EPTTL Mafia 2 [GG] - Page 251
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
L
Canada4732 Posts
| ||
|
Amber[LighT]
United States5078 Posts
On April 22 2008 10:49 L wrote: Okay, so, your defence is that people have looked at me instead of you until now. Solid. You're doubting the detective work that has been going on in this game? Let me remind you of how great of a job these guys are doing. They are picking out names from 110 DIFFERENT USERS. Don't you think if there was a clue worthy enough to pin me as a target it would have been made known Day 2, 3, 4, 5, OR even 6? Why would it take so long to actually accuse me of anything. I think you're desperate because you know you're fucked if you don't somehow manage to get someone else. And I can't be mafia. a) I already let others know this. b) I stated on page 235: On April 17 2008 05:07 Amber[LighT] wrote: Also, L, how do you know your medic save was necessarily guaranteed protection. We can't say for sure. We need to list who was actually hit. Lets also not forget it's possible that some mafia can be inactive? This should have turned a light on or something in your head (not meant to be an ironic statement). It's pretty obvious I don't know what the killing system is for mafia. If I knew, would I ask that question? And maybe I'm using this to cover up, but it was already in a discussion including you, where I already felt you were mafia. Note also I never edited that post and I was corrected by others just posts after. As a side note this is my second mafia game (I was a townie last game), and the fact that I still didn't know how the mafia killed should have made me an automatic name to never even bother accusing or putting on a list. Ask yourself this, L. If I was mafia, would I even bother suggesting there are inactive people? If I die then thats a clue that you should target players who are more inactive with the game since they have 'killing power.' I wouldn't screw the mafia over if I was in that type of position, I would probably accuse someone who hasn't said much the entire game, voted EVERY time (whether I abstained or not I always voted), which makes me feel like you're either out to get me, or you're mafia. In either case I don't trust you. | ||
|
L
Canada4732 Posts
Why would you suggest that? Because if mafia are active and you die as red, suspicion is thrown off your active comrades. It also gives you a bluff to hide under like you've done here. Obviously you won't trust me if i directly link your name to a suite of clues which has been thought to be mine for the past day, but you haven't really doubted the validity of the link in your defense posts, which makes me believe that you know you've been pinned. Either way, no matter what people do, others are going to be suspicious. This is why i didn't want to point a finger at you in the first place. If i really was so out to nail you, why would I hold back my predictions? If i was mafia, for the same reasons i posted above for your ineptitude bluff. Even then, If i die red, or you die red, the other isn't explicitly found innocent, we can simply be dual mafia just throwing ideas off each other to make the other seem less liable come lynch time. But yeah, the fact that you've stated that the fact that I still didn't know how the mafia killed should have made me an automatic name to never even bother accusing or putting on a list. is all the reason you'd need as mafia to state your lack of knowledge in the first place. That the method of killing has been posted prior in thread would be of no worry to you if you were mafia, because you could pin your lack of knowledge on lack of activity. If you were townie, on the other hand, it shows that you haven't even bothered to read the thread. :/. Either way, pretending to be stupid doesn't really help you. | ||
Plexa
Aotearoa39261 Posts
| ||
|
nemY
United States3119 Posts
On April 22 2008 09:14 MTF wrote: Mafia probably haven't sent in their kills yet. Inactive mafia FTL? | ||
|
MTF
United States1739 Posts
I can guess at one of a few scenarios to pass the time. 1: The most paranoid suggestion, that Mafia were waiting for L to get in and tell them who he's on tonight. 2: Crazie and/or Blind were the ringleader(s) and now with them gone, Mafia has become a chicken without a head. 3. They're just taking their time. Personally, number 2 appeals to me the most. : x | ||
|
nemY
United States3119 Posts
#2 seems unlikely, cuz uhh no offense but neither seemed that intelligent ;P #3 is possible | ||
|
L
Canada4732 Posts
Not once have you brought up a single clue relating to him in any of your posts. Apart from the fact that Yagami Light fits every action of enigma, from the fake note all the way down to the grimace? | ||
Bockit
Sydney2287 Posts
On April 22 2008 12:52 MTF wrote: I can guess at one of a few scenarios to pass the time. 1: The most paranoid suggestion, that Mafia were waiting for L to get in and tell them who he's on tonight. 2: Crazie and/or Blind were the ringleader(s) and now with them gone, Mafia has become a chicken without a head. 3. They're just taking their time. Personally, number 2 appeals to me the most. : x #1 isn't possible because L has been posting for the past few days. On this note: the fact that L has been so active recently and mafia didn't even send in a hitlist tonight, makes me doubt the strength of the convictions against him. I'm not saying it makes him a confirmed innocent or anything, just that to me it is by no means set in stone anymore. #2 Out of these possibilities, this is most likely imo. #3 is also possible, but the length of time makes it improbable imo. The fact that mafia *haven't sent in a hitlist* makes me think we should be looking at the completely inactive no-vote-no-post people for some mafia. | ||
|
ShaLLoW[baY]
Canada12499 Posts
| ||
|
L
Canada4732 Posts
:o | ||
|
MTF
United States1739 Posts
On April 22 2008 13:52 Bockit wrote: The fact that mafia *haven't sent in a hitlist* makes me think we should be looking at the completely inactive no-vote-no-post people for some mafia. #1 is actually possible, because the medic "who is protecting who" list went out yesterday while L was gone, so far as I know. Not saying it's the most likely, just that it's possible. :p As for the quoted part of your post, I agree. But you also need to match clues, as well. DamageControl as Mr. Black (all credits to Plexa), for instance, is very inactive in the thread, having never posted and never voted (despite posting on other parts of the site) and is personally a strong fit for his clues. Another pretty inactive person I feel strongly about being mafia is ieatkids5 as Mr. White. However, depending on what happens come day, L will either definitely be or definitely not be on the lynching agenda. The medic situation demands it, and the clues + situation so far as I've investigated all point to L being the only unconfirmed medic out of the original 8 (only 7 legit) that claimed the role. Either his innocence is proven tomorrow or we're gunning for him + one other. | ||
|
Plexa
Aotearoa39261 Posts
1) Plexa 2) Plexa 3) Plexa 4) Plexa 5) Plexa 6) MTF 7) MTF  | ||
|
Plexa
Aotearoa39261 Posts
On April 22 2008 13:59 L wrote: go make yourself useful and send a list to chuiuNot raping people with rakes. :o | ||
|
L
Canada4732 Posts
go make yourself useful and send a list to chuiu Pardon? | ||
|
Ace
United States16096 Posts
On April 22 2008 14:09 Plexa wrote: Obviously the best move for the mafia would be a hitlist like this; 1) Plexa 2) Plexa 3) Plexa 4) Plexa 5) Plexa 6) MTF 7) MTF Then if/when I die who will we nominate as deputy mayor? Shallowbay? | ||
|
fusionsdf
Canada15390 Posts
On April 22 2008 14:06 MTF wrote: #1 is actually possible, because the medic "who is protecting who" list went out yesterday while L was gone, so far as I know. Not saying it's the most likely, just that it's possible. :p As for the quoted part of your post, I agree. But you also need to match clues, as well. DamageControl as Mr. Black (all credits to Plexa), for instance, is very inactive in the thread, having never posted and never voted (despite posting on other parts of the site) and is personally a strong fit for his clues. Another pretty inactive person I feel strongly about being mafia is ieatkids5 as Mr. White. However, depending on what happens come day, L will either definitely be or definitely not be on the lynching agenda. The medic situation demands it, and the clues + situation so far as I've investigated all point to L being the only unconfirmed medic out of the original 8 (only 7 legit) that claimed the role. Either his innocence is proven tomorrow or we're gunning for him + one other. #1 makes sense if L is mafia and the mafia is still trying to save him. They need to know who he is protecting, so they can adjust the number of hits. | ||
|
Plexa
Aotearoa39261 Posts
| ||
|
SoleSteeler
Canada5459 Posts
On April 22 2008 14:38 L wrote: Pardon? There was no stutter. | ||
|
Alethios
New Zealand2765 Posts
On April 22 2008 15:40 Plexa wrote: i'll come right out and say it - L and L alone should be protecting me tonight Thats a rather interesting thing to be telling everybody. | ||
| ||
