Oh shit... Meapak haha I hope the assassin isn't persistent enough to do that.

There's an easier way. The assassin doesn't know how many characters the PM for the bodyguards was. Let me make it clear - DrH did -not- write a simple PM for the bodyguards (you should know what I'm talking about).
Can we not conceivably make a key based on the words in the PM?

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

November 06 2010 03:43 GMT

#69

Aww just as I was all ready with the ciper and stuff, this comes up.

Btw coagulation, you still have the code in your quote -_-

I doubt Meapak is the assassin, as I don't think an assassin would start up so soon with the idea of an encrypted message based on the King's name.

But I further doubt Meapak's story about his 2 role PMs. care to explain?

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

November 06 2010 03:55 GMT

#70

CubedIn's arguments to denounce Meapak is invalid. What he's done, at best, was to try to create an internal communications system among bodyguards. At worst, he still managed to confuse the Assassin. In fact, The very argument he uses, that Meapak jeopardized the mayor points toward him being a bodyguard - if he does know the name of the Mayor, then we'll only be helping the Assassin by increasing his chances of hitting the King.

I'm actually surprised by the ferocity of CubedIn's attack on Meapak, and by how eager he's been to lynch him. Anything to improve your chances, eh? Your post reeks of an assassin frustrated after being unable to crack Meapak's code.

##Vote CubedIn

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

November 06 2010 04:21 GMT

#73

As DrH mentioned, staying silent will completely take the fun out of the game. Though that is the "optimum" strategy, the host wants interaction. So we give him interaction...

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

November 06 2010 04:50 GMT

#77

Well then, what would you have us (me) do? After all, CubedIn was the one who opened the can of worms. It's up to us to deal with it now.

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

November 07 2010 03:51 GMT

#93

Ah fuck. my CubedIn vote was based on his irrational aggression against Meapak. It was the first day - not much we can do.

Screw you coagulation. god damn you are a terrible mafia player. I don't think you're the assassin, but man, you are terrible and might as well be one. It's almost like we're playing against two assassins here - coagulation and the real one.

From DrHelvetica's reaction after Meapak tried to use his code, I think it's safe to say Meapak isn't the assassin - if I as a host saw the assassin fishing for information via a fake code, I probably would've let him go thinking it an ingenious plan.

And Node seems quite pro-town, considering he's against busing someone without reason. An assassin would want lynches ASAP.

I doubt bumatlarge is an assassin either, based on his reactions to the code revelation and coagulation's shit against meapak. (These two are really experienced - I may well be fooled by their silver tongue, but there's not much else to go at this point).

And youngminii also doesn't look like the assassin because he's also trying to slow down the lynches.

Bereft... I don't know. On the one hand, he was quite reasonable in pointing out the 0/7 chance of getting the assassin when voting against Meapak vs 1/7 chance when voting vs anyone else. But On the other hand, he was really persistent on killing off CubedIn. - And the faster the bodyguards are killed off, the easier it is for the assassin.

DarthThienAn is another suspect. The only relevant post in this game was his vote. -_- I think this guy has the highest chance of being the assassin.

##Vote DarthThienAn

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

November 07 2010 03:52 GMT

#94

Especially this:

On November 06 2010 16:38 DarthThienAn wrote:
I got nothing right now, but

##Vote: CubEdIn

"I got Nothing"

Of course the assassin 'got nothing" - he has no information. LOL

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

November 07 2010 18:37 GMT

#103

Were there any variations between your PMs across the roles other than their specific role names and purpose? i.e. Coagulation mentioned that he only received one PM from you, but Meapak mentioned he received two PMs. If both are bodyguards, then it means you sent these two different role PMs despite being in the same role. Did you send different PMs?

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

November 07 2010 20:37 GMT

#105

On November 07 2010 16:26 bumatlarge wrote:
I feel the assassin is among Bereft, youngminii, and darth. But can't say anything for certain. Maybe if everyone does a dance and we will crown the best dancer as successor. I actually missed meapak's actual code, but I don't really care. If he was very clever he could have led it to someone different. But Dr.H makes it seem otherwise.

Darth seems like a solid vote I like your reasoning with everything else. And there is not much detail we should be going into as we only give more information, but more people need to just give their thought, because I'm not having an assasin sit back this game with his arms crossed. And there are no inactives. HOHOHO

I agree with bum here. If Darth flips blue, it's probably gonna be between Bereft and youngminii.

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

November 08 2010 00:24 GMT

#108

I honestly haven't played enough with any of you to really tell how you play in which role. bumatlarge, as a blue while in Insane Mafia, was plenty pro-town early in the game, just as he is now active in this game. Youngminii was a real ass as a vampire in Haunted, but he's been reasonable this game. I haven't seen you before, Darth.

Youngminii hasn't contributed much this game, but he's still been more pro-town than you. All you contributed to our first loss was :"I have nothing, here's my bandwagon vote." Nice....

Your responses after you are accused do smell more like a bodyguard than an assassin. But it may well be you throwing up a smokescreen to delay your kill until the last possible moment.

But so far, my assessment is that either you, Bereft, or youngminii is the assassin. we'll see after the lynch goes through.

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

November 08 2010 00:57 GMT

#110

What is this "point" you are talking about, other than you saying your posting pattern is indicative of a bodyguard? -_- I understand far more than you that the assassin gets closer to hitting the king with every bodyguard kill. But we're doing far more than just killing an inactive - you clearly revealed you "have nothing right now" i.e. no information. Only an assassin has NO information in this game - the rest all know the king's name.

On November 08 2010 09:51 DarthThienAn wrote:
That either makes you the assassin, or incredibly stupid. Lynch orgolove tomorrow plz, maybe bereft/YM after that.

lol.....

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

November 08 2010 02:20 GMT

#113

Well, I'm waiting for others to post their own analyses. So far I'm the only one really looking at people, and I've been wrong in the first day... so I won't mind if others also jump in as well.

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

November 08 2010 03:30 GMT

#116

On November 08 2010 11:55 Coagulation wrote:
Guys im voting Orgolove cause he made a slip that if i point out will compromise the kings secret identity.

Your lack of... sophistication boggles my mind (That's not a personal insult amirite DrH?)

Darth has been quite pro-town for his past couple of posts. I'm just not so sure about changing my vote when his posts have only surfaced after the first death.

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

November 08 2010 06:55 GMT

#124

On November 08 2010 03:37 orgolove wrote:
Were there any variations between your PMs across the roles other than their specific role names and purpose?

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

November 08 2010 08:10 GMT

#128

I had thought that messages in bold green means a message to the mod...

anyway,

##unvote Meapak_Ziphh
##vote Bereft

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

November 08 2010 08:53 GMT

#133

On November 08 2010 17:46 Coagulation wrote:
NOPE HE SAID SOMETHING HE WOULDNT SAY IF HE KNOWS THE KINGS IDENTITY

Are you flippin' serious... Can anyone be this daft? Jesus christ.

orgolove

Vatican City State1650 Posts

November 08 2010 10:05 GMT

#140

On November 08 2010 18:37 Coagulation wrote:
ya i feel like doch just may be sick enough to pull some shit like that on us.

Multiple kings my fucking ass. Every post you've made in this thread reeks of utter stupidity. You should be labeled a biohazard - people will grow a fucking brain tumor from just reading the trash you shit out in this thread. I'm counting the days until the hosts become frustrated enough to put you on the perma ban bus.

Actually, they might want to keep you for the entertainment value - I bet the way you spew your idiocy surely gives a tickle to the hosts who have all the information.

On November 08 2010 18:30 bumatlarge wrote:
Multiple kings would explain bereft's mix-up.

On November 08 2010 18:47 DarthThienAn wrote:
First of all, I dont think DH would host a bad game. So let's assume that the setup was run as stated, and that we all have the same king.

I think I might know what Coag is talking about... kinda not sure at the same time though, because it's iffy to me. I r perplexed by you, Coag x_x.

I agree that orgolove is fishy to me. But I... am not completely sure what you're talking about.

Are you honestly giving a thought to this fool's drivel? Really, bumatlarge? Do you really think DrH would give TWO fucking kings given how he's structured the game so far?

And really? Darth? Doesn't it even remotely cross your idea that your perceived "slip" may be a misinformation to fool the fucking assassin? Knowledge about the mere presence of a misinformation campaign dramatically decreases its effectiveness, so I tried to make it subtle. But because you are giving thought to coagulation's words, you forced my hand. Good job guys.

Do you all honestly believe for a second that if someone of coagulation's ~~5 year old intellect~~ terrible mafia "skill level" could find an actual slip-up, an assassin wouldn't catch it immediately?

Don't. Feed. The. Troll. Reading coagulation's posts will only poison your mind and hide it from the true danger.