• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EDT 06:14
CEST 12:14
KST 19:14
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
[ASL19] Finals Recap: Standing Tall7HomeStory Cup 27 - Info & Preview18Classic wins Code S Season 2 (2025)16Code S RO4 & Finals Preview: herO, Rogue, Classic, GuMiho0TL Team Map Contest #5: Presented by Monster Energy6
Community News
Flash Announces Hiatus From ASL41Weekly Cups (June 23-29): Reynor in world title form?12FEL Cracov 2025 (July 27) - $8000 live event16Esports World Cup 2025 - Final Player Roster16Weekly Cups (June 16-22): Clem strikes back1
StarCraft 2
General
Statistics for vetoed/disliked maps Esports World Cup 2025 - Final Player Roster The SCII GOAT: A statistical Evaluation How does the number of casters affect your enjoyment of esports? Weekly Cups (June 23-29): Reynor in world title form?
Tourneys
RSL: Revival, a new crowdfunded tournament series [GSL 2025] Code S: Season 2 - Semi Finals & Finals $5,100+ SEL Season 2 Championship (SC: Evo) FEL Cracov 2025 (July 27) - $8000 live event HomeStory Cup 27 (June 27-29)
Strategy
How did i lose this ZvP, whats the proper response Simple Questions Simple Answers
Custom Maps
[UMS] Zillion Zerglings
External Content
Mutation # 480 Moths to the Flame Mutation # 479 Worn Out Welcome Mutation # 478 Instant Karma Mutation # 477 Slow and Steady
Brood War
General
BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ [ASL19] Finals Recap: Standing Tall Help: rep cant save Player “Jedi” cheat on CSL Flash Announces Hiatus From ASL
Tourneys
[Megathread] Daily Proleagues [BSL20] GosuLeague RO16 - Tue & Wed 20:00+CET The Casual Games of the Week Thread [BSL20] ProLeague LB Final - Saturday 20:00 CET
Strategy
Simple Questions, Simple Answers I am doing this better than progamers do.
Other Games
General Games
Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Nintendo Switch Thread Path of Exile What do you want from future RTS games? Beyond All Reason
Dota 2
Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion
League of Legends
Heroes of the Storm
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Heroes of StarCraft mini-set
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread Vanilla Mini Mafia
Community
General
Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine US Politics Mega-thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Trading/Investing Thread The Games Industry And ATVI
Fan Clubs
SKT1 Classic Fan Club! Maru Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece [\m/] Heavy Metal Thread
Sports
2024 - 2025 Football Thread NBA General Discussion Formula 1 Discussion TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023 NHL Playoffs 2024
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List
Blogs
from making sc maps to makin…
Husyelt
Blog #2
tankgirl
Game Sound vs. Music: The Im…
TrAiDoS
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Heero Yuy & the Tax…
KrillinFromwales
Trip to the Zoo
micronesia
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 616 users

Harry Potter Mafia!

Forum Index > TL Mafia
Post a Reply
1 2 3 Next All
deconduo
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
Ireland4122 Posts
November 29 2010 09:37 GMT
#30
/in
deconduo
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
Ireland4122 Posts
December 11 2010 15:25 GMT
#225
I'm going to run for MoM as well. I'm not veteran, but I have played a few games. I'm not going to hold a vote for who to lynch, but I will listen to peoples advice and make my own decision. I feel this way I am pretty transparent, and its much more difficult for mafia to manipulate the lynch.

So vote for me
deconduo
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
Ireland4122 Posts
December 11 2010 16:44 GMT
#239
On December 11 2010 11:27 LSB wrote:
[image loading]

Mad that we haven't won a game for such a long time?


Reason Number one two three four five: I win games for the town.

There have been 5 recent town victories and I had a hand in all of them
+ Show Spoiler +
Slightly Embellished

Don't lose yo village: I put together the pieces and guarented victory
And Then There Were None(RAM) I kill everyone else. And as town I win with Radfield
TL Mafia XXX I come up with a giant plan that the town use and the mafia panics and kills me day one.


Pick Your Power Mafia 2!: I picked traitor. As traitor I get our most important mafia member killed, and also the SK killed. Enough deaths meant the mafia lost
Team Melee Mini Mafia II: As scum I am imediatly identified. Our team has one of the members claim doctor... and get killed. Our team then does a noobie mistake and looses.

Simply put. I lose as Mafia. And as town I help the town win. Vote me for mayor if you want to win!


If you are gonna help us win anyway, why do we need you as mayor? Vote for me instead.


deconduo
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
Ireland4122 Posts
December 11 2010 17:28 GMT
#241
On December 12 2010 02:05 Radfield wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
On December 11 2010 11:27 LSB wrote:
[image loading]

Mad that we haven't won a game for such a long time?


Reason Number one two three four five: I win games for the town.

There have been 5 recent town victories and I had a hand in all of them
+ Show Spoiler +
Slightly Embellished

Don't lose yo village: I put together the pieces and guarented victory
And Then There Were None(RAM) I kill everyone else. And as town I win with Radfield
TL Mafia XXX I come up with a giant plan that the town use and the mafia panics and kills me day one.


Pick Your Power Mafia 2!: I picked traitor. As traitor I get our most important mafia member killed, and also the SK killed. Enough deaths meant the mafia lost
Team Melee Mini Mafia II: As scum I am imediatly identified. Our team has one of the members claim doctor... and get killed. Our team then does a noobie mistake and looses.

Simply put. I lose as Mafia. And as town I help the town win. Vote me for mayor if you want to win!



I died night 1 in 'And Then There Were None'..... And didn't town lose that game??


Are you sure? I'm pretty sure it went down to a 3-way between me LSB and you. I voted for you and you voted for me, then LSB hammered us both. We both died, LSB was last man standing and won.
deconduo
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
Ireland4122 Posts
December 11 2010 18:04 GMT
#248
On December 12 2010 02:55 Pandain wrote:
what powers does mayor have?


Picks first day lynch, thats all. No bodyguards or anything.
deconduo
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
Ireland4122 Posts
December 11 2010 20:44 GMT
#268
On December 12 2010 04:39 Radfield wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 12 2010 02:28 deconduo wrote:
On December 12 2010 02:05 Radfield wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
On December 11 2010 11:27 LSB wrote:
[image loading]

Mad that we haven't won a game for such a long time?


Reason Number one two three four five: I win games for the town.

There have been 5 recent town victories and I had a hand in all of them
+ Show Spoiler +
Slightly Embellished

Don't lose yo village: I put together the pieces and guarented victory
And Then There Were None(RAM) I kill everyone else. And as town I win with Radfield
TL Mafia XXX I come up with a giant plan that the town use and the mafia panics and kills me day one.


Pick Your Power Mafia 2!: I picked traitor. As traitor I get our most important mafia member killed, and also the SK killed. Enough deaths meant the mafia lost
Team Melee Mini Mafia II: As scum I am imediatly identified. Our team has one of the members claim doctor... and get killed. Our team then does a noobie mistake and looses.

Simply put. I lose as Mafia. And as town I help the town win. Vote me for mayor if you want to win!



I died night 1 in 'And Then There Were None'..... And didn't town lose that game??


Are you sure? I'm pretty sure it went down to a 3-way between me LSB and you. I voted for you and you voted for me, then LSB hammered us both. We both died, LSB was last man standing and won.


That was Rastaban I think. You killed me night one, at the very least you sent me a PM apologizing



Yah my mistake. I got mixed up between you two. Was a fun game though
deconduo
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
Ireland4122 Posts
December 12 2010 16:54 GMT
#358
On December 13 2010 01:41 Beneather wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 12 2010 23:26 CubEdIn wrote:
On December 12 2010 17:52 aidnai wrote:
Meapak, you have my vote. We've spent a lot of time discussing the candidacy of LSB and RoL. What about deconduo? Here's his posts so far:

On December 12 2010 00:25 deconduo wrote:
I'm going to run for MoM as well. I'm not veteran, but I have played a few games. I'm not going to hold a vote for who to lynch, but I will listen to peoples advice and make my own decision. I feel this way I am pretty transparent, and its much more difficult for mafia to manipulate the lynch.

So vote for me


On December 12 2010 01:44 deconduo wrote:
On December 11 2010 11:27 LSB wrote:
[image loading]

Mad that we haven't won a game for such a long time?


Reason Number one two three four five: I win games for the town.

There have been 5 recent town victories and I had a hand in all of them
+ Show Spoiler +
Slightly Embellished

Don't lose yo village: I put together the pieces and guarented victory
And Then There Were None(RAM) I kill everyone else. And as town I win with Radfield
TL Mafia XXX I come up with a giant plan that the town use and the mafia panics and kills me day one.


Pick Your Power Mafia 2!: I picked traitor. As traitor I get our most important mafia member killed, and also the SK killed. Enough deaths meant the mafia lost
Team Melee Mini Mafia II: As scum I am imediatly identified. Our team has one of the members claim doctor... and get killed. Our team then does a noobie mistake and looses.

Simply put. I lose as Mafia. And as town I help the town win. Vote me for mayor if you want to win!


If you are gonna help us win anyway, why do we need you as mayor? Vote for me instead.




On December 12 2010 02:28 deconduo wrote:
On December 12 2010 02:05 Radfield wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
On December 11 2010 11:27 LSB wrote:
[image loading]

Mad that we haven't won a game for such a long time?


Reason Number one two three four five: I win games for the town.

There have been 5 recent town victories and I had a hand in all of them
+ Show Spoiler +
Slightly Embellished

Don't lose yo village: I put together the pieces and guarented victory
And Then There Were None(RAM) I kill everyone else. And as town I win with Radfield
TL Mafia XXX I come up with a giant plan that the town use and the mafia panics and kills me day one.


Pick Your Power Mafia 2!: I picked traitor. As traitor I get our most important mafia member killed, and also the SK killed. Enough deaths meant the mafia lost
Team Melee Mini Mafia II: As scum I am imediatly identified. Our team has one of the members claim doctor... and get killed. Our team then does a noobie mistake and looses.

Simply put. I lose as Mafia. And as town I help the town win. Vote me for mayor if you want to win!



I died night 1 in 'And Then There Were None'..... And didn't town lose that game??


Are you sure? I'm pretty sure it went down to a 3-way between me LSB and you. I voted for you and you voted for me, then LSB hammered us both. We both died, LSB was last man standing and won.


On December 12 2010 03:04 deconduo wrote:
On December 12 2010 02:55 Pandain wrote:
what powers does mayor have?


Picks first day lynch, thats all. No bodyguards or anything.


On December 12 2010 05:44 deconduo wrote:
On December 12 2010 04:39 Radfield wrote:
On December 12 2010 02:28 deconduo wrote:
On December 12 2010 02:05 Radfield wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
On December 11 2010 11:27 LSB wrote:
[image loading]

Mad that we haven't won a game for such a long time?


Reason Number one two three four five: I win games for the town.

There have been 5 recent town victories and I had a hand in all of them
+ Show Spoiler +
Slightly Embellished

Don't lose yo village: I put together the pieces and guarented victory
And Then There Were None(RAM) I kill everyone else. And as town I win with Radfield
TL Mafia XXX I come up with a giant plan that the town use and the mafia panics and kills me day one.


Pick Your Power Mafia 2!: I picked traitor. As traitor I get our most important mafia member killed, and also the SK killed. Enough deaths meant the mafia lost
Team Melee Mini Mafia II: As scum I am imediatly identified. Our team has one of the members claim doctor... and get killed. Our team then does a noobie mistake and looses.

Simply put. I lose as Mafia. And as town I help the town win. Vote me for mayor if you want to win!



I died night 1 in 'And Then There Were None'..... And didn't town lose that game??


Are you sure? I'm pretty sure it went down to a 3-way between me LSB and you. I voted for you and you voted for me, then LSB hammered us both. We both died, LSB was last man standing and won.


That was Rastaban I think. You killed me night one, at the very least you sent me a PM apologizing



Yah my mistake. I got mixed up between you two. Was a fun game though


Announces candidacy, plugs candidacy, then gets side tracked for three posts--not much of a campaign imo. Yet he was able to garner votes from Jackal58, ilovejonn, and CubEdIn. Why did you three vote for such a non-chalant candidate? Especially Jackal58 and ilovejonn, who are both lurking pretty hard-core.


Just woke up, I was skimming through the thread and was just thinking of this.

Here's how it went:
1. He announced candidacy. I voted for him in the first 5-10mins, because I find the votes for Meapak suspicious.
2. Plenty of time later, a few more people vote for him. "out of the blue" so to say.
3. Meapak posts that he'll probably kill deconduo, because of his suspicious voters
4. ilovejonn switches his vote to himself

Now, please explain:
a) How are there "many votes out of the blue"? I explained mine, and then there were 2 more votes. He never got to be the first place or anything
b) Why would ilovejonn switch his post after Meapak threatened to lynch deconduo due to people voting for him out of the blue? I'm sorry but this looks like a very harsh slip-up from a newbie red. If deconduo dies and he flips red, then ilovejonn should die instantly.
Even if deconduo isn't red, it's still a very weird and scummish move in my eyes.

I must admit that I'm really scared of the alternative winning conditions. I get the reasoning behind meapak's idea, and I know we're short on alternatives, but I don't think there are enough clues to actually take down deconduo because of it.
Please think a bit better before you kill him.


I agree with you CubedIn very good analysis. From what you had said I am persuaded to think that deconduo may be a red. Using our first lynch on him would be a good start. If he turns out red which CubedIn stated we should lynch ilovejohn. This looks like the most reasonable suggestion we have gotten today. Not from "VIBES" but from reasonable logic.


Excuse me what are the reasons behind having me lynched again? Because 3 people voted for me? Cube gave good solid reasons, and the other 2 people are newbs that are probably sheeping or randomly voting. Meapaks bandwagon is MUCH more suspicious.

Your logic is all over the place. 'Decon might be red cos ilovejohn voted for him and ilovejohn is scummy. So lynch decon'. WTF, in that situation you suggest lynching ilovejohn.
deconduo
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
Ireland4122 Posts
December 12 2010 17:00 GMT
#360
EBWOP:

In that situation you *should* suggest lynching ilovejohn, not me.
deconduo
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
Ireland4122 Posts
December 13 2010 00:17 GMT
#441
On December 13 2010 09:10 Meapak_Ziphh wrote:
Ok people here are my possible targets:

Deconduo
I've already explained why I think he should be lynched.

Aidnai
He's the person who I've been keeping an eye on and LSB did a very good analyis of him
+ Show Spoiler +
On December 13 2010 09:00 LSB wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 11 2010 13:07 aidnai wrote:
On December 11 2010 10:28 annul wrote:
THREE MORE IMPORTANT FACTS:

1. there are some number of smurfs in this game. be aware.
2. pay very close attention to the final line of every cycle change post. helpful hint.
3. a reminder from the OP: if a player has a special ability, it will be somewhat related to their character/entity. in this way, a large number of possible roles can already be guessed at. google is awesomesauce. not all players have special abilities, even ones that may be "obvious" to have power roles.


On December 11 2010 10:02 annul wrote:
Hello! I am NotAnnul, your tour guide throughout wizarding Britain!

Welcome to Hogsmeade, the wizarding city. Stores line the streets, such as Dervish and Banges,
...

As of day 1, there are 8 living players loyal to the Death Eaters, the Death Eater kill power is 3, and there are 10 living players with potential alternate victories remaining.


So, our helpful hint is that there are 10 people out of 31 with alternate win conditions. This is almost 1/3 players with ulterior motives.

I'm glad the mayor doesn't have much power. It's great to have mayoral elections so there's something to talk about day one (other than lynching the inactives lol), but I don't trust anyone putting themselves out there for mayor.

As for LSB's plan--
If LSB is mafia, the plan can be abused by mafia by manipulating votes as normal (same as a public vote, except worse because people won't have to post their reasoning). If the auditor is also red, scum can manipulate the reported result as well.
If LSB is town, but the auditor is red, death eaters can still manipulate the votes as normal.
Only if both LSB and auditor are pro town do we get any benefit from this plan. Actually, the auditor makes the odds worse...

So, interesting idea, LSB, but it relies too much on us having to trust you.

Although this seems like a large post. Take a look at it closely. It doesn’t state anything.
First Aidani is trying to seem like he is contributing to the town by discussing the setup. Two paragraphs that are junk and basically irrelevant to the game.
Next he proceeds to criticize the plan. Although it seems like real though. Take note. All these points were already brought up before or are already addressed

Aidani in this post is doing nothing but making a façade of analysis


Show nested quote +
On December 12 2010 05:56 aidnai wrote:
Meapak's summary of MoM candidates is not very accurate. It's more like
-LSB advocates private votes for lynch. There may be advantages or disadvantages, which town can discuss
-A few others advocate public (normal) votes for lynch. This completely trivializes the MoM position.
-A few others are trying to pressure or disrupt by making their platform a specific lynch.

I like what LSB is doing. I don't see how his option is necessarily worse than the other options, and it has the added benefit of generating day 1 discussion.

On the other hand, if we vote for 'someone who will listen to the town', we might as well forget there even is a MoM. Just RNG a mayor, vote as normal for a lynch, lynch the mayor day 2 if he fails to comply.

RoL's tactic would look better to me if he would provide some justification. RoL, you need to be able to convince town that there is something to your hunches.

Firstly, he completely reversed his position on my plan. Very wishy washy. But he’s doing this without actually taking a position. All he says is “there are some good some bad”. Looks like he’s avoiding the issue.

Note one thing, non of the top candidates for the mayor are mafia. I’m getting a green read on Meapak, and I still believe that RoL is Mayor.
There doesn’t seem to be a way for the mafia to take the mayorship. Aidnai then says “How about we RNG a mayor?”
Yeah… Aidnai is trying to get us to trust him with who should be mayor. And just watch, he’ll ‘randomly’ choose someone who happens to be scum.


Show nested quote +
On December 12 2010 17:52 aidnai wrote:
Meapak, you have my vote. We've spent a lot of time discussing the candidacy of LSB and RoL. What about deconduo? Here's his posts so far:

On December 12 2010 00:25 deconduo wrote:
I'm going to run for MoM as well. I'm not veteran, but I have played a few games. I'm not going to hold a vote for who to lynch, but I will listen to peoples advice and make my own decision. I feel this way I am pretty transparent, and its much more difficult for mafia to manipulate the lynch.

So vote for me


On December 12 2010 01:44 deconduo wrote:
On December 11 2010 11:27 LSB wrote:
[image loading]

Mad that we haven't won a game for such a long time?


Reason Number one two three four five: I win games for the town.

There have been 5 recent town victories and I had a hand in all of them
+ Show Spoiler +
Slightly Embellished

Don't lose yo village: I put together the pieces and guarented victory
And Then There Were None(RAM) I kill everyone else. And as town I win with Radfield
TL Mafia XXX I come up with a giant plan that the town use and the mafia panics and kills me day one.


Pick Your Power Mafia 2!: I picked traitor. As traitor I get our most important mafia member killed, and also the SK killed. Enough deaths meant the mafia lost
Team Melee Mini Mafia II: As scum I am imediatly identified. Our team has one of the members claim doctor... and get killed. Our team then does a noobie mistake and looses.

Simply put. I lose as Mafia. And as town I help the town win. Vote me for mayor if you want to win!


If you are gonna help us win anyway, why do we need you as mayor? Vote for me instead.




On December 12 2010 02:28 deconduo wrote:
On December 12 2010 02:05 Radfield wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
On December 11 2010 11:27 LSB wrote:
[image loading]

Mad that we haven't won a game for such a long time?


Reason Number one two three four five: I win games for the town.

There have been 5 recent town victories and I had a hand in all of them
+ Show Spoiler +
Slightly Embellished

Don't lose yo village: I put together the pieces and guarented victory
And Then There Were None(RAM) I kill everyone else. And as town I win with Radfield
TL Mafia XXX I come up with a giant plan that the town use and the mafia panics and kills me day one.


Pick Your Power Mafia 2!: I picked traitor. As traitor I get our most important mafia member killed, and also the SK killed. Enough deaths meant the mafia lost
Team Melee Mini Mafia II: As scum I am imediatly identified. Our team has one of the members claim doctor... and get killed. Our team then does a noobie mistake and looses.

Simply put. I lose as Mafia. And as town I help the town win. Vote me for mayor if you want to win!



I died night 1 in 'And Then There Were None'..... And didn't town lose that game??


Are you sure? I'm pretty sure it went down to a 3-way between me LSB and you. I voted for you and you voted for me, then LSB hammered us both. We both died, LSB was last man standing and won.


On December 12 2010 03:04 deconduo wrote:
On December 12 2010 02:55 Pandain wrote:
what powers does mayor have?


Picks first day lynch, thats all. No bodyguards or anything.


On December 12 2010 05:44 deconduo wrote:
On December 12 2010 04:39 Radfield wrote:
On December 12 2010 02:28 deconduo wrote:
On December 12 2010 02:05 Radfield wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
On December 11 2010 11:27 LSB wrote:
[image loading]

Mad that we haven't won a game for such a long time?


Reason Number one two three four five: I win games for the town.

There have been 5 recent town victories and I had a hand in all of them
+ Show Spoiler +
Slightly Embellished

Don't lose yo village: I put together the pieces and guarented victory
And Then There Were None(RAM) I kill everyone else. And as town I win with Radfield
TL Mafia XXX I come up with a giant plan that the town use and the mafia panics and kills me day one.


Pick Your Power Mafia 2!: I picked traitor. As traitor I get our most important mafia member killed, and also the SK killed. Enough deaths meant the mafia lost
Team Melee Mini Mafia II: As scum I am imediatly identified. Our team has one of the members claim doctor... and get killed. Our team then does a noobie mistake and looses.

Simply put. I lose as Mafia. And as town I help the town win. Vote me for mayor if you want to win!



I died night 1 in 'And Then There Were None'..... And didn't town lose that game??


Are you sure? I'm pretty sure it went down to a 3-way between me LSB and you. I voted for you and you voted for me, then LSB hammered us both. We both died, LSB was last man standing and won.


That was Rastaban I think. You killed me night one, at the very least you sent me a PM apologizing



Yah my mistake. I got mixed up between you two. Was a fun game though


Announces candidacy, plugs candidacy, then gets side tracked for three posts--not much of a campaign imo. Yet he was able to garner votes from Jackal58, ilovejonn, and CubEdIn. Why did you three vote for such a non-chalant candidate? Especially Jackal58 and ilovejonn, who are both lurking pretty hard-core.

Doesn't actually do much. It's like he's trying to get other people to do analysis on Deconduo without putting an opinion himself


+ Show Spoiler [Irrelevant Smurf Stuff] +

On December 11 2010 13:47 aidnai wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 11 2010 13:25 Jackal58 wrote:
Wtf is a "smurf"?
Other than the obvious little blue cartoon people?


Obvious smurf imo.

On December 11 2010 13:47 aidnai wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 11 2010 13:25 Jackal58 wrote:
Wtf is a "smurf"?
Other than the obvious little blue cartoon people?


Obvious smurf imo.

On December 11 2010 14:42 aidnai wrote:
Alright, we have a few smurfs.

The true identities have not been revealed so the smurf is doing its job.
The mod and players are aware that there are smurfs, so we know not to talk about the game with people outside the thread.

Can we all be happy with this? I don't think Annul should learn the identity of the smurfs, since that would give him a leg up in future games....

On December 12 2010 02:53 aidnai wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 11 2010 23:15 Jackal58 wrote:
On December 11 2010 13:47 aidnai wrote:
On December 11 2010 13:25 Jackal58 wrote:
Wtf is a "smurf"?
Other than the obvious little blue cartoon people?


Obvious smurf imo.

My first game. And I'm already making an impression. Scum right there folks.


'What is a smurf?' Let me try to define it for you.
- Joined TL.net november 14
- Requested access to the mafia forum november 14
- Posted nowhere else except this game

Rather than argue details about past games, here's a policy we could discuss right now: LAL.

On December 12 2010 03:13 aidnai wrote:
Ok, i'm sorry for bringing up smurfs again. Smurf or not *actually* wasn't the main point of post--it's just strange to me that an honest-to-god newbie has no other question about the game than 'what is a smurf'. He looked suspicious, so I wanted to see how/if he reacted.


This is just Aidnai trying to seem like he is active and contributing to the game, talking about a subject that doesn't matter at all


+ Show Spoiler [Minor, Unimportant posts] +

On December 11 2010 14:50 aidnai wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 11 2010 14:42 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote:
<3 sorry I will stop with the argument! I would rather establish smurfs with alternate play styles and run with a few different accounts than constantly making new names and asking for access and jumping through all the hoops that go with that -__-;
______
on topic.
vote for me if you want, I will kill LSB day one! That is my platform.

Legit, that is my platform. Upon being elected I will kill LSB, vote for me.


rofl, you're screwed lsb! unless unfortunate complications arise causing RoL to excuse himself from the game.

Actually, I really would love to hear your reasoning on this, rebirth-of-sherlock-fucking-holmes...

Question/spamish post. Not much can be gleaned

On December 12 2010 03:00 aidnai wrote:
From D1 post:

On day one, you must vote for a Minister for Magic. Note above the thirty-one eligible candidates. There are thirty-one players. Coincidence? Nope! The Minister will have no further powers beyond day one (no bodyguards, et cetera) and his only game power will be to decide the day one kill. Election will end at 7 PM EST on Sunday, December 12. The kill submission must come before 9 PM EST the same day. Vote for Minister in the voting thread.

Not much here either


Conclusion
Aidnai is mafia, trying to avoid topics and pretend to be active.
##Lynch: Aidnai



My final target would be Pandain

Please let me know who it should be so I can let annul know.


You say I got a lot of votes out of nowhere. I got 2 votes out of nowhere, you got 7+. By your logic, you should lynch yourself.
deconduo
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
Ireland4122 Posts
December 13 2010 00:32 GMT
#450
On December 13 2010 09:27 LSB wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 13 2010 09:21 ilovejonn wrote:
Btw, I read the rules over again and it says that you CANNOT vote for yourself. So what happens to the people (such as Pandain) that voted for themselves at the end and did not change their vote?

I believe that an exception is made for mayoral elections


Show nested quote +
On December 13 2010 09:17 deconduo wrote:
On December 13 2010 09:10 Meapak_Ziphh wrote:
Ok people here are my possible targets:

Deconduo
I've already explained why I think he should be lynched.

Aidnai
He's the person who I've been keeping an eye on and LSB did a very good analyis of him
+ Show Spoiler +
On December 13 2010 09:00 LSB wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 11 2010 13:07 aidnai wrote:
On December 11 2010 10:28 annul wrote:
THREE MORE IMPORTANT FACTS:

1. there are some number of smurfs in this game. be aware.
2. pay very close attention to the final line of every cycle change post. helpful hint.
3. a reminder from the OP: if a player has a special ability, it will be somewhat related to their character/entity. in this way, a large number of possible roles can already be guessed at. google is awesomesauce. not all players have special abilities, even ones that may be "obvious" to have power roles.


On December 11 2010 10:02 annul wrote:
Hello! I am NotAnnul, your tour guide throughout wizarding Britain!

Welcome to Hogsmeade, the wizarding city. Stores line the streets, such as Dervish and Banges,
...

As of day 1, there are 8 living players loyal to the Death Eaters, the Death Eater kill power is 3, and there are 10 living players with potential alternate victories remaining.


So, our helpful hint is that there are 10 people out of 31 with alternate win conditions. This is almost 1/3 players with ulterior motives.

I'm glad the mayor doesn't have much power. It's great to have mayoral elections so there's something to talk about day one (other than lynching the inactives lol), but I don't trust anyone putting themselves out there for mayor.

As for LSB's plan--
If LSB is mafia, the plan can be abused by mafia by manipulating votes as normal (same as a public vote, except worse because people won't have to post their reasoning). If the auditor is also red, scum can manipulate the reported result as well.
If LSB is town, but the auditor is red, death eaters can still manipulate the votes as normal.
Only if both LSB and auditor are pro town do we get any benefit from this plan. Actually, the auditor makes the odds worse...

So, interesting idea, LSB, but it relies too much on us having to trust you.

Although this seems like a large post. Take a look at it closely. It doesn’t state anything.
First Aidani is trying to seem like he is contributing to the town by discussing the setup. Two paragraphs that are junk and basically irrelevant to the game.
Next he proceeds to criticize the plan. Although it seems like real though. Take note. All these points were already brought up before or are already addressed

Aidani in this post is doing nothing but making a façade of analysis


Show nested quote +
On December 12 2010 05:56 aidnai wrote:
Meapak's summary of MoM candidates is not very accurate. It's more like
-LSB advocates private votes for lynch. There may be advantages or disadvantages, which town can discuss
-A few others advocate public (normal) votes for lynch. This completely trivializes the MoM position.
-A few others are trying to pressure or disrupt by making their platform a specific lynch.

I like what LSB is doing. I don't see how his option is necessarily worse than the other options, and it has the added benefit of generating day 1 discussion.

On the other hand, if we vote for 'someone who will listen to the town', we might as well forget there even is a MoM. Just RNG a mayor, vote as normal for a lynch, lynch the mayor day 2 if he fails to comply.

RoL's tactic would look better to me if he would provide some justification. RoL, you need to be able to convince town that there is something to your hunches.

Firstly, he completely reversed his position on my plan. Very wishy washy. But he’s doing this without actually taking a position. All he says is “there are some good some bad”. Looks like he’s avoiding the issue.

Note one thing, non of the top candidates for the mayor are mafia. I’m getting a green read on Meapak, and I still believe that RoL is Mayor.
There doesn’t seem to be a way for the mafia to take the mayorship. Aidnai then says “How about we RNG a mayor?”
Yeah… Aidnai is trying to get us to trust him with who should be mayor. And just watch, he’ll ‘randomly’ choose someone who happens to be scum.


Show nested quote +
On December 12 2010 17:52 aidnai wrote:
Meapak, you have my vote. We've spent a lot of time discussing the candidacy of LSB and RoL. What about deconduo? Here's his posts so far:

On December 12 2010 00:25 deconduo wrote:
I'm going to run for MoM as well. I'm not veteran, but I have played a few games. I'm not going to hold a vote for who to lynch, but I will listen to peoples advice and make my own decision. I feel this way I am pretty transparent, and its much more difficult for mafia to manipulate the lynch.

So vote for me


On December 12 2010 01:44 deconduo wrote:
On December 11 2010 11:27 LSB wrote:
[image loading]

Mad that we haven't won a game for such a long time?


Reason Number one two three four five: I win games for the town.

There have been 5 recent town victories and I had a hand in all of them
+ Show Spoiler +
Slightly Embellished

Don't lose yo village: I put together the pieces and guarented victory
And Then There Were None(RAM) I kill everyone else. And as town I win with Radfield
TL Mafia XXX I come up with a giant plan that the town use and the mafia panics and kills me day one.


Pick Your Power Mafia 2!: I picked traitor. As traitor I get our most important mafia member killed, and also the SK killed. Enough deaths meant the mafia lost
Team Melee Mini Mafia II: As scum I am imediatly identified. Our team has one of the members claim doctor... and get killed. Our team then does a noobie mistake and looses.

Simply put. I lose as Mafia. And as town I help the town win. Vote me for mayor if you want to win!


If you are gonna help us win anyway, why do we need you as mayor? Vote for me instead.




On December 12 2010 02:28 deconduo wrote:
On December 12 2010 02:05 Radfield wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
On December 11 2010 11:27 LSB wrote:
[image loading]

Mad that we haven't won a game for such a long time?


Reason Number one two three four five: I win games for the town.

There have been 5 recent town victories and I had a hand in all of them
+ Show Spoiler +
Slightly Embellished

Don't lose yo village: I put together the pieces and guarented victory
And Then There Were None(RAM) I kill everyone else. And as town I win with Radfield
TL Mafia XXX I come up with a giant plan that the town use and the mafia panics and kills me day one.


Pick Your Power Mafia 2!: I picked traitor. As traitor I get our most important mafia member killed, and also the SK killed. Enough deaths meant the mafia lost
Team Melee Mini Mafia II: As scum I am imediatly identified. Our team has one of the members claim doctor... and get killed. Our team then does a noobie mistake and looses.

Simply put. I lose as Mafia. And as town I help the town win. Vote me for mayor if you want to win!



I died night 1 in 'And Then There Were None'..... And didn't town lose that game??


Are you sure? I'm pretty sure it went down to a 3-way between me LSB and you. I voted for you and you voted for me, then LSB hammered us both. We both died, LSB was last man standing and won.


On December 12 2010 03:04 deconduo wrote:
On December 12 2010 02:55 Pandain wrote:
what powers does mayor have?


Picks first day lynch, thats all. No bodyguards or anything.


On December 12 2010 05:44 deconduo wrote:
On December 12 2010 04:39 Radfield wrote:
On December 12 2010 02:28 deconduo wrote:
On December 12 2010 02:05 Radfield wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
On December 11 2010 11:27 LSB wrote:
[image loading]

Mad that we haven't won a game for such a long time?


Reason Number one two three four five: I win games for the town.

There have been 5 recent town victories and I had a hand in all of them
+ Show Spoiler +
Slightly Embellished

Don't lose yo village: I put together the pieces and guarented victory
And Then There Were None(RAM) I kill everyone else. And as town I win with Radfield
TL Mafia XXX I come up with a giant plan that the town use and the mafia panics and kills me day one.


Pick Your Power Mafia 2!: I picked traitor. As traitor I get our most important mafia member killed, and also the SK killed. Enough deaths meant the mafia lost
Team Melee Mini Mafia II: As scum I am imediatly identified. Our team has one of the members claim doctor... and get killed. Our team then does a noobie mistake and looses.

Simply put. I lose as Mafia. And as town I help the town win. Vote me for mayor if you want to win!



I died night 1 in 'And Then There Were None'..... And didn't town lose that game??


Are you sure? I'm pretty sure it went down to a 3-way between me LSB and you. I voted for you and you voted for me, then LSB hammered us both. We both died, LSB was last man standing and won.


That was Rastaban I think. You killed me night one, at the very least you sent me a PM apologizing



Yah my mistake. I got mixed up between you two. Was a fun game though


Announces candidacy, plugs candidacy, then gets side tracked for three posts--not much of a campaign imo. Yet he was able to garner votes from Jackal58, ilovejonn, and CubEdIn. Why did you three vote for such a non-chalant candidate? Especially Jackal58 and ilovejonn, who are both lurking pretty hard-core.

Doesn't actually do much. It's like he's trying to get other people to do analysis on Deconduo without putting an opinion himself


+ Show Spoiler [Irrelevant Smurf Stuff] +

On December 11 2010 13:47 aidnai wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 11 2010 13:25 Jackal58 wrote:
Wtf is a "smurf"?
Other than the obvious little blue cartoon people?


Obvious smurf imo.

On December 11 2010 13:47 aidnai wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 11 2010 13:25 Jackal58 wrote:
Wtf is a "smurf"?
Other than the obvious little blue cartoon people?


Obvious smurf imo.

On December 11 2010 14:42 aidnai wrote:
Alright, we have a few smurfs.

The true identities have not been revealed so the smurf is doing its job.
The mod and players are aware that there are smurfs, so we know not to talk about the game with people outside the thread.

Can we all be happy with this? I don't think Annul should learn the identity of the smurfs, since that would give him a leg up in future games....

On December 12 2010 02:53 aidnai wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 11 2010 23:15 Jackal58 wrote:
On December 11 2010 13:47 aidnai wrote:
On December 11 2010 13:25 Jackal58 wrote:
Wtf is a "smurf"?
Other than the obvious little blue cartoon people?


Obvious smurf imo.

My first game. And I'm already making an impression. Scum right there folks.


'What is a smurf?' Let me try to define it for you.
- Joined TL.net november 14
- Requested access to the mafia forum november 14
- Posted nowhere else except this game

Rather than argue details about past games, here's a policy we could discuss right now: LAL.

On December 12 2010 03:13 aidnai wrote:
Ok, i'm sorry for bringing up smurfs again. Smurf or not *actually* wasn't the main point of post--it's just strange to me that an honest-to-god newbie has no other question about the game than 'what is a smurf'. He looked suspicious, so I wanted to see how/if he reacted.


This is just Aidnai trying to seem like he is active and contributing to the game, talking about a subject that doesn't matter at all


+ Show Spoiler [Minor, Unimportant posts] +

On December 11 2010 14:50 aidnai wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 11 2010 14:42 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote:
<3 sorry I will stop with the argument! I would rather establish smurfs with alternate play styles and run with a few different accounts than constantly making new names and asking for access and jumping through all the hoops that go with that -__-;
______
on topic.
vote for me if you want, I will kill LSB day one! That is my platform.

Legit, that is my platform. Upon being elected I will kill LSB, vote for me.


rofl, you're screwed lsb! unless unfortunate complications arise causing RoL to excuse himself from the game.

Actually, I really would love to hear your reasoning on this, rebirth-of-sherlock-fucking-holmes...

Question/spamish post. Not much can be gleaned

On December 12 2010 03:00 aidnai wrote:
From D1 post:

On day one, you must vote for a Minister for Magic. Note above the thirty-one eligible candidates. There are thirty-one players. Coincidence? Nope! The Minister will have no further powers beyond day one (no bodyguards, et cetera) and his only game power will be to decide the day one kill. Election will end at 7 PM EST on Sunday, December 12. The kill submission must come before 9 PM EST the same day. Vote for Minister in the voting thread.

Not much here either


Conclusion
Aidnai is mafia, trying to avoid topics and pretend to be active.
##Lynch: Aidnai



My final target would be Pandain

Please let me know who it should be so I can let annul know.


You say I got a lot of votes out of nowhere. I got 2 votes out of nowhere, you got 7+. By your logic, you should lynch yourself.

Deconduo can confirm this theory, but I believe that he pmed people.
I know he PMed me


I was PMing you and Cube. Though I started talking with Cube after he voted for me, not before.
deconduo
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
Ireland4122 Posts
December 13 2010 00:46 GMT
#457
Already said my choice in PM, here it is in public:

Vote Aidnai
deconduo
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
Ireland4122 Posts
December 14 2010 10:48 GMT
#758
Pretty obvious that LSB is snape.
deconduo
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
Ireland4122 Posts
December 14 2010 21:01 GMT
#783
Big 'I Told You So' moment coming up.
deconduo
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
Ireland4122 Posts
December 14 2010 21:14 GMT
#786
On December 15 2010 06:11 Meapak_Ziphh wrote:
I'm slightly disturbed no counter bandwagon appeared :/


Its so obvious he's legit, town just sheeped mafia.
deconduo
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
Ireland4122 Posts
December 15 2010 13:44 GMT
#868
Hmm, well I was right and wrong I suppose. I shouldn't have trusted him as much as I did.

I have a huge amount of PMs I can post though, which should probably prove I'm town.

+ Show Spoiler +

First set:
+ Show Spoiler +

From: LSB [ 1709 posts | Profile | Buddy ]
Subject: Re: Harry Potter Maf
Date: 12/12/10 08:56
No Idea. Rol's been messing around with the thread x.x

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From deconduo:
Whats with ROL promising to lynch you?

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From LSB:
Hmm... my campaign is probably dead right now. I just really wanted to draw a cool vote sign after I saw all the campaign signs in TL Mafia V.

About Beneather, he was a part of SIFZ so that's probably why he respects me. And also as the mod of insane I helped him out and gave him suggestions.

What I'm concerned about is why no one even bothered so support/discuss it with me :S. Everyone started calling me scum.
This possible could be an organized mafia attack. That's why I'm most suspicious of RoL right now, as he seems to be like the follow up.

The safest vote will probably be Mepak, since it will be a lynch

As for Airbag, he's been messaging me. Obviously he's a smurf since he's started playing the PM game

I'll attach the PMs here
+ Show Spoiler +

I'd rather not draw that much attention to myself...

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From LSB:
If you want, you can be the auditor.

The thing is, since I'm doing it, the mafia won't be able to slip in and and manipulate the vote.

Changing the voting record is also a problem with normal voting. All the mafia has to do is decide slightly earlier.

If you really don't like the private vote idea. (I take it the general sentiment is that they don't want it) We can do reasoned voting, or runoff voting

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From Airbag:
but if you are mafia it increases the ways in which you can manipulate the vote and it gives the mafia a long time to discuss how they'd like their voting record to look without ever having to appear wishy washy for changing it

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From LSB:
The issue is that people like to go with the bandwagon. It seems safer, and there is a false sense of security in voting with the majority.

Private votes allow each person to make their decision independently. It cuts off ways for the mafia to influence people.

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From Airbag:
I understand wanting to vote for a player with experience but you can just manipulate the votes if ur mafia

Why not just have people post their votes publicly, then it's completely impossible for you to lie about it.

I'm getting a blue/red read from him since he doesn't want to draw attention.

I'm going to trust Qatol in that Jackel isn't a smurf.

Defiantly Why is a smurf, or at least played in some other forum

Just something to keep in mind

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From deconduo:
You should totally vote for me cos I'm awesome


On to more realistic things, I'll probably end up voting for you if my campaign is unsuccessful. Your play in yo village was pretty awesome.

What are your opinions on Beneather? Something seems off about him.

Smurfs: Airbag, Jackal

Probably Why as well.


Second Set:

+ Show Spoiler +

From: LSB [ 1709 posts | Profile | Buddy ]
Subject: Re: HP Mafia
Date: 12/13/10 10:38
Yeah... I felt that something was up with that...

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From deconduo:
No idea, he's completely flown under my radar. I don't think I even realised he was playing.

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From LSB:
No worries.

What do you think of Kitaman27?

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From deconduo:
Okey, thanks for clearing that up

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From LSB:
I don't have an alternative victory condition with RoL.

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From deconduo:
I don't think you are mafia, but you've been behaving weirdly so I'm gonna be blunt. Do you have an alternative victory condition with RoL? The way the 2 of you have been playing, this seems to be the only explanation.


Third Set:

+ Show Spoiler +

From: LSB [ 1709 posts | Profile | Buddy ]
Subject: Re: HP Mafia
Date: 12/14/10 10:31

I trust Meapak_Ziphh. And I can confirm his role and actions if you get him to tell you anything.

I believe I can trust anyone. I've come to deduce that my role is both important and bad for the mafia (unless I'm missing a death eater). I will offer myself to be lynched to the town if my role becomes better for the mafia.

And even if the mafia does find out who I am (they have a pretty good idea of who they are looking for), since I didn't die last night, if we lynch a mafia today I should be fine.

I know this sounds kind of vauge, but if you figure out my character, it might make more sense. If you want, I can attach some clues.

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From deconduo:
I was checked (and confirmed to be town)last night by a DT, so I have a small circle with him. If you think you can trust LD + zergling (and if I can convince them we're legit), that makes 6 people.

The DT is dumbledore.

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From LSB:
Although there is no way to confirm my role. Here are a few things I can show you.

1) I can hint at what my character is. I have already hinted in thread. You can discuss this with kenpachi

2) I can provide chat logs that show that Me and RoL were actually working together. You can probably confirm this with Meepak, but I don't really want this known much. Most of the fighting was just fishing attempts. This is how we confirmed Meepak.
I can confirm that RoL checked Orgolove. If Orgolove flips red, would that be enough to convince you that the current lynch is BS?

3) I don't expect this to occur. But maybe... maybe something in the Harry Potter role might hint to the existence of my role.

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From deconduo:
Hmm, anyway of confirming/proving it? I'm not asking you to do it as you have no idea if I'm scum or not, just interested if you can.

Might have a 6 person town circle if so.

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From LSB:
He guessed my role correctly
-----------------------------------------
Original Message From deconduo:
Why is kenpachi defending you so fervently?



Also PMs with RoL:

+ Show Spoiler +

From: RebirthOfLeGenD [ 2591 posts | Profile | Buddy ]
Subject: Re: HP Mafia
Date: 12/14/10 08:36


oh man, so whats your power your using tonight? I read everyone has powers this game.

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From deconduo:
Yep, I'm confusing games -_-

Take gabe out of that list, that was a mistake.

My take on LSB is this: I don't think he is mafia, but I'm sure he has an alternative win condition. At first I thought it was with you, but maybe its someone else.

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From RebirthOfLeGenD:
If by gabe you mean gabriel you are confusing games o_O Malongo isn't in this game. Whats your take on LSB? Everyone keeps disagreeing with me for some reason. I should try to do an analysis on beneather as well.

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From deconduo:
Aww

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From RebirthOfLeGenD:
hmm you have too many of us, we are going to have to put you down tonight.

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From deconduo:
I'm interested of you, Gabe, Meapak, Beneather, LSB, Cube. Don't really have anyone pegged as mafia yet, thats just a list of people that have said or done things that I noticed.

My biggest FOS would be beneather though.



-----------------------------------------
Original Message From RebirthOfLeGenD:
coo coo, so who u think is mafia bro?

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From deconduo:
I'm talking with a few people in PM, but I'm not teamed with anyone rolewise.

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From RebirthOfLeGenD:
who are you working with?

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From deconduo:
I did, but LSB denied it.

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From RebirthOfLeGenD:
hmm? you think I am working with LSB?

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From deconduo:
I don't think you are mafia, but you've been behaving weirdly so I'm gonna be blunt. Do you have an alternative victory condition with LSB? The way the 2 of you have been playing, this seems to be the only explanation.


Thats all the PMs, nothing changed or removed.



As you can see, I didn't think LSB was mafia, but he was behaving weirdly. I was gullible to believe that he was a legit traitor, but ironically he actually was he just didn't know it yet. Wasn't my idea that RoL and LSB were working together, that was someone else's. I just decided to ask them about it.


If you actually still believe I am mafia, and I faked all those PMs, you think I'm a muuuuuch better player than I actually am. -_-

Side note:
The fact that he was talking with Airbag as well leads me to believe Airbag is town. (No reason for LSB to fake that conversation)
deconduo
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
Ireland4122 Posts
December 16 2010 00:27 GMT
#890
My opinions:


Almost certainly town:

3. Airbag
4. Kenpachi
(PMs with LSB)
27. Mr.Zergling
22. LunarDestiny
(Luna's Circle)

Probably town:

25. Thegilaboy
11. CubEdIn
12. Meapak_Ziphh
20. orgolove
(General play, talking with them)


Dunno/lurking/not enough info:

5. pevergreen (who replaced ghrur)
6. Jackal58
13. Barundar
14. Node
15. chaoser
16. jcarlsoniv
17. kitaman27
19. oddo123
23. ghote
24. why
29. zeks
30. tube
31. GGQ


FoS:

28. Pandain
21. ~OpZ~
10. Amber[LighT]
9. Coagulation
7. ilovejonn
deconduo
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
Ireland4122 Posts
December 16 2010 01:31 GMT
#894
On December 16 2010 10:27 Jackal58 wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 16 2010 09:27 deconduo wrote:
My opinions:


Almost certainly town:

3. Airbag
4. Kenpachi
(PMs with LSB)
27. Mr.Zergling
22. LunarDestiny
(Luna's Circle)

Probably town:

25. Thegilaboy
11. CubEdIn
12. Meapak_Ziphh
20. orgolove
(General play, talking with them)


Dunno/lurking/not enough info:

5. pevergreen (who replaced ghrur)
6. Jackal58
13. Barundar
14. Node
15. chaoser
16. jcarlsoniv
17. kitaman27
19. oddo123
23. ghote
24. why
29. zeks
30. tube
31. GGQ


FoS:

28. Pandain
21. ~OpZ~
10. Amber[LighT]
9. Coagulation
7. ilovejonn


My opinion
Supposed PMs with a dead guy don't mean shit.
I'm still believing deconduo is a Death Eater.
I'm also believing his "almost certainly" town list are as well.


Are you honestly saying I faked those PMs?
deconduo
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
Ireland4122 Posts
December 16 2010 20:51 GMT
#961
I'd recommend ghote to be investigated or lynched. He has one post in the thread and he voted for LSB as MoM.
deconduo
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
Ireland4122 Posts
December 17 2010 17:35 GMT
#1027
99% sure Doc H isn't mafia. If you read one of my previous posts, LSB gave me PMs with the 2 of them talking. There was absolutely no reason for LSB to fake PMs from another mafia member at that point in the game. Here they are again:

+ Show Spoiler +

I'd rather not draw that much attention to myself...

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From LSB:
If you want, you can be the auditor.

The thing is, since I'm doing it, the mafia won't be able to slip in and and manipulate the vote.

Changing the voting record is also a problem with normal voting. All the mafia has to do is decide slightly earlier.

If you really don't like the private vote idea. (I take it the general sentiment is that they don't want it) We can do reasoned voting, or runoff voting

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From Airbag:
but if you are mafia it increases the ways in which you can manipulate the vote and it gives the mafia a long time to discuss how they'd like their voting record to look without ever having to appear wishy washy for changing it

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From LSB:
The issue is that people like to go with the bandwagon. It seems safer, and there is a false sense of security in voting with the majority.

Private votes allow each person to make their decision independently. It cuts off ways for the mafia to influence people.

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From Airbag:
I understand wanting to vote for a player with experience but you can just manipulate the votes if ur mafia

Why not just have people post their votes publicly, then it's completely impossible for you to lie about it.

deconduo
Profile Blog Joined January 2008
Ireland4122 Posts
December 17 2010 17:46 GMT
#1031
On December 18 2010 02:42 jcarlsoniv wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 18 2010 02:39 kitaman27 wrote:
On December 18 2010 02:35 deconduo wrote:
99% sure Doc H isn't mafia. If you read one of my previous posts, LSB gave me PMs with the 2 of them talking. There was absolutely no reason for LSB to fake PMs from another mafia member at that point in the game. Here they are again:

+ Show Spoiler +

I'd rather not draw that much attention to myself...

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From LSB:
If you want, you can be the auditor.

The thing is, since I'm doing it, the mafia won't be able to slip in and and manipulate the vote.

Changing the voting record is also a problem with normal voting. All the mafia has to do is decide slightly earlier.

If you really don't like the private vote idea. (I take it the general sentiment is that they don't want it) We can do reasoned voting, or runoff voting

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From Airbag:
but if you are mafia it increases the ways in which you can manipulate the vote and it gives the mafia a long time to discuss how they'd like their voting record to look without ever having to appear wishy washy for changing it

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From LSB:
The issue is that people like to go with the bandwagon. It seems safer, and there is a false sense of security in voting with the majority.

Private votes allow each person to make their decision independently. It cuts off ways for the mafia to influence people.

-----------------------------------------
Original Message From Airbag:
I understand wanting to vote for a player with experience but you can just manipulate the votes if ur mafia

Why not just have people post their votes publicly, then it's completely impossible for you to lie about it.



Didn't the whole LBS situation seem a little fishy to you though? He practically role claimed scum for some weird 1:1 trade with oroglove. PM's can be fabricated. In the previous game, there was a decent amount of discussion on mafia and fake pms. Why fake role claim if you are clean?


Also, I'm not sure what you mean by "There was absolutely no reason for LSB to fake PMs from another mafia member at that point in the game."

At what point in the game does it begin to be good for mafia to start faking PMs?


Can you explain any reason why LSB would fake PMs from someone to try and get me suspicious of them if they were his mafia team mate? It makes no sense whatsoever. So I believe Dr. H is legit.
1 2 3 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
RSL Revival
10:00
Season 1: Playoffs Day 1
ByuN vs Classic
Clem vs Cham
Crank 858
Tasteless710
Rex59
IndyStarCraft 30
IntoTheiNu 24
3DClanTV 8
LiquipediaDiscussion
The PondCast
10:00
Episode 53
CranKy Ducklings12
Liquipedia
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
Crank 858
Tasteless 710
Nina 159
Rex 59
ProTech56
IndyStarCraft 30
EnDerr 1
StarCraft: Brood War
Sea 3517
Rain 921
BeSt 810
Jaedong 758
Killer 452
ToSsGirL 444
Mini 367
GoRush 352
Larva 340
actioN 291
[ Show more ]
EffOrt 262
Pusan 224
Light 128
Nal_rA 92
Mong 85
Shinee 59
JulyZerg 48
Rush 46
Sharp 45
sSak 41
Mind 37
Last 36
Noble 35
Sacsri 32
ajuk12(nOOB) 13
Bale 8
Movie 7
NaDa 6
sorry 6
Dota 2
BananaSlamJamma451
XcaliburYe422
420jenkins212
League of Legends
JimRising 416
Counter-Strike
shoxiejesuss942
Stewie2K410
x6flipin34
Super Smash Bros
Mew2King183
Other Games
DeMusliM294
Happy269
crisheroes220
rGuardiaN93
SortOf57
Organizations
StarCraft: Brood War
Kim Chul Min (afreeca) 952
StarCraft 2
ComeBackTV 221
Blizzard YouTube
StarCraft: Brood War
BSLTrovo
sctven
[ Show 14 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• LUISG 19
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• LaughNgamezSOOP
• Migwel
• sooper7s
StarCraft: Brood War
• iopq 2
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• lizZardDota2101
League of Legends
• Stunt590
Upcoming Events
WardiTV European League
5h 47m
ByuN vs NightPhoenix
HeRoMaRinE vs HiGhDrA
Krystianer vs sebesdes
MaxPax vs Babymarine
SKillous vs Mixu
ShoWTimE vs MaNa
Replay Cast
13h 47m
RSL Revival
23h 47m
herO vs SHIN
Reynor vs Cure
WardiTV European League
1d 5h
Scarlett vs Percival
Jumy vs ArT
YoungYakov vs Shameless
uThermal vs Fjant
Nicoract vs goblin
Harstem vs Gerald
FEL
1d 5h
Korean StarCraft League
1d 16h
CranKy Ducklings
1d 23h
RSL Revival
1d 23h
FEL
2 days
Sparkling Tuna Cup
2 days
[ Show More ]
RSL Revival
2 days
FEL
3 days
BSL: ProLeague
3 days
Dewalt vs Bonyth
Replay Cast
4 days
Replay Cast
4 days
The PondCast
5 days
Replay Cast
6 days
RSL Revival
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2025-06-28
HSC XXVII
Heroes 10 EU

Ongoing

JPL Season 2
BSL 2v2 Season 3
BSL Season 20
Acropolis #3
KCM Race Survival 2025 Season 2
CSL 17: 2025 SUMMER
Copa Latinoamericana 4
Championship of Russia 2025
RSL Revival: Season 1
Murky Cup #2
BLAST.tv Austin Major 2025
ESL Impact League Season 7
IEM Dallas 2025
PGL Astana 2025
Asian Champions League '25
BLAST Rivals Spring 2025
MESA Nomadic Masters
CCT Season 2 Global Finals
IEM Melbourne 2025
YaLLa Compass Qatar 2025

Upcoming

CSLPRO Last Chance 2025
CSLPRO Chat StarLAN 3
K-Championship
uThermal 2v2 Main Event
SEL Season 2 Championship
FEL Cracov 2025
Esports World Cup 2025
StarSeries Fall 2025
FISSURE Playground #2
BLAST Open Fall 2025
BLAST Open Fall Qual
Esports World Cup 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall Qual
IEM Cologne 2025
FISSURE Playground #1
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2025 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.