So, ~80% of the matches are walkovers? Also I know for a fact that a lot of players aren't using the accounts posted on that bracket.
Please don't post like that if you're totally uninformed.

Also some of the scores are posted as 3-0/4-2 or 2-0 (when actually the score was 2-1). Very few matches have replays added. That bracket is a total chaos.

1. I was more responding to your whine about the spoiler free thing
2. I said "I would assume" I did not say "I'm certain"
3. Yes a lot of players aren't using the accounts which are posted, but if you did a bit of research you could actually find out who they actually are, which is what matters, not the their Battlenet IDs which they are using.
4. NASL are using Binarybeast to help them manage a tournament of this scale.
5. I'm not really sure whether you want to know about the Battlenet IDs or who the actual players are but because I am "totally uninformed" I can tell you that the Ro32 players from top to bottom are (TLPDs included)

(P)

SangHo

Time

HRU

Gatored

JYP

InCa

TOP

TargA

Then again, I'm totally uninformed, so yeah, the list maybe very inaccurate. Unfortunately, I'm am actually uninformed about the scores from the previous rounds, so I can't really tell you them. Sorry.

cyclone25

Romania3344 Posts

June 30 2011 13:21 GMT

#802

^ I never said that I don't know who the players on bracket are, or if they advanced or not, so your post is useless.

What I meant is something like this:
For example these matches can't be added to TLPD database because:
1) You can't tell from that bracket if the match was played or if it was a walkover.
2) The score isn't displayed or is incorrect for most matches.
3) A lot of players aren't using the accounts attached to the bracket, so you can't check their match history.

This is how a bracket with very accurate scores looks like: http://challonge.com/koreanweekly3

pdd

Australia9933 Posts

June 30 2011 13:27 GMT

#803

On June 30 2011 22:21 cyclone25 wrote:
^ I never said that I don't know who the players on bracket are, or if they advanced or not, so your post is useless.

What I meant is something like this:
For example these matches can't be added to TLPD database because:
1) You can't tell from that bracket if the match was played or if it was a walkover.
2) The score isn't displayed or is incorrect for most matches.
3) A lot of players aren't using the accounts attached to the bracket, so you can't check their match history.

This is how a bracket with very accurate scores looks like: http://challonge.com/koreanweekly3

Alright, I get what you mean.

I guess it's a question of whether this tournament should actually be put onto the TLPD or not, and I came in with the perspective that it's not really necessary (GSL prelims after all are never put on TLPD except for the final rounds and those are not counted in ELO).

Yeah, NASL could've done a better job. But it's not really a big problem IMO. And that's where our differences lie. There was no need to call me totally uninformed.

Primadog

United States4411 Posts

June 30 2011 13:43 GMT

#804

The goal of the qualifier is analogous to the gsl prelims or the dreamhack byoc. As long as the players get through their brackets properly, it works. I doubt nasl is concerned with whether the games belong in the tlpd or not. If you want, I can check for you.

Also, an account to player crosslist is provided for all the casters that signed up to the event, so from what I am aware of, that was not an issue.