EPT
exactly my pointi've got a list with 50% mafioso thus all my suspects from mandalor have about a 1 in 2 chance of being correct
now qrs, who is guilty from your list?
TL Mafia 2 [GG] - Page 272
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
Plexa
Aotearoa39261 Posts
exactly my pointi've got a list with 50% mafioso thus all my suspects from mandalor have about a 1 in 2 chance of being correct now qrs, who is guilty from your list? | ||
|
jtan
Sweden5891 Posts
On May 11 2008 07:39 Ace wrote: actually that makes you look more like mafia. Posting once your name satrts to be posted consistently and with stronger ties is very mafia like. You read my post wrong, I meant joining now is so obviously a bad idea I wouldn't have done it if I were mafia. Would you start talking when people start being suspicious about you if you've been silent before? No, it would be a lot smarter to just wait and see. Many accusations seems to just be forgotten. Anyway, it's no big deal if I get lynched, I havn't helped town at all anyway. It's just 1 lynch wasted that could be used on a mafia from the towns perspective. | ||
|
qrs
United States3637 Posts
On May 11 2008 11:19 Plexa wrote: now qrs, who is guilty from your list? My list? Do you mean the showtime! list? No idea. If you mean who do I think is guilty in general, I've already mentioned that my top suspects are sureshot, ninja, and clazziquai (in that order). Not much new to add there, sorry. The only person I somewhat suspect who is not already one of the main suspects is Puosu, but I'm hardly sure about him. BTW, I'm not convinced of your reasoning that clues must apply to one person and only one, for the simple reason that Chuiu probably did not read through all 130 profiles before making his clues. | ||
|
Plexa
Aotearoa39261 Posts
08-CDRdude Display Name : CDRdude Birthday : Country : United States Joined : Sunday, 27th of May 2007 Quote : avilo: Every now and then a lurker has to unburrow to reach a new position on the map, and become even more of a legend. Name Meaning: Clues: Image: Display Name : nemY Birthday : February 15, 1987 Country : United States Joined : Sunday, 23rd of July 2006 Quote : Name Meaning: Clues: Image: + Show Spoiler + ![[image loading]](http://teamliquid.net/userfiles/22908.jpg?1186724110) 34-RtS)Night[Mare Display Name : RtS)Night[Mare Birthday : June 05, 1988 Country : Mexico Joined : Thursday, 23rd of December 2004 Quote : <3 the tl.net community Name Meaning: nightmare Clues: Image: South Park character (of himself) [image has since changed] Profile: Pain makes one suffer. Suffering makes one think. Thinking makes one wise. And Wisdom makes life bearable. 48-qrs Display Name : qrs Birthday : Country : Joined : Thursday, 27th of December 2007 Quote : It requires a very unusual mind to undertake the analysis of the obvious. --Alfred North Whitehead Name Meaning: Clues: Image: 51-araav Display Name : araav Birthday : June 19, 1979 Country : Armenia Joined : Wednesday, 29th of September 2004 Quote : The flower that blooms in adversity is the most rare and beautiful of all. Name Meaning: Clues: Image: ![[image loading]](http://teamliquid.net/userfiles/11041.jpg?1162781570) 85-ahrara_ Display Name : ahrara_ Birthday : Country : Afghanistan Joined : Tuesday, 26th of February 2008 Quote : Running 8 min of T in the LOC. Name Meaning: Clues: Image: + Show Spoiler + ![[image loading]](http://teamliquid.net/userfiles/34924.jpg?1206120550) | ||
|
jtan
Sweden5891 Posts
| ||
|
Plexa
Aotearoa39261 Posts
On April 30 2008 16:18 MTF wrote: Joe: Evidence to Support Unforgiven Possibly Being Joe: - All links are being drawn from Unforgiven's profile picture. - Joe is generally supportive and gives a thumbs up. - Joe is smiling in the last Day post - Joe may be short. See: Also note that Joe needed help getting Queasy into his car and that Chuiu did not specify where aznvaliance was grabbed when Joe grabbed him from behind. Mr. Pink: I think everyone who was pointing at Nightmare may have been correct. See: Pain makes one suffer. Suffering makes one think. Thinking makes one wise. And Wisdom makes life bearable. Summation: Pink wants to cause pain and does so. Zeks feels pain and tries to put out the fire, but fails and thus suffers. He then comes to the conclusion after such suffering (thinking -> wisdom) to take off his clothing to stop the burning, which might be construed as making life bearable. Pink judges he's had enough suffering and knocks him unconscious. His posting record seems fairly pro-town with some analysis here and there, but then again, that's exactly how I'd describe L's posts. i like the analysis for joe while the analysis for mr pink i think was worthy of bing revived in light of my suspicion regarding rowdierbob | ||
|
Plexa
Aotearoa39261 Posts
On May 11 2008 11:34 jtan wrote: showtime listHow do you know 1 of those is mafia? 8 people voted for showtime detective revealed one mafioso ulszz is dead, hence 1/7 | ||
|
Plexa
Aotearoa39261 Posts
 why did they have to kill mtf | ||
|
Plexa
Aotearoa39261 Posts
Exhibit A noticed someone driving down the road obviously looking for someone. We note this peculiar phrase, and implies that the driver of the vehicle must be doing something obscure while driving to be able to look for thingsExhibit B "Yeah thats him alright, always drinking a little too much" said Joe as he pulled Sidewinder into the back of the car with the help of LucasWoJ. "Well thanks for the help, Firstly we observe that he needs assistance carrying (a sick) person into the back of his car. And the fact that he acknowledges and appreciates it suggests that he needed the help.Exhibit C He was confused in his response and didn't really want anything to do with the two anymore so he decided to be short and walk back toward his van. Rather interesting choice of words "decided to be short". This coincides with the idea of Joe needing help to lift someone into his vanExhibit D Joe gave Mr. Blue a thumbs up for effort as he grabbed and held onto aZnvaLiaNce from behind. We note that he gives a thumbs upExhibit E Smiling from the roof of the gas station Joe We note that he is smilingExhibit F Joe would jump him from above and knock him out cold instantly then hang him from the wall. We notes that he in going to "jump" onto him rather than "drop" onto himExhibit G he ran over and jumped onto the top of the car causing a huge indentation. Once again joe jumps onto a car - obvious gaining some serious height if he is going to cause an indentationExhibit H Naib got out of his car as fast as he could to see Joe standing up. Joe then kicked Naib in the face, being in the perfect spot to do so We note that joe is in the perfect spot to kick him in the face - this again implies that he is shortExhibit I As Naib was getting up he slashed him repeatedly with the end of the bottle and kicked him back to the ground. We note that joe can only attack naib once he is on the ground, when he tries to get up he is "kicked" back to the ground - this again coincides with the fact that he is short![[image loading]](http://teamliquid.net/userfiles/9932.jpg?1203619588) This image fits every single aspect of joe's character without fail. He fits the car driver in having to do something weird to look for his friend. He fits the short description and the fact he needs help to lift someone into his car. He fits the idea that joe needs to 'jump' around. He fits the kick. He fits the smile and the thumbs up. Unoforgiven absolutely has to be mafia | ||
|
Camlito
Australia4040 Posts
| ||
|
Infundibulum
United States2552 Posts
Just curious, why am i not on your suspect list anymore? Last time i was 40% according to you and now nothing  Also... i don't like the clue analysis for jtan very much. though his posting debut in these recent pages does require to be considered, i suppose. Just that it seems analysed from a perspective like, "if we decide jtan is mafia, we can sorta link x and y to him" rather than "x and y seem to link to jtan." Just my 2c. | ||
|
Plexa
Aotearoa39261 Posts
On May 11 2008 13:05 iNfuNdiBuLuM wrote: you still are a suspect (1/7th to be precise)wow.. plexa strikes again Just curious, why am i not on your suspect list anymore? Last time i was 40% according to you and now nothing .but that list is just so damn confusing when we got the showtime list me, fusionsdf, mtf and associate all were shocked because we hadn't picked of you as mafia..im sure the link will come... | ||
|
Infundibulum
United States2552 Posts
..or perhaps you have already sent the vigilante :s e: 400 posts wooo! | ||
|
Plexa
Aotearoa39261 Posts
i'll put you back on it | ||
|
Camlito
Australia4040 Posts
| ||
|
Infundibulum
United States2552 Posts
On May 11 2008 13:45 Plexa wrote: o shit i did leave you off.. i'll put you back on it and fix my name meaning while you're at it  | ||
|
ahrara_
Afghanistan1715 Posts
On May 11 2008 11:27 Plexa wrote: 85-ahrara_ Display Name : ahrara_ Birthday : Country : Afghanistan Joined : Tuesday, 26th of February 2008 Quote : Running 8 min of T in the LOC. Name Meaning: Clues: Image: + Show Spoiler + pimpin | ||
|
Unforgiven_ve
Venezuela1232 Posts
| ||
|
nemY
United States3119 Posts
-I don't see how Exhibit A has anything to relate to Unforgiven -Exhibit B seems questionable to me. A normal person on his own would have trouble carrying a passed out individual of roughly the same size into the back seat of a car... unless he dragged him in or had help. -Exhibit D doesn't make much sense if Unforgiven is a short rabbit, how could he give someone a thumb's up sign and hold someone else down from behind? -If Joe really is Unforgiven, than Unforgiven shouldn't have any way of being able to talk (since he's a bunny). If crazie-penguin couldn't talk, why should Unforgiven be able to? Sadly I can't really offer anyone else as a potential alternative for Joe though | ||
|
Plexa
Aotearoa39261 Posts
case in point; d.arkive ![[image loading]](http://teamliquid.net/userfiles/25506.jpg?1205439119) every single clue from taipan snake pertained to that single picture - hence my accusation stands On May 11 2008 18:21 nemY wrote: Fair enough, but i ask you this - in the middle of the night can you really tell if someone is obviously looking for someone? I beleive if that bunny was driving then he would be serving over the road imo or similar.. i just thought it was particularly peculiar-I don't see how Exhibit A has anything to relate to Unforgiven -Exhibit B seems questionable to me. A normal person on his own would have trouble carrying a passed out individual of roughly the same size into the back seat of a car... unless he dragged him in or had help. I do beleive that a normal sized person would have been able to drag his friend into the car without assistance - so why does joe need Lucas to help him? because he cant do it himself, its impossible-Exhibit D doesn't make much sense if Unforgiven is a short rabbit, how could he give someone a thumb's up sign and hold someone else down from behind? Note that there is no place where where the person was held by the rabbit - its plausible that the rabbit could still hold him - how can a penguin hold someone's legs? its flippers are incapable of holding legs? its somewhat of the same issue imo-If Joe really is Unforgiven, than Unforgiven shouldn't have any way of being able to talk (since he's a bunny). If crazie-penguin couldn't talk, why should Unforgiven be able to? That is an interesting point and quite frankly i don't have a complete answer for it... Blind Albino didn't talk - yet he was able to... Although given this sole flaw i still strongly feel that unforgiven is mafia and that the clues stacked against him are stronger than any other person in this game... i've been over the profiles so many times and im so certain about this - like d.arkive sure+ Unforgiven is on the mandalor list (50% chance to kill) which always makes me more confident Sadly I can't really offer anyone else as a potential alternative for Joe though Case in point - he's the best fit | ||
| ||
