person you could find so that you could say you were scum hunting. I don't know if you are just lazy or you haven't been looking for scum (because it's a low activity day and you didn't think you would need analysis to survive), but I'm keeping my vote on you for now. I will disagree on the point that all I did was scroll up to find analysis on someone. That can be debated, but I don't see you being able to prove that that's all I did. TBH, that vote wasn't even answering your question. I decided to not even specifically address your question. I will also disagree with your second point. I don't feel like I'm being lazy (well maybe I am compared to like BC or the likes) by my standards. "Haven't been looking for scum" is wrong too. I just don't have a strong case against anyone yet. Sure, maybe I never posted on who I think is scum out in the open, but I am keeping an eye out for specific people (maybe a bit of tunneling xD) Third point I can live with. Your vote is justified I suppose. | ||
|
Misder
United States1557 Posts
On February 12 2011 13:01 Believer wrote: Spoiler tag for long post. + Show Spoiler + On February 12 2011 12:11 Coagulation wrote: Analysis of ACE + Show Spoiler + ok so game hasnt even started yet. no day post or anything i havnt even posted a seriouse post regarding the game and boom hes out the gates trying to get someone lynched + Show Spoiler + people try to reason with him about his pretty lame vote attempt how its a bad start etc. pretty much ignores anyones opinion on it as shown here. + Show Spoiler + On February 11 2011 13:24 Ace wrote: cool so you aren't actually trying to help us find Scum then are you? twists my words to make them sound negative. maybe it was a bad phrasing on my part but im pretty sure anyone who reads that with a town outlook would read "i dont know where you get this "i dont wanna convince people" shit. Hounding me about lack of scumhunting. lets see how much scumhunting he has contributed as the game goes on shall we. + Show Spoiler + Ok no scumhunting here lets move on On February 11 2011 14:10 Ace wrote: 3 Scum vs 27 Townies is pretty much auto loss for Scum. So expect multiple Scum factions, Cults(ughh) or some really strong Scum powers. pretty obvious statement here. anyone who has played more than 2 games of mafia will realize this right away. doesnt help us find scum at all. + Show Spoiler + On February 11 2011 15:27 Ace wrote: well people get accused all of the time. Why panic? Besides I don't see what the voting rules are in the OP. Is it Majority lynch or most votes to lynch? zero scumhunting. and heres a little bit of what is commonly known as a scum tactic. ask general and irrelevent questions regarding the game in a attempt to look like your providing content to the town. + Show Spoiler + On February 11 2011 17:37 Ace wrote: actually gryffindor he answered your question - even though if it was terrible since he never defended Coagulation. What he did wasn't even buddying. Why so jumpy sir? And it only took you 2 minutes between reading Misder's post and voting to come firm to this conclusion? Are you voting just to vote or do you honestly think Node is scummy? pretty much the only real post he has made so far with any substance. however notice it is slightly tinted in a negative contrast. far from solid analysis or scumhunting that i would expect from a vet player like him. + Show Spoiler + On February 11 2011 17:47 Ace wrote: Actually a hard to read player is still bad If you don't appear Pro-Town to me why would I want to keep you alive? more contentless smalltalk. Zero scumhunting here folks. + Show Spoiler + Another Zero content fluff post with general conversation to make it look like hes contributing. no suprise there is Zero scumhunting here + Show Spoiler + On February 12 2011 06:54 Ace wrote: The people voting for Zerroth should be DT checked on Night 1 for sure. Anyway since our characters are based on what went on in the Totalwar forums, players from the totalwar website can you post and give us the characteristics or play style of some of the players there? ALARM BELLS GOING OFF YEAH SURE WE WILL CHECK WHOEVER YOU SAY. CAUSE CLEARLY JUDGING FROM YOUR POST HISTORY YOU HAVE AN INVESTED INTEREST IN FINDING SCUM. WE BETTER LISTEN. also asking other people to scumhunt. Fantastic work ace. zero scumhunting here. MORE ALARM BELLS. was so fucking dedicated to vote me that he couldnt even wait for the fucking day post to get my name on the board. now he unvotes me and doesnt say a word about it. You know what kind of players dont feel compelled to explain their reasoning behind their decision making. If you guessed scum you are correct. I call massive bullshit. Vote: Coagulation Why, may I ask? | ||
|
Misder
United States1557 Posts
On February 11 2011 21:42 gryffindor wrote: I don't like your OMGUS, and I don't like your response to me, you're my top scumspect. Misder, can you give me a reference to your best town and best scum game? IGMEOY Little late on this, but I'll answer as it will help scumhunting if people read previous games, and that you haven't been on lately either, so technically its not "late". I've only played one game as scum, and that was Mafia XXX. I'll warn you that that was a really bad game for me. I don't really have a "best" town game. Maybe the most recent one I played in, PYP3? idk, you can look at any of my games and you'd probably get the same read on me. | ||
|
Misder
United States1557 Posts
And as such, Unvote Ace Vote Aidnai Yay for bandwagoning? How is PM land going for everyone btw? I'm lonely. | ||
|
Misder
United States1557 Posts
I'll be back later. | ||
|
Misder
United States1557 Posts
I did say I was going to be back later, and I am. Stop sleeping so early As for my switch to aidnai, there was no way I was going to convince others to vote for Ace, and I really did believe that Ace was mafia. He hasn't done anything for town, even after death. Even though Ace says hes not going to help anymore, I highly doubt that hes gonna stop reading etc. which leads me to continue to think that he is mafia. As much as aidnai's roleclaim doesn't really add up to Ace's death, posting behavior for me still says that Ace is mafia. Or at least I'm wary of him. Then on aidnai- I'll agree that the fake analysis did convince me a bit more to vote aidnai, i didn't like the way aidnai reacted to it. I'll also agree that I wasn't really certain on aidnai, but then, i rather not vote for zerroth and I knew that kita was sending PMs around about the aidnai lynch (or so he told me/seems), so I still stand by my reasoning on my switch. Now on aidnai's roleclaim- it seems a bit odd doesn't it. he hasn't come back yet, but hopefully, the actual red text that was on the role PM didn't actually specify that he dies in order for the curse to happen. Also note that the curse that the PM talks about in the past; we can't take everything for sure. Of course, there is a possibility that this role PM is forged, but I will say that the possibility is relatively low from my standpoint. The day post is interesting too- One thing to note is that it doesn't seem like there is a connection between Kagemusha (aidnai) and the killer. Also, just letting you all know, pressure voting doesn't really work in this game there really is no downfall for anyone in town to get lynch besides the fact that its not mafia. so basically, stick to scumhunting. and also fos on people that try to pressure vote.And as for that Unvote thefluffyone93 Vote Coagulation I feel that hes smart enough to actually try an scumhunt and not pressure vote in a game like this... and I still find it suspicious that under pressure day 1, he changes his normal playstyle as town to a more "active townie". The others that try to pressure vote: Siniquity seems a bit weird too- when I play with him, he usually is really active... and now hes voting on the fact that I'm inactive? GMarshal is still fitting into what I feel as his playstyle, so I forgive him. Kita just doesn't strike me as mafia (yet -.-) | ||
|
Misder
United States1557 Posts
Wheres the pun on that post? | ||
|
Misder
United States1557 Posts
| ||
|
Misder
United States1557 Posts
On February 14 2011 15:31 Coagulation wrote: BTW Misder My playstyle this game has been 100% Textbook coagulation play. I really hope you mean 100% textbook coagulation town play. if so, fine. i'll admit, i didn't really do research on your playstyle, though i probably should. But I do recall that you are the one to typically just find the mafia, and not really one for analysis and such. And you did get pressured into saying more because everyone on day 1 said that you never posted enough analysis and such. | ||
|
Misder
United States1557 Posts
So it appears that people are yelling about the curse because of Ace, which may confirm that Ace triggered the effects. We know that kita and aidnai have some sort of relationship- it doesn't really seem too friendly. but then again, there are no clues in this game... however, the killer gets to write how the person dies. that means the author may have put in some sarcasm/irony in that, which would then i would like to think that aidnai did that (disregarding his roleclaim). | ||
|
Misder
United States1557 Posts
| ||
|
Misder
United States1557 Posts
| ||
|
Misder
United States1557 Posts
| ||
|
Misder
United States1557 Posts
On February 23 2011 03:10 GMarshal wrote: I feel like we should do a version of this game using TL player as roles, it would be awesome, (imagine getting Bill Murray as your character, or having to play Ace's style) chezinu. | ||
| ||
