|
On February 03 2016 05:55 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On February 03 2016 05:53 Seuss wrote:On February 03 2016 05:26 WaveofShadow wrote:On February 03 2016 05:23 Seuss wrote:On February 03 2016 05:01 PrinceXizor wrote: and this now means i will never go back to that game. period. stopped because i couldnt keep up with gold pace, but now i have no chance? done. Uh, the whole point is that it's easier to keep up. You no longer need Naxx or GVG to compete in Standard. If you want to compete in Wild than things are almost exactly the same as before, arguably easier since you can craft the specific Naxx cards you need and/or dust the ones you don't. Monte, for anyone who hasn't kept up with the cards, the example of Secrets Paladin was given in a thread I read: In order to craft that deck for Wild, you need 4120 dust---a cost that won't be able to be lessened by earning packs/cards from playing other formats. If each pack on avergae gets you somewhere slightly above 40 dust, think about how long that would take. And that's just one deck. If you have few/no cards and want to compete in Wild, then yeah it's slightly harder. Emphasis on slightly. You have to get dust from other sources and turn that into cards, but it's not like Wild is excluding new sets. There will be reasonable substitutes, reprints, and alternatives available to you. Maybe you won't have the exact deck that Kibler or Trump or whoever is using, but that's fine. Honestly I think the subset of people who really prefer Wild over Standard but don't already have a reasonable number of cards is probably really, really low. Yes, for now. But like I said, the parallels can be drawn to what has happened to legacy/vintage in MTG. As more older players quit and new players start, the format becomes increasingly more prohibitive as time goes on. Not to mention players who leave and then return to the game and want to be competitive in either/both formats. You essentially have to choose where you spend you rdust in that case because there's no way you can afford enough dust to stay competitive in standard while also completing your collection/trying to construct a Wild deck. and then there are the players that finally get enough to compete in standard, then it rotates and half the cards they have dont work, they need to make new decks and buy new cards. Rotation is always bad for players outside of the extreme spectrum = competitive players and people who just want to make random decks.
|
On February 03 2016 06:02 PrinceXizor wrote:Show nested quote +On February 03 2016 05:55 WaveofShadow wrote:On February 03 2016 05:53 Seuss wrote:On February 03 2016 05:26 WaveofShadow wrote:On February 03 2016 05:23 Seuss wrote:On February 03 2016 05:01 PrinceXizor wrote: and this now means i will never go back to that game. period. stopped because i couldnt keep up with gold pace, but now i have no chance? done. Uh, the whole point is that it's easier to keep up. You no longer need Naxx or GVG to compete in Standard. If you want to compete in Wild than things are almost exactly the same as before, arguably easier since you can craft the specific Naxx cards you need and/or dust the ones you don't. Monte, for anyone who hasn't kept up with the cards, the example of Secrets Paladin was given in a thread I read: In order to craft that deck for Wild, you need 4120 dust---a cost that won't be able to be lessened by earning packs/cards from playing other formats. If each pack on avergae gets you somewhere slightly above 40 dust, think about how long that would take. And that's just one deck. If you have few/no cards and want to compete in Wild, then yeah it's slightly harder. Emphasis on slightly. You have to get dust from other sources and turn that into cards, but it's not like Wild is excluding new sets. There will be reasonable substitutes, reprints, and alternatives available to you. Maybe you won't have the exact deck that Kibler or Trump or whoever is using, but that's fine. Honestly I think the subset of people who really prefer Wild over Standard but don't already have a reasonable number of cards is probably really, really low. Yes, for now. But like I said, the parallels can be drawn to what has happened to legacy/vintage in MTG. As more older players quit and new players start, the format becomes increasingly more prohibitive as time goes on. Not to mention players who leave and then return to the game and want to be competitive in either/both formats. You essentially have to choose where you spend you rdust in that case because there's no way you can afford enough dust to stay competitive in standard while also completing your collection/trying to construct a Wild deck. and then there are the players that finally get enough to compete in standard, then it rotates and half the cards they have dont work, they need to make new decks and buy new cards. Which people well get annoyed with and then a Modern equivalent will be made.
|
On February 03 2016 06:03 Gahlo wrote:Show nested quote +On February 03 2016 06:02 PrinceXizor wrote:On February 03 2016 05:55 WaveofShadow wrote:On February 03 2016 05:53 Seuss wrote:On February 03 2016 05:26 WaveofShadow wrote:On February 03 2016 05:23 Seuss wrote:On February 03 2016 05:01 PrinceXizor wrote: and this now means i will never go back to that game. period. stopped because i couldnt keep up with gold pace, but now i have no chance? done. Uh, the whole point is that it's easier to keep up. You no longer need Naxx or GVG to compete in Standard. If you want to compete in Wild than things are almost exactly the same as before, arguably easier since you can craft the specific Naxx cards you need and/or dust the ones you don't. Monte, for anyone who hasn't kept up with the cards, the example of Secrets Paladin was given in a thread I read: In order to craft that deck for Wild, you need 4120 dust---a cost that won't be able to be lessened by earning packs/cards from playing other formats. If each pack on avergae gets you somewhere slightly above 40 dust, think about how long that would take. And that's just one deck. If you have few/no cards and want to compete in Wild, then yeah it's slightly harder. Emphasis on slightly. You have to get dust from other sources and turn that into cards, but it's not like Wild is excluding new sets. There will be reasonable substitutes, reprints, and alternatives available to you. Maybe you won't have the exact deck that Kibler or Trump or whoever is using, but that's fine. Honestly I think the subset of people who really prefer Wild over Standard but don't already have a reasonable number of cards is probably really, really low. Yes, for now. But like I said, the parallels can be drawn to what has happened to legacy/vintage in MTG. As more older players quit and new players start, the format becomes increasingly more prohibitive as time goes on. Not to mention players who leave and then return to the game and want to be competitive in either/both formats. You essentially have to choose where you spend you rdust in that case because there's no way you can afford enough dust to stay competitive in standard while also completing your collection/trying to construct a Wild deck. and then there are the players that finally get enough to compete in standard, then it rotates and half the cards they have dont work, they need to make new decks and buy new cards. Which people well get annoyed with and then a Modern equivalent will be made. From Reddit:
Upcoming 2021 Announcement:
After increasing the dust required to build many Wild staples due to changes in how gold and packs function for these sets, Blizzard has realized that Wild has become a very hard format for many new players to enter. Blizzard also acknowledges though that while Wild is out of reach for many of the game's more casual players, Standard rotates too fast for many who are only able to buy into the game slowly.
In light of this, Blizzard introduces 'Mild'.
In the 'Mild' format, all sets from 2020 and later will be usable, and the format will never rotate, allowing players who buy into Hearthstone at a slower rate to still acquire everything they need for a competitive deck, without the format rotating on them before reaching this level, and without the high dust costs of Wild.
However, in order to make this format accessible to the more casual crowd, in contrast to Wild's old die-hards who have shown an affection for static/classic gameplay, Blizzard has seen the need to make sure that this format remains fresh, so that it does not evolve into a Wild-style format where eventually the format depends on a certain selection of key legendaries that new entrants to the format must aquire.
To prevent Mild from stagnating this way, Blizzard understands that the card pool requires some occasional disruption outside of the increasingly dwarfed effect of new cards; however, the existence of the other formats prevents the usual solution of cardtext alteration, as these cards can be providing vital roles in other formats. With this in mind, and in the interest of Mild Diversity, Blizzard would like to announce the following cards as banned from the Mild format starting the upcoming calendar year:
All characters starting with the letter 'S' All cards portraying a picture of a duck The current keystone of the format's best deck
|
On February 03 2016 03:10 TheYango wrote: Honestly the deck can run Evolving Wilds if you don't have the Fetch+Battle base. You effectively have 4 colors to get (while pains are essentially trilands). That's another thing I wondered: when you don't have the budget for fetches and duals, there are budget solutions in the painlands, manlands (if you can do with them coming tapped) or battlelands, but for the purpose of thinning your deck, even in a bicolor deck evolving wilds end up being worth it (and costing basically nothing) as long as you don't have a super small curve that wants to drop turns 1-2-3?
|
On February 03 2016 05:55 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On February 03 2016 05:53 Seuss wrote:On February 03 2016 05:26 WaveofShadow wrote:On February 03 2016 05:23 Seuss wrote:On February 03 2016 05:01 PrinceXizor wrote: and this now means i will never go back to that game. period. stopped because i couldnt keep up with gold pace, but now i have no chance? done. Uh, the whole point is that it's easier to keep up. You no longer need Naxx or GVG to compete in Standard. If you want to compete in Wild than things are almost exactly the same as before, arguably easier since you can craft the specific Naxx cards you need and/or dust the ones you don't. Monte, for anyone who hasn't kept up with the cards, the example of Secrets Paladin was given in a thread I read: In order to craft that deck for Wild, you need 4120 dust---a cost that won't be able to be lessened by earning packs/cards from playing other formats. If each pack on avergae gets you somewhere slightly above 40 dust, think about how long that would take. And that's just one deck. If you have few/no cards and want to compete in Wild, then yeah it's slightly harder. Emphasis on slightly. You have to get dust from other sources and turn that into cards, but it's not like Wild is excluding new sets. There will be reasonable substitutes, reprints, and alternatives available to you. Maybe you won't have the exact deck that Kibler or Trump or whoever is using, but that's fine. Honestly I think the subset of people who really prefer Wild over Standard but don't already have a reasonable number of cards is probably really, really low. Yes, for now. But like I said, the parallels can be drawn to what has happened to legacy/vintage in MTG. As more older players quit and new players start, the format becomes increasingly more prohibitive as time goes on. Not to mention players who leave and then return to the game and want to be competitive in either/both formats. You essentially have to choose where you spend you rdust in that case because there's no way you can afford enough dust to stay competitive in standard while also completing your collection/trying to construct a Wild deck.
Right, but those problems are down the line. For now it's fine, and as we move forward Blizzard has options WotC did not insofar as keeping Wild from becoming too prohibitive.
I mean, there's nothing here that makes life easier on completionists but that's a separate problem that needs a separate solution. Standard looks set to accomplish exactly what it's setting out to do.
Edit: To be clear I'm not saying that any of these arguments are invalid, but Hearthstone is a digital CCG and that gives Blizzard a plethora of options for avoiding and addressing these issues down the road that WotC couldn't have dreamed of for MTG.
Things like making Wild sets cost less to craft, or giving grace periods where sets rotating into Wild could be dusted for increased value and such.
|
United States47024 Posts
Things like continuing to "print" sets even when they're not legal in Standard anymore? Oh wait...
Pretty much the only thing that decision serves to accomplish is to push people away from playing Wild and raising the barrier of entry.
|
United States47024 Posts
On February 03 2016 05:08 Requizen wrote: And what about all the players who have been playing for a long time and want to use all their cards? I mean, I crafted Dr Boom and Mal'Ganis, I will actually want to play with them again instead of wistfully looking at them while queuing up for Standard. I'm sure there are a decent number of people who feel the same way.
I mean, is everyone then just expected to constantly dust their old cards as soon as they go out of season? Seems silly to me. Everyone wants to use all their cards, the problem is that the nature of a social game is that people will gravitate to the format that everyone else is playing.
With accessibility issues, a format always naturally shrinks over time. In it's heyday, Vintage in Magic was actually a format that saw a lot of play. It only "died" over time because the availability issues piled up over years and years and more and more people shifted away from it because it slowly became cost-prohibitive for people to enter, resulting in more people leaving than entering. As the format shrinks, this becomes self-reinforcing because the less people are playing the format, the less other people want to play a format because for the most part people play what everyone else is playing.
EDIT: This is also why "reactive" solutions like Monte is proposing aren't really going to save the format. There's an incredible amount of inertia once the community as a whole is invested into a format because of the social nature of these games. People play the formats their friends play. So unless Standard's gameplay is shit and Wild is just way more fun to play (Blizzard won't let this happen) people are just going to stay in the format they're already invested in--unless Wild is set up to succeed from the start, it's going to be very hard to fix it later.
I'd argue that this very factor is part of what contributed to WotC scrapping the Extended format entirely and rebooting the idea with Modern, but that's pretty speculative, so I won't belabor this point.
|
On February 03 2016 06:25 TheYango wrote: Things like continuing to "print" sets even when they're not legal in Standard anymore? Oh wait...
Pretty much the only thing that decision serves to accomplish is to push people away from playing Wild and raising the barrier of entry.
You'll have to enlighten me about whatever it is you're alluding to because I'm not a MTG nerd.
I don't see why cheaper-to-craft Wild sets would be a problem. A new player wanting to complete in either Standard or Wild has 30 cards they need either way. If crafting costs for Wild were halved the Wild deck would hands down be easier to assemble than the Standard deck.
|
On February 03 2016 05:21 WaveofShadow wrote: No, people aren't expected to, but again, a perfect parallel can be drawn to the legacy and vintage formats in MtG which are barely if at all supported, are prohibitively expensive to enter for anyone not already owning the cards, and have a relatively much smaller playerbase to the extent that, like you said earlier, it is often tough to even play. Man, you say that but if you don't play Legacy you better like drafting or have a spare EDH for a game once every 2-3 weeks over here...
On February 03 2016 04:02 Seuss wrote: Time to stop buying TGT packs and focus on GVG!
I wonder if this will delay the next expansion, or if they'll just barrel ahead. So, uh... I'm supposed to spend my gold on GvG instead of saving my ~4k for the next expansion then? Damn. >_> Then again I'm not sure what I need from it...
+ Show Spoiler +Druid: the Dryad x2, but it's prob almost only Mill Druid, Malorne. Hunter pretty much nothing. Mage: Unstable Portal, Echo x2 (ouch), Wee Spellstopper maybe? Paladin: Coghammer x2, Quartermaster x2 (ouch²) maybe Bolvar but I doubt it. Priest: Lightbomb. Though apparently most lists only run 1? Rogue: Cogmaster's Wrench x2 (I doubt mech Rogue ever becomes a thing though), Gallywix, maybe Sabotage x2? Shaman: Power Mace, Ancestors' Call x2, Siltfin Spiritwalker x2, Neptulon (wtf so many epics; Siltfin prob not worth though) Warlock: Mal'Ganis (Anima Golem, Demonheart missing but not worth it) Warrior: Shieldmaiden, Bouncing Blade x2
Standard: Recombobulator x2, Hobgoblin, Enhance-o Mechano x2, Jeeves, Kezan Mystic, Blingtron 3000, Piloted Sky Golem, Sneed's Old Shredder, maybe Madder Bomber x2, Mimiron's Head/Mogor/Troggzor.
That's mostly epics and neutral legendaries, so I'm probably better off crafting whatever I need.
|
why are they going through all this effort to change constructed when we still only have choose 30 use 30 for arena?
|
United States47024 Posts
Basically what I'm saying is that if Blizzard were actually interested in keeping Wild accessible in any way, they wouldn't make the idiotic decision of making non-Standard sets un-buyable with gold. Wizard's can't do this due to the logistics issues of continuing to print an ever increasing stock of old sets, but a digital game has none of those logistics issues, so there's really nothing stopping them from making older expansions from being eternally buyable.
The only reasonable explanation is that Blizzard wants to raise the barrier to playing Wild and push people toward playing Standard. AND because of the inertia issue i mentioned in my last post responding to Req, it's going to be hard to FIX Wild if they change their mind later and decide that they don't want to push Standard so hard anymore. The biggest impetus to push people into other formats is actually the gameplay of one format being garbage for a season but because Blizzard patches cards when they become too problematic, they won't let systemic dysfunctional gameplay like that persist long enough for it to have that kind of effect. So if Standard is set up to be the dominant format from the start, that just isn't going to change.
On February 03 2016 06:36 Frolossus wrote: why are they going through all this effort to change constructed when we still only have choose 30 use 30 for arena? Talked about this with Wave already, Blizzard doesn't give a shit about limited.
|
Man, you say that but if you don't play Legacy you better like drafting or have a spare EDH for a game once every 2-3 weeks over here... Lol forget finding a different LGS, you should find a different country or something.
That being said I wasn't particularly enamored with having to do 5-person sealed instead of drafting last night. Unfortunately the only other draft night at this store is Fridays which I can't do, and I'm not going to start searching out other stores in the area now that I've gotten semi comfortable with the nerds in this one.
|
United States47024 Posts
Also Req, another thing you have to recognize is the vastly higher power level of an eternal format.
Once you get a few rotations in, eternal formats cease to become "play all the old cards I own" and rather become "play this very small handful of rare cards from each of these separate sets spread over a long period of time". 95% of what's Standard playable is not playable in eternal formats because when you aggregate such a large card pool, decks are just faster and more efficient and the bar for what constitutes an acceptable card is far higher.
So even if you own a huge percentage of a given Standard rotation set, it's not going to be a major impetus to play Wild. Of the 123 cards in GvG for example, it's likely that once a few rotations kick in and the sheer size of an eternal format becomes a reality, the number of cards in the set that are actually playable could likely be counted on one hand. When some of those are Mythics or Legendaries you might not have owned anyway, that's not really going to compel you to play Wild.
It's actually a foreseeable future where a few years from now Wild is so fast that even Dr. Boom is totally unplayable because games are largely decided by turn 6 so the majority of 7-drops are default unplayable.
|
Yango, I think you're drawing too heavily on factors which, while extremely relevant to a game which involves walking down to the comic shop to find a limited set of like-minded players, don't necessarily apply the same way online.
First, matchmaking allows less popular formats to remain relevant and robust for much longer. Dominion and Twisted Treeline still exist in LoL despite being vastly less popular than Summoner's Rift. On a smaller scale, Normal and Ranked queues exist side by side despite the popularity difference between them as well.
Second, players will follow incentives. You can absolutely "fix" popularity disparities that way. If it's significantly easier to put together a Wild deck because most of the cards cost half as much to craft, Joe and Jill Average will gravitate in that direction.
Obviously if Blizzard doesn't want a format to succeed it won't (SEE: Arena) and if you believe Blizzard will treat Wild poorly I can understand the worry. I'm optimistic that they want people to feel like their cards and collections are important (they've said as much in the past) and won't be completely uncaring to the plight of Wild.
Edit: The ever-escalating power level of a Wild format is another matter altogether.
|
United States47024 Posts
On February 03 2016 07:01 Seuss wrote: Yango, I think you're drawing too heavily on factors which, while extremely relevant to a game which involves walking down to the comic shop to find a limited set of like-minded players, don't necessarily apply the same way online.
First, matchmaking allows less popular formats to remain relevant and robust for much longer. Dominion and Twisted Treeline still exist in LoL despite being vastly less popular than Summoner's Rift. On a smaller scale, Normal and Ranked queues exist side by side despite the popularity difference between them as well. These barriers don't exist for playing eternal formats on MTGO, and there Standard is still unquestionably the most popular constructed format.
The argument isn't about whether Wild will be popular enough to survive--it clearly will be simply because Hearthstone's playerbase is orders of magnitude larger than MtG's, but that's not what's being discussed. Req's original question was whether Wild or Standard will be the "primary" format for the majority of the player population, and I think given how Blizzard is pushing Standard, that it's clearly going to be Standard--Blizzard WANTS Standard to be the main format. The decision to stop selling Naxx and GvG can only be rationally explained as Blizzard heavily pushing for people to play Standard over Wild by default.
On February 03 2016 07:01 Seuss wrote: Obviously if Blizzard doesn't want a format to succeed it won't (SEE: Arena) and if you believe Blizzard will treat Wild poorly I can understand the worry. I'm optimistic that they want people to feel like their cards and collections are important (they've said as much in the past) and won't be completely uncaring to the plight of Wild. My underlying assumption is precisely this based on Blizzard's decision not to sell packs and Adventures that aren't in Standard.
|
Wait so what sets are standard? What sets aren't? What sets are they stopping you from buying exactly and why the fuck would anyone think that's a good idea? Did blizzard run out of digital cardboard or something? These changes seem like they want you to not just buy the cards but buy a bunch of cards, to make into dust to make cards you might want so they can profit even more off of the base of people who love collecting cards.
|
United States47024 Posts
On February 03 2016 06:12 Alaric wrote:Show nested quote +On February 03 2016 03:10 TheYango wrote: Honestly the deck can run Evolving Wilds if you don't have the Fetch+Battle base. You effectively have 4 colors to get (while pains are essentially trilands). That's another thing I wondered: when you don't have the budget for fetches and duals, there are budget solutions in the painlands, manlands (if you can do with them coming tapped) or battlelands, but for the purpose of thinning your deck, even in a bicolor deck evolving wilds end up being worth it (and costing basically nothing) as long as you don't have a super small curve that wants to drop turns 1-2-3? Thinning effect is very minor over a very small number of fetches. It only is really significant when your fetchland density is high enough that you see multiple in a game.
For a 2 color deck, Evolving Wilds is pretty much just worse than any dual lands (including no-upside taplands, which nobody plays). Actually being able to tap for both colors is very significant (EW can't--it can only tap for the color you fetch and can't tap for the other color at a later time).
|
Hm, I guess I don't have the experience with this sort of thing. With 40k there's some bloat but a lot of stuff is just new rules for existing models, so the idea of phasing out things someone owns is kind of baffling to me.
So will you guys just dust your non-Standard cards or hold onto them in case they come back into rotation?
|
"Standard" will consist of basic, classic, blackrock mountain, argent tournament, league of explorers, and the spring 2016 expansion cards.
I'm not sure how I feel about this change for hearthstone. Makes me want to play duelyst more, I guess, but down the line they'll have exactly the same problems as every other ccg.
In a completely unrelated note, this presidential candidate is hilarious: + Show Spoiler +
|
So Naxx is out, GvG is out. That kind of blows I like the naxx set and the GvG stuff is good cards for many classes and I say this as someone who doesn't have a lot of GvG cards. I just don't understand why you'd just stop selling those sets. Just toss them under a "wild mode old school shit, buy at your own risk" tab.
|
|
|
|
|
|