|
On August 08 2009 00:34 whyohwhy wrote: What, you have some revelation about how college kids (or whoever else) behind firewalls are going to be able to get on Bnet to play SC2?
You don't need to "wait and see" to see the obvious change in priorities at Blizzard between SC and SC2. A great game like SC isn't a good product, it lasts way too long, the players have control over how they play and organize multiplayer, etc. Back a few years, Blizzard was making great games, now they are making good products. But making a good product (that you keep control of, phases out when you want it to, etc) isn't really compatible with making a great game.
Back when they were idealists and employing only a few people, Blizzard could afford to make great games. Now their size is compelling them to make great products. Pity they aren't the same thing.
Not every college blocks online games. There are plenty that allow WoW, Xbox LIVE, and Battle.net to be played over the firewall. If by chance you can't, college players will solve it the same way they've been solving it for years: gather at a friend's house or go to an internet cafe.
|
Am I the only one who is actually excited to see Bnet 2.0 ? Seems like everyone is just pissed about not being able to crack the game or something. Here is an idea....buy the game?
I can't wait to be able to mess around with all the new features
|
On August 08 2009 00:47 Khaymus wrote: Am I the only one who is actually excited to see Bnet 2.0 ? Seems like everyone is just pissed about not being able to crack the game or something.
Yeah same with DRM, people are just pissed they can't crack the game. Maybe I am pissed because I know I will buy the game, and it won't even have a LAN option without providing the interwebs to the entire LAN? You ever try to do ICS over a LAN with a bunch of different OS versions, with always a couple dudes who can't get it to work (and that's in a small LAN)? Yeah, that's really awesome, can't wait.
Newsflash, apparently 12 yr old gamers think more hoops to jump through before actually playing the game you want is EXCITING. Twitter generation, ready to tell the public when they take a shit. What's wrong with that, huh?
W/e. All hope of common sense is lost on you.
|
Sweden33723 Posts
On August 08 2009 00:10 EchOne wrote: To be the noobs' advocate: at the bottom level where smurf games are rampant, noobs most likely won't learn much from the rape. They'll be painfully reminded that their mechanics are insufficient, and that's it. Sure they might have some decent replays to look at later, but bad players are also bad judges of skill, so it'd be more reliable for them to study pro VODs or TL replays than replays of them getting overwhelmed mechanically. Dozens of games of this get tiring eventually since the noob is essentially deriving 0 benefit from X time, which amounts to an utter waste of time.
Once a player is at least decent, as long as he has an open, learning mind-set, it should be a boon to him to play a greater player, but again it's difficult for him to ascertain exactly how good a smurf that owned him is.
So far lack of anonymity and smurfing are the only drawbacks posited against having 1 account. Well, what are the benefits of this? Playing casual games, generally warming up, playing off-races, experimenting with weird builds, and playing Starcraft while drunk are some suggestions.
Okay, I really don't understand why you would play a competitive game casually. If you want casual gaming, play a casual game. Blizzard has made plenty of those. This is Starcraft, wherein going easy is a bad option.
Oh I don't know - maybe because it's fun?
Warm-up can be accomplished via the AI, a warm towel, or PerfectMan's awesome vial of green gosu extract. If you require noob bashing to warm up, it can be accomplished more efficiently with DotA.
I'm not interested in playing DotA or the AI.
Playing off-races is a waste of time unless you're thinking of maining new matchups. If you are already a decent player at one main, it shouldn't be difficult to learn from getting stomped by players of your former rank. There's no reason but comfort to seek bottom level opponents here. If you want comfort, buy a La-Z-Boy.
Again we have that little thing called "fun". If I could only have one account, and I was A+ rank with protoss, I wouldn't really want to play Zerg on this account, because my zerg is so much worse than my protoss that it's a complete joke.
Easily solved by having each of your races have a seperate ELL, however.
Use practice partners to invent builds. There are too many resources on TL created to obtain practice partners. Practice partner matches are potentially the most controlled and scientific, as long as your partner is cooperative. Bottom level test subjects will play badly and give you a skewed impression of how effective your build is.
Yes because everyone has skilled practice partners just waiting to play. Not as realistic as you think it is.
If your friend brags about beating you drunk, it doesn't even matter. He's just being a douche. If your ego is hurt somehow tell it to man the fuck up.
If you are someone "known" you'll get random douchebags bragging about beating you drunk. Yeah, not a big deal, but I'm pretty sure I'd rather make a smurf and play for fun than deal with tonnes of people whispering you when all you are trying to do is play.
Let's get into some more reasons why it's bad to have 1 account per cd-key:
* Siblings. Are you gonna force everyone to buy their kid brother his own cd-key just so he can play without getting face stomped (and in the process ruining your ELL)?
* The 12 year old effect. Think back to when you were 12. What kind of IDs did you create? My first starcraft ID was Archmage_Fenix.
ARCHMAGE FUCKING FENIX. Jesus christ, can you imagine being stuck with that ID for a decade?
* Anonymity. Covered above, but being able to play - as a known player - without being harassed by fans is essential.
If they absolutely have to limit peoples ability to create smurfs, then there's a simple solution:
Allow each CD-Key to create 2 or 3 profiles. Each profile can create 2-3 accounts (if you want to create more accounts you have to delete an old one). All accounts on a profile share the same ELL (thus you cannot sandbag/newb bash). You should have one ELL for each race.
Obviously the old limitation of only 1 player per cd key being able to play at any one time, should remain.
|
If you play ranked games drunk, you only have yourself to blame.
|
Sweden33723 Posts
Why are you so amazingly opposed to people smurfing? I've already shown how you can easily let people smurf while still preventing them from noob-bashing :[
Give me one good, non-noob bashing-related reason why you should only be able to create 1 account?
|
I tried not to address "fun" since it's a lot more difficult to gauge with common sense than "being efficient about competing and improving." But fair enough, games are for fun, especially at the level where we're still playing a game, not an e-Sport. There will always be people who enjoy a number of the freedoms of anonymity, even if they don't contribute to improvement.
Thanks for reminding me of the troubles known gamers face. I'm definitely not known so I really don't know how they'd feel. If anonymity is a relevant and useful tool for them, I'll have to respect that. I would still remind us that known players build their reputations in reputable games, but again the issue of fun and harassment being the opposite of fun comes up. I have to admit that harassment is downright a complete waste of time.
The sibling concern seems reasonable enough. I don't face it, I wouldn't mind buying my sister SC2 if she was interested, and I'd encourage the kids to buy games with their own money anyhow, but I'm sure it's more convenient to let a kid rank up on his own account without assorted hassles.
I hope they will allow the nicknames displayed to users to vary from our actual account IDs. I agree that people shouldn't be stuck with one tag for eternity. Making tags and IDs be different seems like a simple solution to the 12 year old effect. My 12 year old tag was maelstromofvengeance. Wow. I should post that in the confessions thread.
Your suggestion seems like a nice compromise, but I'm afraid this issue isn't getting enough attention for it to be noticed by Blizzard. There's probably a lack of enthusiasm on this issue. I for one don't care very much about it, and I'm sure a lot of other fans also think, "Whatever, as long as it's a good game I don't mind paying and being hobbled by various B.net controls."
|
Everyone smurfs period. I highly doubt that Echy guy even plays BW competitively but here he is wasping about why one would play a hardcore game casually. Sometimes you even just want to avoid people on battle.net.
"If you play ranked games drunk, you only have yourself to blame." Not even talking about ranked games just any casual game for a named-player could turn into a fiasco. Say a guy like Nony gets wasted and wants to play a game, he has to be an ESPORT ICON? Crossing the line when you cant play a casual match without being under a spotlight (and like FA said, vs comp/dota is gay)
Smurfing is the cornerstone to the internet and xbox live is gay. Battle.net1.0 is vastly superior to any console online gaming platform T.T
|
Blizzard doesn't want siblings, or anyone else for that matter, to play on your account. They want everyone to buy their own copy.
Sure, it would be great for the end user if you could create profiles for your siblings, make spawn copies, and having LAN without having to connect to Internet first. But it just isn't in the best interest of Blizzard to provide that.
Hopefully ELL will be tracked for each of the races separately, but hoping for more than that is probably futile. At the end of the day smurfing is not only bad for Blizzard, but also for the community.
|
It's so retarded for households with one computer to have to buy multiple copies of a game just so more than 1 person in the home could actually play it. Gonna install the game twice on one computer? Ofcourse not, that would basically make an account cost like 60-80 bucks which is fucking ridiculous. Goes well beyond the cost of software distrubition into asshole zone.
|
On August 08 2009 01:51 MiniRoman wrote: It's so retarded for households with one computer to have to buy multiple copies of a game just so more than 1 person in the home could actually play it. Gonna install the game twice on one computer? Ofcourse not, that would basically make an account cost like 60-80 bucks which is fucking ridiculous. Goes well beyond the cost of software distrubition into asshole zone.
Yeah it sucks, but pretty much every PC game company does this, and it doesn't look like the trend is going away anytime soon.
|
You guys pretty much summed it up.
About anonymity : even not known people will be willing to play anonymously. I remember when I used to play WC3 in national leagues (yes I'm an ex-WC3 player, [insert flame here]), I didn't always want to play with my clantag, and suffer harsh insults from some guy playing in the same league eager to brag that he defeated me (these things DO happen). Not that I care, not that I feel my self-esteem hurt, but it's just no pleasant.
Sometimes you want to play without letting your teammates ("Come train with us !") or your friends ("Hey you were playing on Bnet yesterday, you told me you weren't at home !") know, sometimes you just want to chill around and play without pressure, try retarded things just for the sake of it and ENJOY the game for what it is, even if, and I think we all agree, the essence of such games is competitive play.
ELL by race seems a good idea but it's not enough. Suppose you haven't played in ages, you might want to start over again, create a new account that reflects your current level and not the level you used to have when you were on top form.
|
This is assuming that when you login you can't create seperate names, in wow you log in with your account but can make multiple characters. Its just a possibility though as is the possibility you can only have one name.
They did it in AoE3 and many were like grr rawr and stuff, but in the end? It wasn't a big deal at all and made it a tighter knit community. Now granted not a ton of people played it, but still everyone knew everyone so it was kinda cool.
|
Sweden33723 Posts
On August 08 2009 02:05 Spawkuring wrote:Show nested quote +On August 08 2009 01:51 MiniRoman wrote: It's so retarded for households with one computer to have to buy multiple copies of a game just so more than 1 person in the home could actually play it. Gonna install the game twice on one computer? Ofcourse not, that would basically make an account cost like 60-80 bucks which is fucking ridiculous. Goes well beyond the cost of software distrubition into asshole zone. Yeah it sucks, but pretty much every PC game company does this, and it doesn't look like the trend is going away anytime soon. Doesn't mean we should lay down and let them walk right over us :[
The CD-Key should be more than enough "DRM"... If I want to play WITH my brother, he has to buy a copy. If we have just one computer, forcing us to buy one copy each just so we can have our own accounts, is so retarded. It doesn't even affect me personally, since we have 4 computers and my brother isn't much younger than me, but it's still so weak.
|
On August 08 2009 02:25 FrozenArbiter wrote:Show nested quote +On August 08 2009 02:05 Spawkuring wrote:On August 08 2009 01:51 MiniRoman wrote: It's so retarded for households with one computer to have to buy multiple copies of a game just so more than 1 person in the home could actually play it. Gonna install the game twice on one computer? Ofcourse not, that would basically make an account cost like 60-80 bucks which is fucking ridiculous. Goes well beyond the cost of software distrubition into asshole zone. Yeah it sucks, but pretty much every PC game company does this, and it doesn't look like the trend is going away anytime soon. Doesn't mean we should lay down and let them walk right over us :[
The only sure-fire way to stop it is to mass boycott any game that does it. Unfortunately, games that usually do the whole "one copy for each person" also tend to sell like hotcakes (WoW, WC3, anything on Steam, most modern RTSs). Some gamers might grumble over it, but the lack of any mass outrage shows that most gamers can live with it.
|
Sweden33723 Posts
WC3 doesn't do that, you can make however many accounts you want - hell I have several (on account of forgetting my passwords mostly).
|
Well when you have no competition you can pretty much get away with whatever garbage you want in terms of marketing. This isn't news but some people's behavior here trying to make it morally ok "because you won't do anything about it" is just a bunch of dumbed down consumers not even aware of their own interest.
It's a monopoly situation pretty much, nobody makes RTS that come close to Blizzard's so unless you are willing to play crappy games instead you're going to deal with their marketing ploys, at least for the time being. Doesn't mean we have to like it or make excuses for them.
Blizzard is basically counting on not having a real competitor on that market in the near future. And capitalism without real competition = fail.
Now however, if A CHALLENGER APPEARS at some point in time, you can bet the nerd rage they've been creating with SC2's marketing will backfire. But yeah, unfortunately they don't see it happening and neither do I.
|
On August 07 2009 06:24 wo0py wrote: Sc2 will be left alone like they do with other projects/games (read sc:bw and d2) And by that i mean a patch here and there and nothing more really. (
Do you really believe this after they missed out on a decade of profits from their amazing game? With bnet 2.0, blizzard is seeking to be more involved in e-sports and the community, as well as make money off their amazing game. I see no problems here.
|
On August 08 2009 01:43 MiniRoman wrote: Everyone smurfs period. I highly doubt that Echy guy even plays BW competitively but here he is wasping about why one would play a hardcore game casually. Sometimes you even just want to avoid people on battle.net.
"If you play ranked games drunk, you only have yourself to blame." Not even talking about ranked games just any casual game for a named-player could turn into a fiasco. Say a guy like Nony gets wasted and wants to play a game, he has to be an ESPORT ICON? Crossing the line when you cant play a casual match without being under a spotlight (and like FA said, vs comp/dota is gay)
Smurfing is the cornerstone to the internet and xbox live is gay. Battle.net1.0 is vastly superior to any console online gaming platform T.T You're right, I'm only D+, and compared to a inveterate C+ Protoss like you, my enjoyment of BW can hardly be called "competitive." I haven't benefited from smurfing first-hand, and though I haven't suffered from it either (the majority of my losses are Koreans, not smurfs), I was definitely narrow-minded in my approach to arguing against smurfing. I'm sorry for that and thank everyone for offering first-hand accounts on the benefits of smurfing.
Anonymity is intrinsic to the internet, but I don't think it's universally beneficial. It inherently deflects responsibility, and although it's convenient to not be held responsible, some people take advantage of the environment to indulge in total asshattery. Obviously smurfing does not equate to asshattery, but I'd just like people to remember that liberty can show the best and worst colors.
As I mentioned in replying to FA, some sort of compromise is probably best, but we're most likely going to get saddled with something ridiculous.
|
On August 08 2009 02:38 whyohwhy wrote: Well when you have no competition you can pretty much get away with whatever garbage you want in terms of marketing. This isn't news but some people's behavior here trying to make it morally ok "because you won't do anything about it" is just a bunch of dumbed down consumers not even aware of their own interest.
It's a monopoly situation pretty much, nobody makes RTS that come close to Blizzard's so unless you are willing to play crappy games instead you're going to deal with their marketing ploys, at least for the time being. Doesn't mean we have to like it or make excuses for them.
Blizzard is basically counting on not having a real competitor on that market in the near future. And capitalism without real competition = fail.
Now however, if A CHALLENGER APPEARS at some point in time, you can bet the nerd rage they've been creating with SC2's marketing will backfire. But yeah, unfortunately they don't see it happening and neither do I.
It's not that Blizzard has a monopoly though. Almost the entire PC game industry has been doing things like DLC, one copy for each person, and the like for years now. The days of "spawning" are pretty much dead. It's not really competition when every competitor is doing the same thing. All you can really do is buy the games that are the most fun.
|
|
|
|
|
|