On February 02 2016 20:21 Alaric wrote:
Some guy brewed a way to put Displacer, Brood Monitor and Zulaport Cutthroat together for the sweet sweet infinite combo in Standard?
+ Show Spoiler [MtG wall] +
Urgh, finding a budget and what other deck fit with it/what you can brew with what you own is hard. Screw fetches and duals.
Some guy brewed a way to put Displacer, Brood Monitor and Zulaport Cutthroat together for the sweet sweet infinite combo in Standard?
+ Show Spoiler [MtG wall] +
Which makes me think, basically for a deck centered on a combo, you want:
- combo pieces, obviously (with redundancy if needed)
- ways to dig for your pieces cards asap (scry's nice, but you need draw/cycle)
- ways to live till you go off or get your draw engine (good defensive creatures, removal, etc.)
- ways to protect your combo from slower decks (evasion/hexproof for a creature-based combo, counterspells/hand disruption for an otherwise spell-based combo)
- alternate win cons if things go south
If you can't hard tutor your pieces (depends on the colour), you want draw which is usually found from U and G a bit (or from B but with drawbacks).
Removal is usually B, W or U (more tempo-based, unless counterspells), early defensive creatures's more W or G, as is lifegain.
Evasiveness is available to all colours in various forms (flying, trample, or stuff like Rogue's passage), hand disruption is usually B, and counterspells is only in U.
So basically, 4c Rally has a BW core because it relies on Rally/Cutthroat/Nantuko, which also provides hand disruption, hard removal and lifegain against control/aggro decks (both in the sideboard).
It has a low curve to make big Rally plays cheaper, so CoCo hits most of the time and serves the same purpose as card draw. If we're going in G, might as well add Elvish Visionary for low drops and some more card draw.
U is providing counterspells in case hand disruption isn't enough, Jace for more pseudo-card draw and his flashback ability (on, say, CoCo), and Reflector Mage/Sidisi's Faithful for tempo plays, which also strengthen the alternate win condition of beating down with Nantuko Husk (while Rallying with Cutthroats and a Nantuko is the main one).
So the easier colour to cut for a 3c Rally would be U: it removes a bit of consistency/power, but the deck still workds, while without G you're slower, lose the potential for explosive openings, and lose almost all your card draw in a combo deck.
I'm still thinking about my janky list since I wanna stay on a budget so screw fetches and Jace and stuff.
I'm not sure about including non-ally creatures because I expect an effect attached to a body to cost more, and the body will have less synergy. On the other hand, card draw in BW atm is Grim Haruspex, Painful Truths, Read the Bones, Altar's Reap, Vampiric Rites, Smothering abomination. One requires non-tokens to die, 2 require sacrificing creatures at cast, and another doesn't give you a say if you want to sacrifice a creature or not (but rewards you for doing it more).
Altar's Reap's repeatable but expansive, I wanted to use it as a sac outlet but a Nantuko or even Ayli would do that better, although they don't provide card draw unless you run Smothering Abomination.
(Overall I think I need more experience playing the deck to better grasp the balance between maintaining a synergistic board/blockers, and how much you can afford to sac in anticipation for a Rally/March draw.)
If I were to add G to the deck, I'd gain access to Catacomb Sifter and Evolutionary Leap, going more toward aristocrats than a Rally/recur thing. They'd both provide some pseudo draw (how valuable is Scry? If you move a card you won't need soon to the bottom of the deck, it's actually almost like drawing it (both cases make the next card your next draw, and don't give you something to play right now) so I'm probably undervaluing it, esp. in a combo/synergy deck?) and a sac outlet in Evo leap. But in that case I'm probably better off going full aristocrats and include my copy of HGW while I'm at it.
I know CoCo's better than all of these but I don't own any and they're 15$ a piece so no thanks, they'd more than double the price.
- combo pieces, obviously (with redundancy if needed)
- ways to dig for your pieces cards asap (scry's nice, but you need draw/cycle)
- ways to live till you go off or get your draw engine (good defensive creatures, removal, etc.)
- ways to protect your combo from slower decks (evasion/hexproof for a creature-based combo, counterspells/hand disruption for an otherwise spell-based combo)
- alternate win cons if things go south
If you can't hard tutor your pieces (depends on the colour), you want draw which is usually found from U and G a bit (or from B but with drawbacks).
Removal is usually B, W or U (more tempo-based, unless counterspells), early defensive creatures's more W or G, as is lifegain.
Evasiveness is available to all colours in various forms (flying, trample, or stuff like Rogue's passage), hand disruption is usually B, and counterspells is only in U.
So basically, 4c Rally has a BW core because it relies on Rally/Cutthroat/Nantuko, which also provides hand disruption, hard removal and lifegain against control/aggro decks (both in the sideboard).
It has a low curve to make big Rally plays cheaper, so CoCo hits most of the time and serves the same purpose as card draw. If we're going in G, might as well add Elvish Visionary for low drops and some more card draw.
U is providing counterspells in case hand disruption isn't enough, Jace for more pseudo-card draw and his flashback ability (on, say, CoCo), and Reflector Mage/Sidisi's Faithful for tempo plays, which also strengthen the alternate win condition of beating down with Nantuko Husk (while Rallying with Cutthroats and a Nantuko is the main one).
So the easier colour to cut for a 3c Rally would be U: it removes a bit of consistency/power, but the deck still workds, while without G you're slower, lose the potential for explosive openings, and lose almost all your card draw in a combo deck.
I'm still thinking about my janky list since I wanna stay on a budget so screw fetches and Jace and stuff.
I'm not sure about including non-ally creatures because I expect an effect attached to a body to cost more, and the body will have less synergy. On the other hand, card draw in BW atm is Grim Haruspex, Painful Truths, Read the Bones, Altar's Reap, Vampiric Rites, Smothering abomination. One requires non-tokens to die, 2 require sacrificing creatures at cast, and another doesn't give you a say if you want to sacrifice a creature or not (but rewards you for doing it more).
Altar's Reap's repeatable but expansive, I wanted to use it as a sac outlet but a Nantuko or even Ayli would do that better, although they don't provide card draw unless you run Smothering Abomination.
(Overall I think I need more experience playing the deck to better grasp the balance between maintaining a synergistic board/blockers, and how much you can afford to sac in anticipation for a Rally/March draw.)
If I were to add G to the deck, I'd gain access to Catacomb Sifter and Evolutionary Leap, going more toward aristocrats than a Rally/recur thing. They'd both provide some pseudo draw (how valuable is Scry? If you move a card you won't need soon to the bottom of the deck, it's actually almost like drawing it (both cases make the next card your next draw, and don't give you something to play right now) so I'm probably undervaluing it, esp. in a combo/synergy deck?) and a sac outlet in Evo leap. But in that case I'm probably better off going full aristocrats and include my copy of HGW while I'm at it.
I know CoCo's better than all of these but I don't own any and they're 15$ a piece so no thanks, they'd more than double the price.
Urgh, finding a budget and what other deck fit with it/what you can brew with what you own is hard. Screw fetches and duals.
This is essentially what I'm doing with displacer combo, except for having to acquire rhinos/the rest of a set of displacers. I'm not gonna go out and buy fetches and stuff for this, though I do need to get painlands (they're cheap).
i'm just trying to find the perfect rate to stream at with low view count.