Morhaime on Bnet 2.0 : xbox live of PCs - Page 5
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
Klogon
MURICA15980 Posts
| ||
|
isuckalot
France27 Posts
Anonymity is intrinsic to the internet, but I don't think it's universally beneficial. It inherently deflects responsibility, and although it's convenient to not be held responsible, some people take advantage of the environment to indulge in total asshattery. Obviously smurfing does not equate to asshattery, but I'd just like people to remember that liberty can show the best and worst colors. This is a pertinent comment that raises some of the fundamental (I would even say philosophical) problematics of the Internet. But I guess this goes far beyond our discussion about how Battle.Net 2.0 should be ![]() | ||
|
Idle
Korea (South)124 Posts
On August 08 2009 03:12 Klogon wrote: I feel like everybody is moaning about nothing. Nothing is what we should be moaning about. If they weren't implementing all this unneeded crap we'd have people testing the beta right now. Most people want a matchmaking service and sc2, not facebookcraft. Give me a server list, that's all I want. I want to play sc2, I don't need to post my picture, write an autobiography, and tell everybody what I ate for breakfast this morning. If I wanted that I'd use facebook. If I want to play sc2 I'd use bnet 2.0. | ||
|
Spawkuring
United States755 Posts
On August 08 2009 03:39 Idle wrote: Nothing is what we should be moaning about. If they weren't implementing all this unneeded crap we'd have people testing the beta right now. Most people want a matchmaking service and sc2, not facebookcraft. Give me a server list, that's all I want. I want to play sc2, I don't need to post my picture, write an autobiography, and tell everybody what I ate for breakfast this morning. If I wanted that I'd use facebook. If I want to play sc2 I'd use bnet 2.0. It's too late to do that. Although people generally don't say it out loud, the truth is that betas are just as much an advertisement as they are a testing venue. And when it comes to advertisement, first impressions are everything. If the beta comes out and Bnet 2.0 doesn't blow people away, then all the hype will come crashing down on Blizzard's head. The game HAS to be extremely high quality and polished by the time beta comes out otherwise Blizzard will get hit by a huge backlash. | ||
|
thopol
Japan4560 Posts
On August 08 2009 03:12 Klogon wrote: I feel like everybody is moaning about nothing. It's because they're not giving us anything substantial to moan about. | ||
|
Idle
Korea (South)124 Posts
On August 08 2009 03:52 Spawkuring wrote: It's too late to do that. Although people generally don't say it out loud, the truth is that betas are just as much an advertisement as they are a testing venue. And when it comes to advertisement, first impressions are everything. If the beta comes out and Bnet 2.0 doesn't blow people away, then all the hype will come crashing down on Blizzard's head. The game HAS to be extremely high quality and polished by the time beta comes out otherwise Blizzard will get hit by a huge backlash. The GAME has to be extremely high quality and polished. The only reason bnet is becoming the high priority that it is now (not saying it wasn't always a priority, just that we're hearing more about how awesome bnet is than the actual game at this point) is because of the incredible backlash they had when they announced removal of LAN capability. Had they left lan in and given us a simple matchmaking system people would be just as happy, but since they made the extremely poor decision to remove lan and pissed off a huge portion of their player base they're now stuck trying to make bnet blow everyone's minds, leading to more delays that could've easily been avoided in the first place. | ||
|
whyohwhy
60 Posts
On August 08 2009 03:05 Spawkuring wrote: It's not that Blizzard has a monopoly though. On RTS? Give me one other franchise which comes REMOTELY close to Blizzard's titles (SC, Warcraft 3). There's a reason people are still playing SC, it's because there really hasn't been anything better yet, at least if you don't mind the 640x480 res. No self respecting gamer I know REALLY plays westwood RTS atm, or even in the past since the original C&C became outdated. Sure, they play the campaigns, might spend some time in multiplayer, but they are usually quickly forgotten. I guess WH40k wasn't completely bad, although DOW 2 is garbage (all tactical, no base building). From what I gather westwood is headed in that direction too (no base building in the upcoming C&C). Anyway again, there is a reason SC still has such a huge community for a 11 yr old game: it's still the best to this day. When nobody is really able to tackle that in 2009 (save for Blizzard themselves), I would say that's pretty much a monopoly. And even on MMO, which Blizzard is remotely new at, you could say they now have a would be monopoly with WOW. That mf is so successful it's not funny. Compared to those genres, FPS for instance still has quite a bit of competition going on. Hell I'm not saying Blizzard is bad, they obviously have a lot of talent. But when you go without any real competition for long enough, bad things happen. It's starting to show pretty bad with SC2. | ||
|
EchOne
United States2906 Posts
Now if we're focusing on RTS e-Sports, any argument that Blizzard isn't the overlord here is silly. Blizzard owns this arena, and isn't poised to give it up any time soon, even if SC2 is a flop. | ||
|
whyohwhy
60 Posts
I'm saying Blizzard has no serious competitor for best game in genre. So because they'll make the best game which most gamers will flock to and nobody can really challenge, they can go ahead and shove all this BS marketing down your throat. I want to see another company really tackle the beast already for some healthy competition and hopefully less of this "screw the end user because we can" BS. | ||
|
Drowsy
United States4876 Posts
| ||
|
MiniRoman
Canada3953 Posts
On August 08 2009 00:10 EchOne wrote:. Okay, I really don't understand why you would play a competitive game casually. If you want casual gaming, play a casual game. Blizzard has made plenty of those. This is Starcraft, wherein going easy is a bad option. On August 08 2009 02:50 EchOne wrote: You're right, I'm only D+, and compared to a inveterate C+ Protoss like you, my enjoyment of BW can hardly be called "competitive." I haven't benefited from smurfing first-hand, and though I haven't suffered from it either (the majority of my losses are Koreans, not smurfs), I was definitely narrow-minded in my approach to arguing against smurfing. I'm sorry for that and thank everyone for offering first-hand accounts on the benefits of smurfing. I was just trying to use you as an example as to why your argument was bad and not applicable to real people. No one wants to be forced on their toes at all time is all. It's just psychologically different being on a second account. Pretty sure every SC player ever has an off-id just for more relaxing games. | ||
|
whyohwhy
60 Posts
On August 08 2009 06:55 Drowsy wrote: Nobody cares about stupid crap like being able to message my e-friends playing dark elves or whatever. Your e-friends playing dark elves care! | ||
|
D10
Brazil3409 Posts
Whats so revolutionary that is taking so long ? Only one answer comes to my mind, they are scared shitless of what their stockholders will think if after 1 week of beta the whole world is playing it. I bet they have some leet hacker that finds 2 ways to crack bnet everyday and everytime he does they say "fuck we will never release this shit at this rate!" | ||
|
Drowsy
United States4876 Posts
On August 08 2009 08:24 D10 wrote: In the current bnet I cant talk to people playing diablo or wc3, theres icons and all other fancy crap. Whats so revolutionary that is taking so long ? Only one answer comes to my mind, they are scared shitless of what their stockholders will think if after 1 week of beta the whole world is playing it. I bet they have some leet hacker that finds 2 ways to crack bnet everyday and everytime he does they say "fuck we will never release this shit at this rate!" Yeah but you don't understand. You're going to be able to talk to people on WORLD OF WARCRAFT!!! ISN'T THIS REVOLUTIONARY AND GROUNDBREAKING? OF TANTAMOUNT IMPORTANCE TO TEH BNET 2.0 EXPERIENCE. | ||
|
Tyraz
New Zealand310 Posts
On August 08 2009 04:10 whyohwhy wrote: On RTS? Give me one other franchise which comes REMOTELY close to Blizzard's titles (SC, Warcraft 3). There's a reason people are still playing SC, it's because there really hasn't been anything better yet, at least if you don't mind the 640x480 res. No self respecting gamer I know REALLY plays westwood RTS atm, or even in the past since the original C&C became outdated. Sure, they play the campaigns, might spend some time in multiplayer, but they are usually quickly forgotten. I guess WH40k wasn't completely bad, although DOW 2 is garbage (all tactical, no base building). From what I gather westwood is headed in that direction too (no base building in the upcoming C&C). Anyway again, there is a reason SC still has such a huge community for a 11 yr old game: it's still the best to this day. When nobody is really able to tackle that in 2009 (save for Blizzard themselves), I would say that's pretty much a monopoly. And even on MMO, which Blizzard is remotely new at, you could say they now have a would be monopoly with WOW. That mf is so successful it's not funny. Compared to those genres, FPS for instance still has quite a bit of competition going on. Hell I'm not saying Blizzard is bad, they obviously have a lot of talent. But when you go without any real competition for long enough, bad things happen. It's starting to show pretty bad with SC2. Yeah but what does the FPS world have to show for it... That genre has been stagnant for AGES. Newer graphics, slight differences in story (still all about one guy 'saving the world'). Halo bought in the shield mechanic which they've been thrashing ever since. Resident evil and Metal Gear Solid series are pretty much the only two which have any sort of 'revolutionary game play'. And even then, they're 3rd person shooters... I have zero idea why everyone is going towards the micro management 'small army, no base' direction for RTS... its just so dull and repetitive... point is: FPS scene has about as many good game developers as the RTS scene... even though they have way more competition, it only leads to way more crap... Edit: On August 08 2009 14:38 Drowsy wrote: Yeah but you don't understand. You're going to be able to talk to people on WORLD OF WARCRAFT!!! ISN'T THIS REVOLUTIONARY AND GROUNDBREAKING? OF TANTAMOUNT IMPORTANCE TO TEH BNET 2.0 EXPERIENCE. This on the other hand, makes me shudder. People raiding on WoW, getting bored, and wispering me in the middle of a starcraft game. Their lack of intelligible exsistance spreading like a virus throughout Bnet2. :| | ||
|
Ahzz
Finland780 Posts
| ||
|
Rebel_lion
United States271 Posts
They are prolly pushing it back because all the other titles they want you to buy aren't out yet. Bnet2.0 is gonna be like 1 long ad. with some starcraft at the end. If were lucky. sc2 delayed because at this time, we (blizzard) are inefficient at selling you other games. Let us redesign the matchmaking to be a roster of advertisements and game promo's. In a year you can play your game. | ||
|
DeCoup
Australia1933 Posts
Clearly the 1st feature of b.net that they got functioning was the room lobby, and it is the more stat or social features (and whatever other goodies they have in store) that b.net is being delayed for. There is no reason to assume the beta will be delayed. | ||
|
afg-warrior
Afghanistan328 Posts
| ||
|
DeCoup
Australia1933 Posts
On August 08 2009 23:45 afg-warrior wrote: what the hell is this xbox live of PCs??? isn't that what steam is? (not sure if you can talk in a party on steam without being in the same game). besides you can talk to people like an xbox live party with ventrillo. so what exactly is so great about being able to talk to players playing other games? and who cares? can't we already do that? you can go to a channel on b.net and see people playing the other blizzard games and you CAN talk to them. i heard something about them having achievements...i'm gonna agree with the idea that b.net 2.0 is going to be a blizzard infomercial and advertisement mind fuck. Steam allows for friends lists, in game messaging and a few other little things. But it is primarily a platform for the advertising and sale of downloadble games. That is why people describe it as more of an x-box live feel. But it will also be part facebook/myspace, and also draw from alot of other social networking designs. And also integrate a lot of game related features that no other platform does by the sounds of it. | ||
| ||
